Soft, Slow, and Low-cost Architecture: CERF’s Foreign Experts in Morocco (1967-1972)
Résumés
Entre 1967 et 1972, le Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation (CERF) fait fonction d’organisme de conseil et de recherche pluridisciplinaire pour la Direction de l’urbanisme et de l’habitat (DUH) du ministère de l’Intérieur du Maroc. Composé d’ingénieurs, d’architectes, de géographes, d’économistes, de juristes et de sociologues, pour la plupart Français ou Belges, et dirigé par l'influent Alain Masson, ingénieur des Ponts et Chaussées, le CERF fut un pôle d’expertise internationale au Maroc, soutenu par des accords de coopération multilatéraux et bilatéraux.
Cet article retrace l’histoire du CERF, son organisation, ses principaux objectifs et ses programmes. Il est ici présenté comme un élément clé pour repenser l’héritage peu étudié de la Coopération dans l’histoire de l’architecture, ainsi que les stratégies de construction de logements à bas coût (censées répondre à ce qui était alors perçu comme les problématiques spécifiques de ce qu’on appelait le « tiers-monde »), au travers des notions d’architecture douce (soft architecture), inspirée de l’architecture vernaculaire, et de développement progressif (slow). Cela fait du CERF une « zone de contact » singulière après l’indépendance, au sein de laquelle différentes conceptions de « l’habitat pour le plus grand nombre » ont pu être formulées et confrontées, entre collaboration et tensions entre experts étrangers, architectes marocains nouvellement formés et responsables locaux.
Entrées d’index
Index de mots-clés :
développement, expert, échange transnational, modernisme du tiers-monde, urbanisme postcolonialIndex by keyword:
development, expert, transnational exchange, third-world modernism, postcolonial urban planningIndex chronologique :
XXe sièclePlan
Haut de pageTexte intégral
Introduction
- 1 We refer in this text to “foreign experts” as a generic term commonly used in English-language lite (...)
- 2 We refer notably to the growing scholarly attention to “architecture in development” and “architect (...)
- 3 See for instance recent scholarship which includes Sheila Crane, “Algerian Socialism and the Archit (...)
1In the context of the post-independence period in the 1950s and 1960s, new entanglements between nation-building, the expanding discourse of “Development,” emerging bilateral cooperation agendas, and strengthening ties with international organizations facilitated new forms of circulation of architects as foreign experts in what was then referred to as the Third World.1 Focusing on the Moroccan case, this paper contributes to the emerging literature on these intersections2 and to the growing interest in the trajectories and practices of foreign architects in the post-independence Maghreb,3 by analyzing not a single architect trajectory but on a research center—the “Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche, et de formation” (hereafter CERF)—that was directly embedded in the apparatus of the newly independent state and that brought together various types of foreign experts and, to a lesser extent, Moroccan professionals.
- 4 Briefly named the Direction de l’aménagement du territoire (DAT) in 1967 when it was transferred to (...)
2From 1967 to 1972, the CERF served as a research and advisory body to the Department of Urban Planning and Housing [Direction de l’urbanisme et de l’habitat (DUH)], a new institution established in 1967 within the Moroccan Ministry of Interior.4 Described by some Moroccan architects as a “foreign ghetto” within the DUH, this multidisciplinary research center was initially composed almost entirely of foreign technical experts, mainly French and Belgian, including engineers, architects, geographers, economists, jurists, and sociologists.
- 5 Today, the CERF reports are primarily housed in the library and archives of the ministère de l’Amén (...)
- 6 For a more detailed account of the role of the Service de l’urbanisme, see Lahbib El Moumni’s contr (...)
3Until its dissolution in 1972, following the creation of the Ministry of Urbanism, Housing, and the Environment (MUHE), the CERF functioned as a key research institution and platform for debate on architecture, urban planning, and rural development. Although short-lived, the CERF was highly productive during this period, producing and submitting over one hundred reports of varying scope and significance.5 It represented a pivotal moment in architectural and urban research in Morocco and can be regarded as the first major post-independence initiative to critically reassess the practices, imaginaries, and policies implemented during the so-called “Écochard period” at the end of the Protectorate (a period named after the prominent French urban planner Michel Écochard, who directed Morocco’s Service de l’urbanisme from 1947 to 1953).6
- 7 Some recent works—notably those by the authors featured in this issue of ABE Journal (Daniel Willif (...)
- 8 Such as Johnson’s report for the Ford Foundation. Katherine Marshall Johnson, Urbanization in Moroc (...)
- 9 A significant issue is the potential bias in their accounts, which underscores the value of oral hi (...)
- 10 While in Morocco (between 1966 to the end of 1970), Dethier began writing a study on the history of (...)
- 11 Mekki Bentahar, L’aménagement du territoire au Maroc, PhD thesis, Université de Provence, Aix-en-Pr (...)
- 12 For instance: Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” in Jacques Bourdillon (ed.), Les ingénieurs des (...)
- 13 Among others: Abderrafih Lahbabi, Changement social et aliénation en architecture: rapport de l’arc (...)
4The state of the literature on the CERF is notably limited,7 with the most substantial contributions emerging from international surveys at the time8 or directly from former CERF members and collaborators, such as Jean Dethier, Michèle Jolé, Mekki Bentahar, Lahcen Brouksy, Jean Hensens, and Alain Masson.9 The case of the Belgian architect Jean Dethier is particularly noteworthy, as he wrote extensively about his time in Morocco and made efforts to publish a book on the history of twentieth-century urbanism and architecture in Morocco, which would have included the postcolonial CERF period (although the book was ultimately never published).10 In the cases of Bentahar, Brouksy, and Jolé, their doctoral theses in France were derived from their experiences at the CERF.11 Masson and Hensens, two of the most prominent figures at CERF (being among the few foreign experts who remained throughout the lifetime of the agency), also wrote and published several papers reflecting on their work at the research center.12 In addition, more information about CERF can be found in Moroccan master and doctoral dissertations from the 1970s and 1980s in French universities. Some are particularly insightful, while others largely repeat CERF’s own work.13
- 14 Janet L. Abu-Lughod, Rabat: Urban Apartheid in Morocco, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, (...)
- 15 Her understanding of Rabat in terms of “urban segregation” is in fact directly derived from the wor (...)
5Janet Abu-Lughod’s seminal work in 1980 on “urban apartheid” in the city of Rabat is also worth mentioning.14 Her pioneering research is notable not only for its early adoption of a postcolonial approach (highlighting the spatial segregation policies shaped by caste and class dynamics during the colonial period and the transformations in the modalities of this segregation after independence), but also for its analysis of post-independence urban transformations that include the work of CERF. In fact, her initial fieldwork in Rabat, initiated in 1971 with funding from the Ford Foundation, benefited greatly from local collaborations with researchers affiliated with CERF, underscoring the links between international interests and local research initiatives.15
- 16 This study draws on various types of archives that I identified or assembled during my ongoing thes (...)
- 17 Since 2021, interviews have been conducted with a dozen former CERF members and half a dozen former (...)
- 18 As Jean-Robert Henry observed in one of the few studies focusing on oral histories collected from f (...)
- 19 On the concept of “contact zone” in recent architectural historiography: Tom Avermaete and Cathelij (...)
6Drawing on this body of literature, archival sources,16 and interviews,17 this paper examines CERF’s history both as a site for rethinking the still understudied legacy of the “cooperation years”18 in Morocco’s architectural historiography, and as a space in which different imaginaries of how housing strategies—intended to address what were perceived as the specific challenges of the so-called “Third World”—were formulated and contested. The paper first considers the creation of the CERF and the diversity of foreign expertise it attracted, taking the case of CERF as an illustrative “contact zone”19 between different forms of foreign expertise in architecture and urban planning, as well as a space of interaction and/or conflict with the country’s newly graduated Moroccan architects. It then examines the CERF’s organizational structure, its agendas, and the objectives it was assigned, interrogating housing strategies that increasingly sought low-cost solutions, notably through self-help construction approaches inspired by vernacular (“soft”) architecture and through incremental (“slow”) development, in which certain development steps were postponed.
A foreign post-independence contact zone
- 20 Michel Rousset, “Le rôle du ministère de l’Intérieur et sa place au sein de l’administration maroca (...)
- 21 General Mohamed Oufkir (1920-1972) was a central figure in Moroccan politics and military during th (...)
- 22 Mounia Bennani-Chraïbi, “Chapitre 2 – Les luttes politiques de l’indépendance : des échanges de cou (...)
- 23 Katherine M. Johnson, Urbanization in Morocco, op. cit. (note 8), p. 10; Michel Rousset, “Le rôle d (...)
7The CERF was established in 1967 under the Moroccan Ministry of Interior during the formulation of the 1968-72 five-year plan. It reflected a notable transition, with the responsibility for architecture and urban planning shifting from the technical Ministry of Public Works to the more political Ministry of Interior.20 It occurred concurrently with the rise of the infamous General Oufkir,21 who served as Minister of Interior from 1964 to 1971, when he was seeking to consolidate his influence within the state apparatus. This concentration of power must be understood in light of the particularly tense socio-political context of the time, marked notably by the urban social uprisings of 1965 and the subsequent climate of repression and increased authoritarianism (declaration of a state of emergency, suspension of Parliament by King Hassan II, suppression of dissent, etc.).22 In this sense, the CERF can be seen as one of the tools used to strengthen the power of this “super-ministry” (as Johnson referred to it), which centralized issues of control, territorial planning, and architecture within a single institution.23
- 24 Jean-Luc Bodiguel, “La DATAR: quarante ans d’histoire,” Revue française d’administration publique, (...)
- 25 Ben Clark and Axel Fisher, “The WFP 1968-72 Rural Housing Program in Morocco,” op. cit. (note 7).
- 26 From its first session in 1963, the United Nations Housing, Building and Planning Committee identif (...)
8In a similar vein to France’s Délégation à l’aménagement du territoire et à l’action régionale (DATAR), established in 1963,24 Morocco appears to have recognized in 1967 the need for a research center that could operate with a certain degree of autonomy, fostering creativity and initiative in regional planning rather than merely executing predefined policies. The urgency of establishing such an operational and research-oriented entity capable of addressing territorial planning in a holistic manner was particularly evident because the CERF was set up at a time when the Moroccan government was negotiating with the United Nations World Food Programme (WFP) to implement the Rural Housing Program.25 This program’s ambitions and large-scale nature highlighted the need to establish an institution like the CERF to facilitate its implementation and, many of the CERF’s studies were aligned with the program’s deployment throughout Morocco. As such, the creation of the CERF follows the United Nations recommendations to promote and support the establishment of national research centers equipped to address issues related to housing and territorial planning.26
- 27 Urbanisme, habitat et aménagement régional: une nouvelle stratégie. Principes d’action et applicati (...)
- 28 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12), p. 327.
9Nevertheless, the CERF was not limited to this WFP Rural Housing Program or large-scale regional planning alone. Its broader mandate was to find ways to reduce housing construction costs and to “define new methods, techniques, and procedures for planning and housing” in Morocco,27 encompassing territorial studies, experimental pilot programs, training, and surveys addressing a wide range of issues, including technical, material, urbanistic, sociological, and architectural considerations. Hence, the CERF quickly came to be known as the DUH’s “think tank” [boîte à idées].28
- 29 Alain Masson (1927-2013) was a French engineer graduate of the École nationale des ponts et chaussé (...)
- 30 On the importance of French Ponts et Chaussées engineers after independence in a postcolonial conte (...)
- 31 On this resettlement project in the Daoudiate district of Marrakesh, known as BTS62 (for béton de t (...)
- 32 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12).
- 33 Interviews with Jean Dethier (22 July 2022) and François Perrin (20 June 2022).
- 34 Michèle Jolé, Nature et fonction d’un outil de planification, op. cit. (note 11), p. 95-96.
- 35 Jean Hensens, “Le CERF,” (Maroc). Ministère de l’urbanisme, de l’habitat et de l’environnement, 197 (...)
10The CERF's most influential figure was its director, Alain Masson,29 a French ingénieur des Ponts et Chaussées30 (civil engineer) who held significant influence within the DUH during the 1960s and 1970s. Masson was in Morocco from 1961 to 1973 as part of the French technical cooperation program. He attracted the attention of national officials after overseeing a major resettlement project between 1962 and 1965 in Marrakesh for the Ministry of Public Works.31 In 1967, he was appointed to head the technical service of the DUH (including the CERF) after Gilbert Mailhebiau stepped down as director. Masson’s recruitment to CERF seems to have been orchestrated by Maati Jorio, then Secretary-General of the Ministry of Interior, who would later become a prominent Moroccan diplomat and eventually Morocco's ambassador to the United States.32 Jorio and Masson maintained a close working relationship and appear to have been the key figures guiding the CERF’s activities, with occasional involvement from Minister Oufkir, who would personally visit the research center from time to time.33 The involvement of these prominent state figures highlights the central role the CERF would come to play in shaping Morocco’s territorial planning and housing policy during this period. It is also indicative of the CERF’s relative independence from the DUH. For example, the CERF had its own budget and, more visibly, its own offices, separate from those of the DUH.34 In fact, the CERF’s position within the Ministry was somewhat unclear. Although it was part of the technical division and worked sometimes with other DUH departments (the central one and regional delegations), it maintained a great deal of autonomy within the administrative system, where it was never fully integrated.35
- 36 Lahcen Brouksy, Ma vie, Sa Majesté Hassan II, Driss Basri et moi, Rabat : Bouregreg, 2016, p. 68-75 (...)
- 37 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12).
- 38 Saâd Benzakour, Essai sur la politique urbaine au Maroc, 1912-1975 : sur le rôle de l’État, op. cit (...)
- 39 Fathallah Oualalou, L’assistance étrangère face au développement économique du Maroc, Casablanca: É (...)
- 40 Fathallah Oualalou, “Point de vue du tiers-monde,” Esprit, vol. 394, 1970, p. 151-158. URL : https: (...)
11Although Mohamed Daoudi, a Moroccan engineer, was the official head of the DUH during the CERF period, foreign experts like Masson exerted substantial influence in decision-making on politically sensitive matters. As Moroccan jurist Lahcen Brouksy wrote in his autobiographical book about his time at CERF, “Masson controlled Moroccan urban planning over the heads of those [Moroccans] in charge of this sector.”36 Masson himself wrote that during his time at the CERF, he had the opportunity to “rethink everything from scratch” and enjoyed considerable freedom of action, illustrating the trust placed in him by the Ministry in shaping the DUH's policies.37 This situation exemplifies a common trend in 1960s Morocco, where foreign technical advisers wielded significant power, even though formal leadership positions were held by Moroccan nationals: “Those who are supposed to ‘assist’ Moroccans in the management of state affairs are in fact those who hold the most responsibility, in terms of both conception and management.”38 Moroccan intellectuals did not remain silent in the face of this situation. An important figure in this critique was the economist and future politician Fathallah Oualalou, who analyzed the impact of foreign technical assistance on Morocco’s post-independence economic development in his 1968 doctoral dissertation.39 In an article published in the 1970 issue of the French journal Esprit entitled Les coopérants et la coopération, he criticized a managerial [gestionnaire] approach to assistance rather than one that focused on training new Moroccan elite. He deplored for instance the fact that, most of the time, “the coopérants take the place of Nationals to carry out their own work, not to train those who can replace them.”40
Figure 1: Diagrams drawn by K.M. Johnson for the Ford Foundation in 1970.
Diagrams showing CERF's central place in the DUH, and the importance of the Ministry of Interior in matters relating to architecture and urban planning.
Source: Katherine Marshall Johnson, Urbanization in Morocco: An International Urbanization Survey Report to the Ford Foundation, New York, NY: Ford Foundation, 1972.
Figure 2: Photograph of the key figures responsible for architecture and territorial planning policy during the CERF period.
The photograph, taken during a preparatory meeting for the 1973-1977 plan, is indicative of the period of cooperation. At the center, Maati Jorio (Secretary-General of the Ministry of Interior) is seen surrounded on one side by French cooperants: Coulomb on the far left (former head of the Technical Bureau of the CUH) and Masson (Technical Director at the DUH, and head of the CERF). On the other side are three Moroccan officials from the DUH: Daoudi (Director of the DUH), a person we couldn't identify, and then Ben Jelloun on the far right (who would later head the DEP after the CERF).
Source: Rabat (Morocco), Archives du Maroc, Collection Alain Masson, Folder no. 50.
- 41 Ben Clark and Axel Fisher, “The WFP 1968-72 Rural Housing Program in Morocco,” op. cit. (note 7).
- 42 François Pacquement, Histoire de la coopération technique: une généalogie d’Expertise France, Paris (...)
- 43 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12).
- 44 Łukasz Stanek, Architecture in Global Socialism: Eastern Europe, West Africa, and the Middle East i (...)
12When the CERF was established in 1967, it appears that the ministry recognized that the success of the research center and the associated WFP Rural Housing Program hinged on its ability to attract foreign experts capable of collaborating effectively with their Moroccan counterparts.41 Like many newly independent countries, Morocco faced a severe shortage of expertise and funding. Under colonial rule, advanced education and training were typically reserved for the colonizers and conducted in metropolitan France, leaving newly sovereign states highly dependent on external technical assistance in the initial decades following independence.42 The CERF exemplified this enduring dependency, as it was deliberately structured to serve as a “reception center” for the various forms of foreign expertise available to Morocco,43 and quickly became a key node in the “worldmaking of architecture” (to borrow Łukasz Stanek’s expression)44 in Morocco.
- 45 This is the case, for example, of the five landscape and urban planners (Jean Challet, Lucien Gendr (...)
- 46 Note sur le programme d’habitat rural dans le cadre d’opérations de mise en valeur régionale, (Maro (...)
13The establishment of the CERF also signified the departure of the preceding generation of foreign architects who had worked throughout the late Protectorate period. Most of them returned to France during the late 1950s or the mid 1960s.45 At its inception in late 1967 and early 1968, the CERF team was composed of a modest cohort of foreign architects that had been formerly engaged in professional activities in Morocco within the Ministry of Public Works but had not worked in Morocco during the Protectorate. This inaugural cohort—made up in early 1968 of six architect-urbanists from France and Belgium, along with one Moroccan46—defined the CERF’s fundamental objectives and actions under Masson’s direction, before the team rapidly expanded.
- 47 Demande d’assistance adressée au Programme des Nations Unies pour le Développement, fonds spécial P (...)
- 48 A key figure in the establishment of the CERF was Belgian diplomat Suzanne Vervalcke. Between 1966 (...)
14Between 1967 and 1969, requests to strengthen technical assistance were submitted to the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), the Ford Foundation,47 and, through bilateral agreements, the governments of Belgium and France.48 The CERF team was also shaped by significant national funding, which led to the recruitment of several foreign members on so-called “local contracts” (foreigners employed directly by the ministry, paid as if they were Moroccans). This diverse range of national recruitment sources and opportunities available in the international aid context enabled the CERF to expand significantly in 1968 and 1969, eventually becoming a team of more than twenty professionals by 1970.
- 49 Michèle Jolé, Nature et fonction d’un outil de planification, op. cit. (note 11), p. 316-317.
- 50 See the article by Tifawt Loudaoui in this issue about the M’diq village de vacances, built with th (...)
- 51 Société centrale pour l’équipement du territoire-Coopération, La S.C.E.T. Coop au Maroc, 1969.
- 52 Interview with Jean-Paul Garcia (27 September 2024).
- 53 Some of the archives are now held in the CDC archives in Paris, where we were able to find informat (...)
- 54 La S.C.E.T. Coop au Maroc, op. cit. (note 51).
15In particular, the support of the Société centrale pour l’équipement du territoire-Coopération (SCET-Coop that would become SCET-International in 1969), a subsidiary of the French Caisse des dépôts et consignations (CDC), proved crucial.49 Since 1959, the SCET had provided the Moroccan administration with engineers for infrastructure or agricultural development projects, as well as urban planners and architects, who contributed to initiatives such as rural housing research, urban development plans, and tourism projects.50 They also played a major role in the reconstruction of Agadir.51 In 1969, through the involvement of the SCET, French civil engineer Jean-Paul Garcia was seconded to CERF on a part-time basis to recruit additional staff.52 The SCET not only facilitated the extension of the stay of certain foreign personnel who agreed to remain in Morocco beyond their initial period of civil service but also provided a wide range of experts. According to the archives of the Caisse des dépôts et consignations in Paris, 17 people were recruited for the CERF in this way,53 including French architects and planners such as Pierre Clément, Jean-Pierre Gutknecht and Paul Fridé.54
- 55 The Service National de la Coopération (SNC), established in France in 1965, offered an alternative (...)
- 56 On the role of the first Peace Corps volunteer architects in Morocco, please refer to: Maristella C (...)
16Another important source of recruitment consisted of foreign graduates who opted to fulfill their mandatory national service in Morocco instead of serving in the military. This opportunity was notably available to Belgian and French citizens,55 and through the Peace Corps Volunteer (PCV) program in the United States. In fact, the CERF hosted part of the very first group of PCV architects sent to Morocco.56 It enabled the hiring of two young American volunteers, architects Dennis Krause and George Chu, to work at the CERF for a duration of two to three years. Others PCVs architect were spread around the regional and central offices of the DUH. For these newly graduated architects, volunteering abroad was a way of avoiding the draft for the Vietnam War. This underscores the fact that a portion of the CERF’s personnel were individuals actively seeking ways to avoid military service. And that, apart from a few more experienced foreign staff, most of these international volunteers were quite young, fresh from university. They quickly took on significant responsibilities that they probably would not have been entrusted with had they remained in their home countries.
- 57 In the late 1960s, the Moroccan government asked the UNDP to provide them with three planners to he (...)
- 58 Vodislav Kravis, Système de financement et d’imposition communal 1974 (préparé pour le Gouvernement (...)
17During the expansion of the team, the CERF also benefited from more advanced expertise through multilateral assistance. Jan Kratochvil, a Czech expert from the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), was assigned to the CERF and played a significant role in shaping rural planning policies in Morocco.57 While other UNDP experts were involved in the implementation of the WFP Rural Housing Program, Kratochvil appears to have been the only one working directly for the CERF as an urban planner. In 1972, he was joined at the CERF by Vodislav Kravis, a Yugoslav expert from the UNDP.58 However, Kravis arrived when the CERF was already close to dissolution.
- 59 The USSR became an important training ground for many Moroccan architects at the time, such as Moro (...)
- 60 We have not yet been able to establish exactly how many architects were sent abroad on state schola (...)
- 61 During the 1960s, the 4 regional DUH delegations created at the time of the Protectorate were still (...)
- 62 In the summers of 1969 and 1970, for example, around a hundred students from various disciplines (a (...)
- 63 At CERF, geographer Alain Billon (a future French politician) was in charge of examining how to dev (...)
18Moreover, as its name suggests, the CERF aimed to foster “training” [formation] within the broader context of the Moroccanization of the DUH’s personnel. At the turn of the 1970s, the number of Moroccan architects was very limited, with all of them educated abroad. The majority were trained in Paris at the École spéciale d’architecture, but some were educated at other architecture schools, in France, Belgium, and the USSR for instance.59 The CERF period (1967-1972) saw an increase in the number of Moroccan students attending architecture schools abroad thanks to State grants that often required them, upon completion of their studies, to serve for several years for the Moroccan State.60 Upon returning to Morocco, these young architects began to replace European staff, gradually leading to the Moroccanization of key positions, such as the directors of regional delegations within the DUH, who held significant power during this period.61 Therefore, the CERF was established when training qualified local professionals was both urgent and essential. This need was reflected in studies focused on developing architectural education in Morocco and in the organization of summer internships for Moroccan architecture students.62 Training became a central aspect of CERF’s agenda, leading to collaborations with existing universities in Morocco and initiating feasibility studies for the implementation of training programs for architects and urban planners in the country.63 As such, the CERF reflects a period of transition, a decade before the establishment of the first schools of architecture and urban planning in Morocco, the École nationale d’architecture (ENA) in 1980 and the Institut national d’architecture et d’urbanisme (INAU) in 1981.
- 64 Trainee Moroccan architects at CERF included for instance Rachid Sabounji (a 1969 graduate of the M (...)
- 65 Note sur le programme d’habitat rural dans le cadre d’opérations de mise en valeur régionale, (Maro (...)
- 66 See his autobiographical book, in which he writes that when he first joined the CERF he was “the on (...)
19On this matter, the CERF demonstrates an ambivalence between the push for Moroccanization and the reliance on international aid and foreign expertise. Paradoxically, the agency served as a critical entry point for many newly graduated Moroccan architects, providing them with their first connections to research projects and experimental initiatives in Morocco, whether through summer internships or initial professional experiences.64 A report from the Ministry of Interior noted for instance that “six Moroccan architects are due to complete their studies abroad in July 1968, and it is planned to distribute them between the CERF and the [DUH] regional delegations.”65 Nevertheless, there were an overall lack of Moroccan participation in key positions at the research center, which certainly contributed to tensions and frustration among young Moroccan architects returning to the country. Lahcen Brouksy, a legal expert, appears to have been one of the only Moroccans truly employed at the CERF (in the legal department) as early as 1969.66 He was gradually joined by other Moroccans, such as sociologist Mekki Bentahar, as well as other legal experts, including Abdelsadek Rabiah (who later became Secretary General of the Government). The CERF thus underwent a kind of Moroccanization, especially from 1971 onwards. However, the core team at its creation—responsible for defining its guiding principles under the leadership of Maati Jorio—was predominantly French, with Belgians occupying important posts (architects Jean Hensens and Jean Dethier in particular).
- 67 Interview with Mohammed Benelkhadir (Rabat, 28 October 2022) and Abderrafih Lahbabi (Rabat, 23 May (...)
- 68 Michèle Jolé, Nature et fonction d’un outil de planification, op. cit. (note 11), p. 251.
- 69 Interview with Mohammed Benelkhadir (Rabat, 28 October 2022).
20According to Mohamed Benelkhadir and Abderrafih Lahbabi—both Moroccan architects and former regional urban planning inspectors of the Rabat region in the 1960s and 1970s—Moroccan architects did indeed question the utility and legitimacy of a new study center that expanded the existing DUH framework.67 This criticism—often labeling the CERF as a “foreigners’ ghetto” [ghetto d’étrangers], a term informally used by several Moroccan architects we interviewed—was closely linked to the emergence of this new generation of young Moroccan architects primarily educated in France and influenced by the ideas of May 1968. Sociologist Michèle Jolé, who worked in Morocco during the CERF period, recalls that it was a time marked by contestation, “when student and teacher protests were spreading across universities and high schools, and when the coopérant was viewed with suspicion.”68 This climate led young Moroccan architects to organize themselves into associations and to challenge the presence of foreign professionals occupying key institutional positions.69
Soft, Slow, and Low-Cost
- 70 Alain Masson, “Urbanisation et habitat du grand nombre: l’approche marocaine,” op. cit. (note 12); (...)
- 71 For more details on self-help housing in Morocco: Ben Clark, “Le mythe du Castor marocain: pratique (...)
- 72 Alain Masson, “Note générale (sur la politique de l’État en matière d’aménagement du territoire, d’ (...)
21The creation of CERF must also be contextualized within the broader political discourse surrounding the state’s evolving perspective on social and low-cost housing. During this period, the Moroccan Ministry of Interior came to recognize its inability to resolve the housing crisis through direct, state-led construction.70 As a result, the 1968-72 five-year plan drastically reduced public funding for state-led housing construction, promoting the private sector and assisted self-help construction instead.71 In this context, the CERF was tasked with developing low-cost construction standards and models, experimenting with more affordable materials and techniques (including “traditional” methods), and studying the cost-efficiency of various construction approaches. According to Masson, it was a matter of “pursuing technological research for the benefit of an economic habitat adapted to the country’s resources, its history, Muslim civilization, the population’s income and way of life.”72
Figure 3: Extract from the newspaper La Vigie marocaine, 12 February 1970.
Source: Brussels (Belgium), Université libre de Bruxelles, Collection Jean Hensens.
- 73 Jean Hensens, “Le CERF,” op. cit. (note 35). This was also mentioned in the interviews we had with (...)
- 74 Alain Masson, “Fonctions du CERF,” (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, (...)
22To address this wide range of concerns, the CERF was conceived as a space where research, documentation, training, and experimentation would fluidly intersect. Although its organizational structure never fully materialized into a clearly defined framework and was characterized in practice by a certain horizontality,73 the CERF was officially established at the end of 1967 with three distinct sections that help us clarify the roles it would later fulfill.74
- 75 Jean Hensens (1929-2006) was a Belgian architect who worked in Morocco for several decades from 196 (...)
- 76 For instance, CERF French sociologist Stacia Hensens engaged in numerous collaborative interdiscipl (...)
- 77 Regarding the interplay between human and social sciences, urban planning and architecture in post- (...)
- 78 Jean Hensens, Stacia Hensens and Denis Krause, L’habitat économique au Maroc, (Maroc). Centre d’exp (...)
- 79 Two of the main architects of the original CERF team, the Frenchmen Gérard Bauer and Bernard Hambur (...)
- 80 Daniel Pinson, Modèles d’habitat et contre-types domestiques au Maroc, Tours: Urbama, 1992 (Urbanis (...)
23The first section, “Studies of Environments and Needs” [Études des milieux et besoins], led by Belgian architect Jean Hensens,75 was primarily dedicated to assessing housing needs through studies and surveys of bidonvilles (shantytowns), “traditional” housing, rural dwellings and economic habitats. One notable outcome of this research was the strengthening of the interdisciplinary dialogue between the social sciences and architecture,76 reflecting a broader interest in France during the 1950s and 1960s in urban sociology, survey methodologies, and interdisciplinary research-driven approaches to housing and urban planning.77 This shift led the CERF to critically reassess the major housing projects developed during the late colonial period by the Service de l’urbanisme. For example, moving beyond a sole focus on “traditional” housing or slums to engage with the issue of appropriation, the CERF initiated what appears to be one of the first architectural-sociological studies to examine how residents appropriated various models of social and low-cost housing constructed at that time, such as the Écochard 8x8m grid habitats (fig. 4).78 This approach has some parallels to Philippe Boudon’s 1969 study of French modern housing in Pessac, and it is worth noting that Boudon himself maintained close ties with some CERF members.79 It prefigures the many studies that followed, focusing on how low-cost housing was re-appropriated by inhabitants in Morocco.80
Figure 4: CERF survey on how inhabitants appropriated their state-built housing.
Drawings from a CERF survey directed by Jean and Stacia Hensens in 1971 on the changes and appropriations made by inhabitants of different types of state-built low-cost housing dating back to the “Écochard period.”
Source: Jean Hensens, Stacia Hensens and Dennis Krause, L’habitat économique au Maroc, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1971.
- 81 La notion d’études pluridisciplinaires: conséquences de son introduction en matière d’habitat, d’ur (...)
- 82 Alain Masson, Nouvel esprit des études entreprises en matière d’aménagement d’urbanisme et d’habita (...)
- 83 Katherine M. Johnson, Urbanization in Morocco, op.cit (note 8), p. 73.
- 84 James Ferguson, The Anti-Politics Machine: Development, Depoliticization, and Bureaucratic Power in (...)
- 85 Janet L. Abu-Lughod, Rabat: Urban Apartheid in Morocco, op. cit. (note 14).
24The CERF began more broadly to institutionalize interdisciplinary research, framing the study of housing as a “scientific” endeavor (grounded in quantifiable data, statistical analysis, and comparative methodologies).81 According to Masson, urban planning studies had to account for all potential factors influencing development, and therefore had to be interdisciplinary by nature.82 Yet, as Johnson’s Ford Foundation report noted, although the CERF’s interdisciplinary orientation was commendable, it still veered toward a technocratic perspective that tended to overlook the political, social, and economic implications of the proposed measures: “For example, their reports [of CERF] discuss at length how much land is needed to absorb the bidonvilles; what are ideal densities per hectare, and how many houses must be built. There is less concern with where to build them, how to obtain the land, and how to pay for them.”83 Johnson’s observation echoes a recurring critique in development studies (what James Ferguson termed the “anti-politics machine”) where development initiatives depoliticize structural issues by presenting them as purely technical matters, divorced from their broader political contexts.84 Nonetheless, as Abu-Lughod pointed out in 1980, this quantitative data and the CERF surveys still proved important in understanding the living conditions of Morocco’s poorest inhabitants at the time.85
- 86 About CERF raw-earth experimentations, refer to: Nadya Rouizem Labied, Réinventer la terre crue, op (...)
- 87 David Georges Emmerich (1925-1996) was a Hungarian-born engineer and architect, considered a leadin (...)
- 88 Some of these experiments were published: Gérard Bauer and Jean Dethier, “La terre et le roseau: ou (...)
- 89 David Georges Emmerich, Soft Architecture: essais sur l’autoconstruction, Paris: Institut de l’envi (...)
- 90 Ibid. These experiments, part of a more global movement, were closely linked to experiments in othe (...)
- 91 Interview (November 2022 in Rabat) with Moroccan architect Abderhamane Chorfi, (graduated from the (...)
- 92 Le sous-habitat au Maroc: analyse de la situation et stratégie nouvelle d’intervention, (Maroc). Ce (...)
25The second CERF section, “Study of materials, methods, prices and practical tests” [Étude des matériaux, des méthodes, des prix et des expérimentations], focused primarily on exploring innovative, cost-effective construction methods inspired sometimes by local building practices, particularly utilizing raw earth.86 The most emblematic example of CERF’s technological experimentation was the involvement of Hungarian engineer David George Emmerich (1925-1996), then a professor at UP6 in Paris.87 Emmerich, who had been the teacher of a French architect, Bernard Hamburger—who worked for a short time at the CERF but had considerable influence on the projects developed by the CERF—led experimental workshops in Rabat with architecture students from various countries, using reeds as the primary building material.88 He provocatively argued that: “it seems that the best way to get rid of bidonvilles is not to build bidons [barrels].”89 The Moroccan workshops implemented Emmerich’s theory of “soft architecture,” where geometric patterns, making it possible to construct lightweight, low-lying structures using simple methods of execution, would have helped to “improve” forms of self-construction so that housing could easily and inexpensively be built by local inhabitants.90 Although the reed-based projects became iconic symbols of CERF’s experimental spirit, critics (Moroccan architects and even CERF members) viewed them as signs of a certain naïveté.91 They scoffed at the belief that reed structures could address the complex challenges posed by “insufficient housing” [sous-habitat], as it was referred to at the time.92
Figure 5: Photograph of experiments carried out by CERF in 1968.
Photograph of construction workshops carried out by CERF in 1968 (at the Ferme Lauzey in Salé) using reed cane reinforced with plaster to create partition and roof panels, designed by Hungarian engineer David George Emmerich, then a professor at Unité pédagogique d'architecture (UP6) in Paris and a consultant for CERF.
Source: Edmund Hazzard, La construction en roseau au Maroc, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1968.
Figure 6: Photograph of the same experiment.
Source: Photograph from the private archives of Jean Dethier, published in black and white in: Gérard Bauer and Jean Dethier, “La terre et le roseau: ou la réhabilitation et l’amélioration de techniques traditionnelles de construction au Maroc,” L’Architecture d’aujourd’hui, no. 160, February 1972, p. 104-111.
- 93 On the links between “soft architecture” and counter-cultural movements in the 1960s and 1970s, Car (...)
- 94 Jean Dethier, “Liberté pour les bidonvilles,” in Séminaire sur l’habitat sous-intégré et l’environn (...)
- 95 For instance, “L’architecture douce,” L’Architecture d’aujourd’hui, no. 179, 1975. Regarding these (...)
- 96 Interviews with Jean Dethier (Paris, July 2022).
26However, Emmerich’s concept of “soft architecture” transcended mere construction techniques and instead implied a broader critical stance associated with the counter-cultural movements of the time.93 Here, the reed structure embodied the idea, articulated in Morocco at the time by Dethier and Hensens, that self-construction could potentially give rise to a new urban aesthetic.94 This idea was linked to a wider set of imaginaries advocating participation, self-building, cultural specificity, and diversity of form that were prevalent internationally in the architectural discourse of the period. This context included movements and concepts such as advocacy planning, the “return to the city,” the recognition of informal settlements as legitimate urban forms, DIY (do-it-yourself) architecture, etc.95 Such approaches informed CERF’s work, as evidenced by the major international figures it invited, including Hassan Fathy and John F.C. Turner.96 Although both visited CERF only briefly and were not employed as consultants (unlike Emmerich), their presence underlines the wider international network and intellectual milieu in which the CERF was embedded.
27One manifestation of this approach was its emphasis on grounding architectural and urban projects in local cultural contexts and aspirations. This orientation received notable recognition in 1972 when CERF was awarded the prestigious Sir Patrick Abercrombie Prize by the International Union of Architects (UIA). In its citation, the UIA highlighted CERF’s critical reappraisal of “universalist” ideologies and acknowledged its central role in reshaping the discourse on spatial planning in the early 1970s:
- 97 Note Prix Abercrombie. Rabat (Morocco). Archives du Maroc, Collection Alain Masson, Folder no. 3. T (...)
“Inspired by a desire to break away from universalist urban planning, this work [of the CERF] is guided by the will to recognize and satisfy the specific cultural requirements of each people, and to involve the disadvantaged populations of developing countries in shaping their own space. Moreover, in a country undergoing industrialization, CERF has succeeded in integrating the rural problem into the general planning process and proposing solutions that combine tradition and innovation.”97
- 98 As Dethier told us : “… in the CERF team, the majority of people were in their thirties, so rather (...)
- 99 For instance : Jean Hensens, Ain Chouater. Recasement des sinistrés des inondations du Guir. Créati (...)
- 100 This is obvious from the number of reports, plans, and drawings in the CERF archives, compared with (...)
28This intellectual climate within the CERF was significantly influenced by its predominantly young team, representing a new generation of foreign architects who had not been present in Morocco during the Protectorate.98 It manifested itself architecturally through a critique of designs perceived as regular, monotonous, and readily categorized as imported models rooted in colonial thinking, symbolized in Morocco according to them by the “Écochard grid.” Contrastingly, some CERF studies advocated diversity design, driven by grassroots methods and evolving grammar, to define potential forms of variability in state-led low-cost housing projects.99 These principles became central to the CERF approach, particularly in projects led by Belgian architect Jean Hensens, who emerged as the most influential and prolific architect within the CERF.100
Figure 7: Drawing by Jean Hensens for his CERF report on the restructuration of Rabat-Sud districts.
Drawing by Jean Hensens for the 1971 CERF report on the restructuration of Rabat-Sud districts, where he criticized the monotonous grid approach, claiming it would lead to human standardization. The diagram shows Ecochard's 8x8 grids and improved sanitary grids [trames sanitaires].
Source: Jean Hensens, Rabat-Sud. Reconversion des bidonvilles de Chella, Doum, Maadid-extension, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1971.
Figure 8: Research on “modes of open growth” [mode de croissance libre] by Jean Hensens.
Schematic plan of a neighborhood project for low-cost housing as part of his CERF research for the restructuration of Rabat-Sud districts in 1971.
Source: Brussels (Belgium), Université libre de Bruxelles, Collection Jean Hensens, FJH_D48_C2_3.
- 101 See, for example, Bugnicourt’s glowing review of the Documentation Service’s synthesis and bibliogr (...)
29Finally, the third section of the CERF, the “Documentation Service,” headed by Jean Dethier, another Belgian architect, became a key tool in the dissemination and popularization of the DUH policy—aimed at both Moroccan officials and society at large. It also served as a repository for an extensive collection of documentations, including a library and a large photothèque [photo library] with a collection of aerial photographs taken by the CERF. Together, these resources provided a large corpus of architectural documentation for architects and researchers of the period.101 In this sense, the Service played an important role in the implementation of the CERF's overall project, not only by publishing and making available the CERF's reports, but also by organizing exhibitions (such as an exhibition for the UIA in Agadir in 1968, the Casablanca Fair in 1969 or the Algiers Festival in 1969) as well as short films and television events, and by promoting the CERF’s work in the Moroccan press, both specialized and general (Lamalif, La Vigie Marocaine) (fig. 3) as well as international publications (Jeune Afrique).
- 102 Born in 1942, François Perrin is a French jurist who graduated from the Institute of Political Stud (...)
- 103 Alain Masson, Nouvel esprit des études entreprises en matière d’aménagement d’urbanisme et d’habita (...)
- 104 For a summary of the new architecture, urbanism and ruralism policy promoted by CERF, and a present (...)
30Subsequently, this tripartite organizational structure of the CERF took on a more fluid and contingent form (with teams managed on a project basis), in which the Documentation Service gained greater autonomy. Most notably, in late 1968, a new legal department was created within the CERF. This department, headed by the young French legal expert François Perrin, played a crucial role.102 In 1969, Perrin’s small team drafted the framework law on urban and rural planning, which was at the heart of what Masson called the “new spirit” in planning and architecture.103 This draft for a new dahir [law] informed the national policy implemented in the subsequent five-year plans (1973-77 and 1978-82) and became the CERF’s principal lasting legacy.104 It was the first major reform to overhaul the spatial planning and architectural policies established after independence, with the aim of fundamentally revising the basic texts of urban policy introduced during the Protectorate, which in fact remained mostly unchanged until the 1970s.
- 105 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12). Translated from French by the Author.
- 106 Interview with François Perrin (Paris, 20 June 2022).
- 107 Alain Masson, “Urbanisation et habitat du grand nombre: l’approche marocaine,” op. cit. (note 12).
- 108 On the role of ERACs in Moroccan urban policy, see the article by Lahbib El Moumni in this issue. I (...)
31This reform was seen as essential to go beyond mere technical regulation and to promote a more comprehensive planning policy. Moreover, several CERF members stated that while Morocco had been considered a pioneer in urban planning during the Protectorate, it had fallen behind after independence. As Masson puts it: “In the field of urban planning, Morocco had long seemed exemplary. However, the acceleration of demographic growth and the emerging needs of society called for a complete overhaul of existing approaches.”105 To this end, the new regulatory framework was modeled on the French law of 30 December 1967, Loi d’orientation foncière (LOF), which documented new urban planning instruments that, as Perrin noted, had to be “adapted” to the Moroccan context. For Perrin—and for Masson—“adaptation” was synonymous with simplification, reflecting what they refer to as a “pragmatic” approach aimed at working within Morocco’s urgent conditions by streamlining legislation to ensure its practical implementation.106 The CERF then became intertwined with early discussions of new tools for architecture and spatial planning, such as the first Schéma d’armature rural (SAR) and Schéma directeur (SD).107 The CERF also marked the transition to what was to become the Établissements régionaux d’aménagement et de construction (ERAC) in the 1970s, a period in which the public authorities created specialized agencies responsible for real estate promotion on behalf of and under the supervision of the State, thus shaping much of Morocco’s urban landscape from 1973 onwards.108
- 109 Perrin seems to be referring to Moroccan architects such as Idrissi, Hajjaji, Haggy, etc. who worke (...)
- 110 Interview with François Perrin (Paris, 20 June 2022).
32However, “adaptation” primarily meant accepting gradual rather than immediate development (an idea reflected in our use of the term “slow” in this context). This principle led the CERF to promote the concept of “deferred equipment” for the most disadvantaged sections of the population, at a time when the State had hitherto refrained from selling unequipped plots. This scheme, known as the Progressive or Deferred Equipment Zone [zone d’équipement progressif ou différé (ZEP or ZED)], was based on the principle that the state would provide low-income buyers with minimally equipped plots. Buyers could then settle directly on the land and build their own houses using standard plans provided by the DUH, while gradually paying for both the land and the infrastructure development. Meanwhile, the State would complete the full infrastructure over a period of 5, 10, or even 15 years. This program— which appears never to have been fully implemented—highlighted a point of divergence within the DUH regarding the meaning and direction of “development.” One point of contention within the CERF debates, according to Perrin, was the divergent perspectives between some “young Moroccans” at the DUH, freshly returned from French schools,109 who envisioned a liberated, decolonized Morocco that should immediately adopt practices from Europe and the US, and those, like Perrin or Masson, who advocated a “deferred and gradual approach,” arguing that Morocco was not yet ready for fully “developed models.”110
- 111 Ijlal Muzaffar, Modernism’s Magic Hat, op. cit. (note 84).
33This review of some of CERF’s roles and activities in promoting low-cost housing strategies, experimenting with “soft” architecture and “slow” infrastructure development and, in general, always seeking to do more with less, echoes architectural historian Ijlal Muzaffar’s conceptualization of change and risk management as key dynamics in development aid. What emerges is a belief in what Muzaffar describes as the “holy trinity of change”; the trinity being a “malleable space, sequential time, and magical value.” This trinity encapsulates the contradictions inherent in the simultaneous promise of modernization and the lack of real resources.111 In the case of the CERF, the dynamic seems to manifest itself as follows: (1) through studies of culturally and contextually appropriate housing, the focus is on appropriate spatial organisation (“malleable space”) to meet housing needs; (2) through research such as the use of reeds to encourage self-building, it is argued that the residents themselves will create value (“magical value”) through their efforts without substantial financial support; (3) and finally, through the argument that equipment can be deferred and left incomplete (“sequential time”), the beneficiaries are plunged into an extended timeframe of perpetual transition.
Conclusion: An experiment nipped in the bud
34The dissolution of the CERF in December 1972, prior to the implementation of the following quinquennial plan (1973-1977), left many of its exploratory studies incomplete. From 1972 onwards, the newly established Ministry of Housing, Urbanism, and the Environment (MUHE) created a research center, the Division des études et des programmes (DEP), to replace the CERF. However, the DEP did not possess the same resources or the extensive scope of action that had characterized the CERF.
- 112 Pascale Philifert, “Urban Planning in Morocco: Historical Legacy, Approaches to Urban Policies, and (...)
35The reason of this dissolution remains somewhat unclear but appears to be the result of several converging factors around 1972, coinciding with the creation of the new ministry. Political tensions certainly played a part, particularly after the failed coup d’État of 1972 and the subsequent murder of General Oufkir, since the CERF had been originally set up under the Ministry of Interior when Oufkir was its minister. Another important factor is the Moroccanization of professional positions. The increasing number of Moroccan architects returning from abroad and the growing presence of locally trained professionals gradually reduced the reliance on foreign expertise. In this context, the existence of a research center within the new Ministry composed largely of foreign experts may have been perceived as an anomaly. Its dissolution also coincided with a wider decline in state expertise, which was gradually replaced by the growing influence of foreign private firms in Moroccan urban development.112
- 113 Jean Hensens, “Le CERF,” op. cit. (note 35, note 73).
36The years following the CERF marked a definitive shift toward implementation rather than research, with resources increasingly directed toward operational projects such as master plans and ERAC housing estates. Hensens observed this transition with regret, noting that the CERF, originally envisioned as a center for experimentation, dissemination, research, modeling, and hypothesis formulation, had gradually transformed into a purely operational office.113 This shows that the CERF represented a kind of parenthesis in the history of architecture in Morocco, a unique period during which considerable resources were allocated to research in architecture, urban and rural planning.
- 114 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12).
- 115 Ibid.
37Despite its dissolution, the CERF played a crucial role in shaping the policies of the new ministry, which relied heavily on its studies and proposals to implement rural and urban planning strategies. The ideas debated within the CERF, along with the projects it initiated, continued to inform discussions, particularly in shaping the two subsequent five-year plans. This influence was notably sustained through Masson himself, who, despite returning to France in 1973 after twelve years of collaboration in Morocco, maintained a significant impact. Having directly contributed to the formulation of the 1973-1977 plan (fig. 2), he was later called upon to assist in the implementation of the following plan (1978-1982). As Masson himself noted, “the research and proposals of the CERF were widely utilized” in these planning efforts.114 Additionally, he continued to provide lectures on territorial planning at the École nationale d’administration in Rabat until 1981, dedicating one week per year to discussing the CERF’s proposals.115 This may suggest that the most enduring legacy of the CERF “spirit” in Morocco lay in the textual production it left behind (the collection of “red reports”) but also in the fact that some CERF figures have remained in the country afterwards either continuously, like Stacia and Jean Hensens (who eventually left Morocco in the late 1980s), or more intermittently, like Masson, continued to promote concepts that originated with CERF.
Notes
1 We refer in this text to “foreign experts” as a generic term commonly used in English-language literature. However, it should be understood in a broad sense, encompassing, in our case, many facets of the foreign assistance available at the time, which included volunteers, “coopérants”, experts working for international agencies, or foreign professionals employed by local institutions, among others. It is difficult to categorize all these individuals strictly as “experts,” as in many cases, those called upon to work in this context had no prior professional experience. Nevertheless, the term serves here to highlight the competence and authority attributed to these individuals in specific fields (such as architecture) through their participation in development aid projects.
2 We refer notably to the growing scholarly attention to “architecture in development” and “architecture in the foreign aided economy” in the recent historiography, as exemplified by issues 21-22 of the ABE Journal (Sebastiaan Loosen, Erik Sigge and Helena Mattsson, “Introduction,” ABE Journal. Architecture beyond Europe, no. 21, 2023. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/abe.14412), and work of Aggregate members: Aggregate (ed.), Architecture in Development: Systems and the Emergence of the Global South, Abingdon; New York, NY: Routledge, 2022. For the Moroccan case, see for instance Michele Tenzon and Axel Fisher, “Foreign Aid for Rural Development: Village Design and Planning in Post-Independence Morocco,” Planning Perspectives, vol. 37, no. 5, 2022, p. 949-971. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02665433.2022.2116594; Cathelijne Nuijsink, “The Contact Zone of Agadir’s Emergency Aid Operations,” in Tom Avermaete and Maxime Zaugg (eds.), Agadir: Building the Modern Afropolis, Zurich: Park Books, 2022, p. 69-83.
3 See for instance recent scholarship which includes Sheila Crane, “Algerian Socialism and the Architecture of Autogestion,” Architectural Histories, vol. 7, no. 1, 2019. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/ah.345; Kosuke Matsubara, “Gyoji Banshoya (1930-1998): A Japanese Planner Devoted to Historic Cities in the Middle East and North Africa,” Planning Perspectives, vol. 31, no. 3, 2016, p. 391-423. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02665433.2015.1073610; Amel Zerourou, Gérald Hanning. Pollinisations d’un urbaniste voyageur: contribution à l’étude des circulations et transferts en urbanisme, entre modernité et identité des territoires, PhD thesis, Université Aix-Marseille, 2024; Nancy N. A. Demerdash, Tunisia, 1940-1970: The Spatial Politics of Reconstruction, Decolonization, and Development, Art and Archeology Department, PhD dissertation, Princeton University, 2015; Ben Clark, “Comment ‘devenir traditionnel’? Premiers projets et espoirs de l’architecte Jean Hensens (1929-2006) au Maroc,” CLARA, no. 8, 2024, p. 170-203. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3917/clara.008.0170.
4 Briefly named the Direction de l’aménagement du territoire (DAT) in 1967 when it was transferred to the Ministry of Interior, the DUH had formerly been known as the Circonscription de l'urbanisme et de l'habitat (CUH) under the post-independence Ministry of Public Works. Michel Rousset, “Le rôle du ministère de l’Intérieur et sa place au sein de l’administration marocaine,” Annuaire de l’Afrique du Nord, vol. 7, 1968, p. 91-106. DOI: https://doi.org/10.34847/NKL.9EEBV5TH
5 Today, the CERF reports are primarily housed in the library and archives of the ministère de l’Aménagement du territoire national, de l’urbanisme, de l’habitat, et de la politique de la ville, in Rabat. They were identified by the Author, reclassified according to their original organization, and almost entirely digitized. These reports are commonly termed the “red reports” [rapports rouges]—named after their red binding—which were once accessible at the CERF Documentation Service. In addition to the CERF’s own work, the “red reports” include older reports, primarily from the post-war period, produced by various institutions responsible for housing and urban planning, as well as some reports from international organizations.
6 For a more detailed account of the role of the Service de l’urbanisme, see Lahbib El Moumni’s contribution in this issue. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/14vhe. See also: Jean-Louis Cohen and Monique Eleb, Casablanca: Colonial Myths and Architectural Ventures [First published as Casablanca: mythes et figures d’une aventure urbaine, Paris: Hazan, 1998], New York, NY: Monacelli Press, 2002; Tom Avermaete, Serhat Karakayali et Marion von Osten, Colonial Modern: Aesthetics of the Past Rebellions for the Future, London: Black Dog, 2010.
7 Some recent works—notably those by the authors featured in this issue of ABE Journal (Daniel Williford, Michele Tenzon, Lahbib El Moumni and Nadya Rouizem)—have examined CERF activities. However, these references remain partial and no comprehensive study of the history of the CERF has yet been undertaken. My ongoing doctoral research is a first step in this direction, and this paper is part of a series of earlier publications in which we have analyzed other facets of CERF’s history: Ben Clark, “Comment ‘devenir traditionnel’?,” op. cit. (note 3); Idem, “Le mythe du Castor marocain: pratiques et discours de l’autoconstruction assistée au Maroc (années 1950-1960),” Monde(s), vol. 25, no. 1, 2024, p. 111-135. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3917/mond1.225.0111; Ben Clark and Axel Fisher, “The WFP 1968-72 Rural Housing Program in Morocco,” in Nicholas Ferns and Angela Villani (eds.), Yearbook for the History of Global Development. 3. International Organizations and the History of Global Development, Berlin: De Gruyter, 2024 (Yearbook for the History of Global Development, 3), p. 163-204. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783111280356-007.
8 Such as Johnson’s report for the Ford Foundation. Katherine Marshall Johnson, Urbanization in Morocco. An International Urbanization Survey Report to the Ford Foundation, New York, NY: Ford Foundation, 1972.
9 A significant issue is the potential bias in their accounts, which underscores the value of oral history in critically re-examining these narratives, especially considering the experiences of young Moroccan professionals of that era, offering a more nuanced perspective on the legacy of the CERF.
10 While in Morocco (between 1966 to the end of 1970), Dethier began writing a study on the history of urban planning in Morocco during the Protectorate and after independence. In 1972, following its partial publication (Jean Dethier, “60 ans d’urbanisme au Maroc: l’évolution des idées et des réalisations,” Bulletin économique et social du Maroc, vol. 32, no. 118, 1970, p. 5-56), he was invited to spend a year at Princeton University’s Department of Eastern Studies to complete his research (Jean Dethier, “Evolution of Concepts of Housing, Urbanism, and Country Planning in a Developing Country: Morocco, 1900-1972,” in From Madina to Metropolis: Heritage and Change in the Near Eastern City, Princeton, NJ: Darwin Press, 1973). The original French version of the typescript has been available since 2019 at Rabat (Morocco), Archives du Maroc.
11 Mekki Bentahar, L’aménagement du territoire au Maroc, PhD thesis, Université de Provence, Aix-en-Provence, 1972; Michèle Jolé, Nature et fonction d’un outil de planification: le schéma-directeur de Rabat-Salé, PhD thesis, Institut d’urbanisme de Paris, Université de Paris Val-de-Marne, Créteil, 1982; Lahcen Brouksy, Essai sur l’aménagement du territoire au Maroc et ses implications institutionnelles et politiques, PhD thesis, Université Jean Moulin, Lyon, 1988.
12 For instance: Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” in Jacques Bourdillon (ed.), Les ingénieurs des Ponts au service de l’Afrique: témoignages 1945-1975, Paris: L’Harmattan, 2010, p. 323-330 ; Idem, “Urbanisation et habitat du grand nombre: l’approche marocaine,” Annuaire de l’Afrique du Nord. XI. 1972, Paris: CNRS, 1973; Jean Hensens, “Les limites permises à la conception et à la construction autonomes de l’espace local au Maroc,” in Pierre Robert Baduel (ed.), Habitat, État, société au Maghreb, Paris: CNRS Éditions, 2002 (Études de l’année du Maghreb), p. 103-113.
13 Among others: Abderrafih Lahbabi, Changement social et aliénation en architecture: rapport de l’architecture au développement du capitalisme au Maroc, PhD thesis, Unité pédagogique d'architecture, Grenoble, 1975; Saâd Benzakour, Essai sur la politique urbaine au Maroc, 1912-1975: sur le rôle de l’État, Casablanca: Éditions maghrébines, 1978; Ménana Belkhader, L’habitat rural dans la politique du" ruralisme" au Maroc, PhD thesis, Université d’Aix-en-Provence, 1980; M’Hammed Belfquih and Abdellatif Fadloullah, Mécanismes et formes de croissance urbaine au Maroc: cas de l’agglomération de Rabat-Salé, Rabat: El Maârif, 1986; Abdeslam Basset, Politiques d’urbanisme au Maroc & urbanisation de Rabat-Salé-Témara, PhD thesis, Université d’Aix-Marseille, 1989.
14 Janet L. Abu-Lughod, Rabat: Urban Apartheid in Morocco, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1980 (Princeton Studies on the Near East).
15 Her understanding of Rabat in terms of “urban segregation” is in fact directly derived from the work of the French sociologist Michèle Jolé and that of the CERF on Rabat, with particular reference to a little-known, fairly short article, in the Annales de sociologie (from the Rabat Institute of Sociology): Michèle Jolé, Abdelkabir Khatibi and Mona Martensson, “Urbanisme, idéologie et ségrégation: exemple de Rabat,” Annales de sociologie, 1970. In fact, Abu-Lughod’s analyses and findings owe a great deal to Dethier's historical work and the surveys carried out by the CERF, such as: M.S. Hadzivkovic, Mohamed Naciri, Mohamed Guessous and Stacia Hensens, Quartiers sous-équipés de Rabat, Salé et Kénitra en 1969: caractéristiques démographiques et socio-économiques, (Maroc). Institut national de statistique et d’économie appliquée (INSEA), Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation (CERF), July 1971.
16 This study draws on various types of archives that I identified or assembled during my ongoing thesis project. First, it relies on the “reports” and “documents” produced by CERF members between 1967 and 1972. In addition, we consulted the broader collection of materials produced and gathered by the DUH Documentation Service, including the photo library [photothèque] now housed at the National School of Architecture in Rabat (ENA-Rabat). The study also encompasses the private archives of foreign architects or technical assistants involved with CERF, like the archival collection of Jean Hensens (held at the Université libre de Bruxelles), and the archival collections of Alain Masson, Jean Dethier, and the CERF’s French audiovisual expert Paul Moity (that we helped to transfer to Morocco and which are now housed in the Archives du Maroc in Rabat).
17 Since 2021, interviews have been conducted with a dozen former CERF members and half a dozen former Moroccan architects from the first generation of architects who graduated abroad and returned to work in Morocco during the CERF period.
18 As Jean-Robert Henry observed in one of the few studies focusing on oral histories collected from former coopérants—specifically in the context of social sciences, though the same can be said for architecture— the cooperation years [temps de la coopération] have left an important legacy that remains largely understudied: Jean-Robert Henry and Jean-Claude Vatin (eds.), Le temps de la coopération: sciences sociales et décolonisation au Maghreb, Paris: Karthala; Aix-en-Provence : Iremam, 2012 (Hommes et sociétés), p. 28. A few studies document the history of coopérants in Morocco during the CERF period. See Suzie Guth, Exil sous contrat: les communautés de coopérants en Afrique francophone, Paris: Silex; Agence de coopération culturelle et technique, 1984 ; “Les coopérants et la coopération,” Esprit, vol. 7-8, 1970. For more critical and recent studies of the “cooperation syndrome” in African architectural history and its links with the period of late colonialism, see the works: Luce Beeckmans, “The ‘Development Syndrome:’ Building and Contesting the SICAP Housing Schemes in French Dakar (1951-1960),” Canadian Journal of African Studies/Revue canadienne des études africaines, vol. 51, no. 3, 2017, p. 359-388. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00083968.2017.1411820; Hélène Vacher, “From ‘mise en valeur’ to Cooperation: ‘Ponts-et-Chaussées’ Engineers Overseas and the Rise of Planning Expertise in the Twentieth Century,” Planning Perspectives, vol. 34, no. 1, 2019, p. 91-113. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02665433.2017.1352476.
19 On the concept of “contact zone” in recent architectural historiography: Tom Avermaete and Cathelijne Nuijsink, “Architectural Contact Zones: Another Way to Write Global Histories of the Post-War Period?,” Architectural Theory Review, vol. 25, no. 3, 2021, p. 350-361. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13264826.2021.1939745. For a use of the concept in the Moroccan context, see Cathelijne Nuijsink’s chapter on the reconstruction of Agadir as an emergency aid contact zone in Morocco in the early 1960s: Cathelijne Nuijsink, “The Contact Zone of Agadir’s Emergency Aid Operations,” op. cit. (note 2).
20 Michel Rousset, “Le rôle du ministère de l’Intérieur et sa place au sein de l’administration marocaine,” op. cit. (note 4), p. 91-106 ; Mohamed Naciri, “Politique urbaine et ‘politiques’ de l’habitat au Maroc: incertitudes d’une stratégie,” in François Métral, Politiques urbaines dans le monde arabe, Lyon : MOM Éditions, 1985 (Études sur le monde arabe), p. 71-98. URL: https://www.persee.fr/doc/mom_0295-6950_1985_act_1_1_3746. Accessed 30 April 2025.
21 General Mohamed Oufkir (1920-1972) was a central figure in Moroccan politics and military during the 1960s and early 1970s. Born in 1920, Oufkir had a distinguished military career, serving in World War II and the Indochina War. After Morocco gained independence, he became a close and influential collaborator to King Hassan II, serving as Minister of Interior from 1964 to 1971 and later as Minister of Defense. Oufkir was infamous for his role in suppressing political dissent. He is presumed to have been involved in the disappearance of left-wing political figure Mehdi Ben Barka in 1965. His career came to a dramatic end in 1972 when he was implicated in a failed coup attempt against King Hassan II, known as the “Coup of the Aviators.” Shortly afterward, Oufkir died under mysterious circumstances, which may have contributed to the dissolution of the CERF in December 1972.
22 Mounia Bennani-Chraïbi, “Chapitre 2 – Les luttes politiques de l’indépendance : des échanges de coups dans un espace de jeu non délimité (1956-1975),” in Partis politiques et protestations au Maroc (1934-2020), Rennes: Presses universitaires de Rennes, 2021. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/books.pur.143118. Accessed 30 April 2025; Susan Gilson Miller, A History of Modern Morocco, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013.
23 Katherine M. Johnson, Urbanization in Morocco, op. cit. (note 8), p. 10; Michel Rousset, “Le rôle du ministère de l’Intérieur et sa place au sein de l’administration marocaine,” op.cit. (note 4); Pierre Vermeren, Histoire du Maroc depuis l’indépendance, Paris: La Découverte, 2016.
24 Jean-Luc Bodiguel, “La DATAR: quarante ans d’histoire,” Revue française d’administration publique, vol. 119, no. 3, 2006, p. 401-414. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3917/rfap.119.0401.
25 Ben Clark and Axel Fisher, “The WFP 1968-72 Rural Housing Program in Morocco,” op. cit. (note 7).
26 From its first session in 1963, the United Nations Housing, Building and Planning Committee identified the establishment of national bodies (technical and research centers) as a programmatic objective. Report of the Committee on Housing, Building and Planning (36th sess.), UN. Economic and Social Council, 1963. URL: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/213797. Accessed 30 April 2025.
27 Urbanisme, habitat et aménagement régional: une nouvelle stratégie. Principes d’action et applications, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1970.
28 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12), p. 327.
29 Alain Masson (1927-2013) was a French engineer graduate of the École nationale des ponts et chaussées. He worked in Morocco, first as head of the Arrondissement des travaux publics in Marrakesh and then as head of the DUH Technical Division in Rabat from 1967, where he headed the CERF set up that same year. When the Ministry of Urbanism, Housing, and the Environment (MUHE) was created in 1972, Masson became advisor to the Minister until 1973. In 2019, at the initiative of Jean Dethier and in collaboration with Nadya Rouizem, we catalogued Masson's private archives and transferred them to the Archives du Maroc in Rabat.
30 On the importance of French Ponts et Chaussées engineers after independence in a postcolonial context, see Hélène Vacher, “From ‘mise en valeur’ to Cooperation,” op. cit. (note 18). For an overview of the actors themselves (including Masson himself): Jacques Bourdillon (ed.), Les ingénieurs des Ponts au service de l’Afrique, op. cit. (note 12).
31 On this resettlement project in the Daoudiate district of Marrakesh, known as BTS62 (for béton de terre stabilisé [stabilized earth concrete], dated 1962), refer to: Nadya Rouizem, Réinventer la terre crue: expérimentations au Maroc depuis 1960, Paris: Éditions Recherches, 2022; Ben Clark, “Comment ‘devenir traditionnel’?,” op. cit. (note 3).
32 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12).
33 Interviews with Jean Dethier (22 July 2022) and François Perrin (20 June 2022).
34 Michèle Jolé, Nature et fonction d’un outil de planification, op. cit. (note 11), p. 95-96.
35 Jean Hensens, “Le CERF,” (Maroc). Ministère de l’urbanisme, de l’habitat et de l’environnement, 1972. Document found at Rabat (Maroc). Archives de l’Institut agronomique et vétérinaire Hassan II.
36 Lahcen Brouksy, Ma vie, Sa Majesté Hassan II, Driss Basri et moi, Rabat : Bouregreg, 2016, p. 68-75. Translated from French by the Author.
37 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12).
38 Saâd Benzakour, Essai sur la politique urbaine au Maroc, 1912-1975 : sur le rôle de l’État, op. cit. (note 13), p. 164-165. Translated from French by the Author.
39 Fathallah Oualalou, L’assistance étrangère face au développement économique du Maroc, Casablanca: Éditions maghrébines, 1969.
40 Fathallah Oualalou, “Point de vue du tiers-monde,” Esprit, vol. 394, 1970, p. 151-158. URL : https://www.jstor.org/stable/24261265. Accessed 30 April 2025. Translated from French by the Author.
41 Ben Clark and Axel Fisher, “The WFP 1968-72 Rural Housing Program in Morocco,” op. cit. (note 7).
42 François Pacquement, Histoire de la coopération technique: une généalogie d’Expertise France, Paris: Karthala, 2021 (Terrains du siècle).
43 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12).
44 Łukasz Stanek, Architecture in Global Socialism: Eastern Europe, West Africa, and the Middle East in the Cold War, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2020.
45 This is the case, for example, of the five landscape and urban planners (Jean Challet, Lucien Gendre, Pierre Mas, Elie Mauret and Pierre Pelletier) who played a major role in Morocco in the 1950s, working for the Service de l’urbanisme, and who all left the country between 1957 and 1967, just before the creation of CERF. Isabelle Estienne, “L’aménagement comme stratégie professionnelle,” Projets de paysage. Revue scientifique sur la conception et l’aménagement de l’espace, no. 6, 2011. DOI: https://doi.org.10.4000/paysage.17433.
46 Note sur le programme d’habitat rural dans le cadre d’opérations de mise en valeur régionale, (Maroc). Ministère de l’intérieur, 1968. The Moroccan architect in question appears to have been Ali Idrissi. He likely began his career briefly at CERF after completing his studies at the École spéciale d’architecture in Paris. He would later lead the Moroccan section of the International Union of Architects (UIA) and serve as Secretary General of the future Ministry of Housing.
47 Demande d’assistance adressée au Programme des Nations Unies pour le Développement, fonds spécial PNUD/FS, (Maroc). Direction de l’urbanisme et de l’habitat, January 1968; Pour une étude de rénovation de deux agglomérations anciennes au Maroc. Fez et les ksours du Ziz. Requête adressée à la Fondation Ford, (Maroc). Direction de l’urbanisme et de l’habitat, December 1968.
48 A key figure in the establishment of the CERF was Belgian diplomat Suzanne Vervalcke. Between 1966 and 1969, Vervalcke served as a United Nations advisor, employed by the Belgian Ministry of Foreign Affairs within the Office of Development Cooperation, and was assigned as a technical assistance advisor at the United Nations Coordination Body for Technical Assistance in Morocco. According to testimonies from Alain Masson and Jean Dethier, she played a particularly influential role in creating the CERF as a “reception center” for diverse forms of foreign expertise. Her deep knowledge of both the United Nations system and Belgian cooperation frameworks appears to have been instrumental in shaping the CERF’s founding vision and method of recruiting foreign technical assistance. Suzanne Vervalcke’s archives are now held by the Belgian Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
49 Michèle Jolé, Nature et fonction d’un outil de planification, op. cit. (note 11), p. 316-317.
50 See the article by Tifawt Loudaoui in this issue about the M’diq village de vacances, built with the help of SCET-Coop. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/14vh9. Moreover, this project was the SCET-Coop assignment that initially drew Jean-Paul Garcia, who later worked at CERF, to Morocco.
51 Société centrale pour l’équipement du territoire-Coopération, La S.C.E.T. Coop au Maroc, 1969.
52 Interview with Jean-Paul Garcia (27 September 2024).
53 Some of the archives are now held in the CDC archives in Paris, where we were able to find information on the development of staff sent to Morocco in the 1960s and 1970s before the creation of SCET-Maroc in 1975. See in particular : Box 202-31BIS “Morocco documentation 1970-1977.”
54 La S.C.E.T. Coop au Maroc, op. cit. (note 51).
55 The Service National de la Coopération (SNC), established in France in 1965, offered an alternative to military service by allowing young French graduates to fulfill their national duty through an 18-months civilian cooperation mission in a developing country. In Belgium, young male graduates could be exempted from compulsory military service by serving for cooperation abroad for at least 24 months under a government-approved contract.
56 On the role of the first Peace Corps volunteer architects in Morocco, please refer to: Maristella Casciato and Ben Clark, “Portraying the American Volunteer Architect: Case Study of the Peace Corps ‘Morocco13’ Cohort (1969-1971),” Getty Research Journal. To be published.
57 In the late 1960s, the Moroccan government asked the UNDP to provide them with three planners to help them set up the Rural Housing Program. In the end, from 1969 onwards, only one planner, Kratochvil, was seconded by the UNDP and its Center for Housing, Construction and Planning (New York), to the CERF from 1969 to 1973. Jan Kratochvil, Rapport final sur les programmes d’habitat rural et d’aménagement du territoire, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1973.
58 Vodislav Kravis, Système de financement et d’imposition communal 1974 (préparé pour le Gouvernement marocain par l’Organisation des Nations Unies), ONU. Programme des Nations Unies pour le développement (PNUD), 1974, DP.UN MOR-70-005-2.
59 The USSR became an important training ground for many Moroccan architects at the time, such as Moroccan architect Omar Sbai, who graduated from the Moscow Institute of Architecture in 1968 thanks to an Istiqlal party scholarship in the 1960s. Kamal Mellakh, “La formation des étudiants marocains dans les pays de l’Est de l’Europe (1960-2015),” Revue européenne des migrations internationales, vol. 32, no. 2, 2016, p. 39-56. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/remi.7777. To a lesser extent, the École de La Cambre in Belgium was also a training ground for some Moroccan architects since the 1960s, such as the architect Ahmed Assermouh. This is by no means an exhaustive list of training centers, but it does show that the training of Moroccan architects was not exclusively confined to France.
60 We have not yet been able to establish exactly how many architects were sent abroad on state scholarships during this period. However, the account given by the Moroccan architect Abderrahmane Chorfi is revealing: “until 1968, almost every year one or two Moroccans went to France [to train as architects thanks to state grants]. And it was in 1968 that there were 5 of us all at once. Finally, in 1970, larger groups started to go to France. In 1970, maybe 20 Moroccans went at once. Suddenly there were a lot more, but for a long time it was a trickle.” Interview with Abderrahmane Chorfi (Rabat, November 2022). Translated from French by the Author.
61 During the 1960s, the 4 regional DUH delegations created at the time of the Protectorate were still headed by French and Belgian nationals such as de Leenheer in Marrakesh, Godefroy in Casablanca, Ichter in Fez and Fridé in Rabat; and these were to be replaced by newly elected Moroccans, such as Benelkhadir in Rabat or Assermouh in Marrakesh, from the end of the 1960s and early 1970s.
62 In the summers of 1969 and 1970, for example, around a hundred students from various disciplines (architects, geographers, sociologists, etc.), most of them Moroccan, took part in summer programs organized by CERF.
63 At CERF, geographer Alain Billon (a future French politician) was in charge of examining how to develop architecture education in Morocco. In 1969, CERF developed the University Liaison Group to promote links between Moroccan university students and the activities of CERF.
64 Trainee Moroccan architects at CERF included for instance Rachid Sabounji (a 1969 graduate of the Moscow Institute of Architecture) and Abderrahmane Chorfi (a 1973 graduate of the École spéciale d’architecture in Paris). The CERF also hired Moroccan trainee engineers like Mohammed Idabouk (graduated from Mohammedia Engineering School in Rabat around 1969). All held positions with important responsibilities after CERF.
65 Note sur le programme d’habitat rural dans le cadre d’opérations de mise en valeur régionale, (Maroc). Ministère de l'intérieur, 1968.
66 See his autobiographical book, in which he writes that when he first joined the CERF he was “the only Moroccan on board,” and that he was gradually joined by Moroccan sociologists and jurists. Lahcen Brouksy, Ma vie, Sa Majesté Hassan II, Driss Basri et moi, op. cit. (note 39), p. 68-75.
67 Interview with Mohammed Benelkhadir (Rabat, 28 October 2022) and Abderrafih Lahbabi (Rabat, 23 May 2023).
68 Michèle Jolé, Nature et fonction d’un outil de planification, op. cit. (note 11), p. 251.
69 Interview with Mohammed Benelkhadir (Rabat, 28 October 2022).
70 Alain Masson, “Urbanisation et habitat du grand nombre: l’approche marocaine,” op. cit. (note 12); Janet L. Abu-Lughod, “Dependent Urbanism and Decolonization: The Moroccan Case,” Arab Studies Quarterly, vol. 1, no. 1, 1979, p. 49-66. URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/41857498. Accessed 30 April 2025; Jean Dethier, “Evolution of Concepts of Housing, Urbanism, and Country Planning in a Developing Country: Morocco, 1900-1972,” in From Madina to Metropolis: Heritage and Change in the Near Eastern City, op. cit. (note 10).
71 For more details on self-help housing in Morocco: Ben Clark, “Le mythe du Castor marocain: pratiques et discours de l’autoconstruction assistée au Maroc (années 1950-1960),” op. cit. (note 7).
72 Alain Masson, “Note générale (sur la politique de l’État en matière d’aménagement du territoire, d’urbanisme et d’habitat),” (Maroc). Direction de l’urbanisme et de l’habitat, 1970. Rabat (Morocco), Archives du Maroc, Collection Alain Masson, Folders 20-21. Translated from French by the Author.
73 Jean Hensens, “Le CERF,” op. cit. (note 35). This was also mentioned in the interviews we had with Jean Dethier, François Perrin, and Stacia Hensens.
74 Alain Masson, “Fonctions du CERF,” (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1970.
75 Jean Hensens (1929-2006) was a Belgian architect who worked in Morocco for several decades from 1962, when he and his wife Stacia Hensens (a sociologist who also worked at CERF) decided to move to Morocco. For more information on his career, see Ben Clark, “Comment ‘devenir traditionnel’?,” op. cit. (note 3).
76 For instance, CERF French sociologist Stacia Hensens engaged in numerous collaborative interdisciplinary studies (sometimes with her architect husband, Jean Hensens). Prior to her involvement with the CERF, she engaged in collaborative research with the Groupe d'ethnologie sociale in Paris in the 1950s with P.-H. Chombart de Lauwe, a seminal figure in the advancement of urban sociology in urban planning and architecture.
77 Regarding the interplay between human and social sciences, urban planning and architecture in post-war France, refer to: Kenny Cupers, The Social Project: Housing Postwar France, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 2014; Łukasz Stanek, Henri Lefebvre on Space: Architecture, Urban Research, and the Production of Theory, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 2011.
78 Jean Hensens, Stacia Hensens and Denis Krause, L’habitat économique au Maroc, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1971.
79 Two of the main architects of the original CERF team, the Frenchmen Gérard Bauer and Bernard Hamburger, who were key to the CERF’s early actions, established the Atelier de recherche et d’études d’aménagement (AREA) at the same time, along with Philippe Boudon and Alain Sarfati, in France. Philippe Boudon, Pessac de Le Corbusier: étude socio-architecturale, 1929-1985, Paris: Dunod, 1985 (Aspects de l’urbanisme).
80 Daniel Pinson, Modèles d’habitat et contre-types domestiques au Maroc, Tours: Urbama, 1992 (Urbanisation du monde arabe); Françoise Navez-Bouchanine, Habiter la ville marocaine, Casablanca: Gaëtan Morin, 1997. This French-language body of research preceded a more recent interest in architectural studies in examining modes of appropriation of housing, particularly through case studies of social housing in Morocco, Sascha Roesler (ed.), Habitat Marocain Documents: Dynamics Between Formal and Informal Housing, Zurich: Park Books, 2015; Tom Avermaete and Maristella Casciato, Casablanca Chandigarh : A Report on Modernization, Montreal: Canadian Center for Architecture; Zurich: Park Books, 2014.
81 La notion d’études pluridisciplinaires: conséquences de son introduction en matière d’habitat, d’urbanisme et d’aménagement, (Maroc). CERF, Service de documentation, Groupe de liaison avec l’université, [s.d.]. Rabat (Morocco), Library of Ministry of Housing, RAP.I.711.09.AMT.
82 Alain Masson, Nouvel esprit des études entreprises en matière d’aménagement d’urbanisme et d’habitat, (Maroc). Institut technique du bâtiment et des travaux publics, 7 January 1971.
83 Katherine M. Johnson, Urbanization in Morocco, op.cit (note 8), p. 73.
84 James Ferguson, The Anti-Politics Machine: Development, Depoliticization, and Bureaucratic Power in Lesotho, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1994. For an interpretation of this critique of development in architectural history in recent scholarship: Ijlal Muzaffar, Modernism’s Magic Hat: Architecture and the Illusion of Development Without Capital, Austin, TX: University of Texas Press, 2024.
85 Janet L. Abu-Lughod, Rabat: Urban Apartheid in Morocco, op. cit. (note 14).
86 About CERF raw-earth experimentations, refer to: Nadya Rouizem Labied, Réinventer la terre crue, op. cit. (note 31) ; Ben Clark, “Comment ‘devenir traditionnel’?,” op. cit. (note 3).
87 David Georges Emmerich (1925-1996) was a Hungarian-born engineer and architect, considered a leading figure in “structural morphology” in France. A survivor of the Nazi concentration camps of Auschwitz, Flossenbürg, Dachau, and Esslingen, he began his architectural studies at the Polytechnic School of Budapest after the war, continuing them in Israel alongside Yona Friedman. He then settled in France in 1953 and completed his training at the École des beaux-arts in Paris. He participated in the 10th International Congress of Modern Architecture (CIAM) in Dubrovnik in 1956 and co-founded the Groupe d’études d’architecture mobile (GEAM) in 1957. He later taught at the Beaux-Arts in Paris, where his students included Bernard Hamburger (who later worked for CERF). His archives are housed at the Fonds régional d'art contemporain (Frac) Centre Val-de-Loire. URL: https://www.frac-centre.fr/collection-art-architecture/rub/rubauteurs-58.html. Accessed 30 April 2025. Auriane Bernard-Guelle, “David Georges Emmerich et l’enseignement de Jean-Marie Delarue à UP1,” in Enseigner l’architecture en Île-de-France au XXe siècle: une histoire croisée (ENSA Paris-Malaquais / Paris-Val de Seine / Paris-La Villette), Strasbourg: École nationale supérieure d’architecture, 2020; Marie-Ange Broyer, David Georges Emmerich, Éditions HYX, 1997 (Frac Centre). URL : https://hal.science/hal-03128739v1/document. Accessed 30 April 2025.
88 Some of these experiments were published: Gérard Bauer and Jean Dethier, “La terre et le roseau: ou la réhabilitation et l’amélioration de techniques traditionnelles de construction au Maroc,” L’Architecture d’aujourd’hui, no. 160, February 1972, p. 104-111.
89 David Georges Emmerich, Soft Architecture: essais sur l’autoconstruction, Paris: Institut de l’environnement, 1974, p. 67. URL: https://archive.org/details/frapn02-soft-architecture-essais-sur-l-autoconstruction-1974/mode/2up. Consulté le 20 juillet 2025.
90 Ibid. These experiments, part of a more global movement, were closely linked to experiments in other countries of the South, such as Buckminster Fuller's work in Ghana, or Zvi Hecker in Israël. For a study of the international dimension of “soft architecture” in the 1960s-1970s considering Emmerich works: Caroline Maniaque, Go West: des architectes au pays de la contre-culture, Paris: Parenthèses, 2014.
91 Interview (November 2022 in Rabat) with Moroccan architect Abderhamane Chorfi, (graduated from the École spéciale d'architecture in 1973) who took part in these workshops as a student. And interview (October 2022 in Rabat) with Mohammed Idabouk, an engineer graduated from the École Mohammedia d’ingénieurs (EMI) who was also an intern at CERF. This criticism of Emmerich's projects for Morocco can also be found in Abderrafih Lahbabi, Changement social et aliénation en architecture: rapport de l’architecture au développement du capitalisme au Maroc, op. cit. (note 13).
92 Le sous-habitat au Maroc: analyse de la situation et stratégie nouvelle d’intervention, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1970.
93 On the links between “soft architecture” and counter-cultural movements in the 1960s and 1970s, Caroline Maniaque, Go West, op. cit. (note 90); Felicity D. Scott, Outlaw Territories: Environments of Insecurity / Architecture of Counterinsurgency, New York, NY: Zone Books, 2016.
94 Jean Dethier, “Liberté pour les bidonvilles,” in Séminaire sur l’habitat sous-intégré et l’environnement urbain au Maghreb, Rabat: Enda Tiers Monde, 1973; Jean Hensens, “Les limites permises à la conception et à la construction autonomes de l’espace local au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12), p. 103-113. On the socio-technical imaginaries surrounding the notion of self-construction in the history of colonial and post-colonial Morocco, refer to: Daniel Williford, Concrete Futures: Technologies of Urban Crisis in Colonial and Postcolonial Morocco, PhD dissertation, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, 2020.
95 For instance, “L’architecture douce,” L’Architecture d’aujourd’hui, no. 179, 1975. Regarding these imaginaries in architecture, linked to DIY and recognition of informal settlements in the context of development, see other recent scholarship including: Frederike Lausch, “The Case for Self-Education: The Self-Help Manuals of the Communication Center of Scientific Knowledge for Self-Reliance,” ABE Journal. Architecture beyond Europe, no. 21, 2023. DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/abe.14443; Helen Gyger, Improvised Cities: Architecture, Urbanization & Innovation in Peru, Pittsburg, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press, 2019 (Culture, Politics and the Build Environment); Ijlal Muzaffar, Modernism’s Magic Hat, op. cit. (note 84); Farhan Karim, Of Greater Dignity Than Riches: Austerity & Housing Design in India, Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press, 2019 (Culture, Politics and the Build Environment); Diane Aymard, Une mouvance « tiers-mondophile » et ses ambiguïtés (1968-1998): vers un décentrement géographique et épistémologique de l’enseignement de l’architecture en France, PhD thesis, Nantes Université, 2024.
96 Interviews with Jean Dethier (Paris, July 2022).
97 Note Prix Abercrombie. Rabat (Morocco). Archives du Maroc, Collection Alain Masson, Folder no. 3. Translated from French by the Author.
98 As Dethier told us : “… in the CERF team, the majority of people were in their thirties, so rather representative of a new generation of architects, urban planners and engineers, most of whom were sensitive to the evolution of the times, sympathetic to the decolonization and independence movements, and also bearers of new ideas that were emerging worldwide, in the United States with the counter-culture, in Europe in other forms.” Interview with Jean Dethier (22 July 2022). Translated from French by the Author.
99 For instance : Jean Hensens, Ain Chouater. Recasement des sinistrés des inondations du Guir. Création d’un nouveau village, Rabat : CERF, 1969 ; Idem, Rabat-sud. Reconversion des bidonvilles de Chella, Doum, Maadid-extension, Rabat : CERF, 1971.
100 This is obvious from the number of reports, plans, and drawings in the CERF archives, compared with the output of other architects. It is understandable, given that Jean Hensens was present in Morocco throughout the CERF period, and above all that he was older and more experienced than the others, having already had more than fifteen years of professional experience in Belgium, France, and Morocco, when he arrived at the CERF. Ben Clark, “Comment ‘devenir traditionnel’?,” op. cit. (note 3).
101 See, for example, Bugnicourt’s glowing review of the Documentation Service’s synthesis and bibliography work, published in the journal Tiers Monde, attesting to the CERF’s international dimension. Jacques Bugnicourt, [compte-rendu] “Jean Dethier (dir.), Arielle Rousselle et autres, Références bibliographiques sur l’urbanisme, l’habitat, l’architecture et l’aménagement au Maroc,” Tiers Monde, vol. 14, no. 54, 1973, p. 444-445. URL: https://www.persee.fr/doc/tiers_0040-7356_1973_num_14_54_1938_t1_0444_0000_2. Accessed 30 April 2025
102 Born in 1942, François Perrin is a French jurist who graduated from the Institute of Political Studies in Grenoble, where he completed his thesis. In 1968, he moved with his wife, Monique Perrin, to Morocco for his civil service. They both joined the CERF. After his 18-months civil service, he continued his work under the SCET until returning to France in 1971.
103 Alain Masson, Nouvel esprit des études entreprises en matière d’aménagement d’urbanisme et d’habitat, Casablanca: Institut technique du bâtiment et des travaux publics, 1971.
104 For a summary of the new architecture, urbanism and ruralism policy promoted by CERF, and a presentation of the new instruments, refer to: Alain Masson, “Urbanisation et habitat du grand nombre: l’approche marocaine,” op. cit. (note 12).
105 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12). Translated from French by the Author.
106 Interview with François Perrin (Paris, 20 June 2022).
107 Alain Masson, “Urbanisation et habitat du grand nombre: l’approche marocaine,” op. cit. (note 12).
108 On the role of ERACs in Moroccan urban policy, see the article by Lahbib El Moumni in this issue. It should also be noted that this was accompanied by the introduction of financial instruments, which led the State to set up a Fonds national d’achat et d’équipement de terrains (FNAET) in 1973, tasked with acquiring and developing land.
109 Perrin seems to be referring to Moroccan architects such as Idrissi, Hajjaji, Haggy, etc. who worked at the DUH for the central or regional services during the CERF period.
110 Interview with François Perrin (Paris, 20 June 2022).
111 Ijlal Muzaffar, Modernism’s Magic Hat, op. cit. (note 84).
112 Pascale Philifert, “Urban Planning in Morocco: Historical Legacy, Approaches to Urban Policies, and Changes in Urban Planners’ Roles and Practices, 1960-2010,” in Carlos Nunes Silva, Urban Planning in North Africa, London: Routledge, 2016.
113 Jean Hensens, “Le CERF,” op. cit. (note 35, note 73).
114 Alain Masson, “Mes années au Maroc,” op. cit. (note 12).
115 Ibid.
Haut de pageTable des illustrations
![]() |
|
|---|---|
| Titre | Figure 1: Diagrams drawn by K.M. Johnson for the Ford Foundation in 1970. |
| Légende | Diagrams showing CERF's central place in the DUH, and the importance of the Ministry of Interior in matters relating to architecture and urban planning. |
| Crédits | Source: Katherine Marshall Johnson, Urbanization in Morocco: An International Urbanization Survey Report to the Ford Foundation, New York, NY: Ford Foundation, 1972. |
| URL | https://journals.openedition.org/abe/docannexe/image/17133/img-1.jpg |
| Fichier | image/jpeg, 109k |
![]() |
|
| Titre | Figure 2: Photograph of the key figures responsible for architecture and territorial planning policy during the CERF period. |
| Légende | The photograph, taken during a preparatory meeting for the 1973-1977 plan, is indicative of the period of cooperation. At the center, Maati Jorio (Secretary-General of the Ministry of Interior) is seen surrounded on one side by French cooperants: Coulomb on the far left (former head of the Technical Bureau of the CUH) and Masson (Technical Director at the DUH, and head of the CERF). On the other side are three Moroccan officials from the DUH: Daoudi (Director of the DUH), a person we couldn't identify, and then Ben Jelloun on the far right (who would later head the DEP after the CERF). |
| Crédits | Source: Rabat (Morocco), Archives du Maroc, Collection Alain Masson, Folder no. 50. |
| URL | https://journals.openedition.org/abe/docannexe/image/17133/img-2.jpg |
| Fichier | image/jpeg, 190k |
![]() |
|
| Titre | Figure 3: Extract from the newspaper La Vigie marocaine, 12 February 1970. |
| Crédits | Source: Brussels (Belgium), Université libre de Bruxelles, Collection Jean Hensens. |
| URL | https://journals.openedition.org/abe/docannexe/image/17133/img-3.jpg |
| Fichier | image/jpeg, 469k |
![]() |
|
| Titre | Figure 4: CERF survey on how inhabitants appropriated their state-built housing. |
| Légende | Drawings from a CERF survey directed by Jean and Stacia Hensens in 1971 on the changes and appropriations made by inhabitants of different types of state-built low-cost housing dating back to the “Écochard period.” |
| Crédits | Source: Jean Hensens, Stacia Hensens and Dennis Krause, L’habitat économique au Maroc, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1971. |
| URL | https://journals.openedition.org/abe/docannexe/image/17133/img-4.jpg |
| Fichier | image/jpeg, 341k |
![]() |
|
| Titre | Figure 5: Photograph of experiments carried out by CERF in 1968. |
| Légende | Photograph of construction workshops carried out by CERF in 1968 (at the Ferme Lauzey in Salé) using reed cane reinforced with plaster to create partition and roof panels, designed by Hungarian engineer David George Emmerich, then a professor at Unité pédagogique d'architecture (UP6) in Paris and a consultant for CERF. |
| Crédits | Source: Edmund Hazzard, La construction en roseau au Maroc, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1968. |
| URL | https://journals.openedition.org/abe/docannexe/image/17133/img-5.jpg |
| Fichier | image/jpeg, 575k |
![]() |
|
| Titre | Figure 6: Photograph of the same experiment. |
| Crédits | Source: Photograph from the private archives of Jean Dethier, published in black and white in: Gérard Bauer and Jean Dethier, “La terre et le roseau: ou la réhabilitation et l’amélioration de techniques traditionnelles de construction au Maroc,” L’Architecture d’aujourd’hui, no. 160, February 1972, p. 104-111. |
| URL | https://journals.openedition.org/abe/docannexe/image/17133/img-6.jpg |
| Fichier | image/jpeg, 393k |
![]() |
|
| Titre | Figure 7: Drawing by Jean Hensens for his CERF report on the restructuration of Rabat-Sud districts. |
| Légende | Drawing by Jean Hensens for the 1971 CERF report on the restructuration of Rabat-Sud districts, where he criticized the monotonous grid approach, claiming it would lead to human standardization. The diagram shows Ecochard's 8x8 grids and improved sanitary grids [trames sanitaires]. |
| Crédits | Source: Jean Hensens, Rabat-Sud. Reconversion des bidonvilles de Chella, Doum, Maadid-extension, (Maroc). Centre d’expérimentation, de recherche et de formation, 1971. |
| URL | https://journals.openedition.org/abe/docannexe/image/17133/img-7.jpg |
| Fichier | image/jpeg, 74k |
![]() |
|
| Titre | Figure 8: Research on “modes of open growth” [mode de croissance libre] by Jean Hensens. |
| Légende | Schematic plan of a neighborhood project for low-cost housing as part of his CERF research for the restructuration of Rabat-Sud districts in 1971. |
| Crédits | Source: Brussels (Belgium), Université libre de Bruxelles, Collection Jean Hensens, FJH_D48_C2_3. |
| URL | https://journals.openedition.org/abe/docannexe/image/17133/img-8.jpg |
| Fichier | image/jpeg, 205k |
Pour citer cet article
Référence électronique
Ben Clark, « Soft, Slow, and Low-cost Architecture: CERF’s Foreign Experts in Morocco (1967-1972) », ABE Journal [En ligne], 25 | 2025, mis en ligne le 31 juillet 2025, consulté le 18 novembre 2026. URL : https://journals.openedition.org/abe/17133 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/14vh7
Haut de pageDroits d’auteur
Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence CC BY 4.0. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont susceptibles d’être soumis à des autorisations d’usage spécifiques.
Haut de page











