1The La Vergne site was discovered during a preventive excavation carried out in 1995 (Courtaud and Duday 1995). The remains from this site form an exceptional funerary assemblage for recent prehistory on the Atlantic coast of Europe. The only comparative sites are those discovered on the Breton islets of Téviec and Hoëdic (Péquart et al. 1937, Péquart and Péquart 1954), notably on account of the abundance of ornamental elements sometimes presented as the remains of a disappeared “language” (Taborin, 2004). At La Vergne, uncertainty persists as to the presence of possible contemporaneous settlement levels (Courtaud et al. 1999, p. 289). Three burials correspond to as many distinct pits (fig. 1). The available radiocarbon dates are all centred around 8300 BC. (Duday et al. 1998). Carbon and nitrogen isotope studies suggest a predominantly land-based diet, in keeping with the inland location of these burials (Schulting et al. 2008). The objects associated with these different individuals, however, contain a very large quantity of seashells.
Fig. 1 – Location of La Vergne and distribution of the archaeological structures located in the perimeter of the Mesolithic graves (7 m²), in the largest excavated area of a preventive excavation. Structures 3, 7, 10, and 11 correspond to Mesolithic burials. Structures 1, 2 and 12 are later. They correspond to a large ditch, a clay extraction pit and a Gallic pit in which reworked ornamental elements and human bones were discovered. The later ditch intersected some of these structures and was attributed to the Iron Age.
From Duday and Courtaud 1998, CAD L. Quesnel and C. Dupont.
2Among these burials, pit 3 yielded the human bones of a woman associated with the remains of a foetus near term, and those of a child in a seated position (Duday and Courtaud 1998). The infill of pit 7 contains the bodies of two individuals lying on their left side in a very contracted position, as well as the remains of a child, covered by several burnt human bones (Duday and Courtaud 1998). The excavators specify that some of these deposits “must correspond to offerings rather than ornaments worn by the deceased” (Duday and Courtaud 1998, p. 30). The southern half of pit 10 contains two aurochs’ horns from kills, and to the north the body of a very robust man lies on his left side, with the skeleton of a child against his shoulder. In all cases, these are simultaneous primary burials, in a sealed space, sometimes associated with large deposits of ochre.
3The study of prehistoric adornment has too often been limited to considering each element separately. At La Vergne, the rapid sealing of the pits, highlighted by anthropologists in the field, is a major asset for the study of the assemblages. Traces of wear sometimes attest to how ornamental items were suspended or worn, and the spatial distribution of the objects is not the same in each grave, which is conducive to proposing a reconstruction of the adornment associated with each of the deceased.
4The first steps involved in the analysis of seashells are aimed at tracing the first stages of the adornment production chain, starting with the search for raw material. Using spatial data, comparisons of the composition of the malacofauna according to the different structures of the site can then be undertaken. All the collected shells were quantified in number of remains (NR), weighed and measured.
5The determination of the 18 species (table 2) was carried out with reference to the biological literature (Tebble 1966, Olivier 1975, Sabelli 1981, Philips 1987, Wye 1990, Poppe and Goto 1991, 1993, Dance 1993, Chavan 1996, Dautzenberg 1913). The scientific names used (WoRMS 2020) have been updated since the first publications (Dupont 2006, Dupont et al. 2014, Laporte and Dupont 2019). Vernacular names are also specified and a list of synonyms is proposed (Taborin 1974, Barge 1982, Newell et al. 1990, Taborin 1993, Tebble 1966, Fretter and Graham 1976, 1978, 1981, 1985, Poppe and Goto 1991, 1993).
Table 2 – List of genera and species determined at La Vergne with their valid scientific names and synonyms from the archaeological literature.
6Netted dog whelks and tusk shells alone represent 97% of the malacofauna. Tritia reticulata dominates with more than 66% of the remains and 48% of the mass of the shells analysed at La Vergne. In terms of weight, the relative abundance of tusk shells (small species) decreases in favour of large bivalves. We should not overlook the fact that the choice of shells may have been influenced by shell size (weight, volume). Eight of the fifteen identified species are only represented by one or two specimens. The accessibility of the different biotopes and other cultural factors may have influenced the relative quantities of each species (Fischer 1995).
7The biogeographical distributions of the molluscs were studied in order to determine whether the species represented at La Vergne were consistent with those currently found on the Charente coast. Only the case of Semicassis saburon, which lived in the Charente estuary 8,000 years ago (Carbonel et al. 1998), caught our attention. Its presence along the Charente coastline during the Mesolithic indicates a slightly warmer climate than at present. The chronology of the site corresponds to a phase of general climate warming that began more than 10,000 years ago (Duday and Courtaud 1998), when the oceanic temperature may have been a few degrees higher than today (Kaufman et al. 2020, Martin et al. 2020).
8Species determination also provides access to several parameters of the marine mollusc biotope (Babin and Glémarec 1971, Shackleton 1988). The majority of the species at La Vergne are marine molluscs, with the exception of Theodoxus fluviatilis which lives in fresh or brackish water (Hubendick 1947, Jaeckel 1952). The preponderance of strictly marine shells, with thicker and more solid tests than those of fluvial malacofauna, is a regular feature of the assemblage (Rozoy 1978, Taborin 1982, Barge-Mahieu and Taborin 1991, Binant 1991).
9We thus looked for the potential collection sites of these shells. Reconstructions in the Charente region (André 1986), starting from a level of 11 metres above the present level for the 10,000 BP period, took into account a difference below recent syntheses but with more geographically distant data (Stéphan and Gosselin 2014). These reconstructions show that the coast would have been more than 90 km away from the site. However, the marine influence was felt much further inland via the paleo-Charente (Carbonel et al. 1998). Thus, the marine molluscs of La Vergne could have been accessible less than 30 km from the site, or even less for Theodoxus fluviatilis. The analysis of the substrates of the different determined species backs up this assumption with more than 97% of the shells from La Vergne belonging to a sandy sediment that may have been silted up. The probably sheltered environment of the paleo-Charente thus represents a potential collection site, which is also corroborated by the presence of Tritia nitida. Although we cannot rule out the hypothesis of exchanges with other human groups, the shells used at La Vergne could also have been collected during one or more trips by the population that frequented the site. Isotopic analysis of human skeletons shows that the people buried at La Vergne did not consume enough marine resources to leave a marine signal in their bones (Schulting et al. 2008). This result is in line with what we know about seafood consumption by hunter-gatherers on the French Atlantic coast (Dupont 2006).
10The different altitudinal levels of the determined species at La Vergne show that several species (31% of the assemblage) are strictly subtidal: the dog cockle, the Norwegian whelk, the tusks and the helmet shell. The shells used as ornaments at La Vergne were either collected alive using techniques such as snorkelling or dredging, or collected dead washed up on the beach.
11The observation of numerous marks linked to prolonged marine wear (Rolin 1971, Barge 1982, Barge-Mahieu and Taborin 1991) of the shells from La Vergne corroborates the second hypothesis.
12Given the degree of wear of certain shells and the location of their perforation (Cabral and Martins 2016), some of them were already perforated when they were collected. Piercing by lithophagous organisms is another natural path to be considered (Boekshote 1966, Rolin 1971, Bishop 1975, Barge-Mahieu and Taborin 1991, d’Errico et al. 1993, Taborin 1993, Cabral and Monteiro-Rodrigues 2015). This type of mark was observed on a spisula valve.
13At least some of the shells collected on the beach to make the La Vergne ornaments were already perforated. The rare oysters and limpets show signs of erosion which indicates that these molluscs were not consumed. It is thus possible to imagine that this activity was sufficiently important for these human groups to be carried out alongside the search for food (Dupont 2019). Finally, we should not forget that the original colour of shell tests may have influenced selection.
14The funerary structures stand out mainly on account of the abundant presence of malacofauna. Indeed, there are more than 400 remains in each grave. The specific diversity of structures is not correlated with the number of remains. Structure 3 differs from the other two burial structures in that it has a higher proportion of Dentalium sp. than Tritia reticulata. Minority species are also different from one structure to another. The spisula, the helmet shell and the flat oyster are only represented in structure 10. Structure 3 shows low species diversity, with medium-sized species such as moon snails, or two river snails. Finally, structure 7 comprises seven small- to medium-sized species, two of which are exclusive to this burial (cockle, murex). These different elements show the heterogenous malacofaunal composition of the structures.
15The shells collected in the Mesolithic burials of La Vergne belong to 18 species. Two small-sized shells were predominantly used: the netted dog whelk and the tusk shell. Almost all the species come from the sea. They were collected less than thirty kilometres from the site, on the sandy or even silty banks of the paleo-Charente estuary. Raw material procurement by the men and women of La Vergne may have resulted from short journeys, as well as exchanges with other human groups. Some of the shells were collected washed up on the beach and do probably not derive from recycling previously consumed seafood shells. This observation echoes the writings of Claude Lévi-Strauss: “It is not enough that food is good to eat, it must also be good to think (about)” (Lévi-Strauss 1962). Shell collecting activities anticipated the future use of the shells, as shown by the presence of the natural perforations used to attach them.
16The shaping of pieces is generally limited to a perforation, when this is not the result of a natural action. The study of traces of shaping was carried out with an individualised analysis grid for each species separately: tusk shells underwent rudimentary shaping, whereas dog whelks often present perforation of anthropic origin.
17For gastropods, the shell is oriented in the direction of suspension (Barge-Mahieu 1991). The last spiral forms most of the available surfaces. The location of marks was noted in accordance with the proposals of Y. Taborin (1993). Such surfaces, when unaltered, may bear gloss, polish, abrasion or patina, each of these terms being defined beforehand. Both the lip of the labrum and the lip of the perforation bear different marks, such as rounding, curvature, indentation, or flaking. Eleven observation criteria were described for each of the studied 1,300 pieces (fig. 25). Three observation criteria were retained for the 1,000 tusk shells: the test, the anterior and posterior ends. The location of each perforation, as well as its shape, length and width, the regularity of the contour or state of preservation, were also noted. The contour of the perforation was divided into eight zones (Taborin in Gaillard et al. 1984), for which the profile of the lip (flat, rounded, flattened outwards, curved inwards or bevelled), marks related to a technical action, or traces of wear, were systematically recorded (fig. 26). Marks resulting from technical action are chips, punctures, striations, abrasion or cutting marks, which indicate the use of percussion, pecking, grooving, abrasion or scraping (Julien et al. 1999). The use of a rotary borer is rarely attested. The operative chain consists of three stages: surface preparation, then perforation, possibly followed by reworking (Taborin 1993). Some parts of the shell show more or less accentuated traces of wear. The presence of an indentation of the lip, a patina or abrasion are signs of pronounced wear (index 2). A few chips, rounding, a curved lip, and a localized polished area on the test indicate more limited degrees of wear (index 1). The absence of these marks corresponds to index 0.
Fig. 25 – Division of Turbo gastropod tests into distinct zones, and division of the perforation into eight zones.
After Taborin 1984, 1993; CAD L. Quesnel and L. Laporte.
Fig. 26 – Main types of marks observed on shells.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre. Unless otherwise stated, all the photographs in the figures in this section show shells collected in the La Vergne burials.
18Just over a thousand tusk shells (Dentalium sp.) were collected. 95% of the tusks are smaller in size than the specimens washed up on the foreshore (fig. 27). The segmentation of the shell ends was obtained by bending without any prior preparation. Some of them are wedged together, like so many elements threaded on a cord (fig. 28). Ochre is sometimes present between two wedged shells, suggesting that the shells were coloured prior to being assembled. At least 10% of the individual shells also show clearly marked signs of wear.
Fig. 27 – Size of tusk shell ornaments from La Vergne (NR = 971) compared to present-day references (NR = 43) found on the Vendée and Arcachon Basin beaches.
CAD L. Laporte and C. Dupont.
Fig. 28 – Two nested tusk shells. Note the indentation on the edge of the second tusk.
Photograph by J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
19Nearly 2,000 perforated netted dog whelk shells (Tritia reticulata) constitute the bulk of the studied corpus. Three-quarters of them are from structure 7 (1,600 individuals), compared to 250 shells in structure 10 and 210 in structure 3.
20Most of the shells were collected dead on the foreshore, where many of them were already perforated by one or more natural perforations. The contour of the perforation may have been regularised with a sharp instrument. There is no way of distinguishing them from anthropogenic perforations (fig. 29). The perforation used for threading a cord is almost always located at E2 (fig. 30). There are few variations in the stages of the process. The preparation of the shell consists of marking by incisions and, above all, abrasion, with some examples of pecking. The incisions reflect at least three different techniques (figs. 31 and 32). Perforation is obtained by percussion, most often on the outer surface of the shell. The contour is then regularised with a sharp instrument.
Fig. 29 – Type and location of the perforation on dog whelks.
The numbers at the top left of each photograph refer to the inventory number of the piece assigned during the excavation. The same applies to the following figures.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 30 – Characteristics of perforations on dog whelks.
A. Location of the perforation on the shell, expressed as the number of perforations on the y-axis (each piece generally bearing a single perforation, very rarely two); B. Dimensions of the perforation.
CAD L. Laporte.
Fig. 31 – Perforation preparation (dog whelks)—presence of incisions on the edge of the perforation. The observed incisions are clearly distinct from any other form of alteration of the shell, notably possible chemical alterations that could have highlighted the crystallographic structure of the shell, which is not the case here.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 32 – Perforation preparation (dog whelks)—traces resulting from grooving.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
21Traces of wear are extremely frequent. The trace of a cord connecting the labrum to the perforation is clearly marked by a band of red ochre on a specimen in structure 10, in keeping with the traces of wear observed on the perforation lips and on the labrum itself (fig. 33). The lower part of the last spiral shows the most pronounced wear marks (fig. 34). Wear marks on the labrum are almost systematic, usually opposite equivalent marks on the lip of the perforation (figs. 35 and 36). Wear on the columellar margin can range from glossy to abrasive (fig. 37). This zone, which is rather acute on present-day reference specimens collected dead, shows a rounded shape on some of the specimens from La Vergne (fig. 38). The elongation axis of the perforation shows a clear predominance in a privileged direction, mainly linked to traces of wear observed on the lip of the perforation (fig. 39). The edge of the perforation shows a different profile in the different zones (fig. 40), due to the equally differentiated wear marks (fig. 41). Some pieces bear a notched perforation at both ends, giving them a double-lobed shape (fig. 42). The study of wear marks sometimes points to the existence of two cords, one attaching the shells to a mount made of perishable material that goes around the labrum, and the other linking the shells together (fig. 43). Differentiated wear of the columellar edge and the labrum was observed in each grave (fig. 44).
Fig. 33 – Traces of wear in E1 on perforated dog whelks.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 34 – Test wear on perforated dog whelks, expressed as the number of marks observed on the y-axis (different marks could be observed at different points on each piece).
A. In the direction of width; B. In the direction of height.
CAD L. Laporte.
Fig. 35 – Wear marks on the labrum of perforated dog whelks.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 36 – Types of wear represented on dog whelk labra, expressed (y-axis) in number of pieces except for the differential wear of the labrum, expressed as a percentage.
CAD L. Laporte; Drawing Y. Gruet.
Fig. 37 – Wear on the columellar edge of dog whelks.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 38 – Abrasion of the siphonal canal of dog whelks.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 39 – Deformation of the perforation on dog whelks.
A. Elongation axis of the perforation; B. Location of traces of cords on the edge of the perforation.
CAD L. Laporte.
Fig. 40 – Distribution of types of profile and wear marks on the edge of dog whelk perforations.
CAD L. Laporte.
Fig. 41 – Wear on the lip of the perforation on dog whelks.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 42 – Indentation in the perforation.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 43 – From the marks observed on shells to the hypotheses formulated regarding their mode of attachment.
CAD L. Laporte; Drawings Y. Gruet.
Fig. 44 – Differential wear of the labrum on dog whelks from structures 7 and 10.
CAD L. Laporte; Drawing Y. Gruet.
22Another species of dog whelk (Tritia incrassata) belongs to the same genus as T. reticulata, but the size of the smallest specimens represented on the site hardly differs between species (fig. 45). It is doubtful whether any difference was made between the two species, both in terms of collection and use.
Fig. 45 – A. Comparison of the size of Tritia reticulata (NR = 2107) and T. incrassata (NR = 38); B. Comparison of Tritia sp. by structure: St. 3, NR = 227; St. 7, NR = 1534; St. 10, NR = 384.
Figure by L. Laporte and C. Dupont.
23The moon snails (Euspira catena) come from funerary structure 3 and from the intersecting ditch 1. The perforation is located in the lower part of the last whorl of the coil. It was initiated by the action of a rotary borer. Wear marks are mainly present on the labrum (fig. 47). The shells may have been attached to a twisted cord, as proposed for the Tritia sp shells. Only two examples of river moon snails (Theodoxus fluviatilis) were found in burial structure 3. In one of the specimens, the main perforation is supplemented by another, smaller perforation, probably due to weathering (fig. 3.24). A single pierced murex (Ocenebra erinaceus) shell was collected from Structure 7. The apex of the shell is broken and the surface of the test is very weathered. The perforation was obtained by the technique used for dog whelks.
Fig. 47 – Perforation techniques and traces of wear on dog whelks.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
24Limpets (Patella sp.) are only represented in three burial structures, and bear at least one natural or artificial perforation (fig. 49). Some also bear marks resulting from prolonged wear. The perforation is mainly located on the apex, but sometimes also on one of the edges of the shell. Traces of wear were observed on six specimens, some of which could be due to the presence of a cord connecting the hole of the perforation to the edge of the shell attached to a perishable mount (fig. 50). Small areas of lateral abrasion could result from the shell edges rubbing against such a mount.
Fig. 49 – Perforated limpet.
25[Image non convertie]
Photograph J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 50 – Location of the perforation and wear marks on Patella sp.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
26Two helmet shells (Semicassis saburon) from Structure 10, each with two perforations located opposite each other on the back of the shell (fig. 51). At least one of these perforations was made intentionally. In both cases, wear marks indicate the presence of a cord (fig. 52).
Fig. 51 – Perforated Semicassis saburon.
Photograph J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 52 – Wear marks on the edge of perforations and the siphonal canal (Semicassis saburon).
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
27All these shellfish are quite similar in size and morphology. The shells of Glycymeris glycymeris and Laevicardium crassum were apparently used indifferently to make the same type of ornamental object (fig. 53, 54 and 55). The hook bears a perforation, but none were made by human hands, apart from two exceptions (fig. 56).
Fig. 53 – Valves found nested in each other: From top to bottom the species are: Glycymeris Glycymeris, Laevicardium crassum, Laevicardium crassum.
28[Image non convertie]
Photograph by J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 54 – Nested Glycymeris and Laevicardium valves.
29[Image non convertie]
Photograph by J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 55 – Nested Glycymeris and Laevicardium valves with a moon snail inside.
30[Image non convertie]
Photograph by J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
Fig. 56 – Location and techniques of perforation on valves.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
31A single cockle shell valve (Cerastoderma edule) was collected in structure 7. The perforation is located on the umbo. Three perforated dog cockle valves (Glycymeris sp.) were collected from structure 10, and two others from structures 1 and 2. The perforation, located near the hook, is natural. A small isolated Glycymeris sp. shell also shows wear on the ventral side of the shell, which is interpreted as wear from a cord that also caused a clear curvature of the inner edge of the hinge (fig. 57). Norwegian buckeye (Laevicardium crassum) valves are mainly represented in Structure 10, where there are 12 specimens. Two other perforated valves come from structures 1 and 7. The perforation near the hook is natural. A few traces of wear on the edge of the perforation are probably the result of rubbing on a cord.
Fig. 57 – Wear marks on the valves.
1. Glycymeris glycymeris; 2-6. Laevicardium crassum.
Photographs by L. Laporte and J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
32A single fragment of a pierced flat oyster (Ostrea edulis) upper valve was found in structure 10 (fig. 58). The off-centre perforation is located at one of the ends of the valve. Traces of wear suggest that the piece was suspended by means of a cord. Two perforated spisulae (Spisula sp.) were found in the same structure 10. The perforation was made by some kind of perforator. A warty venus (Venus verrucosa) valve was found in structure 1. The perforation is very altered and located near the hinge.
Fig. 58 – Perforated right valve of an oyster.
Photograph J.-Y. Lefeuvre.
33Descriptions of tusk shells often involve threading on cords (Rivière 1905, Barge-Mahieu 1991). Indeed, those from La Vergne were found nested inside each other. They may have formed elements of necklaces. On the other hand, gastropod shells bear traces of wear hardly compatible with shells simply threaded onto a cord to form a necklace. They appear to have been attached to a perishable material. Most of the Tritia sp. appear to have been attached using two cords with distinct functions, or a twisted two-strand tie, which passed through the shell opening and out through the single perforation. Similar wear patterns were observed on Euspira sp. shells. The two large biforate shells of Semicassis saburon, on the other hand, appear to have been attached by a single tie, which enters through one perforation and exits through the second, in the same axis as the elongation of the shell. As for limpets, the observed traces of wear would also be compatible with an attachment to a long and narrow tie, such as a leather strap for example (fig. 59).
Fig. 59 – Summary of the location, frequency and intensity of wear marks on the test.
Red: frequent and generally well-marked traces; Yellow: generally more tenuous and sometimes less marked traces.
CAD L. Laporte, drawings Y. Gruet and C. Dupont.
34During a mission in Argentina, we were surprised to observe gastropod necklaces attached by a similar process to the one we envisaged for the perforated dog whelks and moon snails of La Vergne. These necklaces were worn in the last century by a group of hunter-gatherers from Patagonia: the Yamanas (fig. 60). The gastropod shells with single perforations are linked by a twisted cord comprising two strands with different functions. Traces of wear are similar to those observed on the dog whelks and moon snails from La Vergne (fig. 61).
Fig. 60 – Yamana gastropod necklace (Patagonia).
Coll. of the Olavarria Municipal Museum, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina; photograph by L. Laporte.
Fig. 61 – Detail of the suspension method of the Yamana gastropod necklace (Patagonia). Note the presence of an indentation in the labrum corresponding to where the cord was threaded.
Coll. of the Olavarria Municipal Museum, Province of Buenos Aires, Argentina; photograph L. Laporte.
35At first sight, the perforated shells are so abundant in each of these burials that they appear first of all as an almost continuous dot plot throughout the volume of the corresponding grave pits. This same difficulty was encountered during the excavation of the Mesolithic burials at Téviec and Hoëdic (Péquart and Péquart 1954, p. 35). As far as the burials at La Vergne are concerned, we benefited from a wealth of documentation of remarkable quality. Naturally, when it comes to a burial, the excavation is generally technically and mentally guided by the corporal volumes of the deceased, but grave goods can also participate, in the same way as the ornamental objects deposited in the tomb beside the deceased.
36This grave contained the remains of two individuals in connection with one another and those of a child mixed with some burnt bones. It contained 1,961 shell elements which appeared to be spread quite randomly throughout the thickness of the pit fill. An empty space with no grave goods is limited by a deer antler at the southern end of the pit. At the base of the fill, a wall effect isolates an area with a high shell concentration in the centre and north of the pit (fig. 62). The corresponding shells could correspond to an envelope, probably made of perishable material, pressed against the walls of the pit. In this space, the perforated shells not linked to body volumes are organised into two distinct batches, only one of which comprises a very large number of tusk shells. The individual located to the east seems to be associated with a much larger number of tusk shells than the second.
Fig. 62 – Distribution of shells in Structure 7.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original excavation records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
37By plotting all the pieces at the same altitude on the same plan, the organisation of the deposit gradually becomes apparent (fig. 63). The central area of the pit contains almost no perforated shells. To the east, a concentration shells in a half-crown shape may have adorned a perishable object covering the remains of a cremated individual (fig. 64). Two further concentrations were noted at the excavation. The volume of batch 1 can be likened to that of a mantle, in which there are two child bones and a perforated animal tooth (fig. 65). The dog whelks in batch 2 may have been placed in, or adorned, a container, in which two bones of a child and two perforated animal teeth were found (fig. 66).
Fig. 63 – Shells disjointed from the corporal volumes of the two connected individuals from Structure 7.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original excavation records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 64 – Batch n° 3 from structure 7.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original excavation records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 65 – A. Batch n° 1 from Structure 7; B. Cross-sections of batches 1 to 3.
CAD L. Laporte.
Fig. 66 – Batch n° 2 from Structure 7.
CAD L. Laporte; photograph by P. Courtaud.
38Initially, the projection on a single plan of all the objects located at the site of the two connected individuals does not reveal any major information (fig. 67). For each altimetric level, we then proceeded to graphically dismantle the shells and the main bones of the skeleton simultaneously (fig. 68). The shells on the right side of each individual are concentrated in a wide band that covers the back and the right arm in a folded position under the left leg (fig. 69). This may correspond to a mantle or band of cloth holding the arms in a folded position against the chest. Another set of shells may have been sewn onto a strip of cloth, animal hide or an ornamented mat, passing down the back of the deceased and holding his upper limbs against the chest (fig. 70). This was then covered by the legs held in a tightly contracted position.
Fig. 67 – Shells closely associated with the corporal volumes of the two connected individuals in Structure 7, dismantled by altimetric levels.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 68 – Shells closely associated with the corporal volumes of the two connected individuals in structure 7, dismantled according to body volumes for the same altimetric level.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 69 – Shells closely associated with the corporal volumes of the two connected individuals in Structure 7, synthesis for the right side.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 70 – Shells closely associated with the corporal volumes of the two connected individuals in Structure 7, synthesis for the left side.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 71 – Tusk shells closely associated with the corporal volumes of the two connected individuals in Structure 7.
A. Right side of the body; B. Left side of the body.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
39Numerous shells were also collected in the lumbar region or at the location of the pelvis of the two connected individuals. The hypothesis of a belt in one case or a loincloth in the other would not be in contradiction with these observations (fig. 71). Two perforated limpets are located at the level of the knee and the calf of the left leg of individual n° 1. Finally, only the presence of perforated shells on the upper chest of both individuals, in the lumbar region of individual n° 2 or in the crotch of individual n° 1, as well as the two limpets located along the left leg of the latter, can be attributed to corporal ornamentation.
40This structure is only partially conserved and also suffered from the first mechanical stripping of the upper levels. At first sight, the distribution of shell ornaments in the fill seems random, except that the large shells are all in the southern half of the fill (fig. 72). The body volumes of the two individuals take up all the available space, and it is not possible to isolate sets of ornaments that are not directly associated with them.
Fig. 72 – Distribution of shells in Structure 3.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
41We then proceeded to partially dismantle (fig. 73), for example the objects of adornment placed on the left leg of the large child or the shells located under the right leg and on the pelvis or feet of the adult woman. In the first case, we observe the presence of numerous large dog whelks, whereas in the second, piles of tusk shells are particularly frequent. Three concentrations also appear among the shells placed under the bones of the two individuals. A first batch seems to be arranged in a crown on the bottom of the pit, against its eastern wall. It adjoins a second roughly rectangular batch located in the centre of the pit. A last batch, oriented east-west, rests against and passes under the site of the left leg of the large child.
Fig. 73 – Interlocking of human bones and shells in structure 3.
A. Horizontal projection of all the pieces; B. Selection of pieces placed on the leg of the young male; C. Selection of pieces placed on the bones of the adult female; D. Selection of pieces located on the bottom of the pit and under the bones of the two previous individuals; E. Transverse section a’ b’.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
42We then mapped the objects situated under the two bodies, by altimetric levels, distinguishing the distribution of the tusk shells from those of the dog whelks and other shells, which are often much larger in size (figs. 74 and 75). As far as the tusk shells are concerned, two wall effects can be noted, one of which covers the right foot of the adult female. Both individuals could have been deposited seated on the same mat, or on any other object made of perishable material decorated with numerous tusk shells. A photograph taken during the first excavations shows three rows of superimposed tusk shells, arranged in a herringbone pattern, each row facing in an opposite direction (fig. 76).
Fig. 74 – Spatial distribution of dog whelks and tusk shells in Structure 3, by altimetric levels.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 75 – Composition of batch no. 1 of structure 3 by altimetric levels.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 76 – Tusk shells at the base of the fill of structure 3, elements of synthesis.
A. Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud; B. Photograph by P. Courtaud.
43The dog whelks are divided into two sets. One is made up of small-sized elements that seem to correspond to the presence of a circular object placed under the buttocks of the adult woman. The other is made up of much larger elements that completely envelop the leg, with a significant concentration above the ankle. This concentration ends with the presence of some bones of a small mammal. A perforated canine tooth was found at the knee. A similar concentration is found at the thigh. Photographs taken during the first excavations allow us to confirm that these elements of adornment completely surrounded the upper leg (fig. 77).
Fig. 77 – Dog whelks and gastropods in the fill of Structure 3, elements of synthesis. For the sample corresponding to the histogram, NR = 70.
A. CAD L. Laporte and C. Dupont for the figure, and L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently; B. Photograph by P. Courtaud.
44Traces of wear are organised in a non-random way, for example when wear on the edge of the perforation of a dog whelk is in the continuity of the opening of an adjacent tusk shell that may have been attached with the same cord (fig. 78). Other dog whelks appear to be paired. Some tusk shell segments are nested together and nearly three-quarters show traces of lateral abrasion. Of the thirty or so dog whelks with particularly pronounced wear, some are also located around the left calf of the older child. Some of the pieces of clothing or decorated objects deposited in the grave thus appear to have been worn, or used, for a long time beforehand.
Fig. 78 – Elements of adornment located on the left leg of the young male deposited in Structure 3.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
45In this tomb, a significant number of pieces seem to correspond to the presence of richly decorated objects in perishable material, particularly tusk shells. Other perforated pieces are more closely linked to body volumes, sometimes attached to pieces of clothing, particularly around the legs of the young male, where elements of corporal adornment are distinguished either by the type of shells used (moon snails, nerites), or by a selection of the size of the dog whelk shells used, or even for some of the latter by an original method of shaping the perforations (preparation by grooving).
46This grave is the best preserved and contained the remains of an adult and a child. In contrast to the previous cases, the whole body of the adult in anatomic connection was uncovered. In the upper parts of the fill, only a few ornamental pieces appear in the form of seemingly random dots (fig. 79). Immediately below, a first concentration of items of adornment is closely associated with the bones of the child laid against the adult’s back. An aurochs bucranium on the feet of the latter is also associated with some perforated elements. In front of the face of the adult individual, a concentration of perforated objects includes a few tusk shells, dog whelks, a batch of much larger shells and some perforated teeth. Several valves are arranged around the skull, and the first perforated elements directly associated with the body volume of the adult buried in this grave appear. Some shells are always present in the corporal volume, at the base of the filling.
Fig. 79 – Distribution of shells in Structure 10, dismantled by altimetric level.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
47The child’s bones and the associated shells fit into a volume with a generally rectangular cross-section (fig. 80). The perforated pieces are aligned on the longer sides of this volume, as on the walls of a container. Tusk shells make up the bulk of the shells on the southern side, whereas they are absent from the northern side of the volume. In the centre, on the other hand, a group of dog whelks is closely intermingled with human bones. The child’s bones, perhaps with elements of corporal adornment, thus seem to have been placed in a container made of perishable material decorated with numerous shells. A few shells are also arranged just above and around the central part of the bucranium placed on the adult’s feet (fig. 81), as if they had been attached to a perishable mount covering the latter.
Fig. 80 – Shells closely associated with the bone remains of the child deposited in Structure 10.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 81 – Shells present at the level of the bucrania deposited in structure 10.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
48Near the skull and slightly in front of the adult’s face, all the perforated elements contained in the thickness of the fill mark the presence of a wall effect (fig. 82). The first is associated with well above average-sized dog whelks, while the second comprises a high number of tusk shells on the surface. Another dog whelk and a Laevicardium crassum valve are pressed against the skull on the frontal bone. Two nested Laevicardium crassum valves, topped by a limpet shell, are located near the occipital (fig. 83).
Fig. 82 – Shells present around the skull and in front of the face of the adult individual deposited in Structure 10.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 83 – Batches 1 and 2 in structure 10.
CAD L. Laporte for the figure, and by L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
49Slightly in front of the face, a second set of valves is surrounded by numerous tusk shells. More than half of the tusk shells collected in Structure 10, some of which are nested, are grouped in this area. This batch has been subdivided into three subsets, which include two opposite, nested Laevicardium crassum valves (fig. 83); one Laevicardium crassum valve on an oyster valve; one large gastropod and four Laevicardium crassum valves, three of which are nested (fig. 84). Two sets of valves are located below the skull. For the elements situated at the bottom of the pit and under the bones of the skeleton, the previously mentioned wall effect is most clearly observed at this level.
Fig. 84 – Batches 3 and 4 in Structure 10.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original surveys drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
50For the perforated elements in the body volume of the adult, a rather loose scattering of dog whelks and a few rare tusk shells cover the whole body (fig. 85). A spisula valve is present at the waist and a limpet is found on the upper right thigh. A few elements have also slipped inside the rib cage, while others are wedged between the bones of the right and left limbs. Most of these perforated shells probably belonged to bodily ornamentation. Dog whelk shells show much more pronounced signs of wear than all the other shells from the same grave (fig. 86).
Fig. 85 – Shells closely associated with the body volume of the adult deposited in Structure 10.
A. All bones are in place; B. The right half of the body has been dismantled.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original records drawn by H. Duday with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 86 – Degree of wear of the pierced dog whelks collected in Structure 10.
The figures in brackets indicate the proportion of heavily worn pieces for each set.
CAD L. Laporte.
51Ultimately, the ornamentation worn by the adult at the time of burial comprises at most about sixty perforated shells, mainly dog whelks, a few rare tusk shells, a spisula valve and perhaps a limpet. Most of the perforated shells deposited in the grave seem to correspond rather to the ornamentation of diverse objects in perishable material accompanying the deceased.
52A large proportion of the shells collected during the excavation of the La Vergne burials seem to correspond rather to the deposit of richly decorated objects in perishable materials, although we cannot exclude the presence of some body ornaments or clothing decorated in this way. Only the presence of ornamental elements, in this case shell pieces, can sometimes identify the existence of such objects. The presence of traces of wear indicates that at least some of these objects were used beforehand.
53The grouping of burials in cemeteries is observed during the Mesolithic (May 1986, p. 10, Cauwe 2005). Only Téviec and Hoëdic are comparable in France to La Vergne in terms of the clustering of burials associated with concentrations of perforated shells. The two sites in southern Brittany are more recent with dates distributed around 5,200-4,500 cal. BC for Hoëdic and 5,000-4,900 cal. BC for Téviec (Marchand and Schulting 2019).
54Despite these chronological and geographical differences, several common denominators have been identified in the overall composition of the ornamentation from these sites. Seashells make up the vast majority of the ornamental items but other elements are also associated with the skeletons (Jeunesse 1997, Rigaud 2011). At each site, most of the shells correspond to two small-sized species (Taborin 1974). These are Littorina obtusata associated with Trivia monacha (T. europea in Taborin 1974) for Téviec and Hoëdic, and tusk shells associated with dog whelks for La Vergne. These four species are rarely observed alive by coastal populations. This fact may add another dimension to these shells, which may symbolize mystery and belief, or even fear of the unknown. The presence of subtidal molluscs among the ornamental elements from Téviec and Hoëdic, as well as the observation of marks linked to marine erosion, point to similar behaviour to what we described at La Vergne, namely the collection of shells in the high seas. In the same way as for La Vergne, the shells mainly used as ornaments in Téviec and Hoëdic were not part of the diet of these coastal populations (Dupont 2006, 2019). This distinction shows that the choice made by Mesolithic populations was not only guided by the abundance of shells on the coast, but also by cultural choices. This distinction between shells for food and shells for making ornaments is interesting. It seems to be perpetuated throughout the chronology (Dupont 2019).
55Although the general profile of the malacofaunal assemblage at La Vergne is close to that of the Breton sites, it differs in terms of the identified species. Indeed, while the cowry and the flat periwinkle represent the majority of the corpus at these sites, the tusk shell and the netted dog whelk are legion at La Vergne. This difference can be explained by the facies of the coastlines closest to the sites, and therefore by raw material accessibility.
56Despite the small number of sites, similarities in terms of adornment contrast with the geographical, chronological and distance from the coastline of the sites and what this implies in terms of marine resource inputs (Schulting 1996, Schluting et al. 2008). The survival of traditions associated with these elements of adornment suggest that they were extremely important to hunter-gatherer societies in the vicinity of the coastline (Borić and Cristiani 2016), even if the message conveyed is unknown to us.
57We have already had the opportunity, also in the context of a recent article, to distinguish between two types of anthropogenic action on matter; those consisting in reappropriating a natural entity, and those involving shaping a raw material (Laporte and Dupont 2019). We will begin by discussing the degree of shaping for each type of shell object present in the La Vergne burials, then we will describe the different shaping methods in detail.
58During the Mesolithic period in Western Europe, the raw materials used to make ornaments derived mainly from the animal world. Among the latter, by far the best represented elements are very characteristic, and allow for the identification of the animal even after its death (shells, teeth...). These elements only underwent limited shaping that does not alter the general shape of the piece, and at times the species of the most characteristic elements can be determined. Such common features can be found in the shaping of shell ornaments at the La Vergne site, but also in the burials at Téviec and Hoëdic. The term “raw material” is therefore perhaps not the most appropriate in this case. It is more a question of appropriating witnesses from the animal world than of a real transformation of materials. These pieces, used as elements of adornment, bear witness to the existence of precisely identifiable living beings. This is also the case for the shells washed up on the foreshore, subsequently selected for use as ornaments and then buried on the La Vergne site. This points to the very different attitude of hunter-gatherers, compared to that of the first farmers of the Atlantic coast, although, all in all, the technical baggage of both is broadly equivalent in this field. From the Early Neolithic onwards, in western France, elements of adornment included an increasing number of manufactured objects, sometimes with purely conceptual shapes that were not at all reminiscent of that of the initial element. Gradually, bone and shell materials were treated more and more as an inert raw material, like others mainly deriving from the mineral world.
59When it was not possible to take advantage of naturally occurring perforations, a perforation was made. In this case, various techniques were used for the same type of ornamental object. Anthropogenic perforations are very common on dog whelks. Tusk shell ornaments were fashioned by segmenting the distal and proximal ends of the shell. Almost all the valves used as ornamental elements are shells washed up on the foreshore and selected on account of the presence of a natural perforation near the hinge. This is also the case for the valves collected in the Mesolithic burials of Téviec and Hoëdic, which are perforated at the hook or umbo (Péquart et al. 1937). The perforation of pendants, generally on the front and curved part of the shell, has often been associated with a mode of suspension and presentation of the shells (Barge-Mahieu and Taborin 1991), as well as with a flat stability of the suspended ornament (Péquart et al. 1937).
60Among the perforated gastropod shells, dog whelks constitute almost two-thirds of the entire corpus (table 4). Where necessary, the perforation was made by percussion. No traces of percussion were observed. In contrast, the Euspira sp. from Structure 3 were perforated using a very different technique involving the use of a rotary borer. The location of the perforation in line with the peristome has sometimes been associated with a perforation of the test through the interior of the shell (Taborin 1974, Barge-Mahieu and Taborin 1991). The resulting orifice then has irregular edges, more rarely circular, and a conical profile. The wide part of the cone is on the convex side. Chipping can be seen around the outer face (Barge 1982). This method would have been widely used by Epipaleolithic and Mesolithic groups by introducing a point into the peristome, including at Téviec and Hoëdic (Péquart et al. 1937). On the other hand, on the vast majority of the pieces examined from La Vergne, the flakes resulting from this operation were observed on the inner face of the perforation lip, which would be more in keeping with a perforation obtained by percussion placed on the outer, concave face of the shell. It is therefore easy to understand the usefulness of a preliminary preparation of this convex surface in turban Gastropods. A preliminary preparation of surfaces by abrasion or incision could sometimes be detected on some La Vergne dog whelks. This latter operation seems to present the greatest technical variability.
Table 4 – Main techniques used (frequently, in black, more rarely, in grey) for perforating shells.
61Even when the shell bears several natural or artificial holes, only one perforation seems to have been used. At La Vergne, only the shells of large gastropods, such as the two Semicassis saburon, bear two perforations aligned along the main axis of the shell. In this respect, they are reminiscent of the numerous biforate cowry shells from the Mesolithic burials of Téviec and Hoëdic, although the latter are much smaller in size. Conical gastropods, only represented by limpets, are either perforated at the apex for nine of them or on the anterior edge for two specimens. Apical perforation is also predominant on limpets from Breton Mesolithic burials (May 1986). All these elements, apart from contributing to a history of techniques, only make sense when they can be compared in coherent groups. Which leads us now to consider the position of the objects in the grave.
62The very high quality of the recordings made during the excavation of these burials at La Vergne enabled us to discuss the position of each of these shell objects in the grave. In particular, it was necessary to distinguish between perforated elements used to decorate various items of clothing, such as the corporal adornment of each individual, and those that also decorated other types of objects made of perishable material that were deposited in the grave. In Western Europe, few reports on ancient excavations provide sufficiently precise information on the place of the pierced objects in the burial site. D. Peyrony’s description of the position of some 1,100 pieces of shell ornaments—900 of which were tusk shells—on the body of the child from La Madeleine, is far too laconic, as is the published diagram (Capitan and Peyrony 1928, Vanhaeren and d’Errico 2001).
63In the nineteenth century, and at the dawn of the following century, necklaces strung on a tie or tied in the hair seemed to be the adornments most in keeping with the image of “primitive” humans. However, some early studies recorded extremely precise observations. The report on the laboratory excavations carried out by Dr Verneau on the skeletons from the Grimaldi caves is exemplary from this point of view for the time, with an approach that in principle is not far removed from what we have attempted to apply a posteriori to the La Vergne corpus (Verneau 1906). The lower burial contained two connected skeletons, closely intertwined with the limbs in a very strongly contracted position, as in some of the La Vergne tombs. A detailed study of the traces of wear enabled M. Vanhaeren (2002) to propose a reconstruction of the piece of clothing corresponding to the thousand cyclopes (dog whelks) covering the stomach and thighs of the two very young individuals discovered by E. Rivière in the Grotte des Enfants. Increasingly precise excavations are now leading to more and more such examples: the place of each object in the grave can thus be discussed even in cases of extremely extensive body reductions (Bugajska and Guminski 2016). To take head ornaments alone, although these are now much more precisely documented (Butrimas 2016, p. 210, fig. 31), their reconstruction sometimes also leads to increasingly exuberant representations (Petersen 2016, p. 122, fig. 18b), for the Mesolithic period. There are no longer any obstacles to using such objects in the reconstruction of large pieces of clothing (see also Borić et al. 2014, Borić 2016, Ghelen 2016, p. 841, fig. 15).
64In contrast to the previous case, proposals for the presence of richly ornamented objects deposited in the grave independently of corporal adornment are still rather limited for the prehistoric period. We will take here only a few Mesolithic burials from northern Europe, in particular those from the cemeteries of Bogebakken in Vedbaek and Dragsholm in Denmark (Albrethsen and Petersen 1977). At Bogebakken, the 15 individual burials generally lack corporal ornamentation; only one of them yielded five perforated teeth. In contrast, they are abundant in two of the three multiple burials in this cemetery, with a total of 50 pieces in one case and over 240 pieces in the other. For the prehistory of other continents, we have already had the opportunity to question the possible meanings of such disparities (Laporte 2014). In Europe, they are particularly complex in the case of the multiple Epipaleolithic and Mesolithic burials.
65At the time of discovery, the fifty perforated canines present on the neck and chest of one of the two adults in Grave 19 at Bogebakken seemed to correspond, without much doubt, to elements of corporal adornment, as did the numerous perforated pieces collected on one of the arms, in and under the pelvis of the two women buried in the Dragsholm grave. Such an interpretation was, however, more difficult for the grave of an adult woman and child at Bogebakken (8), where the bulk of the ornamental elements are concentrated above the right shoulder and against the head of the adult. A recent review, published forty years later, now favours the hypothesis of a cradle used for the transport of children on their mother’s back, among highly mobile hunter-gatherer populations (Petersen 2016, p. 118). This hypothesis, extended here to other Danish Mesolithic burials, had already been proposed for the earlier Upper Palaeolithic period (Einwögerer et al. 2006).
66The direct association between certain concentrations of perforated shells and the corpses, or bones, of young children is also a case that we encountered in the La Vergne graves. However, a complementary hypothesis, attested by numerous ethnographic examples concerning hunter-gatherer populations, holds that the young deceased were buried at a later date, transported by their mother while awaiting the death of an adult individual from the same group (Boulestin 2016). Following the work of A. Testart (2004) who questioned the frequency of double or multiple burials in recent prehistory, B. Boulestin (2016) introduces this element as an alternative to debates on sacrificial death practices or accompanying deaths in hunter-gatherer populations.
67The previous examples all start from the premise that a direct link has been established between the corpse of a human individual and the volumes of a richly decorated object made of perishable material. At La Vergne, this connection can be extended to certain animal parts, as in the case of the aurochs’ horns in grave 10 (fig. 87). Ethnographic examples such as representations of bovines with richly decorated bodies and horns are extremely numerous, but generally for domestic animals and particularly when they are being sacrificed. Other objects deposited in the Mesolithic tombs of La Vergne are even more difficult to identify. We pointed out that the clashing of opposite bivalve valves assembled on the same tie could have functioned as bells (fig. 88), a bit like the anklets worn by dancers during traditional ceremonies. Among many other possibilities...
68More generally, in prehistoric tombs, the existence of ornamental objects in perishable materials that are totally independent from any corporal adornment has rarely been mentioned, perhaps also on account of the symbolic weight that such remains represent in our eyes, conceived as inseparable from the death of a human being. They are only really taken into account for much more recent periods, such as for Egyptian tombs for example, especially when conservation conditions or more perennial materials for so much ornamentation make their identification indisputable.
Fig. 87 – Spatial structuring of the adornment in Graves 7 at La Vergne, main hypotheses considered.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original excavation records drawn by H. Duday, with annotations by P. Courtaud.
Fig. 88 – Spatial structuring of the adornment in Grave 10 at La Vergne, main hypotheses considered.
Construction of the figure L. Laporte; CAD L. Quesnel for the drawing of each piece independently, as reported on the original excavation records drawn by H. Duday, with annotations by P. Courtaud.
69The Mesolithic burials of the islets of Téviec and Hoëdic, discovered in the 1930s on the southern coasts of Brittany, remain essential elements of comparison for our study, due to the high number of associated objects of adornment. The detailed study of each of the pieces in this collection was included in the PhD presented by Y. Taborin in the 1970s. More recent revisions of the available documentation on these burials have also been published (Schulting et al. 2008, Dupont et al. 2009, Boulestin 2016). The descriptions proposed at the time of discovery, full of assumptions, could only imagine loincloths on the pelvis, necklaces on the chest, a few bracelets around the limbs, hairnets or crowns on the head.
70In grave H in the cemetery of Hoëdic, the Péquart couple described the corpse of an adult woman lying “slightly bent over on her right side. Her head was slightly tilted towards the chest with an air of contemplation that is further accentuated by the position of the two hands joined at the base of the neck and clasping a perforated Cardium shell with the fingers. There is no doubt that this is a pendant and that it is the main element of a necklace made up of periwinkles, some elements of which we find in place, on the chest and the remains scattered in the pelvis” (Péquart and Péquart 1954, p. 44). Apart from the romanticism of the narrative, we cannot fail to be intrigued by the length of the reconstructed necklace, which would start at the neck and end in the crotch region.
71A little further on, grave K was originally that of an adult male, deposited on his back. The adornment consisted of several hundred small Gastropods, three valves and two ray loops. It consisted of “bracelets, the elements of which are still in place on each wrist, a necklace with beads around the neck and on the sternum. Moreover, the existence of a net covering the head of the dead man seems more than probable, judging by the number of pierced periwinkles accumulated behind and under the skull, as we saw after it was removed” (ibid., p. 57). It should be noted here, as in the previous example, that there are no perforated shells on the head of the deceased, but that they are located under and around the skull. A detailed examination of the documentation now suggests to anthropologists a decomposition of the body in a sealed space. The hypothesis of a hairnet around the head of the deceased can therefore be ruled out.
72Grave J contained the remains of an adult woman, lying on her back with her legs strongly contracted upwards, with the skeleton of a child on her stomach. “In addition to the 134 cowries and 604 perforated periwinkles, elements of necklaces and bracelets scattered all over the skeleton—and even near the left ankle (probable remains of a leg ring)—we see, tightly encircling the neck of the deceased, 25 large valves, still in place, one next to the other in perfect order. In addition to this imposing necklace, and as if to add to the aesthetics of the spectacle, two abalones (Haliotis tuberculata) placed on either side of the neck on each of the clavicles, still shimmer to our eyes with all their pearly iridescence” (ibid., p. 54). The two abalones found on the collarbones could indeed be part of a garment. The presence of numerous valves near the head of the deceased is particularly noteworthy, as is the case for tomb 10 at La Vergne, where they correspond to objects distinct from the corporal adornment itself.
73The descriptions of the Téviec burials are even more laconic and raise the same kind of questions (Péquart and Péquart 1929). In the end, the lyrical words of the Péquart couple highlight the role of all these ornaments in the staging of the bodies of the deceased during their burial. On the other hand, the text is so full of presuppositions and imprecisions that it is very difficult to decide on the exact nature or status of the decorated objects. We assume that the tombs of La Vergne would not have been described in very different ways from those of Téviec or Hoëdic, as far as the ornamentation is concerned, if they had been excavated at the same time and by the same authors. But conversely, for the Mesolithic burials at La Vergne, we only know what remains below a level of the prehistoric soil that has now been completely erased. Those of Téviec and Hoëdic were built in the middle of shell mounds. They are inserted and sometimes backfilled with domestic waste where the discovery of perforated shells is not exceptional (Kayser 1990). This problem is particularly well illustrated by the Portuguese site of Moita do Sebastiao, where the majority of the ornamental elements seem to come at least as much from the surrounding layers as from the burials themselves (Roche 1972, Figueiredo et al. 2016).
74The study of prehistoric ornamental objects is still mainly the study of disjointed pieces. This is particularly true for shell ornaments. Each piece provides a great deal of extremely valuable information on the environment in which it was collected, transport distances, shaping methods, or the way in which it was worn. Like each piece of clothing, they are part of the material culture of a given group. For more than a decade now, we have become fully aware that these perforated shells could have adorned many other objects of daily life. While the study of each element taken separately mobilises increasingly complex technical methods, our knowledge of prehistoric “adornment”, strictly speaking, is still somewhat embryonic.
75The quality of data from the excavation of the Mesolithic burials at the La Vergne site will at least have enabled us to identify the existence of many ornamental objects in the grave, distinct from the corporal adornment of the deceased. Under these conditions it is sometimes difficult to substantiate further comparisons with our own deductions for these exceptional assemblages, which are moreover separated by large chronological ranges and great geographical distances. The cemeteries of Téviec and Hoëdic, for example, the closest of the cited examples, are several hundred kilometres and at least three millennia away from the burials at La Vergne.
76The closest elements of comparison in geographical terms come from the only burial site definitely attributable to the Early Neolithic in west-central France, which has also yielded an exceptional number of shell ornaments (Gaillard et al. 1984, Laporte and Gomez 2001). With 3,200 ornamental elements collected, the Neolithic burial site at Germignac is hardly comparable on a national scale, with the possible exception of one of the burials discovered in the neighbourhood of la Balance in Avignon (Courtin et al. 1966, Zemour et al. 2017). Both the La Vergne and Germignac graves include an impressive number of perforated shells, although the shape and degree of shaping are radically different. At La Vergne, we even questioned the relevance of the term raw material, replaced here by natural entities that are displayed, assembled and used on different objects, perhaps for aesthetic purposes, perhaps for prophylactic purposes, perhaps for other reasons.
77The variety of forms of Mesolithic adornment, such as that studied at La Vergne, stemming from a long tradition rooted in the Upper Palaeolithic, thus appears even more clearly when contrasted with the standardisation of finished products that is beginning to emerge in very early Neolithic assemblages in western France. In other contemporaneous contexts, discs quite similar to those from Germignac were made in limestone, for example, although it is not always possible to tell the difference with the naked eye. It is as if the major transformation that the shell tests underwent seemed to take them away from their original marine environment. This opposition between the transformation of matter and the appropriation of natural entities can be seen very clearly in the La Vergne corpus, where many perforated shells come from selective collection on the coastline.