Navigation – Plan du site

AccueilNuméros56Comptes rendusGilberg Rolf, Mongolian and Siber...

Comptes rendus

Gilberg Rolf, Mongolian and Siberian Shamans. Costumes and Paraphernalia at the National Museum of Denmark

Copenhagen/Aarhus/New Haven, CT, The National Museum of Denmark/Aarhus University Press/Yale University Press, 2024, 313 pages, 250 illustrations, ISBN 9788772197760. Preface by Rane Willerslev (director of the National Museum of Denmark); text edited by Christel Braae
Isabelle Charleux
Référence(s) :

Gilberg Rolf, Mongolian and Siberian Shamans. Costumes and Paraphernalia at the National Museum of Denmark, Copenhagen/Aarhus/New Haven, CT, The National Museum of Denmark/Aarhus University Press/Yale University Press, 2024

Texte intégral

Cover of Afficher l’image
Crédits : The National Museum of Denmark/Aarhus University Press/Yale University Press
  • 1 The shamanic collection had been previously showcased in a 1974 exhibition featuring Siberian, Kore (...)
  • 2 On this collection of more than three thousand Mongol artefacts, see the outstanding 2017 catalogue (...)

1This catalogue highlights one of the most remarkable collections of Mongol and Siberian shamans’ costumes and ritual equipment, housed at the National Museum of Denmark. The Mongol collection of the National Museum, including some of the shamans’ costumes and paraphernalia discussed here1, was recently showcased at the exhibition “On the Steppes of Genghis Khan. Mongolia’s Nomads” held at the Moesgaard Museum (Aarhus, April 2018-May 2019) and then at the National Museum of Denmark (Copenhagen, June 2019-September 2019)2.

2R. Gilberg, a former curator (1971-2007) at the Department of Ethnography at the National Museum, spent more than forty years gathering expertise to produce this highly detailed study of Mongol and Siberian shamanic costumes and paraphernalia. The “Mongol” (including Solon) artefacts originate from two scientific expeditions (1936-1937 and 1938-1939) led by Danish explorer and writer Henning Haslund-Christensen (1896-1948) in Inner Mongolia (PRC). The Siberian items come from different collections (some were purchased by Danish polar explorer Knud Rasmussen) – the oldest costume arrived at the museum in 1861. The Mongol shamans’ costumes were previously published in a catalogue by Henny Harald Hansen, which featured more than three hundred costumes from the museum and was republished in 1993 as part of the same book series (Hansen [1950] 1993). Gilberg also consulted unpublished notes from the Department of Ethnology’s archive, and included in his catalogue old photographs from the Danish expeditions and other travels, as well as highly detailed drawings of the artefacts by Inger Achton.

  • 3 A remarkable and still poorly known collection is that of the Sergio Poggianella Fundation (https:/ (...)

3The book offers a wealth of information about shamanism, shamans, and their costumes among the Mongol, Turkic, Tungusic, and Samoyede peoples. While shaman costumes can be found in museums worldwide3, they are generally decontextualised, with little known about their origin or usage. The exceptional quality of the Danish collection stems from the fact that Haslund documented the objects he acquired by interviewing their owners, descendants, and entourages. Haslund left behind numerous handwritten notes, articles, letters to his wife, texts from his European lectures, records, and photographs, all of which help provide context for the objects. It appears he intended to write a book on these shamans. As a result, we know the names and biographical details of the shamans to whom the costumes belonged, as well as various interpretations of the elements of their costumes and their uses. After acquiring a costume, Haslund photographed a Mongol wearing it and posing in the manner of a shamanic performance. His notes are invaluable, not only concerning the costumes but also for other observations; for instance, he noted in 1936 that children in Chahar – an area without active shamans – were playing as if they were dead shamans (pp. 36-38). The illustrations are of outstanding quality, accompanied by detailed captions.

4The first chapter provides definitions of “shamans” and “shamanism” and introduces shamanic cosmology, types of shamans, and rituals. The second chapter presents the various components of the shamans’ costumes and headdresses, as well as ritual instruments used by various Mongol and Siberian peoples, exploring their distinct functions and symbolic meanings. It also offers valuable insights into the creation of these items, their ritual uses, their previous owners, and their destiny after the shaman’s death. Chapter 3, titled “Searching for Mongolian shamans in Inner Mongolia”, details Haslund’s encounters with two shamans in 1936-1937 in Barga (Hulunbuir, Inner Mongolia), then under Japanese occupation. It describes the challenges he faced in acquiring the costumes, particularly due to widespread fear of the curses associated with the shaman’s ongod (auxiliary spirits). Haslund engaged in lengthy discussions with the shamans or their descendants, showing a deep respect for their traditions. Regarding the costume of Dölgöre Büge, a Buryat shaman who had migrated to Hulunbuir, the shaman agreed to concentrate the spirits into two locks, rendering the costume harmless and thus available for purchase (without the locks), effectively deconsecrating it. Haslund also managed to acquire a second costume, that of Basaman, a Solon shaman, in exchange for the shaman’s body: the shaman had lost his fight against a Japanese locomotive and the Japanese authorities prohibited the Solons from retrieving the body and performing the appropriate funerary rites. However, Haslund was eventually able to locate the remains and facilitate their return. He couldn’t purchase Basaman’s copper mask, but he arranged for a copy to be made by the same artisan who had crafted the original. In 1939, Haslund used a trick to acquire the tent, costume, paraphernalia and numerous artefacts of a Barga shamaness, who had died in 1909 in Chahar; her costume had been passed down from earlier shamans (pp. 157-160). Her son, “Purup”, continued to make sacrifices at the shamanic altar, but when Purup’s wife introduced a Buddhist altar in their yurt, the coexistence of the two spiritual powers led to misfortunes and calamities, including the deaths of children. His entourage urged him to get rid of the “black altar”, and they hoped that Haslund could provide a solution that would “restore value and happiness to these unfortunate people’s lives” (p. 159). Haslund suggested placing the black altar two hundred steps northeast of the tent at midnight, and if the altar disappeared the following day, it would be proof that the shamanic powers had left “to the far northeast where they belonged”. He also left eighty dollars for the Buddhist altar. The next day, when the altar was gone, the people believed Haslund’s prediction had come true, and “thus the family was released from its troubles”. Soon after, the wife gave birth to a healthy boy. While this could be seen today as Haslund deceiving the couple and taking the shamanic artefacts, Gilberg does not present it in this way. Instead, he emphasises that Haslund, in a sense, compensated for the shamanic artefacts by leaving eighty dollars and helped resolve a dramatic situation. He was not coercing anyone but had been asked for his advice and “felt he could leave the decision to the Mongols”. However, Haslund faced challenges in transporting the black altar: the camel became crazy, and the Mongols were frightened by the altar.

5Chapters 4, 5, and 6 provide a detailed description of the costumes (including headdresses, masks, and boots) and paraphernalia associated with Dölgöre Büge, Basaman, and the Barga shamaness of Chahar. These chapters include additional illustrations of each accessory and explanations of the symbols, numbers, colours, terminology from local informants, and the materials and uses of various costume accessories (small bells, Chinese coins, mirrors, and bronze seals, etc.) and ritual instruments (drums, drumsticks, sceptres, and weapons such as a French bayonet and a pistol, horsehead staffs, a “red-hot glow-feet” [p. 189], rosaries, etc.). The Barga shaman’s altar contained 221 objects, including a table, incense burner, offering cups, offering spoons, masks made of copper and cowhide, bags containing ongod and other “power bags”, magic ropes with Chinese coins and anklebones (fig. 6.66), ancient Scythian-style bronzes, and pieces of cotton used to capture the last breath of the deceased shaman, which were believed to hold the shaman’s power (fig. 6.68, p. 212).

6Gilberg also visited contemporary shamans in Mongolia and participated in rituals in 1996. Despite not speaking Mongolian and being unable to ask the questions he wished, he describes and documents the costumes of Darhad and Buryat shamans (chapter 7).

7The Siberian collection (chapter 8) is less extensive and less thoroughly documented compared to the Mongol collection. It features Evenki, Nanai, Samoyed (Netsy), and Yakut costumes, as well as a wooden mask and drums. The appendix provides details about Danish expeditions to Mongolia in the 1920s and 1930s, along with the biographies of key figures involved.

8The reader may sometimes be confused by the transcription system used in the text, which is inconsistent, blending phonetic transcriptions of Buryat, Chahar, Halh, and other dialects. As a result, the same term appears in varying spellings, such as Barga (Barag, Bargha, Barak), ongon (ongghon), and tenger (tengeri, tegri, tengri). Additionally, the text contains some inaccuracies, such as on page 19, where “lus” (< Tib. klu, nāga) is incorrectly derived from the Mongolian word us (meaning “water”) and land spirits are referred to as savdag (< Tib. sa bdag, “lord of the earth”), incorrectly described as a Mongolian word meaning “soil”.

  • 4 The shamanic artefacts (including costumes of Tungus and Evenki shamans) of Musée de l’Homme were t (...)

9In addition to Haslund’s notes and articles, Gilberg draws upon an impressive array of sources on Mongol and Siberian shamanism, including works by S. Badamhatan, Vladimir N. Basilov, Vilmos Diószegi, V. P. Djakonova, Uno (Holmberg) Harva, Walther Heissig, Caroline Humphrey, Lawrence Krader, Ethel J. Lindgren, Morten Pedersen, O. Pürev, Sergei M. Shirokogoroff, Käthe Uray-Köhalmi, and S. I. Vajnstejn. Francophone readers can further enrich this bibliography with works by Roberte Hamayon (1995-1996, 1990), the catalogue Festins d’âmes et robes d’esprits. Les objets chamaniques sibériens du Musée de l’Homme by Marie-Lise Beffa & Laurence Delaby (1999)4, and articles by Charles Stépanoff (2005).

10This meticulously documented catalogue will appeal not only to scholars of Mongol and Siberian shamanism but also to contemporary shamans. Its significance is all the more important given the growing popularity of shamanism in the West, where museum exhibitions often display reconstructed and speculative versions of ancient shamanic costumes (fig. 1).

Figure 1. Imaginary reconstruction of a “shaman costume” in the exhibition “Gengis Khan. Comment les Mongols ont changé le monde” (14 October 2023-5 May 2024, Château des Ducs de Bretagne – Musée d’histoire de Nantes)

Figure 1. Imaginary reconstruction of a “shaman costume” in the exhibition “Gengis Khan. Comment les Mongols ont changé le monde” (14 October 2023-5 May 2024, Château des Ducs de Bretagne – Musée d’histoire de Nantes)

Photograph of a shaman costume adorned with various bronze objects originating from different locations and dating between the 7th and 2nd centuries B.C., a period for which there is no evidence of shamanic practices. According to the lateral panel, “To achieve this [entering a trance], he must ‘animalize’ himself; thus, he adorns himself with magical attire, surrounds himself with öngön [ongon], sacred supports, amulets, bells, mirrors, and various other items, including a drum to gather the spirits”

© Isabelle Charleux

Haut de page

Bibliographie

Beffa, M.-L. & L. Delaby 1999 Festins d’âmes et robes d’esprits. Les objets chamaniques sibériens du Musée de l’Homme (Paris, Publications scientifiques du Muséum).

Braae, C. 2017 Among Herders of Inner Mongolia. The Haslund-Christensen Collection at the National Museum of Denmark (Aarhus/Lancaster/Oakville, CT, The Carlsberg Foundation’s Nomad Research Project/Aarhus University Press).

Hamayon, R. 1990 La Chasse à l’âme. Esquisse d’une théorie du chamanisme sibérien (Nanterre, Société d’ethnologie).
1995-1996 Religions de l’Asie septentrionale, Annuaire de l’École Pratique des Hautes Études 104, pp. 85-86 [online, URL : https://www.persee.fr/doc/ephe_0000-0002_1995_num_108_104_15118, accessed 18 December 2025].

Hansen, H. H. [1950] 1993 Mongolian Costumes (Copenhagen/London, The Carslberg’s Foundation Nomad Research Project/Rhodos International Science and Art Publishers/Thames and Hudson).

Lot-Falk, É. 1977 Le costume de chamane toungouse du Musée de l’Homme, Études mongoles et sibériennes 8, pp. 19-71, https://doi.org/10.3406/emong.1977.938.

Stépanoff, C. 2005 Le costume chamanique et ses énigmes, Religions & Histoire 5, Chamanismes, pp. 42-47.

Haut de page

Notes

1 The shamanic collection had been previously showcased in a 1974 exhibition featuring Siberian, Korean and Mongol shaman objects in 1974, entitled “Spirits and human beings”.

2 On this collection of more than three thousand Mongol artefacts, see the outstanding 2017 catalogue edited by Christel Braae in 2017, entitled Among Herders of Inner Mongolia. The Haslund-Christensen Collection at the National Museum of Denmark. See the review here: https://journals.openedition.org/emscat/3186. The collection was previously displayed in the exhibition “Mongols – the Nomads of the Steppes” in the National Museum of Denmark, curated by Rolf Gilberg, from 1992 to 1996.

3 A remarkable and still poorly known collection is that of the Sergio Poggianella Fundation (https://www.fondazionesergiopoggianella.org/collezioni).

4 The shamanic artefacts (including costumes of Tungus and Evenki shamans) of Musée de l’Homme were transferred to the Musée du quai Branly - Jacques Chirac in Paris in 2006. On the Tungus costume that entered the Musée de l’Homme in 1887, see Lot-Falk 1977. In 2008, the Musée du quai Branly purchased a complete costume of a Mongol Darhad shaman from Transbaikalia (inventory numbers 70.2008.25.1.8, 70.2008.25.1.7, 70.2008.25.1.2. See the online catalogue Collections - musée du quai Branly - Jacques Chirac, https://collections.quaibranly.fr/).

Haut de page

Table des illustrations

Titre Figure 1. Imaginary reconstruction of a “shaman costume” in the exhibition “Gengis Khan. Comment les Mongols ont changé le monde” (14 October 2023-5 May 2024, Château des Ducs de Bretagne – Musée d’histoire de Nantes)
Légende Photograph of a shaman costume adorned with various bronze objects originating from different locations and dating between the 7th and 2nd centuries B.C., a period for which there is no evidence of shamanic practices. According to the lateral panel, “To achieve this [entering a trance], he must ‘animalize’ himself; thus, he adorns himself with magical attire, surrounds himself with öngön [ongon], sacred supports, amulets, bells, mirrors, and various other items, including a drum to gather the spirits”
Crédits © Isabelle Charleux
URL http://journals.openedition.org/emscat/docannexe/image/7395/img-1.jpg
Fichier image/jpeg, 401k
Haut de page

Pour citer cet article

Référence électronique

Isabelle Charleux, « Gilberg Rolf, Mongolian and Siberian Shamans. Costumes and Paraphernalia at the National Museum of Denmark »Études mongoles et sibériennes, centrasiatiques et tibétaines [En ligne], 56 | 2025, mis en ligne le 31 décembre 2025, consulté le 10 septembre 2026. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/emscat/7395 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/15h7h

Haut de page

Auteur

Isabelle Charleux

GSRL, UMR 8582, CNRS - EPHE, PSL, Paris (France)

Articles du même auteur

Haut de page

Droits d’auteur

CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0

Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont susceptibles d’être soumis à des autorisations d’usage spécifiques.

Haut de page
Rechercher dans OpenEdition Search

Vous allez être redirigé vers OpenEdition Search