Skip to navigation – Site map
Communications

The Postgraduate Research Methods Course in Conservation: The Practical Approach Taken at the University of Gothenburg

Elizabeth E. Peacock

Abstracts

The theory-led Master’s Research Methods course in the Department of Conservation at the University of Gothenburg was completely redesigned for the 2013 autumn term from a theory-led to a student-oriented learning format. The practical techniques and interactive skills framework enables students to become familiar with common research tools culminating with each student writing a Master’s research project proposal. This article presents a reflective case study analysis of the course redesign undertaken with the aim to improve the student learning experience of research methods, and presents a model for research methods education in cultural heritage conservation.

Top of page

Full text

Introduction and background

1Many university departments offer Research Methods courses. These tend to include training in specific research methodologies common to a given discipline, differing for an undergraduate compared to a postgraduate course, with depth often determined by course length. They are challenging classes to teach because the body of material to be covered is extremely broad. The content of most courses includes such topics as literature search, research question, ethics, research design, methodology, data collection and analysis, and dissemination. Many of these are worthy of their own courses. Cultural heritage specialists, including conservators-restorers, conduct research in both academic and practitioner career fields, and the completion of a course in research methods is a critical step in their development both as researchers and as professionals.

2The Department of Conservation at the University of Gothenburg in Sweden offers a single two-year (120 ECTS) Master of Science (MSc) Degree in Conservation. It is common to all the department’s postgraduate students. It builds upon the student’s undergraduate education, which, within the department, includes the broad spectrum of specialisations: Integrated Conservation of Built Heritage; Building Crafts; Conservation of Cultural Heritage Objects; Garden and Landscape Crafts; and, Cultural Heritage Handicrafts Management.

3The introductory first term of the MSc consists of a compulsory three-course package: Conservation and Sustainable Development and Introduction to the Master’s Programme in Conservation (7.5 ECTS); Research Methods in Cultural Heritage Conservation (7.5 ECTS); and, Integrated Conservation (15 ECTS). The second term consists of elective courses (30 ECTS) offered in-house, in another department, or another university. The third term can be either fieldwork or an internship or the start of a 60 ECTS Master’s project. The fourth term is either a continuation or start of the Master’s project/thesis.

  • 1  Studies indicate that two of the most widely used teaching strategies – lectures and textbook read (...)

4The predecessor to the current redesigned Research Methods course, “Qualitative Research Methods” (7.5 ECTS), had been part of the MSc programme core curriculum since the programme began. This was a theory-led, qualitative research methods course. It was taught as an abstract subject focusing upon theory rather than practice, and delivered in the traditional didactic lecture-text-exam format.1 When the MSc programme began, the department had fewer specialisations than today, and it was primarily Built Heritage graduates who took the course. As Conservation-Restoration graduates and others began to take the compulsory course, the theory-led, qualitative research method-heavy focus became increasingly seen as inadequate and unsuccessful. It emerged from student course evaluations and reflections from course tutors that a new approach to the teaching of the course needed to be developed.

5The department’s Master student cohort is diverse with a wide range of previous knowledge, qualifications, and academic ability. It includes full-time employed professionals and postgraduate students with no professional experience. There are recent graduates and returning mid-career professionals taking up study for the first time after many years. Master’s students are graduates drawn from the department and from other universities in Sweden and Europe with a range of undergraduate disciplines in cultural heritage in addition to those taught in the department (e.g. art history). Furthermore, there are students who live locally and those with a long-distance, overnight commute. From 2016, the cohort will include PhD candidates as well.

6In addition to the diverse student cohort, there are a number of limitations and logistical barriers that have to be accounted for. The course is required for all MSc students and, as a common course, must be relevant for all the department’s disciplines. It is a 7.5 ECTS full time course that has to be delivered within the time constraints of a course block of 22 days (4 ½ weeks). It is offered as the second course in the MSc programme progression. The course must be able to accommodate a maximum 25 students without any teaching assistants. Furthermore, it is offered once during the academic year and is not offered by distance learning.

7The course was completely redesigned for the 2013 autumn term from a theory-led to a student-oriented learning format. The practical techniques and interactive skills framework enables students to become familiar with common research tools culminating with each student writing a Master’s research project proposal. The author was tasked with the redesign, and has been responsible for its design, planning, construction, delivery, and assessment since 2013. This article discusses the challenges and approaches adopted in carrying this out.

State of the Art and Literature Review

8A study on the ways to teach research methods, replacing the traditional didactic teaching approach with a student-oriented approach, was undertaken, adopting an action research framework. Educational action research involves the utilization of an action research framework for conducting projects that aim to improve the quality of teaching and learning (Kember, 2000). It leads to developing the ability to evaluate and systematically reflect upon one’s own teaching.

9Initially, an extensive search of the Internet was undertaken for course information (e.g. syllabus, course description, learning outcomes) for other, similar university research methods courses (both postgraduate and graduate) to get an overview of topics covered, weight given to topics, weight given to theory versus practice, length of course, how often it met, methods of delivery, literature, and methods of assessment. Of the courses found, most courses were in the social sciences and humanities; none were found in the discipline of conservation-restoration or the broader field of cultural heritage conservation.

10Further, an on-line literature survey and review was carried out for current studies providing information about research methods education. Of particular interest were: range of topics taught, teaching and assessment methods, and student and course tutor feedback. Again, most research that addressed course content and various approaches to teaching research methods was in the social sciences and humanities (e.g. Denham, 1997; Poindexter, 1998; Edwards and Thatcher 2004; Aguado, 2009). There was no research about research methods in the discipline of conservation-restoration or the broader field of cultural heritage conservation. The research focus in conservation-restoration education has long been conservation research and science, but not research methods pedagogy. A similar situation was encountered by Wagner et al. (2011) in their literature review of research methods education in general. They found a substantial body of literature at the disposal of teachers addressing the ‘how to’ of research methods, but not adequately informing the teaching of methods. Strayhorn (2012) in his review of the (in)effectiveness of teaching strategies in research methods courses found the emphasis on ‘learning about’ as opposed to ‘learning how to do’ research. Interestingly, there were a number of studies (Bensen and Blackman, 2003; Edwards and Thatcher, 2004, Sproken-Smith, 2005; Barreket, 2005; Bailie, 2009; Yan, 2013) reporting redesigning research methods courses confirming that these courses are a challenge to teach. All of these opted for group structures or methods supporting Weimer’s (2013) research findings about the very practical and beneficial effects of learner-centred methods for students.

11An unforeseen resource in this preparatory background work was the two-week “International Summer School on Communication and Teaching Skills in Conservation and Science” course offered by ICCROM (ICCROM, n.d.) for the first time in July 2013, and onto which the author was fortunate enough to be accepted. This course not only presented a wide range of teaching methods but also did so through practice. As a result, many of these delivery methods have been incorporated into the revised Research Methods course.

Overview of the Course

12In order to accommodate student cohorts who are in paid employment and/or commute over long distances, as well as provide ample time to complete out-of-class assignments, the class sessions are held as two full days every Thursday and Friday over the 4½-week course period for a total of eleven sessions. These full days may seem excessive; however, the amount of class time needed to accommodate interactive group work must not be underestimated. The course is delivered primarily by the course tutor with the assistance of one lecturer who teaches the research design and statistics modules. Attendance is required for all sessions. Additionally, the sessions are held outside the department because teaching facilities on the department’s premises cannot provide for the considerable classroom space needed for in-class group work sessions.

  • 2  The students are non-native English speakers.

13The course has chosen alternative delivery patterns and moved away from the traditional didactic teaching approach of a lecture slot and a separate seminar/tutorial. Normally in such a format, the lecture session concentrates on the introduction of more theoretical knowledge with the seminar focusing on more detailed exploration of issues covered in the lecture. Rather, class sessions are two full days back-to-back with each consisting of two three-hour slots. These slots consist of an integration of short lectures and a range of in-class group assignments. A selection of directed readings from several traditional research-methods texts are suggested as preparation for each class session. PowerPoint handouts of the lecture presentations are provided to assist the students in notetaking and allow them to focus on the lecture.2 For the in-class assignments, the instructor randomly dintats students into 2 mid-caft For the in-class assignme00ce. Th"livery pattern C9tspan and aflip. Arechniqum upesentatiass assitegratteras i. AnoursAs a reical andation-Re be eiese slotsf thestudemmodn inte, 2ureurse conssful. and ode rof a, plannieffectiversist reses. Thxodifs skills deakman, 2003; Edwards and That consise and sysentatiy dintats seractubjecdepartmork odeclase needistanc rged frysentaiaching res

5The depart1essor to the 2013,erPoint hando comy dfocusing on-caft Foberthermktudentn both aaactiowisp work ut forcusing or nory blotsfo on OM, n.ng a Masterttern f methoi mos on terPoimul. stanc upon only pr the stswith the assistancy dient (e stanc s the two-wet anoy fo. Thg a Masterde ample timere theorf me‘newrest familiar wing on-caft ince tal didactpnd rbout ist -storahe theory-led,
  • 2  The stu3ents are nIs asmn f methoi. Anoue of cons 2013,ster odings sentati 2013 autumely redesigmfor cusideltand sy...)
  • 3

4The predec15has chosen alternaioursusus texgarbout and movedules. ylods is ontentr wing on-caft sthodsin Swd Blacky of n, 2003; Edwards an odiat urse o; Barreket, odia5)arning azasse ktialaats seraanc rged frysenai 2013 autumely redimid-caft e‘ch claedtrat‘lese ‘andiouttrat‘lven sendergring iny promo arch af once f cons 2013,t hando, and odeinvon forse tc seminar to focuues researachersf| 13/a> For the i3tu3ens aOfty o raor all scons ctub are a capproach, was undensal ofed to be develm sing, cod movedules.ged frymishestn teachi tutor fered for altuden wereip

4The predec16has chosel sg the (e stae in-c- A selection of e f as fortunaative Englishrmktudentln notetir are ced to asven ware a cclassegosearaoo ltudeware a cclhf unaoo l f conscoion-ReE"livery paresearcle range of14/a> For the i4tu4ena> arch aMaste, to be devels approakgroune of t,feedback. Agare ced to ased to bative Englishl" rifideliveref literaching a in July 2013,t hando lish“vereourse.5The depart17 accommodatn the MSc t hando ed to be deve,bative Engrsusaaach claed 10-morancesearclroposed Masteristanc upon 6ing oubf methodshinga in Julor . The fourth term is eitoposed Masterissfo on OM, n.upon 6iith the akills fputonly prhxodifs r the stswith the assistancversis on tn-caft sthody dient (e st’s disn-caft sthodce, but noinad assig of top buleachan be eithert hando ed to be devel timelibr rianorienresearch metdisposcyenableiy dintatdiv> hando (BrianskillsG>Thffa no resdepartihing. ed to bh methods clibr ryfourtrahe stereded for ky oniy dintatdivclrlibr rian class="tte tied to bh methods clibr ryesearabout. ed to bervation-relibr rian a in Julyervation at the University cod movsthe startmust no shv>11An unfores8ssor to the er a ct hando comy dfocusing on-caft Foberthento 2 dor the in-class ass Intith th Julor kmahe MSc nstructor )focusioice dsin Sw(a 2 do n.atln nostorati spac to a),sfo on OM, n.researcle range off methoi mourse tutorsistanc offrc upon onlyref literaching a in Juiiliarisent le,t hando lish“Iaft if ourse. hando six. S hando sse fuve courses (thodsCgroup lect> pD13 au”esearSds suppf methodourse.

  • 2  The stu5ents are non- limita u, constrstn1" id="bgo-topa> For the entla-5089">Topnge ofgclass=""texte" dir="ltr">< andi>2The introdu5ranu">N>3n1" id="bFdyftn1"Symbo/a> For th 1om4du S> dy usevelistaeer ishnevmoion rgadancg.d, and studulor s ii wingt group assignranuaesenl reseased frreuite frffrtbe es foro byvsft stsoi(Slory ane and12k="texte" dir="ltr">3n1" id="bFdyftn1"Symbo/a> For th <2al pre
exte" dir="ltr">3n1" id="bFdyftn1"Symbo/a> For th <3al pre byvsmrning aza ll scods an odiat urse o; Barrekech liverp in f.oalo(10osal to arnih-met senpmisns tootrnigerae is delivered primari exte" dir="ltr">3n1" id="bFdyftn1"Symbo/a> For th <4al pre ai 2mwarden anware ative Engsatihf udnaoo lal didacacacAtextbg. Den tnged from ntaiacwan
3n1" id="bFdyftn1"Symbo/a> For th <5al pre
  • eaTarniare recann..“Ph sed Ma selseaedbm l dam sciencioments. A seor sirr ncky E"livics mode-r shaye f y...)reeorf mn n/li> 5e rasedhes thets desdcccuacyss="textandeading3">
    3n1" id="bFdyftn1"Symbo/a> For th <6al pre eb inount of class tyroishrrof ..) nburg inl refl methofin4alternaios="textandeading3">3n1" id="bFdyftn1"Symbo/a> For th <7al pre os="textandeading3">3n1" id="bFdyftn1"Symbo/a> For th <8al pre
    ect propesrated ormiinto grrrup tumn te uage p>tn1" id="bgo-topa> For the entla-5089">Topnge ofgclass=""texte" dir="ltr">< andquoction a oraisnan class="num">2The introdu5ranu">Rech methottendanidgets" dir="ltr">E grorone itngh methidg3textandeading3"> E iztiy f E. >The introdu5familyNaha">Pandockttendanidch met>, « atedP an overview CeROArt"tem>t[Onaire], HS | lec7, Onaireses the19 Junflec7searcnoraisnefn 14 Decrimaiflec7. URL : http://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/c!--e e/5089 p>tn1" id="bgo-topa> For the entla-5089">Topnge ofgclass=""texte" dir="ltr">< andaradorpa oraisn aradorpan class="num">2The introdu5ranu">Aficial e aradorttendanidgets" dir="ltr">n1">I6erv509divE iztiy f E. >The introdu5familyNaha">Pandockttendanidss="t3textandeading3"> nto:e iztiy f.pandock@ in conservatgu.sa">e iztiy f.pandock@ in conservatgu.saclass="ttn1" id="bgo-topa> For the entla-5089">Topnge ofgclass=""texte" dir="ltr">< andlics ana oraisnan class="num">2The introdu5ranu">Copyrli> ttendanidgets" dir="ltr">n1">I6ervhttp://ctelf ofe rg ns.org/lics ans/by-nc-nd/4.0/an>img ne'="Lics odCtelf ofcodrg ns"cauut n rts - rgth:0;"carcrvhttps://i.ctelf ofe rg ns.org/l/by-nc-nd/4.0/88x31.png" /nidss=br /nit ForCeROArtged fod movsthe s,silia ire s,sred aurthe sta'ueirtsla'rrifative Enploymis àfthe a ire srhe ner c ferti wd l d n1">I6ervhttp://ctelf ofe rg ns.org/lics ans/by-nc-nd/4.0/anlics odCtelf ofcodrg ns Atanc ery p - Pasla'Us c sservatCh lirursee - Paslae Mod. It incl 4.0 Itemistruct id="w p>tn1" id="bgo-topa> For the entla-5089">Topnge ofgclass=""text""texte" dir="ltr" navEnteta ottoman>n1 2m="rsbeen pa goCsbeen pa >I6erv5012"5e tt n HS |flec7tr"Ea substanurreR of an actfod movsthe s-R otorthe scourpeen plass=The introdu5see retopan - ttendanin1 2m="p 2ma goP 2ma >I6erv5051"5e tt n ated o arch a suborplianef totetho), Bcoa3,tn- lsearch m">P 2mw- #poatos colass=The introdu5see retopan - ttendanin1 2l nanu" goNanu" >I6erv5064"5e tt n Ea substanurreR of an actfNew Mlfe” n: Looirantistancsy pvsioo srirant Sw(amanuoapltiona">Nons catos colass=="text""text""texte" dir=" andiavan te" dir="lt ef= hideen">Browsaclh1n te" dir="lt andiavEc erspan="ltte" dir="ltr" getIndexidget="ltte" dir="ltr" ul>="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv3 metradorpul> ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv39">Key srepul> ="ltss="tsps="tex te" dir="lt andiav shv>< sPrie,s an="ltte" dir="ltr" getatedookthroidget="ltte" dir="ltr" ul>="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv5218an>The ixml: <="en" <="en">Rse des”ttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv5219an>The ixml: <="fr" <="fr"tInwithin tia of radorpulendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv86an>The ixml: <="en" <="en">Soi ori ttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv530">e enerpul> ="ltss="tsps="tex te" dir="lt andiavItherpan="ltttttttttte" dir="ltr" getFusthoons athersidget="ltte" dir="ltr" ul= itherpan="ltttte" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv4484"e stu8ents are no theor0 |ated ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Lasred aurthe s,da4< The 1">I6erv373 me stu8ents are no theo9 |ated4ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">quite movsth"B-r otorssingalalrcledgarerrentcognis”ttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv277 me stu8ents are no theo8 |ated2ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Polc nstrucdus in conserva-red aurthe sttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv2194"e stu8ents are no theo7 |ated1ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Scmemmode-con ocmemmottendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv2079"e stu8ents are no theo6 |ated1ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Réinvure rc mé ologoepulendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv1399"e stu8ents are no theo5 |ated0ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Lasred aurthe s ll"scènode-clandculliaulendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv1229"e stu8ents are no theo4 |ate09ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Lrucdne dmi wd l d red aurthe sttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv1084"e stu8ents are no theo3 |ate09ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Lingmi%)urll d f raell e f rxttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv58"e stu8ents are no theo2 |ate08ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">R) ar/div> el scrs-> erl d red aurthe sttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv88"e stu8ents are no theo1 |ate07ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Oeirtslaingd conœuvp asaingd cttendanidss=" ="ltss="tspttte" dir="ltr" getScourse Ithersidget="ltte" dir="ltr" ul= itherpan="ltttte" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv5012"e stu8ents are no theoHS |flec7ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Ea substanurreR of an actfod movsthe s-R otorthe sttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv481 me stu8ents are no theoEGG 5 |ated6ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Fgs sepub It inclucAtextyoulcaouvervieplian in conservattendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv4506"e stu8ents are no theoHS |fJuianted ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">TerovneededRostrhMarijnliaattendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv4206"e stu8ents are no theoHS |fted4ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">qand studod movsthe s-R otorthe sttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv3897me stu8ents are no theoEGG 4 |fted4ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Fgs sepub It inclucAtextyoulcaouvervieplian in conservattendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv3508"e stu8ents are no theoHS |fted3ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">od movsthe s/aChe re assignCrcnoraisnpulendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv3355"e stu8ents are no theoHS |fted3ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">D l ingd cde-cd l d naiv id=endanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv3051"e stu8ents are no theoEGG 3 |fted3ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Fgs sepub It inclucAtextyoulcaouvervieplian in conservattendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv2922"e stu8ents are no theoHS |flec3ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Le f rx,l ingdraddgn,ccoeeli red aurth)urttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv2542"e stu8ents are no theoEGG 2 |ated2ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Fgs sepub It inclucAtextyoulcaouvervieplian in conservattendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv2314"e stu8ents are no theoHS |flec2ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Lasred aurthe s deplœuvp asaingd cclanEurop a wtre 1789eeli1815 : prthestru,ier|nsfend/erenjerxttendanidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv1560"e stu8ents are no theoEGG 1 |ated0ttendanibr /nit Fointrodu5r tt ">Fgs sepub It inclucAtextyoulcaouvervieplian in conservattendanidss=" ="ltss="tspttttte" dir="ltr" ge andallItherpan 1">I6erv5ojeced tthersid"widgetsps="tex te" dir="lt andiav shv>< sSr )fo,s an="ltte" dir="ltr" getNewsidget="ltte" dir="ltr" ul ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv99"eCalefo,sidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv101">R)of an epul> ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv9divChrone lepul> ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv164"eLinkpul> ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv763an>The ixml: <="en" <="en">Cno r ofademiattendanidss=" ="ltss="tspttte" dir="ltr" getInwithin tiidget="ltte" dir="ltr" ul ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv179"eurpeactidss=" ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6erv430">Mdgn,clucléga rc eliCréditpul> ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/c!--e e?ofgc=grwithin tipanPub Is ="ltss="tsps="tex te" dir="lt andiavSy dy use scospttte" dir="ltr" getof pro usidget="ltte" dir="ltr" ul ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/c!--e e/msntefo"5e tt n RSS disran>img ne'="RSS disracarcrvimag t/sourse-i in /rss.png" rgthrv16" heli> rv16" /> RSS disrul> ="ltss="tsps="tex te" dir="lt andiavNewsl devepan="ltte" dir="ltr" getNewsl devepidget="ltte" dir="ltr" ul ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/c!--e e/?ofgc=l der ">oeROArtgnewsl deveul> ="ltr"te" dir="ltr">< The 1">I6ervhttp://newsl deve.ectied outs.org">OctiEd outs Newsl deveul> ="ltss="tsps="tex te" dir="lt andlogonbox" log-iscospttte" dir="ltr" fincyfcot rrv5089"hey fou="i anan="ltttte" dir="ltr">< fieldsetn="lttttts" dir="ltr">es woa>ttlbueln="lttttttttte" dir="ltr">"introdu5ranu pes woa>"i and rs wd" namend rs wd" / "nur="ltr">C thelidovntinn="lttttts="tex tttts=fieldsetn="lts=finctsps="text""texte" dir=" andlogosan te" dir="lt ef= hideen">Ino), Bcoa3,tnn srespidget="te" dir="lt ="tspttte" dir="ltr" The 1">I6ervhttps://doaj.org/toc/1784-5092"5e tt n DOAJged fDa, plhxodof Octi Awan Jokthrouan>img ne'="Logo DOAJged fDa, plhxodof Octi Awan Jokthrouacarcrvdocand xe/imag /5206/logo-DOAJ-arclr120.png" rgthrv120" heli> rv26" /nidss= ="ltte" dir="ltr" The 1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/"5e tt n Pscoritng 1 2merprti Scmemmos humrs-rc elisourseeuan>img ne'="OctiEd outs Jokthrouacarcrvimag t/logo- 2merp-org.png" /nidss= ="ss="texte"ir="s="texte" dir=" andodyftheo="te" dir="lt cintrodu5ngs s">E grorone iISSN 1784-5092 p>="te" dir="lt ce 1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/c!--e e/?ofgc=map">Sangamapidss  – n1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/c!--e e/?ofgc=msntefo">Sy dy use sclass="t="te" dir="lt cintrodu5trot"e 1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/">OctiEd outs Jokthrou primaiidss – n1">I6ervhttp://www.lodel.org/">Pub Is f y...)Lodelidss – n1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/c!--e e/lodel/">Abeen 3,tnn sinl class="textand s="text""text""texextan/hingpa>extan/hingpa>extan///hingpa>extan/hingpa>extan/hingpa>extan//I6ervicmcanby">Ci -rom5clas' ); jQtrry( '#cmcanby li' ).css( "mts,on","1em 0" ); } } }); xtan}); //]]n>/hingpa> te" de" dvari_paq = _paq || []; xtan// 3,nter datic"setCu omDed Mson a rnigerabeeusch meayer ca" 3,ntPag View" xtan_paq.push(['setCu omV ie urg', 1, 'Domrs-', eatos co.domrs-, 'ofgc']); xtan_paq.push(['en urgCroerDomrs-Linking']); xtan_paq.push(["setDatos coT tt ", eatos co.domrs- + "/"5+ eatos co.e tt ]); xtan_paq.push([' 3,ntPag View']); xtan_paq.push(['en urgLinkTrrse to']); xtan(fun offr()a{ and variurvhttps://pk.Bcoatlao.org/"; and _paq.push(['setT3,nterUrl', u+'pk.php']); xtan _paq.push(['setSangId', '3']); xtan varid=eatos co, g=d.ctelfeE. Anou('hingpa'), s=d.getE. AnousByTagNaha('hingpa')[0]; xtan g.lypeu'ranu/javahingpa'; g.async=erue; g.g onr=erue; g.arcru+'pk.js'; s.l aantNode.in cotByer c(g,s); xtan})(); xt>/hingpa>xt>!-- E). SiwikrCoder--> extan>/hingpa>extan/hingpa>extan>!-- xtanjQtrry(eatos co).l rey(fun offr($)a{ aif ( $.fn.f thybox ==elivef h f )a{ and $.getSingpa(vhttps://s rthc-origpv.ectied outs.org/js/f thybox/jstrry.f thybox-1.3.1.jua, fun offr()a{ and d $('a.it aha').f thybox(); xtan }); xtan } elt d{ and $('a.it aha').f thybox(); xtan } xtan dradurl= xtan $.juonp({ and url: ('https://drad.ectied outs.org/draddgn, use'), and uschb,ntPa ahants: 'uschb,nt', and acwan :efun offr(n-ca)a{ and d $('#aradn-ca').html('>img arcrv'+n-ca.f vi in+'a>en1">I6erv'+n-ca.url+'a>'+n-ca.name+'clas'); xtan $.ajax({ xtan alype: "GET", xtan aurl: "5089?within=pdfepub&nontcordurl=1", xtan aacwan :efun offr(msg){ xtan a $('#dlLinkp'). thend(msg); xtan } xtan }); xtan }, xtan error:efun offr(n-ca){ xtan //$('#aradn-ca').html('emplo, 1">I6ervhttps://drad.ectied outs.org">st>oiioclas'); xtan $.ajax({ xtan a alype: "GET", xtan a aurl: "5089?within=pdfepub&nontcordurl=1", xtan a aacwan :efun offr(msg){ xtan a $('#dlLinkp'). thend(msg); xtan } xtan }); xtan } }); xtan $('#purtswithe da').tic ('toucddgd', fun offr(e)a{}); xtan $('inpci[namenq]').furse(fun offr()a{ and if ( $(anur). ttr('t or ') ==e'Sf an ' )a{ and $(anur). ttr('t or ', ''); xtan } }); xtan}); jQtrry(eatos co).l rey(fun offr($)a{ $(fun offr()a{ if (eatos co.cooire.indexOf("__cooirealcot=1") ==e-1)a{ $("it For").html("it Fointrodu\"cooireranu\">Byfawan e of cif class t,dhtho,ntlrcledgarerreawanpstancs daidtcooires.6 \vhttp://www.ectied outs.org/6540\">ls.< grwithin ticlass=endanit Fointrodu\"cent cooirealcot\"ss=endan"). ttr("ida, "cooirealcot"). thendTo( "); $("a,.cent cooirealcot").cleck(fun offr()a{ variexpDview=gnew Dvie(); expDvie.setTed (expDvie.getTed ()5+ (365 * 24 * 3600 * 1mh0 ); eatos co.cooirew=g"__cooirealcot=1;expires="5+ expDvie.toGMTStt of()5+ ";domrs-=.ectied outs.org;path=/"; $("#cooirealcot").remove(); }); } }); xtan}); -->t"hingpa>extan< andectib4 dir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://www.ectied outs.org">OctiEd outsclasndir="ir ubs cu nav-toggne-rniwan="ltttttttttttlttttts" dir="ir="ir ="ltr"ir="ir endanOctiEd outs Bese ative En"ltr"ir="ir uln="ltttttttttttltttttttlttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://aese .ectied outs.org">it Fointrodu5r tt ">OctiEd outs Bese ative EBese d tancshumrnaus s iin4aourse ocmemmopul> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://aese .ectied outs.org/ usaloemp">Bese at> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://aese .ectied outs.org/pub Is rpanPub Is erpul> ="ltttttttttttltttttttlttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://aese .ectied outs.org">Furthe Mghwithin ticlass= ="ltr"ir="ir /uln="lttttttts= ="ltr"ir="s" dir="ir="ir ="ltr"ir="ir endanOctiEd outs Jokthrouative En"ltr"ir="ir uln="ltttttttttttltttttttlttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org">it Fointrodu5r tt ">OctiEd outs Jokthrouative EJokthrou d tancshumrnaus s iin4aourse ocmemmopul> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://www.ectied outs.org/ usaloemp-jokthrouanJokthrouat> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/6438">Furthe Mghwithin ticlass= ="ltr"ir="ir /uln="lttttttts= ="ltr"ir="s" dir="ir="ir ="ltr"ir="ir endanCalefo,ative En"ltr"ir="ir uln="ltttttttttttltttttttlttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://calefo,.org">it Fointrodu5r tt ">Calefo,ative EAcade a< iinoun Anousat> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://calefo,.org/arch m">Ainoun Anousat> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://calefo,.org/ifici">Furthe Mghwithin ticlass= ="ltr"ir="ir /uln="lttttttts= ="ltr"ir="s" dir="ir="ir ="ltr"ir="ir="ir ive EHypo osouative En"ltr"ir="ir="ir uln="ltttttttttttltttttttlttttttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://hypo osou.org">it Fointrodu5r tt ">Hypo osouative ER of an abloesat> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://www.ectied outs.org/ usaloemp-i>Bloes usaloempat> ="ltr"ttttttttlt /uln="lttttttts= ="ltr"ir /uln="lttts="tex tttttttttts" dir="ir trot nav-toggne-rniwan="ltttttttttttltte" dir="ltr" ul ubs cuan="ltttttttttttlttttts" dir="ir="ir ="ltr"ir="ir endanNewsl devepeer neerifative En" dir="ltr" ul ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://newsl deve.ectied outs.org">it Fointrodu5r tt ">Newsl deveulive ESubhingdelivmldinriwsl deveul> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttts" dir="ir="ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://of an .ectied outs.org/indexneeri.php?a=dshingpaisnanit Fointrodu5r tt ">Aeerifconsisfbhingpaisnfative EAeeriT confcpat> ="ltr"tttttt /uln="lttttttts= ="ltr"ir="s" dir="ir="ir ="ltr"ir="ir 1">I6ervhttp://www.ectied outs.org/14043">OctiEd outs Free aumclasndir="irtts= ="ltr"ir /uln="lttt="ltr"ir="s" dir="ir=" align-rli> an="ltttttttttttlttttts" dir="ir="ir fincyfcot rrv//of an .ectied outs.org/"hey fou="getan="ltttttttttttlttttttttts" dir="ir="ir>< fieldsetn="ltttttttttttttttlttttttttts" dir="ir="ir><="<"tex ttttltttttttttttttttlttttttttts" dir="ir="ir><="an inpcianamendq"alypeu5ranu"i/ "nur="ltr"><="anan inpcialypeu5roacots and heookthroroacotsnamendul"ft or rvhttp://ookthrou.ectied outs.org/c!--e e" checkeandcheckea" / "nur="ltr">ttedookthroidlbueln
    inbuelothendectied outsroacot>d tOctiEd outscllbueln="lttttttttttttttttt ="tex ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttlttttttttts" dir="ir="ir><="aniovntin Sypeu5submiu"introdu5i in i in-arch m"> endanSf an ttendanidovntinn="lttttttttttt ="tex tttttttttts=fieldsetn="lttttttts=finctsptttttt ="tex tttt ="tex tt ="tex ="tex ttttte" dir iv> ext nav-toggne-rniwan="ltttttte" dir=" ntrodu5r tt -rnarpan="ltttttttttttte" dir="lt =" ubs cuan="ltttttttttttlttttts" dir="ir=" bg-iavan dir="ir="ir><="anit Fointrodu5i in i in-ghwi"> endanInwithin ti ttendanidive En"ltr"ir="ir="ir="lt ="x ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">T tt : ="tn="ltttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">CeROArt"tddx ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">Cd movsthe s,silia ire s,sred aurthe sta'ueirtsla'rrifatddx ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">Briefly: ="tn="ltttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">="ltttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt "nur="ltr">A m(10otanciplin,s rookthrotoursea hristot handmovsthe s,snsibleetorthe setacilitiexhib outs Engsorkic y ort"tp>="ltttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttatddx ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttatd"x ttttttttttttttttttlttttttttt ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">Pub Is er: ="tn="ltttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">AsaourservatCeROArt"tddx ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">Med um: ="tn="ltttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">É groroneqmpatddx ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">E-ISSN: ="tn="ltttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">1784-5092 ddx ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttatd"x ttttttttttttttttttlttttttttttt ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">Awan : ="tn="ltttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">Octi awan Free aumclddx ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttatd"x ttttttttttttttttttlttttttttttttt ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">I6erv//www.ectied outs.org/2582">R)adds eaih mepRse des”tt> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttttttttttttttttt ="x tttttttttttttt ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ir=" bg-iav trot"ettttttlttttttttttttttttttttt ive EDOI / Rech methottendanttttttlttttttttttttttttttttt ="x ttttttttttttttttttltttttttttttttttttlttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttts" dir="ltr">I6erv5089?within=cmcthe scouif arcgh methid> ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttttttttttttttttt" dir="ltr"> s" dir="ir=" bg-iav trot"s anddlLinkp" ="ltr"ttttttttltttttttlttttttttttttttttttttt" dir="ltr">I6ervhttp://tw Ther.com/ narp? ext=The+P an overvie+R of an + <+C dir=+in+Cd movsthe s%3A+The+Png forma+Aseparat+Trser+at+lit...&url=&via=ectied outssaypa tw Ther ovntin-wr t"> endanTw Therttendanidss=" ="ltr"ttttttttttttttte" dir="lt=" i in i in-facsgese"e 1">I6ervhttps://www.facsgese.com/ narpr.php?u=The+P an overvie+R of an + <+C dir=+in+Cd movsthe s%3A+The+Png forma+Aseparat+Trser+at+lit...&e tt n introdu5facsgese ovntin-wr t"> endanFacsgesettendanidss=" ="ltr"ttttttttttttttte" dir="lt=" i in i in-googne-plus"e 1">I6ervhttps://plus.googne.com/ narp?url=The+P an overvie+R of an + <+C dir=+in+Cd movsthe s%3A+The+Png forma+Aseparat+Trser+at+lit...&e tt n introdu5googne ovntin-wr t"> endanGoogne +ttendanidss=" ="ltr"tt ="x tt ="tex ttttttte" dir=" ntrodu5align-rli> an="lttttttttttts" dir="ir andaradn-ca"> ="tex tt ="tex ="tex ttte" dir ovntin i in i in-iavanidovntinn="lt !--[if lf aIE 9] ="ltr"ir="s" dir nk1 2l auut s eeu" >I6ervhttps://s rthc-origpv.ectied outs.org/ectib4 xt>/html>