Skip to navigation – Site map

HomeIssues2020/4Book ReviewsCHow, Yiu Fai. 2019. Caring in Ti...

Book Reviews

CHow, Yiu Fai. 2019. Caring in Times of Precarity: A Study of Single Women Doing Creative Work in Shanghai. Camden: Palgrave Macmillan.

Gladys Pak Lei Chong
p. 62-63

Full text

1Single women in China, socially stigmatised and marginalised as shengnü (剩女, literally, leftover women), are popular subjects of cultural productions that deserve but are yet to receive systematic scholarly attention. Yiu Fai Chow’s Caring in Times of Precarity: A Study of Single Women Doing Creative Work in Shanghai is a pioneering study that examines the relationship between single women and creative work. Apart from being an academic, Chow is also a creative writer, and this role has given him “direct access” and curiosity for this exceptional ethnographic and political project. The author has brought his observations in the East Asian context to a theoretical level, shedding new light on the dynamics and complexities of precarity, while also shifting the gaze from the political economy to the politics of (self)-care.

2This book is distinguished by its resistance to “dishistorizing and flattening precarious experiences” (p. 13). Chow discerningly draws “Asia as method” (Chen 2010) to accentuate the use of Shanghai and China so as to enrich and rethink the theoretical scholarship in single womanhood and precarity in creative work. By bringing in the subjective experiences of single women, the author demonstrates the importance of empirical understanding that does not universalise precarious experiences. It challenges the dominant understanding and critique of precarity – “increasing informalization, flexibilization, and precarization of employment” (p. 12) – that gravely overlooks intersectional subjective experiences. Although sharing similar experiences of exploitation, long working hours, and job insecurity, these single women in creative industries “do like the work they do and find ways to do” (p. 14), and their experiences are “affectively different from one posited by critical thinkers” (p. 16). The author argues for the politics of recognition (p. 19) that acknowledge individuals’ ability to refuse social expectations, and to care for themselves.

3The contents of the book are well-organised and presented with a strong sense of coherence. Its nine chapters are well-connected with each other, but each can easily be turned into independent reading on a specific aspect in singlehood studies. The book’s empirical and analytical core lies in chapters 3 to 8. The introductory chapter provides an investigative framework of this study of single women in Shanghai along two intersecting areas of study: 1) single woman studies and 2) creative class and precarity. Chow presents a comprehensive scholarship in these fields, skilfully bringing them into dialogue.

4Chapter 2 examines the media representations of single women in popular cultural productions. The author first offers a lucid overview of these representations across a wide array of genres and platforms, from dating shows to TV dramas. This is followed by a detailed textual analysis of Ode to Joy (Huanle Song 欢乐颂), the most popular TV drama series in mainland China in 2016, about five single women living in the same Shanghai residential complex. Chow’s analysis demonstrates powerfully how popular media productions can represent “the symbolic realities single women in China have to live with” (p. 73). Chapter 3 examines how these single women experience the generational discourses – the post-1970s (qilinghou 七零后), the post-1990s (jiulinghou 九零后), and the post-1980s (balinghou 八零后). The author draws on three women’s narratives of their generational experiences to investigate the merits and limitations of such generational discourses, urging readers to consider the intra- and intergenerational complexities.

5Chapter 4 examines the intertwining relationship between single lives and their creative work. Chow engages critically with studies in creative work. Paying specific attention to informants’ experiences in creative work and start-ups (chuangye 创业), he proposes to look beyond the concerns of exploitation and alienation, at least briefly, to understand a sense of achievement experienced by these single women in creative work. Chow unfolds three overlapping scenarios about the mutual constitutions of singlehood and creative work, calling for the urgent need to insert gendered perspective in creative work studies. Chapter 5 inquires further into these single women’s lives in domains of intimacy. Not only does he discuss parental persuasion against singlehood, including matchmaking (xiangqin ), but, more intriguingly, Chow demonstrates the various tactics these single women use to reject these social pressures and their tactics for finding a partner (e.g. Love Club).

6Chapter 6 is a unique case study that examines single women’s after-work lives. Intrigued by the informants’ devotion to Kunqu (昆曲), the author investigates how and why this traditional operatic art builds an “informal society” (p. 189). It extends sociality among creative labourers beyond the professional sphere by engaging debates on community, citizenship, and fan studies. Chapter 7 explores an alternative research method – “mattering map” – to look into these women’s spatial relationship with Shanghai. From their mobile narratives to Shanghai and daily (im)mobility, Chow probes into the issues of belonging, security, convenience (fangbian 方便), choice, and freedom, and above all their rights in the city. Chapter 8 creatively employs a visual methodology – “cultural probing” – to let the informants use their creative skills to express and represent themselves. These self-portraits vigorously display these women’s intense longing for change and transformation. In the epilogue (Chapter 9), Chow critically reflects on how he, “not a single woman,” can “speak on their behalf” (p. 287). He closes this book with an eloquent quote from D. H. Lawrence – “Ours is essentially a tragic age, so we refuse to take it tragically” (p. 288) – hope despite desperate circumstances.

7Caring in Times of Precarity is well-structured and innovative in design, methodologically rich and strong in combining conventional qualitative interviews and ethnographic research methods with alternative ones, such as mapping and cultural probing. The narrative accounts of informants’ lives present not simply data or research materials, but also lively sharing that lures readers to engage, think, and reflect on their struggles, joys, pain, and hope. Chow’s criticality and reflectiveness is revealed in how he successfully bridges the relationship with the informants as a friend and as an academic.

8This book is full of valuable insights, engaging brilliantly with theoretical debates and existing literature on creative industries, singlehood, sex and gender studies, Chinese and Asian studies, and fandom studies. Chow’s work, as part of the European Commission’s funded research project on Asian woman in Shanghai and Delhi, has powerfully generated curiosity, urgency, and importance toward contemporary Asian women that invites further comparative studies of the regional, national, cultural, social class, and age impacts on singlehood. Caring in Times of Precarity will be a classic and a must-read for those interested in singlehood and creative industries.

Top of page

Bibliography

Chen, Kuan Hsing. 2010. Asia as Method: Towards Deimperialization. Durham and London: Duke University Press. https://doi.org/10.1215/9780822391692.

Top of page

References

Bibliographical reference

Gladys Pak Lei Chong, « CHow, Yiu Fai. 2019. Caring in Times of Precarity: A Study of Single Women Doing Creative Work in Shanghai. Camden: Palgrave Macmillan. », China Perspectives, 2020/4 | 2020, 62-63.

Electronic reference

Gladys Pak Lei Chong, « CHow, Yiu Fai. 2019. Caring in Times of Precarity: A Study of Single Women Doing Creative Work in Shanghai. Camden: Palgrave Macmillan. », China Perspectives [Online], 2020/4 | 2020, Online since 01 December 2020, connection on 11 May 2021. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/chinaperspectives/11088 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/chinaperspectives.11088

Top of page

About the author

Gladys Pak Lei Chong

Gladys Pak Lei Chong is Associate Professor at the Hong Kong Baptist University. Department of Humanities and Creative Writing, RRS 603, Sir Run Run Shaw Building, Ho Sin Hang Campus, HKBU, 224 Waterloo Road, Kowloon Tong.gladyschong@hkbu.edu.hk

Top of page

Copyright

© All rights reserved

Top of page
  • Logo CEFC – Centre d’études français sur la Chine contemporaine
  • OpenEdition Journals
Search OpenEdition Search

You will be redirected to OpenEdition Search