Count Alerino Palma in the Age of Revolutions or Greek 1821 in Context
Résumés
L’histoire d’un migrant politique italien, le comte Alerino Palma, élucide les éléments clés des années révolutionnaires de 1820, lorsque les anciens officiers de Napoléon Bonaparte ont servi divers soulèvements démocratiques autour de la Méditerranée. Palma a finalement offert son expertise dans le cas du premier emprunt grec et du système juridique du nouvel État grec où il s’est finalement établi. À travers ses pérégrinations géographiques et ses nouvelles expériences, Palma a transformé ses idées politiques démocratiques en soutenant la monarchie constitutionnelle. Son étude de cas de l’« amitié politique » gréco-italienne marque une période de transition qui a alimenté le transnationalisme des années 1820 à l’aube de l’ère de l’État national dans de nombreux pays méditerranéens.
Entrées d’index
Haut de pageTexte intégral
- 1 Mark Mazower, The Greek Revolution: 1821 and the Making of Modern Europe, London, Penguin, 2021.
1During the bicentenary of 2021, the Greek Revolution of 1821 was framed from the point of view of both time and political significance in the panorama of the European revolutions of the 1820s. Although all but that of Greece failed, in the long term they constituted an important phase of those revolutionary and democratic processes that resulted in the formation of national states1. Over the course of almost a century, the revolution of 1821 led to the gradual creation of the Greek state and sovereign territory. In 1828 the newborn Greek state occupied an area of 47,000 square kilometres and had a population of approximately 750,000 inhabitants. The establishment of the Greek state marked the formation of a national state and economy. It has now been well documented that the role of Greek transnational merchants in the trade with the Ottoman Empire, the advantages conferred by the Capitulations and the absence of national state borders favoured flexible family networks, their entrepreneurial strategies and relocations, allowing some Greeks to remain in the diaspora, while others moved to the new economic centres of the Greek state such as Ermoupolis, Patras and Piraeus.
2Greece was a small country with a small population that offered many opportunities for the relocation of foreigners, such as Napoleon’s officers Antonio Morandi, Count Santorre di Santarosa, and Giuseppe Pecchio. Some of these foreigners had republican aspirations and were deprived of a professional career and a disciplined environment, while others were driven away from their home town by foreign or authoritarian rule. The majority were professionals who were forced to disperse throughout the Mediterranean area in the 1820s with various political and investment ideas for the future of their region and nation state. They belonged to wider elite migrations in the Mediterranean area which encompassed a) migrants without a nation state, such as Jews and Armenians (who were merchants and craftsmen), b) migrants from nation states, such as the French and the British (merchants and consuls), and c) migrants from European countries or the Balkan area who were active adherents of efforts to establish nation states, such as Greeks and Italians (merchants and professionals).
3Some were politically persecuted for their ideas, but even more so for their actions against foreign authorities, and faced legal consequences due to their actions. All were scattered throughout the Mediterranean
area as far afield as Portugal and England and carried with them social capital, military and economic skills, cultural values and political ideas. These individuals and groups, who came from different national and/or ethnic backgrounds, controlled sectors of trade and finance and played an important role in the “European” process of solidarity and cooperation, all while developing their own organizational savoir-faire and practices, often creating, through solidarity and reciprocity, communities that harboured ideas and feelings of national identity. Some members of these groups formed social and political networks, secret societies (such as the Carboneria and Filiki Etaireia) and participated decisively in the formation of their nation states.
- 2 Nicolas Barreyre and Nicolas Delalande, A World of Public Debts. A Political History, part I, Poli (...)
4In the 1820s, Greeks of both the Ottoman Empire and the diaspora had been active for a long time in the narrow and wider Mediterranean area, from the nearby Adriatic to the Black Sea, Gibraltar and beyond; they were in contact and collaborated with Italians, French, English and others. Their relationships were formed in the fields of economics and politics, but also education and art. This world was altered by the revolutionary movements that initiated new fields of economic and political cooperation. It was the time that contracting sovereign loans was the principal resource for financing war expenditures. Since the 1820s, foreign state loans were internationalized, both in terms of contracts and negotiations as well as stocks and bonds that circulated in the early European financial markets. An indispensable prerequisite for contracting these sovereign loans was a national state and government. This new economic reality determined the internationalization of the foreign debts of European countries through contracting sovereign loans, and the circulation of their corresponding bonds and shares in the British, French and Dutch financial markets2.
- 3 Maria Christina Chatziioannou, « La presenza degli Italiani nella Grecia indipendente », in France (...)
- 4 Marco Novarino, “The Contribution of Alerino Palma di Cesnola to the Independence and Consolidatio (...)
- 5 Alerino C. Palma, A Summary Account of the Steam Boats for Lord Cochrane’s Expedition; With Few Wo (...)
5From the 1820s, the revolutionary uprisings in Italy also brought Italian political refugees to the Mediterranean area, where they would encounter migrants from other countries and other ethnic and religious groups3. A characteristic example was Count Alerino Palma di Cesnola (Rivarolo Canavese 1776‑Ermupolis 1851). He had studied law and had been in close contact with Napoleon since 1796. He expressed republican democratic views and migrated to France and Spain (1816‑1820), and later participated in the Piedmontese conspiracy and the unsuccessful uprising of 1821. Consequently, Palma fled to Spain, where he fought with the Constitutionals. After the end of the Spanish Liberal Triennium, he moved to England in 1823. In London, he participated in the philhellenic activities of the London Greek Committee. He was involved in the Greek Revolution, when he took on the task on behalf of the London Greek Committee of transporting and delivering an instalment of the first loan that the Greek and English intermediaries had contracted with the British merchant bankers in the City of London to the Greek Provisional Government. Palma first stayed in Greece in 1824‑18254. Against the backdrop of the new political and economic discussions of the 1820s, the international loans contracted in the City of London opened up a new field of political negotiations around the concept of national sovereignty. Palma wrote two books in English on the question of the Greek international loans contracted during the Greek Revolution in 1824 and 18255.
- 6 Alerino C. Palma, Κατήχησις πολιτική εις χρήσιν των Ελλήνων, συνταχθείσα μεν ιταλιστί υπό του φιλέ (...)
6Palma made a fundamental contribution to the establishment of the new institutional structures in Greece. He published an essay on political doctrine and an account of Europe’s sentimental and political involvement in the Greek Revolution. With these books, Palma addressed the members of the Greek Provisional Administration and the insurgent Greeks in general, future citizens of the independent state. In them he established priorities and explained the fundamental concepts of the future institutional and political organization of the country and defined the rights and duties of national rulers but also of citizens. The formation of a government administration was not only useful, it also had to be legitimate. Without a government, i.e. without law and order, a union of individuals would have been harmful to themselves and would have failed in its objectives. He stressed the need to establish a government capable of preventing or repressing anarchy – which was understood to be a lack of order, justice, law and administration – a condition in which life, private property and honour are threatened and remain defenceless. Consequently, Palma addressed the Europeans, defended the struggle of the Greeks and rejected all critical allegations that circulated against the Greek revolution, its objectives and protagonists6.
7The history of the loans contracted to finance the struggle for Greek independence was a characteristic example of the intertwining of economic aspirations with ethical values. Upon arriving in London in 1824, Palma declared that none of those involved in the loan negotiation were acting under the terms of the agreement and in the interest of Greece, and furthermore, that there was no understanding between the intermediaries. Therefore, Greece needed a strong central authority, a constitutional monarchy. Aspects of Palma’s constitutional patriotism were directed toward the newly established institutional structure of the Greek state.
- 7 Alerino C. Palma, Enologia/Οινολογία. O l’arte di fare e conservare li vini. Ήτοι περί οινοποιίας (...)
8During his thirteen years of wandering throughout the Mediterranean (including through Italy, France, Spain and Greece) and to England, Palma created new net-
works among former officers of Napoleon’s armies, as well as Italian political migrants. In Greece, where he settled in 1829, he was appointed head of various courts. Count Alerino Palma is an example of an expatriate who went from being an Italian militant revolutionary to an international advocate of legitimacy as an attribute of power and its exercise in the modern Greek state. He thus put together modern Greek civil law and established a rational management of the agricultural economy to the advantage of trade7. Unlike other political migrants, Palma did not return to his place of origin, but offered his services to a new country, Greece. His views, stemming from the French Revolution and Napoleon, and inspired by universal democratic values, were gradually forged based on legality and constitutionalism. Individual itineraries like Palma’s help us understand the continuities and discontinuities of economic and political phenomena through agency. He was part of a “transnational revolutionary diaspora” and his story can help us better integrate Greek revolution into the broader Mediterranean and European context of the 19th century revolutions and their aftermath. During his relocations he gradually transformed his ideas through new political experiences. This account of close cooperation and transnational affinities includes key elements of the Greek-Italian “political friendship”, deriving from the Napoleonic era to the revolutions of the 1820s. It was a transitional period that, after the Enlightenment’s cosmopolitanism, fuelled the transnationalism of the 1820s in the dawn of the nation state era of many Mediterranean countries.
Notes
1 Mark Mazower, The Greek Revolution: 1821 and the Making of Modern Europe, London, Penguin, 2021.
2 Nicolas Barreyre and Nicolas Delalande, A World of Public Debts. A Political History, part I, Political Crises and the Legitimacy of Public Debts (1770‑1860s), London, Palgrave Macmillan, 2020, p. 5‑106.
3 Maria Christina Chatziioannou, « La presenza degli Italiani nella Grecia indipendente », in Francesco Guida, Enrica Lucarelli and Caterina Spetsieri Beschi (dir.), Risorgimento greco e filellenismo italiano, Roma, ed. del Sol, 1986, p. 137‑143 ; Maurizio Isabella and Davis Scaffei, Risorgimento in esilio. L’internazionale liberale e l’età delle rivoluzioni, Laterza, Roma/Bari, 2011.
4 Marco Novarino, “The Contribution of Alerino Palma di Cesnola to the Independence and Consolidation of the Greek Nation”, in Francesca Minutoli (ed.), Italian Support for the Greek Revolution, 1821‑1832: A Dress Rehearsal for the Risorgimento, Athens, ETP books, 2021, p. 104‑126.
5 Alerino C. Palma, A Summary Account of the Steam Boats for Lord Cochrane’s Expedition; With Few Words upon the two frigates ordered at New York for the Service of Greece, London, Effingham Wilson, 1826; The Greek Steam‑boats, and Mehmet Ali’s Firman; Being a Following Statement of the Pamphlet a Summary Account of the Steam-boats for Lord Cochrane’s expedition, London, 1827.
6 Alerino C. Palma, Κατήχησις πολιτική εις χρήσιν των Ελλήνων, συνταχθείσα μεν ιταλιστί υπό του φιλέλληνος Κ.Α.Π. [Κόμητος Αλερίνο Πάλμα], μεταφρασθείσα δε παρά Νικολάου Γ. Παγκαλάκη [΄Υδρα], εκ της εν Ύδρα τυπογραφίας, 1826; Greece Vindicated; in Two Letters by Count A.P.; to which are added by the same author critical remarks on the works recently published on the same subject by Messrs. Bulwer, Emerson, Pecchio, Humphreys, Stanhope, Parry & Blaquiere, London, 1826; Lettre de l’auteur de “Greece vindicated” à Louis Frusinate : sur son ouvrage De la force dans les choses politiques, imp. de Charles Wood, London, 1826. He also defined Εngland as the cradle of representative governement: Α. Palma, Difesa dei Piemontesi inquisiti a causa degli avvenimenti del 1821, Bruxelles, [publicher not identified], 1829.
7 Alerino C. Palma, Enologia/Οινολογία. O l’arte di fare e conservare li vini. Ήτοι περί οινοποιίας κατασκευής και συντηρήσεως των οίνων, Athens, Anastasios, 1842-1843.
Haut de pagePour citer cet article
Référence papier
Maria Christina Chatziioannou, « Count Alerino Palma in the Age of Revolutions or Greek 1821 in Context », Diasporas, 40 | 2022, 143-146.
Référence électronique
Maria Christina Chatziioannou, « Count Alerino Palma in the Age of Revolutions or Greek 1821 in Context », Diasporas [En ligne], 40 | 2022, mis en ligne le 13 juin 2023, consulté le 08 novembre 2026. URL : https://journals.openedition.org/diasporas/9736 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/diasporas.9736
Haut de pageDroits d’auteur
Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont susceptibles d’être soumis à des autorisations d’usage spécifiques.
Haut de page



