Navigation – Plan du site

AccueilDossiers66Hors ThèmeChoosing to Retire? A Study of Wo...

Hors Thème

Choosing to Retire? A Study of Women’s Patterns for Retiring or Continuing to Work

« Choisir » de prendre sa retraite ? Les logiques de sorties ou de maintien en emploi de femmes âgées
Isabelle Marchand et Diane-Gabrielle Tremblay

Résumés

Les femmes issues de la génération du babyboom représentent la première génération de femmes qui présentent une trajectoire de vieillesse-retraite basée sur un modèle a priori masculin. À partir d’un devis qualitatif, 20 récits de vie ont été réalisés auprès de femmes âgées entre 60 et 70 ans, retraitées pour la plupart, toutes nées au Canada (Québec). À l’aide d’une analyse narrative, cinq logiques d’action ayant amené les participantes à effectuer une sortie de carrière ou, à l’inverse, à repousser cette sortie d’emploi et l’entrée dans la retraite ont été identifiées : 1) Se choisir pour profiter de sa retraite ; 2) La retraite raisonnée : choisir de faire le deuil de sa carrière ; 3) La rupture : l’obligation de prendre sa retraite ; 4) La retraite par extension au conjoint-travailleur ; 5) Mettre à distance la retraite. L’analyse montre que les logiques tracées varient en fonction de divers contextes socio-économiques tels que l’état de santé, le rapport au travail, le statut de retraité du conjoint, le travail de care et le désir de liberté. Ces logiques reflètent également des formes de continuité des rôles sociaux endossés au cours de la vie, qu’il s’agisse du travail de care (formel ou informel), du travail rémunéré, du travail ménager et des engagements sociaux. Dans cette perspective, pour mieux saisir toute la diversité des transitions de retraite des femmes âgées, il importe d’appréhender leur trajectoire au carrefour des histoires collectives et individuelles ainsi que des effets entrecroisés du genre avec d’autres rapports sociaux.

Haut de page

Texte intégral

1. Introduction

  • 1 ‘The Old Age Pension was first introduced in Canada in 1927. Initially, pensions were only availabl (...)

1Social and generational changes in second post-war welfare states were transformative for female baby boomers (Arber, Davidson, & Ginn, 2003; Mc Daniel, 2007). While women’s work trajectories are not homogeneous (Cau-Bareille, 2011; Nichols, 2019), many women did have the opportunity to pursue post-secondary studies, enter the labor market, have a career, and enjoy the “choice” about whether and when to have children, enter public and political life, etc. Breaking out of the compulsory role of wife-mother-homeworker, the trajectories of women baby-boomers are far more influenced by emancipation, individualization, and social mobility than those of previous generations. Historically, this is the first generation of women have been active in the labor market to reach retirement age in massive numbers (Mc Donald, 2006; Sawyer & James, 2018), thus following a work-retirement trajectory constructed on a masculine archetype (Charles, 2007; Foster & Walker, 2013). Even for men, however, access to an old-age pension in Canada1 is a relatively recent phenomenon in the history of post-second war welfare state societies. The age of retirement in Canada, all sectors of employment combined, is nearly 64 (Statistics Canada, 2018), while there is no compulsory retirement age.

2We know that aging-retirement trajectories are gendered (Calasanti, 2010; Calasanti, 1996; Price, 2000; Price & Nesteruk, 2010). Women’s experiences in the labor market are different from men’s, partly because they are still somewhat less present in the workforce and have lower incomes than men (Gin, Street & Arber, 2001; Women’s Philanthropy Institute, 2018). Moreover, socio-economic issues (i.e., poverty; financial insecurity, unequal retirement income) that affect women more particularly, have been well documented (Herd, 2009; Madero-Cabib & Fasang, 2016; Riekhoff & Järnefelt, 2018; Townson, 2009). More women than men are single parents and live alone as they get older (Quéniard et al., 2019; Gambold, 2013; Gazso & McDaniel, 2010; Townson, 2009). Women are also more affected by other issues, such as care work, for which they remain primarily responsible, whether as the primary care-giving parent or as a close caregiver (Ginn, Street & Arber, 2001; Mc Daniel, 2007; Vanier Institute of the family, 2017). These specific realities that circumscribe women’s life courses naturally shape their retirement experiences (Gambold, 2013; Newton, Chauhan, Spirling & Stewart, 2018; Prince; 2000; Price & Nesteruk, 2010).

3These interactions between the public and private spheres help maintain the social inequalities in the marketplace and family domain (Tremblay, 2019), which may be even more so in the post-Covid-19 pandemic context, as this crisis in employment seems to hit women more than men. Indeed, if previous economic recessions have mainly affected male sectors such as manufacturing or construction, the COVID crisis has hit more severely service sectors where women are more numerous, and women have thus been harder hit by unemployment and even more precarious positions. Statistics Canada data indicate that the gender gap in employment has increased between men and women, mainly because of women’s family responsibilities (Qian and Fuller, 2020).

4Also, unemployment in Canada went from about 5-6% in January 2020 to a high of 13.7% in May 2020 and 10.9% in July 2020 (Statistics Canada, 2020). Quebec is the province hardest hit by the pandemic, as the unemployment rate has increased from 4.5% in February, to a high of 18.2% in April, returning to 9.2% in July (Observatoire des inégalités, 2020). Some female sectors were more hardly hit; for example, the accommodation and food service industries remain 25% below pre-pandemic level, information, culture, and leisure still 14% below (Renner, 2020) a few months later. On a monthly average, 12% of Canadian workers were laid off in the months from March to June, while in previous recessions, Statistics Canada only reported job losses between 2.5 and 3.5%, indicating the utter strength of the backlash (Statistics Canada, 2020).

5As usual, it is mainly young workers, newly hired and the less educated who are hit first, but this time women were more hard-hit than men, like personal services, retail (except for food), and the hospitality sector (hotels, restaurants) were very hard hit and have not yet fully recuperated, especially as restaurants have been closed for at least two periods of time. In Quebec, women went from a 58.6% employment rate to 47.8% in April 2020, and returned only to 54.7% in July, while men went from 65% to 52.6% and back to 61.7% for the same months. The pandemic thus hit women’s employment more than men, and furthermore, the risk of increasing the social inequalities in aging is real. In this regard, although the present research was done before the pandemic, the interest for women’s different passages from work to retirement, the object of this paper, appears relevant to capture in order to better understand the conditions or dynamics that lead women to retire in the contemporary context.

6In this perspective, based on qualitative research that studies older women’s daily activity, our contribution aims to present, different dynamics that led women to end their paid employment and retire or to stay in the labor market. Before turning to the empirical findings, we will present an overview of the state of knowledge about retirement and especially, knowledge about women’s retirement. Next, our methodological framework will be explained. The dynamics for leaving (or not leaving) paid employment and entering retirement will then be described, and, in the last section of the article, discussed.

2. Retirement: midway between a transition and a passage

7The concept of retirement has changed many times in the last decades (Byles et al., 2013; Price, 2000; Price & Nesteruk, 2010; Sawyer & James, 2018). In the West, retirement has traditionally referred to a specific event in a person’s life, a moment of transition between the world of work and the world of well-deserved leisure and rest. This concept of retirement, characterized by “non-productive” activities, now seems obsolete (Byles et al, 2013). The idea of a retirement cut-off age within a 3-part cycle (study-work-retirement) now seems to be vanishing due to the ever blurrier boundaries between the stages of life (Guillemard, 2010). Retirement is no longer represented as an “abrupt transition” (Byles et al. 2013) and some describe it more as a passage (Boboc & Metzger, 2013). Hooyman et al. (2002, cited in Byles et al., 2013) describe it as a “fluid concept” describing different phases of transition and fluctuations between employment entries and exits in old age. Indeed, the transition to complete retirement can be long and complex; many people alternate between retirement and work, or combine both, while others decide to permanently cease any form of paid work (Canadian Longitudinal Study on Aging, 2018). Thus, the concept of retirement becomes polymorphic, depending on the contexts in which it appears in international studies (Maestas, 2010). For many of the baby boom generation, it represents a passage into a new stage of life, brimming with new possibilities (Byles et al, 2013; Mansour et Tremblay, 2018b). This “new beginning” or “time of revitalization” (Gibson, Ashton-Shaeffer, Green, & Corbin, 2002) was evoked by the activist and positivist discourse and practices associated with the “young-old" in normative theories on successful, productive, and active aging (Kojola & Moen, 2016; van Dyk & Turner, 2010).

3. Women’s retirement choices and activities when paid employment comes to an end

8Retirement is an increasingly diverse phenomenon for women (Byles & al, 2013; Newton & al. 2018; Sawyer & James, 2018; Women’s Philanthropy Institute, 2018). Concerning the numerous interrelationships between the family and work spheres, many researchers “stress the necessity of including family life courses in retirement studies along with employment trajectories” (Madero-Cabib & Fasang, 2016: 44). For example, the close link between motherhood, care to work, and paid work may explain why women holding traditionally female jobs leave paid work earlier (Cau-Bareille, 2011). According to Byles et al. (2013: 38) “one of the most common reasons given [by women] for retiring was for personal health problems or physical disabilities and having attained some level of financial security.” These contextual factors connected with socio-economic status and health influence the decision of when to retire, as do the family situation, care work, and the work context (Newton et al., 2018). In addition, retirement decisions must be situated in the intertwining of the micro (individual experiences), meso (workplace, organizations), and macro (social policies, types of socio-political regimes) contexts (Kojola & Moen, 2016). They are also influenced by gender (Byles et al. 2013; Newton, et al, 2018) and social class (Kojola & Moen, 2016).

9Activities pursued in retirement are as varied as the reasons for stopping work. In this perspective, regardless of the types of activities pursued in retirement, care work, manifested in diverse daily practices, remains central to women’s lives (Dentinger & Clarkberg, 2002; Marchand, 2018a). More specifically, women are still very much involved in formal volunteering—for instance, in organizational structures (Charpentier et Quéniart, 2009; Lie, Baines, & Wheelock, 2009; Pavelek, 2013; Price & Nesteruk, 2010; Seaman, 2012)—and informal volunteering or commitments such as caregiving within the family and intergenerational networks (Byles & al; 2013; Charpentier et Quéniart, 2007; Dentinger and Clarkberg, 2002; Martinez, Crooks, Kim, & Tanner, 2011; Price & Nesteruk, 2010). When women retire, their lives often continue to be heavily centered on the family (Price & Nesteruk, 2010), while others continue full- or part-time paid work after turning 65 (MacEwn 2012; Price & Nesteruk, 2010). Leisure is another aspect of retired women’s pathways (Price & Nesteruk, 2010). In short, retired women combine various roles and social, political, and civic commitments (Byles et al., 2013; Charpentier et Quéniart, 2009; Kulik, 2015; Marchand, 2018a).

10As part of the research continuum investigating “the unique nature of women’s retirement” (Prince, 2000: 82), our study, based on a narrative method (life stories), considers the daily life practices of Canadian women aged 60 to 70. The analysis of these stories revealed retirement as an omnipresent theme. We, therefore, focus on the dynamics that led participants to leave the workforce, or, inversely, continue working and delay retirement. To capture the unique experiences of women baby boomers, our article focuses on the important biographical transition of leaving paid employment and entering retirement. We propose to describe the patterns observed in women’s retirement experiences, and then, we discuss the gendered aspects of women’s experience of aging and finally, the results issues in light of the dominant active aging contexts and policies.

4. Methodological framework

  • 2 The interviews were conducted in 2014-2015, as part of a doctoral thesis (Marchand, 2016).

11Our theoretical frame is inspired by different perspectives: critical perspectives of aging, social gerontological, and feminist studies. The results presented in this paper emerge from a larger qualitative study that focused on different ways in which older women experiment with citizenship through their daily activities (Marchand, 2016; 2018a). However, the study revealed some unexpected results on older women’s retirement transitions and experiences. We thus decided to analyze them in a specific article. Using the life story method to understand the everyday reality lived by actors, we collected 20 life narratives from women aged 60 to 70, mostly retired, all born in Québec (Canada). The narrative method permits a rich description of individual histories and explores how actors-subjects structure and construct their life experiences, attributing to them a singular meaning and significance (Chase, 2005; Creswell, 2012). Each participant’s narrative considers her sociohistorical context. The narratives thus enabled us to uncover the social reality, events, and the emotional and psychological states experienced by the respondents and relate to them both temporally and spatially. We interviewed 20 women from different backgrounds2 The sample was selected based on the “maximum variation” (Miles & Huberman, 2014) method, to obtain cases representing a variety of positions and experiences related to the research question. This method generates a “constellation of cases,” which are first analyzed vertically and horizontally, and then, comparatively (Pires, 1997). The participants were recruited via social networks and by the snowball method. The criteria for diversity were the following: Age (60 or 70); Being a carer or not; having had children or not; being married, single or divorced; having been employed or stayed at home most of one’s life; occupational category; level of education; living in a rural or urban area; socioeconomic status; health condition. All interviewees were francophones and interviews were done in French. Parts selected for the article were then translated into English.

12To be coherent with the storytelling method, non-directed interviews were conducted, where the interviewer acted more as a guide based on a general question asking the women to tell us what they did during a typical week. Then, when respondents stopped talking, the interviewer would ask stimulus questions to go further on the answers. While the focus was on the present, women often referred to past events of their lives (divorce, stopping work, etc.) This made it possible to cover various periods of their lives before retirement. The interviews lasted between 2 and 4 hours. Table 1 presents the general characteristics of the respondents (N: 20).

13All the interviews were recorded and fully transcribed. In deconstructing–reconstructing the corpus (Paillé & Muchielli, 2012), we began with a codification system guided by “different realities” (empirical, discursive, and reflexive reality; cf. Bertaux, 2010). Next, we referred to fact-based segments (empirical reality) to reconstruct the chronology of everyday life in which actions and concrete practices occur. Segments about discursive and reflexive aspects were classified under broad categories (Paillé & Muchielli, 2012), referring to the “social worlds” of the respondents (Bertaux, 2010) (i.e., private/domestic universe, family universe, and social universe) and two categories of meaning (practices themselves and contribute to society). The step of data “condensation” (Miles & Huberman, 2014) provided us with an enriched and thus deeper reading of each story. Beyond a reconstruction of everyday life, we managed to piece together a dialogical analysis of the stories, revealing the messages underlying the discourses and their content, and thus, the points of tension, disruption, consonance/dissonance. Third, because we wanted to conduct a comparative analysis of the stories, we synthesized the data using the broad category themes for the discursive and reflexive segments (Paillé & Muchielli, 2012). To create a crosscutting overview of themes for the entire sample of respondents, we produced comparative tables, drawing on the themes related to each of the previously introduced six categories. This method allowed us to compare our reconstructed corpora and to analyze the "reappearance of the same situations, rationales, and similar actions” (Bertaux, 2010: 95) or, on the contrary, antagonistic processes or mechanisms, as well as the tensions and ambiguities that cross the narratives.

14Finally, let us mention a few limits of the research and paper. One of the important limits to this study concerns the diversity of women profiles from the point of view of the race (all Caucasian), and social class (middle class for the majority), and language (all Francophones. Because of the small number, we were unable to analyze the effects of gender with the other intersections. In this regard, a more heterogeneous sample would probably contribute to refining the complex realities of leaving careers and entering retirement. Future research should try to include more people of different socio-cultural and economic contexts. Otherwise, we could have extended the theoretical perspectives to include Bridge Employment, which puts the accent on sources of revenue and also symbolic investment in work. While we did address this aspect of symbolic investment in work to a certain extent in the analysis, it is an issue that could be analyzed in more detail in future work; however, this might require a higher number of respondents invested in work after retirement to address more fully the Bridge Employment issue and its impact on retirement (Mansour &Tremblay, 2018).

5. Results

15Analysis of the life stories revealed very diverse aging trajectories. The women interviewed belonged to a “pivot generation”, that is, “a generation that had split with earlier family models after the introduction of changes far more radical than those of previous generations and the following generation" (Attias-Donfut, 1995: 53, author’s translation). In the West, women, and men of this generation underwent social changes instituted by the feminist revolution, which modified socialization trajectories, models of reference, and the identity of a large part of the population. Notwithstanding the uniqueness of individual trajectories, we did note common experiences (e.g., long presence in the labor market for most, divorce, break for children in some cases, and reentering the labor market once children were older, etc.). For all participants in the study, ending paid employment and entering the world of retirement represented a turning point in their lives, and different dynamics informed the decision to stop (or not stop) working in later life. These dynamics are analyzed based on the respondents’ different contexts, status, socio-economic situations, and health status; this led to defining five patterns that reflect women’s retirement experiences.

5.1. “Choosing myself” to take advantage of my retirement years

16For one group of respondents, leaving paid employment was a choice, even for those who had not yet turned 65, which is often seen as the “normal age” of retirement in Canada, as even if there is no obligation to retire, it is this age that entitles a person to the full old-age pension benefit paid by the federal government. For this first pattern, two primary factors influenced the decision to leave paid work: health issues and those related to the uncertainties in the aging trajectory.

17Regarding health, the respondents grouped under this pattern considered themselves “in good health.” They nonetheless expressed a strong desire to remain in good health “as long as possible.” In their view, the idea of extending their career into old age was not compatible with continuing good health and being able to take good care of themselves. According to Pauline:

“I think I was just tired… I wanted to stop at 65, I was 62 then, but my partner said, ‘Listen, if you work until you’re 65, you’ll have more money for sure, but will you be healthy enough to continue ?’ . . . I had to choose between my health and work. And I chose myself.” (Pauline, 64, retiree from the field of administration)

18Along the same lines, choosing to retire, said Céline (60), is like a “gift” we give ourselves when we’re still “young” and in good health. When we anticipate uncertain health in old age and become conscious of our potential decline and the emergence of fragility or serious diseases, we consider our possible choices from this perspective:

“I worked with older people for 26 years and in the last 5 years, it began to hit me : the walker, the wheelchair, Alzheimer’s . . . seeing people becoming more dependent, it was a shock. I said, ‘oh . . .that’s me in 15 or 20 years. I needed to step back.” (Pauline, 64, retiree from the field of administration).

19A second important factor in the decision to stop paid work is embodied in the temporal dimension, namely the reappropriation of all social times. As Chantale (67) explained : “Every hour in the day belongs to me,” adding that “now, I am totally in control of my time.” The phrases “Taking time, having time” were like a constant tune in these women’s stories, most of whom chose to retire after “spending my life on the run between work and kids.” Catherine is a good example of this preoccupation, describing herself as an “authentic girl of ‘68," a product of the 1970s, anti-conformist, freedom-loving, and fleeing the constraints of the work world. As soon as she turned 65, she retired, “not wanting to spend a minute more at my job.”

20Last, ridding oneself of the stress and demanding responsibilities of a profession that requires a high level of education is an important, if not crucial, factor in the decision to retire. This was the case of Christine (63), a former CEO who made a deliberate decision to end her career at 57 : “I’ve noted a big difference in my stress level. Every decision I made affected a thousand people. This changed from one day to the next. It was huge for me. Just huge…For me, the major difference is my stress level.” Like the other respondents grouped under this rationale, she affirms that she has “never regretted her decision” to retire from the workforce when she was still relatively young. This is not the case for all women, however, as we will see with the next rationale.

5.2 Rational retirement : the decision to end a much-loved career

21Retiring is “mourning a career that I loved.” This comment accurately summarizes a pattern in which the departure from paid work is a deliberate choice but nonetheless one that is traversed by tensions and constraints related to family contexts and circumstances. Still very much attached to her job, Marie-Andrée (64) was spending more and more time with her grandchildren. The hospitalization of her husband led her to consider a career end from the perspective of her overall life path : “I said to myself that I had more years behind me than in front of me and how did I want to live the years I had left ?” She added that it was important for her to “take care of her relationship.” Her situation resembles that of Claire, who was also carrying out several care tasks. Several years before she finally left her job, she had already cut back her work hours to care for her sick mother. Retiring was a difficult choice for her, she admitted, but, like other respondents, the desire to commit herself fully to her grandchildren prevailed :

“When I left my job, I was spending more and more of my time with my granddaughters. I wanted to be able to be with them. I worked atypical hours . . . it was hard in that way. And even though I really liked my job, that (being a grandmother) was what motivated me to retire. . . . So, for me it’s family first, no question.” (Claire, 63, retiree from the field of social services)

22Entering retirement was not something that Marie-Andrée and Claire had planned to do “so soon" in their trajectory, but they made this choice to be able to spend more time with family, especially children and grandchildren. The importance of family and the centrality of the grandmother’s role, as well as attention to the couple, played a fundamental role in the decision these women made to retire. In a similar vein of attention to loved ones (caring about), the spouse’s activity can also precipitate the decision of married women to leave the workforce. This was the case of Françoise (64), married to a “born builder,” a “man of the land” who bought a house in the French countryside as a renovation project. Due to the long stay overseas necessitated by this project, she ended her career, an experience she found difficult : “For sure, it was hard to stop working, there was a period of mourning. I had to find another project, so I threw myself into the renovations.”

23Like Françoise, Michelle also chose the timing of her retirement, mostly to be closer to her family, but experienced entering retirement as a “shock” :

“The first year was really hard. As I said to my friend, G. : ‘I didn’t enter retirement, I fell into it. It’s not the same. I guess I just wasn’t ready. . . In the North, I was the nurse, everyone knew me up there and then I came here where I’m nobody . . . it was a shock.” (Michelle, 67, retiree from the field of health and social services)

24Retirement, for this woman who worked some 30 years with Indigenous communities in Canada’s far North, meant returning to the “city”, a letdown of sorts ; a porous zone between two stages of life where she engaged in a process of personal reconstruction in the privacy of her home to “build a new system of references.” In short, this pattern for leaving paid work is pervaded by uneasiness : in response to family situations and circumstances, the respondents grouped under this rationale made the reasoned decision to retire, a biographical transition that was not without clashes and ambivalence.

5.2.1 The break : obligation to retire

25In contrast to the two preceding patterns, the few participants who corresponded to this third pattern were all forced to leave their paid jobs due to health-related incidents or diagnoses. Odette, a woman who had always been “as healthy as a horse,” was diagnosed with advanced fibromyalgia and had to leave her job “the very next day.” This forced retirement was experienced as a brutal break, generating a series of consequences in different areas of her life (economic, social, psychological/emotional, etc.). This “hurricane,” as she describes her illness and its impacts, not only upset her life, but also her sense of belonging in the world :

“As soon as I got sick, I had the feeling that I wasn’t part of the world. . . . because I didn’t feel I was an active member of society . . . because I felt . . . so different, inadequate . . . When I was healthy and working, I was into performing, being active. . . No longer being active, it makes me feel like I don’t really exist . . .” (Odette, 63, retiree from the manufacturing sector)

26Marie’s story evokes a similar turning point because after suffering a stroke, she was paralyzed on her left side, a physical condition that precipitated her into early retirement before she turned 60. For both women, family support was a crucial pillar during the forced transition, which involved a series of psychological and emotional reactions, on top of which came the gradual loss of a social network as a result of the abrupt cessation of employment. These realities are present in the narrative of Lorraine (63), who became blind in her fifties when she was teaching. After a difficult transition period, treatment and rehabilitation, she now considers that she is “living a second life, even though she had never imagined her life as it is today.” In short, the aging-retirement rationale characterized by a break refers to a dramatic event that severs the employment trajectory, followed by family and social upheaval. Faced with these biographical splits, the respondents employed diverse resilience strategies : combativeness in the face of illness and defending their rights with the employer (employment insurance claims), proactivity in seeking various resources, and great personal resilience ; they refused to “feel sorry about themselves” for the rest of their lives.

5.2.2 Retirement as an extension of the retirement of a spouse-breadwinner

27It must first be kept in mind that paid work does not figure in the lives of all older women. As Charles (2007 : 5) mentions, until the 1960s and 1970s, most women declared themselves “inactive” because “women’s essential activity took place outside the labor market." This is the case of a minority of the respondents who did not engage in paid employment. For them, “retirement,” and its associated social rights can be understood “in extension” to the retirement of a husband-breadwinner.

28At the discursive level, the term “retirement” was rarely used by respondents to describe their own aging trajectory. It is rather the partner’s retirement that represents a moment of transition in these respondents’ older years. As such, their pathway is conditioned, not by their own pattern for stopping work and commencing retirement, but by those of their spouse. For example, Rita’s (66) story is strongly shaped by her role as a caregiver for her husband, who retired due to deteriorating health : “He [her spouse] is very ill ; it takes almost all I’ve got to take care of everything. I have to do everything, our finances, debts, etc. He can’t do a thing, so it’s hard. It’s tough for the morale too.”

29Carole’s situation is altogether different. Still living in the village where she was born, she remembers that when women married and had children in that community, they stayed at home to dedicate themselves to their children’s education. Having volunteered in her parish all of her life, it was when her husband retired, healthy and with a good retirement plan, that she was able to enjoy new sports and cultural activities and travel.

5.2.3 Postponing retirement

“For me, retirement equals boredom, stopping everything, and ceasing to think or be involved.” These remarks from Suzanne (61) echo the notion of “retirement as a social death” conceptualized by Guillemard in 1972, illustrating the social exclusion experienced by retirees at that time. Although representations and experiences connected with aging have changed, for some respondents retirement represents a setback ; a period of life to be deferred “as long as possible.” Respondents grouped under this pattern indicated that their degree of satisfaction with work remained high ; they said they “love” what they do, in their work as an artist, child care educator, university professor, or street newspaper seller.

The prospect of their eventual retirement raised questions about their post-employment trajectory and activities since, for them, work was an important place of social integration and recognition. Furthermore, their job or career played a significant role in their personal and professional identity, remaining intrinsically linked to their values and sense of meaning. Hélène exemplifies this :

“At the moment, it’s hard for me to imagine how I would find meaning or value in my life once I have retired. I don’t actually think about it much right now . . . but I’m aware of it and tell myself that probably I won’t have the choice in a few years, I’ll have to start planning it . . . I mean, the psychological aspect of retirement . . .” (Hélène, 61, artist-painter).

30Moreover, for these respondents, retirement increased the sensation of “feeling and looking old” tenfold. “When you’re healthy and fit, you don’t need to stop working,” said Suzanne, echoing Hélène, who also stated that she remained at work because “people don’t see me as dead wood,” adding that in our aging societies, she “can’t imagine that we will work for only 35 years.” Moreover, as a teacher, her job gives meaning to her life : “My sense of meaning comes from my job, not my hobbies.”

5.2.4 Synthesis

31In sum, with the first two patterns, the cessation of paid employment is preceded by serious thoughts about personal aspirations for the later years of life, health issues, and the importance of taking care of oneself (self-care) and loved ones. What most distinguishes the first from the second pattern is the quest for freedom that motivated the decision to leave paid work, to “choose myself.” The third pattern as opposed to the first two : the pattern for entering retirement is constrained and brutal ; it causes a definitive break with productive work, thus staging an abrupt transition, or even a split in the life course between "having always been active" and becoming, suddenly, "inactive". The last two patterns express a form of continuity with life as it has been up until now : postponing retirement enables one to continue paid work and put off issues associated with the biographical transition of retirement.

32In the case of women for whom retirement is an extension of their breadwinner husband’s retirement, there is a sort of continuity with life as they have lived it because the practices of daily life were never associated with paid employment. Nevertheless, the context of a breadwinning spouse’s retirement shapes their own relationships to aging-retirement and the practices of their later years. Finally, for those who postpone retirement, they can be seen as implicitly referring to the notion of “retirement as a social death” conceptualized by Guillemard (1972), and retirement is something that would make them ‘feel and look older.

6. Discussion

33What most interested us in considering these five patterns was the analysis of the contexts, individual and collective experiences, and social relations underlying these decisional or event patterns that lead to retirement. As various authors have noted, health is unquestionably a recurring reason behind women’s choice or obligation to stop working (Byles et al. 2013 ; Cau-Bareille 2011 ; Kojola & Moens, 2016 ; Price & Nesteruk, 2010). Beyond the objective health situation, the rationales reflect a subjective relationship to health in the course of aging : the link between work and health, which may become increasingly difficult as we age ; the uncertainty of health status in the coming years ; the desire to be healthy to enjoy new freedom, not to mention the emotional states caused by the state of health, one’s own or that of a sick spouse, which forces women to retire. Even the decision to continue working “while I’m still healthy” requires a subjective evaluation of one’s state of health. As Cau-Bareille (2011 : S25) remarked, "Health is a state of balance – in fact, a state of fragility – and one’s personal assessment of this balance changes over time."

34Family trajectory and caregiving responsibilities also influence women’s career exit and retirement patterns (Byles et al, 2013 ; Dentinger and Clarkberg, 2002 ; Price & Nesteruk, 2010). In our study, women who have evolved according to the traditional male breadwinner-female caretaker model, even after having held paid employment for a large part of their lives, are more likely to make a rational choice to retire, because of the predominance of care work, particularly with the arrival of grandchildren. It is interesting to note that while this generation of women has been active in the labor market, almost as much as men, retirement often comes along as an important break and while some chose to postpone it, women’s intertwined relation with family often imposes retirement. It must be noted that “even if women of this generation have manifested the desire to exist outside the family sphere, intergenerational mutual aid still has the effect of steering them into domestic care duties” [Translation] (Pennec, 2009 : 149). In the case of the caregiver, it is important to question the structural conditions in which this choice is made, to avoid to essentialize care work, which would fall under the self-sacrifice relating to the "feminine nature" (Marchand et Firbank, 2016b).

35However, the care work performed by many older women contributes to the traditional gendered division of labor once they have retired, but also has a differing influence on women’s and men’s perceptions of employment (Byles et al., 2013 ; Dentinger and Clarkberg, 2002 ; Prince & Nesteruk, 2010 ; Farges & Tremblay, 2016). Similarly, the “retirement of the spouse-breadwinner” pattern, like the “retirement as Husband’s retirement” pathway described by Gibson and others (2002), reproduces, in retirement, the traditional male breadwinner-female caretaker model. The retired male breadwinner model, which perpetuates the gendered division of labor, results in women’s continued economic insecurity in their old age (Calasanti, 2000 ; Prince, 2000).

36Also, the desire to postpone retirement to keep working as long as possible was not associated with financial considerations for the respondents we interviewed. Ass in other studies, the reasons given were more about contributing to society, continuing to be useful and active, and sharing their knowledge (Gibson et al. 2002 ; Kojola & Moens, 2016 ; Mansour et Tremblay, 2018a ;b ; Newton et al. 2018). Similarly, for professional women, work gives life meaning. The central place of work in the lives of women of this generation is also evoked in the findings of Kojola & Moens (2016) and Newton et al. (2018). Moreover, we hypothesize that a strong professional identity is linked to the desire to extend one’s career. In contrast to this pattern, participants who chose to retire as soon as possible reflect the quest for freedom, expressing a deep-seated desire to take advantage of this “new period of life” by liberating themselves from the constraints of work. “Freedom from time constraints enabled them to develop a more holistic lifestyle (Gibson et al., 2002 : 261). Last, as with the data of Newton et al. (2018), which shows that women who have the luxury to choose the timing of retirement exhibit a higher degree of satisfaction than women who do not, our findings also reveal the influence, in everyday life, of having, not having, or having only a little power to determine the timing of retirement.

7. Conclusion : the implication for policies and future studies

37In the present pandemic context, where women are harder hit than men by job losses, this lack of power is surely an important issue to consider. Also, while job losses may lead to the retirement of older women, it is not yet clear that this may have had an impact beyond a few sectors where women of all ages have lost their job ; in Canada, this was the case for hospitality, hotels, restaurants and some retail sectors, but it is not yet clear if these will transform into retirement. Some US researchers indicate this is not the case (Munnell and Chen, 2021), but it might be different for Canada, given the different retirement but also health plans (Tremblay, 2014), as well as strategies that firms can put forward to retain older workers (Mansour & Tremblay, 2019). While all stories here are related to health issues, the sudden break is something which can also be characteristic of persons who suffer job termination or cuts, as is often the case in the present pandemic context, but also in all times of recessions. As well, for many other subjects, the pandemic will surely have important impacts on work-retirement transitions and our five types can be useful in the future to analyze the transitions of women who will have lost their jobs during the pandemic and not been able to return to employment, as many female sectors were particularly hard hit (the hospitality, restaurants and travel industry in particular, but other service sectors as well). Some new categories might well appear following the pandemic which exacerbated, and highlighted, issues related to gender, race, and social class. The analysis of these different power relations, within their specific context, would probably influence entry into retirement for some senior workers. As mentioned previously, not having the ‘luxury’ to choose the timing of their retirement will surely have important socio-economic impacts on many, as paid employment was an important part of women’s identity in the baby boom generations.

38The patterns underlying a decision or the obligation to retire vary based on various contexts and processes : state of health that can influence or force retirement, identity relationship to work and career as well as the feeling of remaining in “active” life, husband’s retirement status for women who have lived according to the traditional male breadwinner-female caretaker model, family caregiving responsibilities that concern most respondents and, finally, desire for freedom, which is expressed by the possibility of choosing retirement activities and leaving behind the constraints of the working world. Yet, despite the changes that influenced the trajectories of women of this generation, for most of the respondents, the patterns underlying their decisions to stop or continue paid work reveal a form of continuity of the social roles adopted over their life course, whether care work (formal and informal), paid work, household work, or civic involvement.

39These dynamics, which influence careers and retirement need to be taken into account in economic, retirement, and aging policies, including so-called active-aging policies which are now frequent in many industrialized nations. First, active aging policies are not gender-neutral (Marchand, 2018b), nor are they without political objectives, as the male trajectories still dominate the views on work and retirement. As mentioned by Le Feuvre et al., (2014, p. 14), women are in the ‘blind angle’ of policies to increase labor market activity, and thus also of policies for active aging, which tend to neglect reproductive and care work assumed by women. As research has shown in recent years, care work, defined as practices and attitudes of caring for others (Brugère, 2010) is embedded in women’s trajectories, in employment, a career as well as in aging and retirement.

40From this perspective, the retirement transition must be understood, in social and economic policies as well as in future research, as occurring at the intersection of social contexts, individual life courses, and gender (Newton et al, 2018 : 3). In this respect, we find the feminist life course perspective very useful for understanding retirement pathways and considering the interdependence of work-related and private or family imperatives (Dentinger and Clarkberg, 2002). To capture the diversity and complexity of women’s retirement experiences, in the present and future generations, therefore, it is important, to not only concentrate on the dominant pathways of retirement but also to investigate fully the influences related to the intersection of social relations, such as those associated with age, sexual orientation, ethnic/racial background, etc. in the aging-retirement trajectory. These all impact women’s life courses and retirement dynamics.

Haut de page

Bibliographie

Arber, S., Davidson, K., & Ginn, J. (2003). Gender and Ageing : Changing Roles and Relationships. Maidenhead : Open University Press.

Attias-Donfut, C. (1995). Les solidarités entre les générations. Vieillesse, familles, État, . Paris : Nathan.

Bertaux, D. (2010). Le récit de vie. Paris : Armand Colin.

Brugère, F. (2010). L’éthique du care : entre sollicitude et soin, dispositions et pratiques. In L. Benaroyo, C. Mino, & F. Worms (Eds.), La philosophie du soin (pp. 69-86). Paris : Presses Universitaires de France.

Boboc, A., & Metzger, J.-L. (2013). Parcours et passages : les recompositions identitaires autour de la retraite. Retraite et Societe(3), 41-66.

Byles, J., Tavener, M., Robinson, I., Parkinson, L., Smith, P. W., Stevenson, D., Curryer, C. (2013). Transforming retirement : New definitions of life after work. Journal of Women & Aging, 25(1), 24-44.

Calasanti, T. (2010). Gender Relations and Applied Research on Aging. The Gerontologist, 50(6), 720.

Calasanti, T., Slevin, K. F., & King, N. (2006). Ageism and Feminism : From “Et Cetera” to Center. NWSA Journal, 18 (1), 13-30.

Calasanti, T. M. (1996). Gender and life satisfaction in retirement : An assessment of the male model. The Journals of Gerontology Series B : Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences, 51(1), S18-S29.

Canadian Longitudinal Study on Aging (CLSA) (2018). Report on Health and Aging in Canada. Findings from Baseline Data Collection 2010-2015, https://www.clsa-elcv.ca/doc/2639.

Cau-Bareille, D. (2011). Factors influencing early retirement in a female-dominated profession : Kindergarten teacher in France. Work, 40(Supplement 1), 15-30.

Charpentier, M., & Quéniart, A. (sous la dir., 2009). Vieilles et après ! Femmes, vieillissement et société. Montreal : Editions remue-ménage.

Charpentier, M., & Quéniart, A. (sous la dir. 2007). Pas de retraite pour l’engagement citoyen. Québec : Presse Universitaire du Québec.

Chase, S. E. (2005). Narrative Inquiry, Multiple Lenses, Approaches, Voices. In N. K. Denzin & Y. S. Y.S. Lincoln (Eds.), The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (pp. 651-681). Thousand Oaks : 3rd Edition, Sage Publications.

Creswell, J. W. (2012). Five Qualitative Approaches to Inquiry. In J. W. Creswell (Ed.), Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design : Choosing Among Five Approaches (pp. 69-110). Thousand Oaks : Sage Publication.

Dentinger, E., & Clarkberg, M. (2002). Informal caregiving and retirement timing among men and women : Gender and caregiving relationships in late midlife. Journal of Family Issues, 23(7), 857-879.

Farges, G. & Tremblay, D-G. (2016). Temps sociaux et fins de carrière des enseignants ; continuité et recomposition dans les inégalités hommes-femmes. Cahiers du Cirtes, 313-328.

Foster, L., & Walker, A. (2013). Gender and active aging in Europe. European Journal of Ageing, 10(1), 1-8.

Gambold, L. (2013). Retirement abroad as women’s aging strategy. Anthropology & Aging, 34(2), 184-198.

Gazso, A., & McDaniel, S. A. (2010). The risks of being a lone mother on income support in Canada and the USA. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 30(7/8), 368-386.

Gibson, H., Ashton-Shaeffer, C., Green, J., & Corbin, J. (2002). Leisure and retirement : Women’s stories. Loisir et Société/Society and Leisure, 25(2), 257-284.

Ginn, J., Street, D., & Arber, S. (2001). Women, work, and pensions : international issues and prospects : Open Univ Pr.

Guillemard, A. M. (2010). Les défis du vieillissement. Age, Emploi, Retraite, Perspectives internationales. Paris : Armand Colin.

Herd, P. (2009) Women, Public Pensions, and Poverty : What Can the United States Learn from Other Countries ?, Journal of Women, Politics & Policy, 30 :301–334.

Kojola, E., & Moen, P. (2016). No more lock-step retirement : Boomers’ shifting meanings of work and retirement. Journal of Aging Studies, 36, 59-70.

Le Feuvre, N., Kuehni, M., Rosende, M., & Schoeni, C. (2014). Le genre du’vieillissement actif’ : du principe de traitement équitable à la multiplication des injonctions contradictoires. Revue suisse de sociologie, 40(2), 307-324.

Lie, M., Baines, S., & Wheelock, J. (2009). Citizenship, Volunteering and Active Ageing. Social Policy & Administration, 43(7), 702-718. doi :10.1111/j.1467-9515.2009.00690.x

MacEwn, A. (2012). Working After Age 65 What is at Stake ? Retrieved from https://www.policyalternatives.ca/sites/default/files/uploads/publications/National %20Office/2012/04/WorkingAfter65.pdf

Madero-Cabib, I., & Fasang, A. E. (2016). Gendered work–family life courses and financial well-being in retirement. Advances in Life Course Research, 27, 43-60.

Mansour, S. & D.-G. Tremblay, (2019) "What strategy of human resource management to retain older workers ?", International Journal of Manpower, vol. 40 Issue : 1, pp. 135-153, https://doi.org/10.1108/IJM-07-2017-0170.

Mansour S. & D.-G. Tremblay (2018), Blended work and opportunities for knowledge sharing : Human resource management practices to increase innovative work behavior and life satisfaction of bridge workers. In International Journal of Knowledge-Based Development. https://www.inderscienceonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1504/IJKBD.2018.096419

Marchand, I. (2016). Récits du vieillir actif et de la citoyenneté au quotidien : l’expérience des femmes aînées au Québec. (Thèse présentée à la Faculté des arts et des sciences en vue de l’obtention du grade de docteur en service social ). Université de Montréal, Montreal. Retrieved from http://hdl.handle.net/1866/16013

Marchand, I., & Firbank, O. (2016). Récits du quotidien après la sortie de carrière : quelles expériences du vieillir « actif » et quels enjeux de citoyenneté ? Politique et sociétés, 35(2-3), 119-145.

Marchand, I. (2018a). Stories of contemporary aging : An analysis of “lived” citizenship in later life. Journal of gerontological social work, 61(5), 472-491.

Marchand, I. (2018b). Traduction du référentiel du vieillissement actif au Québec et enjeux d’activation du vieillir. Retraite et Société, 80(2), 97-119. doi :10.3917/rs1.080.0097

Martinez, I. L., Crooks, D., Kim, K. S., & Tanner, E. (2011). Invisible civic engagement among older adults : Valuing the contributions of informal volunteering. Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology, 26(1), 23-37.

Mauger, G. (2009). Générations et rapports de générations In A. Quéniart & R. Hurtubise (Eds.), L’intergénérationnel. Regards pluridisciplinaires (pp. 17-36). Rennes : Éditions de l’École nationale de Santé Publique.

Mc Daniel, A. S. (2007). Pensions, Privilege and Poverty : Another ‘Take’ on intergenerational Equity. In J. Véron, S. Pennec, & J. Légaré (Eds.), Ages, Generations and the Social Contract. The demographic Challenge Facing the Welfare State (pp. 301-322). The Netherlands : Springer.

Mc Donald, L. (2006). Gendered retirement : The welfare of women and the ‘new’ retirement In New Frontiers of Research on Retirement Government of Canada : Statistics Canada.

Miles, M. B., & Huberman, M. (2014). Qualitative Data Analysis. A Method Sourcebook. Sage Publications. Third Edition.

Munnell, A.H., and A. Chen (2021) “COVID-19 is not a retirement story”. Issue in Brief 21-4, Chestnut Hill, Mass. : Center for Retirement Research at Boston College, February 2021. http://hdl.handle.net/2345/bc-ir:109046.

Newton, N. J., Chauhan, P. K., Spirling, S. T., & Stewart, A. J. (2018). Level of choice in older women’s decisions to retire or continue working and associated well-being. Journal of Women & Aging, 1-18.

Observatoire des inégalités (2020). Baromètre des inégalités. Août 2020. P.11.

Paillé, P., & Muchielli, A. (2012). L’analyse qualitative en sciences humaines et sociales. Paris : Armand Colin.

Pavelek, L. (2013). Senior Volunteering in the Context of Active Ageing. World Applied Sciences Journal, 26(8), 1070-1078.

Pennec, S. (2009). Des générations de femmes aux multiples engagements : du quotidien à la longue durée. In M. Charpentier & A. Quéniart (Eds.), Vieilles et après ! Femmes, vieillissement et société (pp. 139-163). Montréal : Éditions du remue-ménage.

Pires, A. P. (1997). Échantillonnage et recherche qualitative : essai théorique et méthodologie. In J. Poupart, J.-P. Deslauriers, L. Groulx, A. Laperrière, R. Mayer, & A. P. Pires (Eds.), La recherche qualitative : enjeux épistémologiques et méthodologiques (pp. 113-169). Boucherville Gaëtan Morin.

Price, C. A. (2000). Women and retirement : Relinquishing professional identity. Journal of Aging Studies, 14(1), 81-101.

Price, C. A., & Nesteruk, O. (2010). Creating retirement paths : Examples from the lives of women. Journal of Women & Aging, 22(2), 136-149.

Quéniart, A., Chamberland, L., Coté, I. (2018). Vieillir et vivre seule : une exploration du quotidien de femmes de 65 ans et plus. Rapport de recherche présenté au RÉQEF, UQAM . https://reqef.uqam.ca/wp-content/uploads/sites/23/Monitoring-activite-scientifique-du-ReQEF-et-soutien-a-la-recherche-–-projets-en-cours.pdf

Qian, Y. & Fuller, S. (2020). COVID-19 and the Gender Employment Gap Among Parents of Young Children, Canadian Public Policy, 46(2), S89-S101. DOI : 10.3138/cpp. 2020-077

Renner, Cory (2020). Economy continues to add jobs, but many remain lost

Riekhoff, A.-J., & Järnefelt, N. (2018). Retirement trajectories and income redistribution through the pension system in Finland. Social Forces.

Sawyer, A. M., & James, S. (2018). Are baby boomer women redefining retirement ? Sociology Compass, 12(10), e12625.

Seaman, P. M. (2012). Time for my life now : Early Boomer women’s anticipation of volunteering in retirement. The Gerontologist, 52(2), 245-254.

Statistics Canada, (2020), Covid 19 and Job Displacement. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/45-28-0001/2020001/article/00030-eng.htm

Statistics Canada. (2018). Table 14-10-0060-01 Retirement age by class of worker, annual, https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action ?pid =1410006001.

Statistics Canada (2017). Age and sex, and type of dwelling data : Key results from the 2016 Census, Retrieved from https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/en/daily-quotidien/170503/dq170503a-eng.pdf ?st =ITOPBwtv.

Townson, M. (2009). Women’s Poverty and the Recession. CCPA Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives - Centre canadien de politiques alternatives.

Tremblay, Diane-Gabrielle (2019). Conciliation emploi-famille et temps sociaux (4eédition), Québec : Presses de l’Université du Québec.

Tremblay, Diane-Gabrielle (2014, dir.). Management de la retraite, de l’emploi et des temps sociaux. Québec : Presses de l’Université du Québec.

van Dyk, S., & Turner, M. E. (2010). Active, Productive and Healthy Aging in Germany and the United States. Some insights and critical remarks from a comparative perspective. AARP.

Vanier Institute for the family (2017). Infographic: Women, Caregiving and Work in Canada. Retrieved from https://vanierinstitute.ca/infographic-women-caregiving-work-canada/.

Haut de page

Notes

1 ‘The Old Age Pension was first introduced in Canada in 1927. Initially, pensions were only available to British subjects aged 70 and older with 20 years of residence in Canada; pensioners were paid up to $20 per month. The Old Age Security Act of 1951 introduced less stringent residence requirements and provided a universal pension of $40 per month to all Canadians over 70.’ http://www.bac-lac.gc.ca/eng/discover/genealogy/topics/employment/Pages/pensions.aspx

2 The interviews were conducted in 2014-2015, as part of a doctoral thesis (Marchand, 2016).

Haut de page

Pour citer cet article

Référence électronique

Isabelle Marchand et Diane-Gabrielle Tremblay, « Choosing to Retire? A Study of Women’s Patterns for Retiring or Continuing to Work  »Revue Interventions économiques [En ligne], 66 | 2021, mis en ligne le 11 juin 2021, consulté le 30 juillet 2021. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/interventionseconomiques/14065 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/interventionseconomiques.14065

Haut de page

Auteurs

Isabelle Marchand

Professeure, Université du Québec en Outaouais, isabelle.marchand@uqo.ca

Diane-Gabrielle Tremblay

Professeure, École des Sciences de l’Administration, Université TÉLUQ, diane-gabrielle.tremblay@teluq.ca

Articles du même auteur

Haut de page

Droits d’auteur

Licence Creative Commons
Les contenus de la revue Interventions économiques sont mis à disposition selon les termes de la Licence Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International.

Haut de page
  • Logo Université du Québec à Montréal (UQAM)
  • Logo Université TELUQ
  • Logo Centre d'études sur l'intégration et la mondialisation (CEIM)
  • Logo La revue est reconnue et financée par le programme de soutien aux revues savantes du Conseil de recherches en sciences humaines du Canada (CRSH)
  • Logo Centre de recherche sur les innovations sociales (CRISES)
  • Logo Alliance de recherche université communauté sur la « gestion des âges et des temps sociaux » (ARUC-GATS)
  • Logo Faculté de science politique et de droit | UQAM
  • Logo Association d’Économie Politique
  • DOAJ - Directory of Open Access Journals
  • OpenEdition Journals
Rechercher dans OpenEdition Search

Vous allez être redirigé vers OpenEdition Search