- 1 Among them, see: Assouline, 1997; Benchimol, 2006; Bitton, 2020; El Maleh, 1980; Kosansky, 2002; Bo (...)
1For over 40 years, cemeteries have been protagonists in academic, cinematographic, and literary investigations of Moroccan Jewish life.1 For those familiar with diasporic communities, this preoccupation with gravesites may not be all that surprising. In his seminal work on Hadrami communities and their relationship to sites in modern-day Yemen, anthropologist Enseng Ho notes that, because the cemetery is “a place that brings together persons and texts,” it becomes the “focus of an excess” transforming into a site “where incompatible projects and thoughts come together” (Ho, 2006, xxvi).
- 2 The Musée du Judaïsme Marocain is frequently hailed as the first and, until recently, only “Jewish” (...)
- 3 Many of Levy’s close friends, including those I interviewed, use his Arabic name (Shim‘ūn) instead (...)
2One of the few documentarians of Moroccan Jewish life openly committed to Palestinian liberation, Kathy Wazana, made the “incompatible projects and thoughts” that converge in Morocco for resident and non-resident Moroccan Jews a focus of her 2013 film “They Were Promised the Sea.” The documentary largely followed Shira Ohayon—a Mizrahi Israeli feminist educator of Moroccan origins—as she traveled to Morocco for the first time. In a scene at the Musée du Judaïsme Marocain,2 the founder, Shim‘ūn Levy,3 (re)introduces Ohayon to Moroccan Jewish heritage and during his guided tour, “incompatible projects” across the Moroccan Jewish diaspora are laid bare:
Figure 1. Still from Kathy Wazana’s Film “They Were Promised the Sea” (2013) at the Musée du Judaïsme Marocain
© Kathy Wazana
- 4 All translations from Arabic, Moroccan Arabic, and French into English are my own. Many of the docu (...)
Shim‘ūn Levy [SL]: “Because, I’m sorry, but the story of Israel is a story of colonization. And therefore, there’s a whole ideology that goes with it…”4
Shira Ohayon [SO]: “Can I speak to you in Arabic?”
SL: “With pleasure”
SO: “I speak with an Egyptian accent, but do you think that Jews could really return to Morocco?”
SL: “In the current circumstances, I do not think so…. But, politically, I believe that the time has come for all Israelis, of Moroccan or Polish descent, to understand that their politics now do not have a way out… This narrow nationalist discourse, which comes from Nazism, I mean it is a response to Nazism. I fear that Jews who suffered under Nazis appear in front of other peoples like [Nazis]. This is the problem of today. Ultimately, we’re the ones who are your victims [hennā daḥāya diyālkum]…
SO: “Ours?”
SL: “Yours. The Israelis”
SO: “But tell us how… the problem is that… in Israel, we struggle for this culture, this history of coexistence in Morocco between Jews and Arabs to be more, to appear more in Israel… But, the problem is we are also the victims of Zionists…”
SL: “Excuse me, my dear… you are not victims of Zionism…”
SO: “Of course, this isn’t…”
- 5 I maintain the translation—“destruction of…the spirit of Judaism”—that was used in Wazana’s documen (...)
SL: “You are not victims of Zionism, don’t exaggerate… that’s a load of hot air [mā tazīdūsh… hadhī hadra khāwiya]… You are living in circumstances that Zionism developed in its European formation. In other words, the time has passed for this type of talk… Now, what are the two possibilities?… either Israelis come to an understanding with their neighbors and open the way for their integration in the culture [and] economy, meaning they no longer appear like opponents and instead appear like an additional contribution, a positive contribution, and this is hard… or the other route is to go with tanks into Lebanon or Jordan or I don’t know where… That would be the destruction of Judaism [qadā’ ‘alā al-yahūdiyya] generally speaking and… the spirit of Judaism5…”
Figure 2. Still from Kathy Wazana’s Film “They Were Promised the Sea”
The camera is focused on a photo by David Cowles of the Jewish cemetery in Asjen, near Ouazzane that hung at the Musée du Judaïsme Marocain.
© Kathy Wazana
3Levy’s comment about the “destruction of Judaism” echoes what a fellow Moroccan Jew, Edmond Amran El-Maleh described as the “poison” of Zionism for Jewish communities in Morocco: “Zionist propaganda…uprooted Moroccan Jews from their country, from villages and cities, and threw them into the furnace of battle [in Palestine]” (El Maleh, 2021, 135). Wazana’s choice to frame Levy’s prediction about the destruction of “the spirit of Judaism” if Israel’s settler colonial project continues with an image of a Jewish cemetery in Morocco suggests that she recognized these sites would become ever more contested spaces.
4For viewers familiar with Arabic, the deracinating effects of Zionism were clear from the moment Ohayon requested they speak in Arabic. Despite being a Moroccan Jew, she mostly speaks in Egyptian Arabic, meanwhile Levy—a professor of Spanish and expert in multiple Moroccan languages—seamlessly transitions from French into Classical and Moroccan Arabic. Levy’s short interjections in Moroccan Arabic convey certain points to Ohayon with particular clarity, like when he says “we [Moroccan Jews] are the ones who are your [Israelis’] victims [hennā daḥāya diyālkum]” and firmly rejects her argument that Mizrahim in Israel are victims of Zionism: “don’t exaggerate… that’s a load of hot air [mā tazīdūsh… hadhī hadra khāwiya].”
5The tension produced by Ohayon and Levy’s differing objectives—her focus on educating the Israeli Jewish public on interfaith histories and his race to preserve Moroccan Jewish heritage in Morocco—is indicative of how we got to this moment. While Jewish cemeteries in Morocco have been restored such that they may be better cared for now than ever before, they are simultaneously being emptied of bodies through ever more frequent exhumations. Some of these exhumed Moroccan Jewish bodies are subsequently being reburied in historic Palestine, where Palestinians have been systematically violated by the Israeli State since its founding through ethnic cleansing, mass displacement, and the desecration of Palestinian cemeteries (Belli, 2022; Eghbariah, 2024; El-Haj, 2002; Khalidi, 2020). The violation of Palestinian bodies in life and death has perhaps never been starker than during the ongoing genocide that began in 2023.
6Levy’s warning suggests that without an end to Zionism’s settler colonial project both Ohayon’s and Levy’s work may be for naught given that “the spirit of Judaism” will be destroyed. As will be elucidated in this article, for many Moroccans the spirit of Moroccan Judaism rests upon the existence of Moroccan Jewish cemeteries, filled with the bodies of Moroccan Jews in Morocco. Long before Moroccan state-funded restoration in the 2000s, Jewish cemeteries were an essential piece of the country’s landscape, preserved thanks to interfaith practices, with Muslims serving as principal caretakers and participating regularly in spiritual pilgrimages to saintly gravesites. Thus, when one focuses on the movements traversing Moroccan Jewish cemeteries over the last few decades, a serious incompatibility appears between how Moroccan (Jewish and Muslim) belonging in Morocco has been preserved and the settler colonial relationship to Palestine that Zionism imposes.
7Specifically, I argue that the removal of Jewish bodies from their resting place in Morocco for reburial in occupied Palestine/Israel disrupts historic, celebrated, interfaith practices for cultivating Jewish and Muslim belonging in Morocco through shared custodianship of the dead. Furthermore, I contend that what Meriam Belli has described as the State of Israel’s “ethno-necrocratic order,” which reinforces “the supremacy of Jewish bodies and afterlives over non-Jewish ones” through the appropriation of land in Palestine, extends to other places, like Morocco (Belli, 2022, 624). In other words, exhumations of deceased Jews from countries like Morocco for reburial in historic Palestine contribute to Israel’s implementation of a Jewish supremacist ethno-necrocratic order while simultaneously deracinating Jews from their historic homelands. Moreover, the significant investment in restoration of Moroccan Jewish cemeteries, despite this practice of exhumation, draws attention to inequalities across the Moroccan funerary landscape, what we might call a Moroccan ethno-necrocratic order. Recent research on cemetery maintenance in Morocco has found that, on a national level, Jewish and Christian cemeteries generally had “great security and care” compared to neighboring Muslim funerary sites characterized by “neglect… pollution and vandalism” (Hilāl et al., 2023, 98). Similarly, others have highlighted that Black African migrants are frequently interred as “Muslims by default” and “collectively grouped… relegated to the periphery of the cemetery, lack proper registration and may only be marked by small stones” (Sonneveld & Alami Merrouni, 2025, 1012‑1013). Relatedly, there are claims that segregated burials for Black Moroccans may have existed in a few limited historical cases (Bouhchichi & Berrada, 2016; Zafrani, 1998).
8Drawing from fieldwork conducted between 2015 and 2025, the article begins by describing several exhumations at Moroccan Jewish cemeteries over the past few decades, using data from interviews conducted with cemetery caretakers, participant observation at these sites, and literary as well as documentary films about these spaces. I also analyze secondary literature on the topic of Jewish reburials in historic Palestine over the last century. I then provide an overview of the role that cemeteries have played in Moroccan Jewish heritage preservation over the last 40 years, referencing extensive archival material from the papers of the late Shim‘ūn Levy, widely considered to be the father of Moroccan Jewish heritage preservation. Finally, I examine recent burials of Moroccan Jews in Morocco through analysis of informational material on Moroccan Jewish funerary practices produced by Moroccan heritage workers, international media coverage, and films that have documented these burials.
- 6 I am using a pseudonym here because of the sensitivity of this topic.
9When I first met Khaled6, the caretaker of a northern Moroccan Jewish cemetery, he told me about people coming to the cemetery and digging up bodies that were subsequently taken out of Morocco. I was skeptical because over years studying heritage sites in Morocco I had noticed how frequently these spaces acquired an almost mythical nature, filled with stories of the most sacred and profane happenings. With regard to Muslim cemeteries in Fes, Yousra Sbaihi has argued that their heterotopic nature transforms them into sites of placelessness, “more than a storage area for the dead,” that become an “elucidation of death as continuation rather than annihilation” through visitor interactions (Sbaihi, s.d.).
10As an anti-Zionist Jew who is not Moroccan but was drawn to Morocco because of Moroccan Jewish resistance to European colonialism, I myself took part in mythologizing the region’s cemeteries. Guided by anti-Zionist Moroccan Jewish writing, like El Maleh’s essay “Le dernier juif d’Asilah,” I saw these spaces as a counterpoint to Zionism’s claim of primary or exclusive Jewish belonging in historic Palestine. One section of El Maleh’s essay, which recounts the last person buried in Asilah’s Jewish cemetery in 1966, explicitly states why Moroccan Jewish burial in Morocco counters colonial, Zionist deracination:
The last Jew of Asilah. Never will another Jew die within this whiteness. Not another will be born among the glory of this light. Nahon! With him, a destiny was fulfilled. Others, perhaps, died in this city after him, but their death was stolen from this land of their birth. Buried elsewhere so as not to say that they had lived there (El Maleh, 1980, 6).
11El Maleh’s description of the burial of Moroccan Jewish dead after Nahon outside Morocco as a form of robbery reflects an understanding of the continuation of Moroccan Judaism—and Moroccan Jewish belonging to Morocco—as fundamentally linked to the burial of Moroccan Jews in Morocco.
12When I asked Khaled for more details about exhumations at the cemetery he preserves, he shared that the majority of those removing bodies came from Israel and that they took the remains of their ancestors. Since I had heard about increased security concerns during conversations with caretakers in larger cities, particularly stories of people trying to practice magic at cemeteries, I dismissed Khaled’s observations. It was not until 2023 that I was forced to reconsider when a heritage worker with deep connections to institutional Jewish life mentioned to me that soon there will be “Jewish cemeteries without the dead [mi‘ārāt bilā ’amwāt]” in Morocco.
13I was shocked to hear about the danger of cemeteries being emptied of their bodies, especially given the fact that so much heritage work in Morocco has centered around these spaces (Boum, 2012; Kosansky, 2002; Paloma, 2022; Stoolman, 2025). In 2010, King Muhammad VI launched a Jewish cemetery rehabilitation project, which identified 167 sites in 14 regions of Morocco for state-funded restoration. While some have characterized the movement to restore Jewish cemeteries as a step toward Morocco’s eventual normalization with Israel through the 2020 Abraham Accords, in reality, investment in this heritage work has for decades been a staple of grassroots, anti-colonial movements and of Moroccan Jewish community-led initiatives (Boum, 2013; Bouziane & Stoolman, 2025; Kosansky, 2002).7
14The increased rate and openness with which exhumations are occurring has caught the attention of community members and heritage workers. Prominent documentaries on Moroccan Jewish life have included scenes detailing the practice. In Simon Bitton’s “Ziyara” (2020), Leila, the caretaker of Meknes’ Jewish cemetery, reveals the growing phenomenon and its effect on Moroccans who remain in Morocco:
Perhaps they didn’t want to keep coming and going a lot, maybe they have circumstances [ẓurūf]…God only knows. I don’t know what they have, the poor souls [msākin]. May God help them… In front of me, they have taken around 12. I was present. Everyone was present. Everyone knows, the government [makhzen], everything [is done by] law… They bring a box, like this, and they take out those bones… I saw them. They take out the bones, quickly… this is the head, legs, these are the hands…. They gather them in a cloth bag and then they put it in the box and then they pray with the Rabbi. It is not random. No! With their rabbi, they bring those things and when they take them, you see misery here. I won’t lie to you… We feel sadness here… We don’t laugh or talk, nothing… Just silent. They take care of their stuff and finish. We don’t talk at all. Nothing. We help them if they want us to help them and that’s it. I swear, we don’t talk. We don’t talk. Nothing…. Misery.
15The next scene is an image of several rows of graves with what appears to be a cemented over section that may have once been the site of graves. Jewish cemeteries across Morocco have sections like this.
Figure 3. Still from Simon Bitton’s film “Ziyara” (2020) showing Meknes’ Jewish cemetery
© Simone Bitton
16It is fair to assume that many—if not most—are taking bodies to historic Palestine for multiple reasons. Firstly, there are well-documented cases of Moroccan Jewish reburials in historic Palestine. Secondly, recent changes to Moroccan administrative procedures—in the wake of the Abraham Accords—that clarify the procedure for exhumations also suggest this connection. Thirdly, and perhaps most persuasively, scholarship on Jewish burial over the last century in occupied Palestine/Israel, particularly the work of Doron Bar and Alex Weingrod, has indicated that Zionism—specifically “the new perspective of Zionist time and space and the need to ‘sanctify’ the land and define the Zionist Israeli territory”—has led to the exhumation of Jewish bodies across the world and their reburial in historic Palestine (Bar, 2020, 2016, 15; Weingrod, 2006).
17During my fieldwork in Morocco as well as through personal experiences, I have found that the reasons for investing the thousands of dollars required for exhumation and reburial range from earthly justifications, like wanting to have family gravesites close-by in historic Palestine, to a common (mis)conception that reburial in the Holy Land is a well-established Jewish ritual. Quite to the contrary, rabbinic writing since at least Late Antiquity has broadly agreed that the deceased should not be disturbed, claiming that exhumation “defiles the dead person, violates his dignity, and troubles the souls of those who have died” (Bar, 2016, 14-15; Garibova, 2020; Polak, 2001; Ydit, s.d.). In addition to centuries-old rabbinic agreement on respecting a person’s final resting place, there is no archaeological evidence that systematic exhumation and reburial of Jewish bodies in the Holy Land ever occurred before the establishment of the State of Israel. Even in recent years, controversy has erupted regarding the excavation of medieval Jewish burial sites in Europe, leading to reburial of these excavated bodies in nearby, functioning Jewish cemeteries—not in historic Palestine (Ayaso Martínez, 2022; Colomer, 2013).
- 8 It is important to clarify that there is scholarship on exhumation of Jewish bodies following the N (...)
- 9 This term generally refers to Jewish immigrant settlers in historic Palestine during the decades im (...)
18Weingrod demonstrates that Moroccan Jews have figured prominently in what we might call an exhumation movement since at least the 1980s.8 Though Weingrod and Bar have mainly identified the reburial of prominent Zionist thinkers like Theodor Herzl in historic Palestine as the earliest examples of “political reburials” with Israeli state support, Moroccan Jewish reburials in historic Palestine have also risen to similar levels of prominence. In the 1980s, for example, Israelis of Moroccan origin—who were also “religious functionaries”—went to Agadir and “surreptitiously acquired the bones of four rabbis, all of them saintly [tzaddikim], packed them in suitcases and then flew back to Israel (via France) where the bones were reburied in a site close to the cemetery of the Israeli town of Kiryat Malachi” (Weingrod, 2006, 49). Their new burial place in historic Palestine has become a site of pilgrimage, just as it had been in Morocco. Years later, and this time with official Israeli and Moroccan State support, the victims of the capsize of the Pisces—a Mossad-commissioned ship clandestinely carrying Moroccan Jews to Palestine—would also be reburied on Mount Herzl in the State of Israel, alongside Zionist thinkers who had been disinterred from their respective homelands. Weingrod notes “this, too, was a political statement: they were ‘martyrs’ [for Zionism], and in addition… this reburial was part of a lengthy process in which Moroccan Jews—and, more generally, Jews from Middle Eastern countries—were deemed to have become more ‘fully Israeli,’ as the tale of their heroic struggle to immigrate to Israel placed them among the legendary maapilim”9 (Weingrod, 2006, 47).
19Yoram Bilu investigates the Agadir case further in his ethnography The Saints’ Impresarios. Rabbi Hayyim Pinto was one of the religious functionaries who participated in the smuggling of the bones of his own family line out of Agadir. Bilu notes that Moroccan authorities at the time of his fieldwork (up until the early 2000s) were reticent to allow Moroccan bodies—namely Jews—to be removed from their burial place in Morocco (Bilu, 2009, 51). Today, the prevalence of news articles from major publications in Morocco and Israel explicitly recognizing this practice and, in some cases associating it directly with the Abraham Accords, suggests that circumstances have changed since its signing. For example, in 2021, Benny Gantz wrote an op-ed thanking the King of Morocco, Muhammad VI, for providing his private plane to transport Rabbi Avraham Elhadad—a rabbi for the Jewish community of Sarcelles who was born in Tangier—to Israel after his unexpected death during a visit to Morocco in 2021: “Upon learning of this horrific incident, His Majesty King Mohammad VI contacted the family and chartered a private plane to repatriate Rabbi Elhadad for burial in Israel” (Gross, 2021). While it is unclear if Rabbi Elhadad had been temporarily buried in Morocco and then exhumed and reburied in historic Palestine, a very clear case of exhumation and reburial took place that same year. Seven Jews—one a non-Moroccan Lubavitch Rabbi living in Morocco for decades—who had died at the beginning of the COVID pandemic in 2020 were reburied in historic Palestine (Middle East Eye, 2023). These bodies were sent to historic Palestine in one of the direct flights between Tel Aviv and Marrakesh that began following the Abraham Accords (Hanau, 2021).
20Consequences of the Abraham Accords—signed in December 2020 between the U.S., Israel, and Morocco—have extended well beyond the reburial of Moroccan Jewish bodies in historic Palestine. The most deadly outcomes include: joint training of the Moroccan military with Israel’s Golani Brigade, which has been accused war crimes in Gaza (Uddin, 2025); plans to build Israeli weapons-manufacturing factories in Morocco in addition to Morocco’s purchasing of weapons from Israel, becoming its third largest supplier (Middle East Monitor, 2025); and the authorization of U.S.-Israeli military “overflight” in Moroccan air space, which has been used repeatedly during the Israeli genocide in Palestine (Bouziane & Stoolman, 2025). More specific to the issue of reburial, after the Abraham Accords, Moroccan law regarding exhumation of bodies was updated, “simplifying the procedures and administrative actions” (Yabiladi, 2022).
- 10 A clipping with Levy’s article is held in the Fonds Shim‘ūn Levy at the Archives du Maroc, 6AP 40-4 (...)
21These accords did not suddenly make diplomatic, economic, and military relationships between Morocco and the State of Israel possible. For decades, Morocco and Israel maintained close ties (Boum & El Guabli, s.d.). Activists and scholars alike trace normalization back to the 1960s when prominent collaborations between the two states began, including Operation Yakhin, a coordinated effort to move thousands of Moroccans from their homeland in rural areas of the Moroccan south to historic Palestine (Al-Kohan, 2022; Assidon, 2024; Boum & El Guabli, s.d.; Meddeb & Stora, 2013; Wazana, 2013). By 2013, normalization went far beyond collaboration in the mass exodus of Jews from Morocco and other clandestine activities like the assassination of Mehdi Ben Barka (George, 2020, 128), extending into the commercial sector. Morocco became Israel’s third largest trading partner in the SWANA region (Al Jazeera World, 2015). Over the years, the Moroccan State never put major impediments on the ability of Moroccan Jews to return to their homeland in Morocco, despite the existence of legislation that calls for the removal of Moroccan citizenship for those who have served in foreign armies (Assidon, 2024). In 1967, Shim‘ūn Levy affirmed that Moroccan Israelis were able to return to Morocco freely in an article for Al-Qabs entitled, “Moroccan Jews Returning from Israel Enjoy all Citizenship Rights.”10 Israeli Black Panther, Reuven Abergel, recently echoed Levy’s contention about the unhindered relationship between Moroccan Jews and their homeland in a December 2023 interview with Al-Ayām: “Our links with our country, Morocco, continue and extend all these years and we do not need American middlemen or Israelis to mediate between us or our king or our mother country” (qtd. in Bouziane and Stoolman, 2025).
Figure 4. Al-Qabs newspaper clipping
Fonds of Simon Levy at the Archives du Maroc. Photo taken by Jessie Stoolman in October 2023
22Despite Moroccan Jews never experiencing major legal obstacles to maintaining a relationship with their ancestral cemeteries in Morocco, exhumations have been occurring for decades. Changes to Israeli law in the 1970s may help explain why most known examples of Moroccan Jews being reburied in historic Palestine began in the 1980s. The Jewish Religious Services’ Law of 1971 affirms that any Jewish person who can prove to an Israeli religious council that they have made the “administrative and financial arrangements necessary [for burial]” is granted permission to be buried in the State of Israel/occupied Palestine.11 Relatedly, research has shown that non-Jewish Palestinian cemeteries have repeatedly been the target of seizure by Israeli authorities (El-Haj, 2002; Khalidi, 2020). Belli has noted that “[o]nly non-Jewish funerary land has been systematically subject to real estate development” (Belli, 2022, 625). Given this practice of non-Jewish funerary land seizure and that a recent Israeli governmental report estimated “a shortfall of 1.5 million burial plots” for the “central and Tel Aviv regions” alone, it is fair to assume that Jewish burial within historic Palestine, particularly of non-Israelis, is implicitly connected to Israeli settler colonial expansion.12
23Jewish cemeteries have been a focus of heritage preservation in Morocco for over 40 years. These spaces were and are still under the custodianship of institutions of Jewish life in Morocco, like the Conseil de Communautés Israélites du Maroc (CCIM). By the time Jewish heritage preservation took root in the 1980s, cemeteries in areas that no longer had Jewish residents were largely falling into disrepair—similar to the situation of Muslim cemeteries.
- 13 See also: “Les réformes constitutionnelles et les droits culturels,” June 23, 1992, Al-Bayane, “Pat (...)
- 14 “Au Musée du Judaïsme Marocain” by Stephen Smith, 1996, “Bulletin d’information de la Fondation du (...)
24In the Post-independence period, Moroccan-led heritage preservation was propelled initially by leftist anti-colonial movements (Bouziane and Stoolman, 2025). Following independence, many leftists involved in anti-colonial struggles encouraged inquiry into Moroccan pluralism as part of Morocco’s nation-building process (Ayache, 1981, 1979).13 In the 1980s, many in the Moroccan left began advocating for restoration of cultural sites to engage in this work of historical excavation.14 Writings and actions of members in the Parti du Progrès et du Socialisme (PPS) during this time demonstrate the intermeshing of anti-colonial solidarity, particularly with Palestine, alongside preservation of Morocco’s pluralism, including Jewish and Amazigh heritage. Prominent Amazigh and Jewish members of the PPS, like Mohammad Ferhat and Shim‘ūn Levy, countered legacies of European colonialism that instrumentalized minoritized communities by emphasizing that an anti-colonial praxis in Morocco demanded a defense of pluralism. This anti-colonial pluralism, characterized by solidarity with Palestine, was also evidenced through popular musical anthems in Tamazight and Darija from the 1970s like Jīl Jilāla’s “Al-Quds” and Izenzaren’s hit “ⵚⴰⵀⵉⵓⵏ” [“Zionism”] (Boum & El Guabli, s.d.).
- 15 Simon Levy Fonds, Archives du Maroc; “Fondation du patrimoine culturelle judéo-marocain; Pamphlet “ (...)
- 16 See, for example, documents from the Fonds Shimon Levy showing that Moroccans of all faiths were do (...)
- 17 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B_-QACHprqo.
25It is in this context that Levy started organizing Moroccans and interested external parties, like American Jewish foundations, to preserve Moroccan Jewish heritage inside Morocco. The approach was multipronged as the first documents of the Fondation du Patrimoine Judeo-Marocaine, established by Levy with the CCIM in 1995, lay out: “…restore, conserve, maintain synagogues [and] cemeteries… organize the collection of religious objects, books and manuscripts… Saving our heritage is everyone’s business, wherever we are, whatever our possibilities.”15 Moroccans of all faiths were at the root of Jewish heritage preservation from the outset.16 Many early financial supporters were ordinary Moroccans—Muslims and Jews. In 2020, the late Sion Assidon, an early donor to the Foundation’s work, described Levy’s project as “an attempt to block the door in the face of Zionists who wanted to seize Moroccan Jewish heritage and transfer it to Palestine in museums.”17
Figure 5. Pamphlet from the Fondation du Patrimoine Culturel Judeo-Morocain
Fonds of Simon Levy at the Archives du Maroc. Photo taken by Jessie Stoolman in October 2023
- 18 See, for example, the documents Levy gathered in the folder entitled “Fondation du patrimoine cultu (...)
26By 2006, the Ibn Danan synagogue, Mansano Synagogue, Slat al Fassiyine, and cemeteries in Ifrane, Tetouan, and Tinghir were in the process of being restored. 18The papers of the Fondation reveal, however, that this work was not always effortless and that other Jewish communities were sometimes reticent to participate. One of the most notable examples is the Hôpital Benchimol—Morocco’s first modern hospital built in Tangier in 1904 and named after the Jewish doctor who established it (Diarna, 2010). While Levy fought for the space to be classified as a national monument in the early 2000s, the Communauté Israélite de Tánger (CIT) was suspected to have attempted to sell the space. The site was eventually demolished, causing uproar across the Moroccan Jewish diaspora (Levy, 2010; Silver, 2010). Levy was among the many who publicly decried the loss and placed blame both on the CIT and the local government. Eventually, local governmental and state actors would become increasingly convinced of the social and economic capital to be gained at the intersection of heritage preservation and tourism, resulting in the restoration of whole Jewish neighborhoods like Marrakesh’s mellah.
27Boum has argued that the Moroccan State’s increased involvement in supporting tourism in the 1990s and 2000s, in part, through the creation of museums dedicated to Jewish history and restoration of Jewish sites, has been central to “the branding of Moroccan ‘convivencia’” (Boum, 2020, 209). Kosansky made a similar argument a few years prior in his work focused on the increased participation of Moroccan Jews who were living outside Morocco in the celebration of hillulot in the 1980s and 1990s: “The transnational revitalization of Jewish pilgrimage in Morocco reflects a strategic refashioning of the hillulah as a political showcase of liberal pluralism and as a multifaceted juncture of economic revenue” (Kosansky, 2002, 390). This branding of interfaith convivencia has been mobilized to present Morocco as “a site of moderate Islam” (Boum, 2020, 209) and, I argue, a partner in the U.S.-led campaign for normalization with the State of Israel across the Muslim world.
28Perhaps the most emblematic triangulation of U.S., Israeli, and Moroccan policy objectives in Moroccan Jewish heritage work today are organizations like Bayt Dakira and the Association Mimouna. The Association Mimouna, which started as a club at Al-Akhawayn University in 2007, was part of a trend in the 2000s of greater involvement in heritage work by actors outside the immediate purview of Moroccan Jewish institutional life. Today, it collaborates with the U.S. State Department and the American Sephardi Federation. While continuing to focus on university life in Morocco—helping establish a degree in “Moroccan Judaism Tourism”—it has expanded its scope, deepening ties between the U.S., Israel, and Morocco through the establishment of “leadership” programs, participation in promoting “Holocaust Education,” and organization of workshops for artisans on making Judaica.
29Bayt Dakira, housed in the restored Slat Attia synagogue of Essaouira, is a research center, functioning synagogue, and “space of memory” that opened almost simultaneously with the signing of the Abraham Accords in 2020. Its founder, André Azoulay, has served as advisor to the Moroccan monarchy and has been involved in projects that instrumentalize Moroccan pluralism for diplomatic and economic aims, like the Association Essaouira-Mogador. Bayt Dakira’s permanent exhibit largely highlights social, economic, and diplomatic elites from the city’s Jewish communities and its programming is geared toward bringing together Israeli, Euro-American, and Moroccan politicians and academics.
- 19 “Fondation du Patrimoine Cultural Judeo-Marocain: Juifs Du Maroc ou Extra-Terrestres?” 6AP 43, “Fon (...)
30The very visible and explicit engagement with normalization in the work of the Association Mimouna and Bayt Dakira contrasts, to a degree, with some legacies of Shim‘ūn Levy’s heritage work. Levy focused on countering misinformation that would have the average person believe that all Jews are Zionist. For example, after its establishment in 1995 his Fondation produced educational material that included a pamphlet explaining the existence of non-Zionist Jews and American Christian Zionists.19 It also highlights the imbrication of Zionism and colonialism and their detrimental effects on Morocco’s Jewish communities:
…the Arab-Israeli conflict in the Middle East had negative repercussions such as the anti-Jewish riots of 1948 in Oujda and Djerrada and their many victims. These bloody events were taken advantage of by the colonial administration to destroy the mining unions, imprison their leaders… But Independence brought the Jews full citizenship, from the first speech of Mohamed V. Until 1956, departures for Israel concerned mainly the disadvantaged classes, the perpetually poor and also direct or indirect victims of the economic changes induced by colonization… The colonial administration allowed Zionist activity that “rid” it of a part of the Jewish population, and which created a tension, muted and sometimes violent, between Jews and Muslims.
31Levy’s successor, Zhor Rehihil, has carried on that push to make the diversity of Jewish perspectives and experiences of colonialism visible through interviews she conducted as part of the national radio program on Moroccan Judaism that she hosted, entitled “Nāss el-Mellāḥ,” and her participation in the documentary work of vocal Moroccan Jewish critics of Israel like Simone Bitton.
32Today, over 150 Jewish cemeteries across Morocco have been fully renovated, many with full-time security, completely new infrastructure, and ever greater accessibility. Asilah’s cemetery, which was renovated alongside one of the medina’s synagogues and the community’s old farrān and hammām in 2022, is an example of the disparities across Morocco’s heritage landscape, as the city’s Muslim cemetery is located nearby and remains in disrepair. The inauguration of many renovated Jewish cemeteries has been the subject of extensive fanfare—with national and international coverage.
Figure 6a. Asilah’s Jewish cemetery
Photo taken by Jessie Stoolman in November 2022
Figure 6b. Asilah’s Jewish cemetery
Photo taken by Jessie Stoolman in November 2022
Figure 6c. Asilah’s Jewish cemetery
Photo taken by Jessie Stoolman in November 2022
Figure 7 Marrakesh’s Jewish cemetery
Photo taken by Jessie Stoolman in May 2023.
33Serge Berdugo, the current Secretary General of the CCIM, like Raphael El Maleh and others who have worked closely on cemetery restoration, is quick to detail the “welcome” with which these restoration projects were received, particularly in the south of Morocco. 20Both Raphy El Maleh and Berdugo provide examples of villagers maintaining a precise memory of the borders of cemeteries despite, in some cases, the more than 60 years since the departure of the last Jew in their region.21 Raphy El Maleh, in an interview with Zhor Rehihil on “Nāss el-Mallāḥ,” reinforced this claim. She asked him what are the traces of Moroccan Jewish life that can be found throughout the country to which El Maleh responded, “the cemetery [al-maqbara], it is always there and Muslims always respect them,” explaining later that the King chose to restore Jewish sites throughout Morocco, “because his ancestors, they always respected Jews’ things.”22
34This discourse of supposed Moroccan exceptionalism has accompanied much state-sponsored heritage work over the last two decades and is frequently combined with an unambiguous political strategy, perhaps no more clearly encapsulated than by André Azoulay being awarded in September 2023 the Israeli “Presidential Medal of Honor” by Isaac Herzog, who has served as Israeli president throughout the ongoing genocide in Gaza. Azoulay, standing in occupied Jerusalem, lays out this instrumentalization of Moroccan Jewish heritage: “I leave even more convinced than ever to make prevail what… my Moroccan Judaism… has taught me about the world… our world needs a compass and I have the immodesty to think that this compass can be Moroccan.”
- 23 Importantly, some have criticized the 2011 Moroccan Constitution’s use of the term “Hebrew” to desc (...)
35As the involvement of the advisor to the king and the Fondation nationale des musées, which is constructing Jewish museums across Morocco (Misk, 2023), indicates, Moroccan heritage preservation is no longer relegated to the private sector. Under the directorship of Dr. Jamâa Baïda, a historian with a long record of interest in documenting Morocco’s non-Muslim communities, the Archives du Maroc implemented an explicit acquisition strategy aimed at repatriating from France archives of Morocco’s pluralism, including those pertaining to its Moroccan Jewish history (Baida, 1996, 2013; Baida & Feroldi, 2005; Baida, 2019). Today, the Archives host the private papers of major Moroccan Jewish figures, like Levy and the Corcos family, as well as agreements with other archives pertaining to Moroccan Jewish life like the archives of the Alliance Israélite Universelle. The 2011 constitution further enshrined Jewish heritage work into law by recognizing the “Hebraic”23 element of Moroccan identity, as well as Amazigh, Sahrawi, Arab, and Muslim elements.
- 24 Khevra Kadisha (sacred society) is the group of men or women who accompany community members on the (...)
36Within this context of intense national and international instrumentalization of Moroccan Jewish heritage, and despite the nascent exhumation movement described above, bodies do continue to be buried in Jewish cemeteries across the country. As affirmed by Yaakov Tordjman, a member of Morocco’s only remaining khevra kadisha which is based in Casablanca,24 the rituals have remained more or less the same, with many Moroccan particularities still in practice. In an interview on “Nāss El-Mellāḥ,” Tordjman provides a step-by-step overview of how Jewish bodies have been prepared for burial in Morocco for most of the last century (MedRadio Officiel, 2021). Tordjman details shared customs between Muslims and Jews in Morocco, like the placing of wood and rocks inside the graves. Importantly, he acknowledges that one of the newer steps in the process of burial preparation has been the establishment of a waiting period, immediately following a death, to allow family from outside the country to arrive and, perhaps, decide where the person would be buried.
37Much like Jewish heritage, the burial of Moroccan Jews living outside Morocco in their homeland has been mobilized to reflect a range of political ideologies from neoliberal multiculturalism to militant anti-colonialism. Edmond Amran El Maleh, for example, has been the object of diverse Jewish heritage preservation projects in the years since his death in 2010 (Bouziane & Stoolman, 2025). In 2023, the Archives du Maroc organized an extensive homage to the writer, highlighting, in a section entitled “Ses œuvres au cœur de l’identité plurielle,” his main argument that the tragedy of mass Jewish exodus from Morocco and Israel’s anti-Palestinian violence are intimately intertwined. The exhibit also detailed multiple public denunciations of Zionism and the State of Israel that El Maleh made alongside other anti-colonial Moroccans of Jewish descent like Sion Assidon and Abraham Serfaty. Meanwhile, at Essaouira’s Bayt Al-Dakira, a short video from his funeral and burial in the city’s local cemetery—with Azoulay in attendance—figures prominently on the first floor, without any mention of El Maleh’s political commitments. Most recently, Simone Bitton released the film “Les Mille et Uns Jours du Hajj Edmond,” in which she centers his critique of Israel, with the trailer featuring the following observation: “What concerned Edmond most was not Palestine but Morocco. He could not forgive Israel for destroying the Moroccan Jewish identity in his country” (Bitton, 2024).
Figure 8a. The Archives du Maroc exhibit on Edmond El Maleh
Photo taken by Jessie Stoolman in November 2023
Figure 8b. Video showing Edmond El Maleh’s funeral at Bayt Dakira
Photo taken by Jessie Stoolman in October 2022
38El Maleh’s burial in Essaouira’s cemetery was the first to take place in over 150 years according to Joseph Sebag, a renowned antiquarian in Essaouira, frequently referred as the last Essaouiran Jew, and a friend of El Maleh. National media in Morocco—which covered the event heavily—narrated El Maleh’s choice of Essaouira for a final resting place as “his desire to rest in the land of his ancestors.”25 In accordance with his wishes, El Maleh’s tomb epitaph was engraved in four languages—Arabic, Tamazight, French, and Hebrew. Over the past six years visiting Essaouira, I have watched the mi‘āra where he is buried receive ever-more visitors, particularly catering to those wishing to pay tribute to Morocco’s tsaddikim.
Figure 9. Essaouira’s Jewish cemetery
Photo taken by Jessie Stoolman in October 2022
39In vain, I have been searching for the graves of a small Black Jewish community that once existed in Essaouira, which Moroccan historian Haim Zafrani mentions in his oeuvre covering 2000 years of Moroccan Jewish history (Zafrani, 1998). The cemetery’s caretaker has tried to help me locate a few gravestones—with my only finding aid being first names like “Mbaraka” and “Ghalya” that were frequently used for enslaved Black women in Moroccan (Muslim and Jewish) homes. Zafrani mentioned that the conversion of these enslaved women to Judaism, and the fact that they sometimes bore children as a result of sexual assault by their enslavers, occassionally leading to intra-communal friction (as in the case of Muslim communities)—particularly when deciding where they should be buried. Each year more gravestones on the older side of the mi‘āra (not where El Maleh is buried) are refurbished and their engravings reemerge, bringing me hope that I might one day locate some of these individuals whose burials Zafrani took the time to record.
40Whereas El Maleh’s burial in Essaouira was the subject of intensive media coverage, the burial of another revolutionary leftist, anti-Zionist Moroccan Jew, Abraham Serfaty, in Casablanca’s main Jewish cemetery in the same year did not garner similar levels of media attention The circumstances were slightly different—while both Serfaty and El Maleh had returned to live in Morocco almost a decade prior to their deaths, Serfaty’s choice to live his last years and die in Morocco was particularly significant, especially considering the fact that Serfaty, unlike El Maleh, had been forced into exile twice—even having his citizenship revoked—and yet yearned to return to Morocco (Slyomovics, 2016).
41In her documentary “Ziyara,” Simone Bitton interviewed Serfaty’s comrade, Fouad Abdelmoumin, who had also been imprisoned during the Years of Lead, in the Casablanca cemetery where Serfaty is buried. The interview begins with her asking if it had some meaning for Abdelmoumin that Serfaty was Jewish: “…it was the affirmation of us overcoming closed identities of archaic affiliations to religious references. The fact that he was Jewish, for us, was to assert that we all belong to the human race, that we have the same rights, the same duties, and the same struggles.” After sharing his experience being a political prisoner with Serfaty, she asks him “Are there any political prisoners in Morocco today?” His response is “Unfortunately, a lot!” Nonetheless, the interview ends on an optimistic note:
Abraham is an image and testimony of a very beautiful potential of ours, that we are far from having fully realized, but continues to feed our dream and pushes us to move forward and progress. It reminds us of that part of us that is Jewish, that is poorly recognized, and that we remember from time to time. When in a cemetery, it’s nostalgia, sometimes bitterness, but with a lot of love… Moroccan Judaism cannot be considered as something external. It is part of our collective heritage. The fact that we have been deprived, by this hemorrhaging of the Jewish community, is a wound to the body of Morocco, which has left us impoverished in terms of our diversity [alterité].
42Other examples of expatriate Jews being buried in Morocco have caught national and international attention, despite the relative anonymity of the dead, indicating that figures like Serfaty pose a challenge to triumphalist instrumentalization of Jewish burials in Morocco. Johana Devico Ohana, one of the members of Fes’ Jewish community (living abroad) is in charge of one of the city’s 200-year-old cemeteries and shared her father’s story in a video for the United Nations. After introducing herself, she talks about her childhood in Fes “we lived in harmony. We had no tension” (ONU Info, 2023). The video then reads in large text “Morocco’s Jewish and Muslim communities have lived in harmony as neighbors for over a millennium.” She recounts that her father, who was ill for many years and receiving treatment in France, would constantly demand of her: “You will promise me one thing: that if I ever pass when I am in France, bring me back to Fes.” The video ends with her saying, “he is in Fes. He is not far from us…I hope he rests in peace.”
43While Ohana’s testimony of burying her father in Morocco despite his living abroad certainly was politicized in its instrumentalization, much like El Maleh’s burial, as a symbol of Morocco’s millennium-old coexistence of faiths, I have encountered many more stories like hers, of parents requesting burial in Morocco. A close friend and anti-Zionist activist born and raised in New York, whose father left Morocco decades ago and has never returned, was surprised to learn that he, too, wishes to be buried in Morocco. This friend was pleased to hear his request, after years of being at odds with her father politically, particularly with regard to Zionism and its impacts on Morocco’s history. She has shared with me that she wonders if years of sharing anti-Zionist perspectives on Moroccan Jewish and other Arab Jewish histories—like Wazana’s film—had finally changed her father’s mind about his home country. I reassured her that this wish was attainable given the 2020 loosening of administrative hurdles to repatriation of Moroccan bodies from abroad for burial in the country. However, the reality has proven to be much more complicated than I expected, raising the question: which Moroccan Jews can still rest eternally in Morocco?
44In this overview of happenings at Moroccan Jewish cemeteries over the last few decades, it appears that, for many Moroccan Jews, burial of saintly and non-saintly bodies in Morocco is important precisely because custodianship of the dead has connected Moroccan Jews to their place of birth and death for generations. I have argued that this widespread understanding of Moroccan Jewish belonging in Morocco extends beyond Moroccan Jews to Muslims, especially those that care for deceased Jews and Jewish heritage. Thus, exhumations of Moroccan Jews for reburial outside Morocco—particularly in historic Palestine—which appear to have increased over the last few decades, disrupt preservation of Moroccan Jewish belonging in Morocco through long-established, oft-celebrated, interfaith custodianship of the dead.
45Additional inquiry will need to address the entanglement of Israeli ethno-necropolitics in historic Palestine with burial and exhumation practices in Morocco as well as other homelands where Jews have lived throughout the world. This entanglement, especially in contexts like Morocco where Jewish heritage has been the focus of extensive preservation efforts, elucidates how the coloniality of Zionism’s relationship to Palestine fundamentally challenges millennial practices of Jewish belonging outside the Biblical Holy Land. Investigation of how Israeli ethno-necropolitics are exported outside the Levant also brings into relief other ethno-necropolitical orders, demonstrating the importance of afterlife rituals in understanding how belonging continues to be negotiated, even for the dead.