Navigation – Plan du site

AccueilIssues65Book reviewsJonathan K London, Jagannath Adhi...

Book reviews

Jonathan K London, Jagannath Adhikari, Thomas Robertson (eds), Environmental Justice in Nepal: Origins, struggles and prospects

Nikita Biswakarma
Référence(s) :

Jonathan K London, Jagannath Adhikari, Thomas Robertson (eds), Environmental Justice in Nepal: Origins, struggles and prospects. Routledge, 2024

Texte intégral

1When the reciprocal relationship between humans and their environment is weakened by dominant power dynamics, this prompts many changes, paving the way for disenfranchisement and environmental injustices. Various manifestations of environmental injustice in Nepal with respect to natural resource endowment, unfair and ineffective government policies and exposure of marginalised people to poor environmental conditions are discussed in this book. The latter is organised into seven parts, with 24 chapters spanning 279 pages, covering different coherent and easily understood themes and issues, thereby making an important contribution to scholarship in the field of environmental justice in Nepal. Navigating through its different parts and chapters was an illuminating journey in itself.

  • 1 Where citizens can file a petition on certain issues on behalf of the general public’s interest.

2Part I addresses the origins of environmental justice in Nepal. It comprises three chapters which begin with Jonathan K London and Sudikshya Bhandari’s ‘Towards a new paradigm for environmental justice studies in Nepal’ (chapter 2), which attempts to provide a framework for Nepalese environmental justice studies by tracing the changes in scholarship on environmental justice in Nepal. The authors argue that the distinctiveness of environmental justice movements in Nepal lies in their ‘intersecting disparities caused by caste, class, ethnicity, and gender structures’ (p15). In chapter 3, ‘Environmental justice movements in Nepal: a historical perspective’, Jagannath Adhikari provides a synoptic view of social movements in Nepal with respect to three phases – that is the Rana regime, the Panchayat era and the democratic period – highlighting the environmental concerns and social movements of the poor and marginalised, while in ‘Environmental justice and the role of Nepalese judiciary: a missed opportunity’ (chapter 4), Jony Mainaly analyses four court cases under public interest litigation1, in this case environmental issues. He examines the concept of environmental justice and its implication in Nepal’s legal system.

  • 2 System where ‘an individual coerced into working in a landlord’s field as a plowman or any other as (...)

3Part II comprises five chapters that highlight contemporary environmental movements in Nepal, with particular emphasis on ‘land, forests, and agriculture’. Srijana Baral, Kalpana Karki and Kanchan Lama in ‘Environmental injustice in confronting gendered access to land in Nepal: joint land ownership as a promising practice’ (chapter 5) examine women’s position in Nepali society with regard to land access from a gender perspective. They argue that the government’s joint land ownership programme, which has reached a large number of women, has the potential to serve as an empowering mechanism and to ensure the effective implementation of environmental justice. In ‘Environmental justice and unfree agricultural laborers in the eastern Tarai of Nepal’ (chapter 6), Suresh Kumar Dhakal examines the ecological injustice experienced by marginalised Dalit bonded agricultural labourers in Madesh province, southern Nepal, who live as Harawa Charawa.2 In ‘Connecting Dalit land rights and climate justice’ (chapter 7), Madan Pariyar and Arjun Kumar B K examine the socio-economic injustices faced by Dalit communities and the consequent environmental injustices with respect to access to resources. In ‘Environmental justice and pesticides’ (chapter 8), Kishor Atreya, Kanchan Kattel, Anisha Sapkota and Hom Nath Gartaula enquire into how the use of pesticides in farming imposes a disproportionate burden on Dalits, Janjatis and women peasants. Sunita Chaudhary, in ‘From red to green to grey hills: reflections on the four-decade-long journey of community forestry and environmental justice in Nepal’ (chapter 9) evaluates decentralised community forestry programmes and their avowed goal of forest restoration through participatory governance. She argues that sociopolitical conditions foster elite domination in terms of acquiring forest benefits, which hindered the participation of marginalised people in forest management processes. Consequently, poor forest management often resulted in uncontrollable forest fires.

4Part III comprises two chapters that focus on conflicts over river and lowland conservation. In chapter 10 Dhirendra Nalbo examines human-wildlife conflicts in Koshi Tappu Wildlife Reserve in the south eastern plains of Nepal. He argues that government conservation measures and the creation of protected areas have not only robbed communities of their land but have also fuelled the human-wildlife conflict. Naya Sharma Paudel, Sudeep Jana Thing and Rahul Karki analyse the experiences of fishing communities around Chitwan National Park (Bote, Majhi and Musahar communities) and Bardiya National Park (Sonaha community) in chapter 11. Reflecting on the shift in conservation strategies – from a state-led protection approach to community participation – they argue that despite this marked change, the state has failed to recognise and accept indigenous knowledge and world views, therefore perpetuating injustices and the marginalisation of local communities.

5The two chapters in part IV address infrastructures and indigenous peoples. In ‘Disaster is social: uneven effect and recovery from the 2015 Nepal earthquake’ (chapter 12), Mukta S Tamang explores the relationship between natural disasters and social life. He analyses the impact of the 2015 earthquake in Nepal, arguing that the natural disaster had unequal consequences, with marginalised communities suffering the most, showing inequality even in their recovery. Prabindra Shakya in ‘Indigenous struggles for development justice in Nepal: environmentalism on the ground’ (chapter 13) discusses the grass-roots activism of indigenous communities in their opposition to development projects, such as the construction of a dam along the Sunkoshi river in eastern Nepal by the Majhi community or infrastructure projects such as the Fast Track Highway in the south of the Kathmandu valley initiated by the Newa community.

6Part V groups together six chapters that deal with urban development and environmental justice.Prashanna Man Pradhan and Bhawana Sharma in ‘Ensuring health, hygiene, and dignity for solid waste workers’ (chapter 14) consider the hardships and stigmatisation faced by sanitation workers as occupation-based environmental injustices. In ‘Urban environmental justice: for whom, from whom?’ (chapter 15) Kirti Kusum Joshi examines the cases of Sisdol landfill and brick kiln sites, and argues that government policies based on cost-benefit analysis (CBA) undermine and fail to address socio-environmental issues. Tara Lal Shrestha and Bidhya Shrestha in ‘Cycling for livelihood in Nepal: seeking justice on two wheels,’ (chapter 16) argue that the government fails to address the health and safety needs of marginalised people who are dependent on bicycles for their livelihood and for transportation. These people are unrecognised heroes who contribute to sustainable transportation but often face environmental injustices as they are often exposed to urban pollution which is created by the escalating ‘car culture’ in Nepal. In ‘Through the haze: air pollution and environmental justice’ (chapter 17) Arnico K Panday and Arti Govinda Shrestha examine air pollution in Nepal. While highlighting various factors such as poverty, the lack of education and of awareness-building measures, unclean fuels (including solid firewood and cow dung) and unregulated pollution frameworks, they argue that women and poor people are those the most affected and suffer environmental injustices. Bhushan Tuladhar in ‘Transport justice on the streets of Kathmandu’ (chapter 18) argues that, due to vehicle-centric transport model in Kathmandu, environmental issues adversely affecting the health of the poor people and this prompts him to raise a call for transport justice and a shift in modes of transport. Sangeeta Singh and Bijay Singh in ‘Building political capabilities through participation for environmental justice in informal housing in Kathmandu’ (chapter 19) examine the challenges faced by residents of informal settlements, called Sukambasi in Nepali. By delving into the case of the Kirtipur Housing Project in Kathmandu, they argue that such a holistic model with the participation and political empowerment of grassroots people serves environmental justice, which is otherwise disregarded.

7The three chapters in Part VI focus on ‘climate justice’. In ‘Climate change in Nepal through an indigenous environmental justice lens’ (chapter 20), Pasang Yangjee Sherpa argues that Nepal’s institutional scientific policies and activities with respect to climate change and its impact in the Himalaya fail to recognise the various dimensions of indigenous knowledge and informed perspectives, thereby exacerbating risks, vulnerability and marginalisation. In ‘Women, water, and weather: Kavre villages adapt to the increasing impacts of the climate crisis’ (chapter 21), Sonia Awale examines water depletion in Kavre. By linking the water crisis to climate change, she argues that women bear the brunt of this hardship because men have migrated to the city in search of job opportunities. She further highlights how communities have adopted ways to address the crisis by protecting the functional springs, by building ponds and by reforesting land with native trees. Gyanu Maskey, Poshendra Satyal, Monika Giri and Prajal Pradhan in ‘Applying a climate justice framework to understand inequities in urban water governance amid climate change challenges in Nepal’ (chapter 22) examine urban water governance in Dulikhel and Diktel. The authors argue that climate change adaptation strategies, such as ensuring a water supply in a context of water insecurity adopted by outside institutions such as the Asian Development Bank, could not cater to the needs of marginalised people given the pre-existing internal social inequities and ‘inherent social differences’ (p238), thereby rendering marginalised communities more vulnerable to the impact of climate change.

8The two chapters in Part VII focus on health equity. In ‘The stress of poverty in tackling tuberculosis in Nepal’ (chapter 23), Marissa Taylor argues that tuberculosis, ‘one of the oldest diseases in the history of mankind’ (p252), is a great threat to Nepal and claims many lives, especially of marginalized people exposed to poor air and poor environmental conditions because ‘pollution sources, such as industrial facilities or sewage corridors, are disproportionately located in low-income neighborhoods’ (p254). Meghnath Dhimal, Mandira Lamichhane Dhimal and Madhusudan Subedi in ‘Impacts of lead contamination on children’s health in Nepal’ (chapter 24) argue that ‘the increasing pattern of urbanization, industrialization, generation of municipal and electronic waste, use of enamel paints in buildings’ (p260) in Nepal have led to an increase in lead exposure that affects the health of children, especially those of socially marginalised groups.

9Overall, this edited volume makes a substantial contribution to research and scholarship on environmental justice. It systematically addresses both contemporary and historical instances and processes, while engaging with Nepal’s environmental vulnerability and highlighting the multifarious responses expressed by the different communities. Nonetheless, the main focus of the book is on the Tarai. As a reader, I felt that the book’s engagement with highland Nepal was instrumental in that only five out of 24 chapters underline issues of environmental injustice in the context of the high mountains, while only two chapters emphasise the relationship that indigenous communities living in the middle mountains (chapter 13) and high mountains (chapter 20) shared with their environment, including rivers and mountains, and hinted at overall ecological justice. For the rest, the high mountains and middle mountains come across as mere field sites, with no sustained engagement with their ecological specificities. Nevertheless, the book proves to be a valuable reference to researchers, policymakers and organisations working on environmental issues and environmental injustices in Nepal.

Haut de page

Notes

1 Where citizens can file a petition on certain issues on behalf of the general public’s interest.

2 System where ‘an individual coerced into working in a landlord’s field as a plowman or any other assigned agricultural work for the interest of loan received, or for grains or the small piece of land cultivated or for shelter in a bonded situation’ (p63).

Haut de page

Pour citer cet article

Référence électronique

Nikita Biswakarma, « Jonathan K London, Jagannath Adhikari, Thomas Robertson (eds), Environmental Justice in Nepal: Origins, struggles and prospects »European Bulletin of Himalayan Research [En ligne], 65 | 2026, mis en ligne le 20 mai 2026, consulté le 14 juillet 2026. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/ebhr/4057 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/169jf

Haut de page

Auteur

Nikita Biswakarma

Nikita Biswakarma is a UGC junior research fellow and is pursuing her doctoral research at the Centre for Himalayan Studies, University of North Bengal, India. Her research focuses on Himalayan political ecology in general and environmentalism in eastern Nepal highlands in particular.

Haut de page

Droits d’auteur

CC-BY-4.0

Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence CC BY 4.0. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont susceptibles d’être soumis à des autorisations d’usage spécifiques.

Haut de page
Rechercher dans OpenEdition Search

Vous allez être redirigé vers OpenEdition Search