Navigation – Plan du site
85
Y. Garfinkel

« Dancing Diamonds, In Memory of P.R.S. Moorey ». Iran, XLIII, 2005, pp. 117-133.

Compte-rendu réalisé par Aurélie Daems

Texte intégral

1As much as I do embrace any attempt at elucidating the hidden meaning of any man made artefact or image, Garfinkel’s interpretation of diamond shaped motives on a selected sample of proto-historic Iranian sherds feels like a bridge too far. A set of Susiana Black on Buff sherds from Luristan to Kerman is subjected to a very scrutinised, balanced stylistic analysis but sadly only effectuated in order to support a preconceived idea of net-covered and plain diamonds ‘with limbs’ (p. 121 onwards) as being abstract representations of people dancing during a ceremony (p. 131). The connection between the images and the conclusion made by the author is not transparent enough in the article. The diamonds are dancing; for a fact, but the supporting / comparative evidence is too meagre; at least to me. There is the problem of fragmentation of the Bakun sherds, of the Nevali Çori sherd having no connection with the material discussed (in time, in space) and of the problematic Giyan seal (see c.r. n° 48) who described the many problems with which the seals from Giyan are concerned; one of them being that Herzfeld’s drawings of the seals often do not match the original seal’s scenery! (and Garfinkel relies on the drawing here). We are also guided to other references that support the dancing statement but these are mainly prior works made by the author – and arguments are not repeated here. I am not saying Garfinkel is wrong: the interpretation put forward is an interesting and alluring one certainly worth acknowledging but I would have preferred ‘dancing’ as one of several suggested interpretations rather than as a clear-cut fact. The only sherds that may indeed be abstract representations of people (but even then it should not necessarily be during a dance) are the ones from Kozagaran, since there are more supporting arguments here. Overall the study is a thorough, interesting and elaborate one, but it is a pity the abstraction of a human is taken as a fact / certainty throughout the article rather than as a suggestion enforced by strong arguments.

Haut de page

Pour citer cet article

Référence électronique

Aurélie Daems. Y. Garfinkel, « « Dancing Diamonds, In Memory of P.R.S. Moorey ». Iran, XLIII, 2005, pp. 117-133. », Abstracta Iranica [En ligne], Volume 28 | 2007, document 85, mis en ligne le 18 septembre 2007, consulté le 18 avril 2019. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/abstractairanica/15752

Haut de page

Droits d’auteur

Tous droits réservés

Haut de page