Skip to navigation – Site map

HomeIssues6:1Transnational Policy Transfer and...

Transnational Policy Transfer and the emerging use of Social Network Analysis: supplementing the researcher’s toolkit

Christopher Walker
p. 23-45

Abstract

Policy transfer is increasingly recognised as a process that occurs through networks of organisations and actors (Pal & Spence, 2020), but challenges persist in recognising and applying appropriate methodological tools to unpack and scrutinise this process (Stone, 2020). This paper addresses this challenge by examining the usefulness of Social Network Analysis (SNA) for policy transfer research, which is a methodology that focuses attention on networks as the central structure of social systems and foregrounds relationships between actors as the primary unit of analysis. The paper reviews the literature where SNA is applied to critique and analyse transnational policy transfer processes. The main finding demonstrates that SNA can serve as both the principal methodological framework for researching transnational policy transfer, as well as being a supplementary method. As a result, this paper argues that SNA uncovers overlooked aspects of transnational policy transfer research, making it an important component of the toolkit for policy transfer researchers.

Top of page

Full text

The author would like to acknowledge the research assistance provided by Patrick Lucas and Dr Andrew Bushnell, as well as the two anonymous reviewers who provided helpful suggestions that improved the paper.

Introduction

1Within the policy studies literature, there has been a longstanding interest in policy transfer and diffusion between jurisdictions and across regions (Baker & Walker, 2019; Clifford & Morphet, 2015; Hadjiisky et al., 2017; Marsh & Sharman, 2009; Hulicka et al., 2020). Analysis of policy transfer continues to be guided by the questions identified by Dolowitz and Marsh (1996) concerning the how and who influences the circulation, consideration, and adoption of policies between states and policymakers, and why these processes occur. In approaching these questions, researchers have tended to use qualitative data collection methods, like interviews and surveys of actors in the policy spaces under analysis. However, in recent years, there has emerged a small but growing body of literature that uses quantitative data, Social Network Analysis (SNA), to capture the interactions of policy actors and help explain the relationships and processes of policy transfer. The premise of this analysis is that policy transfer occurs within networks (Pal & Spence, 2020). Within this new literature, our overarching findings are that SNA can provide a useful complement to qualitative research methods, producing novel insights such as a visual map of the actor network and measures of the intensity of interaction that signal the likely sharing of information; and that SNA can also be the primary methodological framework. There are, of course, limitations to what SNA can reveal, centred in particular on the static nature of the method and the fact that it tends to document and reveal a network structure at one point in time, thus failing to capture the evolving nature of networks and how this connects with a dynamic policy transfer process over time (Chu et al., 2013). Nevertheless, this paper argues that SNA can reveal new insights for transnational policy transfer research and should therefore be considered part of the policy transfer researchers’ toolkit. The purpose of this paper is to discuss how SNA has been used and what has so far been revealed about the methodology’s strengths and limitations when applied to the analysis of transnational policy transfer. The paper commences with an explanation of SNA, noting how the methodology connects with elements of policy transfer theory and research. This is followed by an explanation of the scoping study method used to build our critique of published studies. Section 4 presents a critique of specific policy transfer studies and their use of SNA, before moving on to a discussion of policy practice and the value of SNA and identifying areas for further research. The conclusion brings the paper to a close.

Social Network Analysis

2Before embarking on a scoping review of transnational policy transfer research, this paper first unpacks some of the core assumptions, principles and ideas of policy transfer theory and identifies why SNA is relevant to research in this field. The discussion then moves to an introductory discussion of SNA, although it is important to note that for a detailed and technical understanding of SNA, its various analytical capabilities and its diverse applications across the social sciences, one should refer to the vast body of expert literature.

3At its core, policy transfer research is concerned with understanding the processes through which knowledge about policies, administrative systems, programmes and services in one location are used to develop similar policies and administrative arrangements in another. The study is concerned with both the transfer of ideas and administrative arrangements over time and across locations (Dolowitz & Marsh, 1996, p. 344). The analysis investigates the motivation for policy adoption along a continuum ranging from voluntary emulation and proactive learning from others to more coercive forms of mandatory adaptation. The study of transfer has a particular focus on the actors involved in policy activity. The thinking here is that understanding who is involved and how they interact will influence the outcome of what is ultimately transferred and implemented (Hadjiisky et al., 2017). The interest in identifying who the participants are and understanding their interactions makes policy transfer research a fertile field for the application of SNA. What particularly draws SNA into the analysis of policy transfer is the growing interest in the role of networks in the shaping and delivery of public policy. Public policy, as individuals, business and communities experience it, is not the result of independent activity but involves a network of actors engaged with states through bureaucracies, institutions, and other agents of influence. Identifying the actors that constitute networks and understanding how they connect to exchange and share knowledge is central to the study of policy transfer.

4SNA is a well-established and robust research method that can help map and theorise how the organisation of actors might influence and impact on policy transfer phenomena. Put simply, SNA is a methodology that describes social systems as networks constituted by actors (‘nodes’) and their interactions (‘ties’). Actors can be individuals (for example, individual policymakers), organisations (an agency, department or company), collectives (informal common interest groups) or other entities (for example animals, see Farine & Whitehead (2015)). Actors interact with each other, and these ties can be direct contacts, mutual participation in events, citations of work, or any other connection that might be specified by the analysis (Knoke & Yang, 2008; Krackhardt, 1987; Wellman, 1983). Defining the type of node and the type of tie has implications for the type of data collected. In policy transfer studies nodes (actors) may, for example, be public or private organisations or even individuals, and this then influences the type of relational information collected on ties. This may focus on social relations such as who individuals talk to, occurrences such as membership of groups and participation in events, or flows, such as the exchange of ideas and information. This relational information may need to be directly observed or may be accessible from data bases or records (Borgatti et al., 2018). The information presented in Table 2 details the types of nodes and ties defined in each study reviewed for this paper, providing an indication of the types of network relations considered important for critiquing each case of policy transfer.

5Using qualitative and/or quantitative measures, it is possible to identify the actors in a shared policy space and track the specific nature of their interactions. This information reveals how actors form a network around their common policy interests. For its proponents, this methodology enables the study of actors’ positions within the network and the analysis of the cognitive and social forces that structure these positions (Kilduff & Krackhardt, 2008; Scott, 2013; Victor et al., 2016; Hanneman & Riddle, 2005). SNA shifts the unit of analysis from the individual, organisation, or group to the relationships of interest between actors (Victor et al., 2016). This method thus helps address a concern identified by Stone et al (2020) who argue that policy transfer research generally focusses on single organisations and governments, with considerably less focus on the network as a feature of analysis. SNA assumptions hold that the nature of relational ties within networks exposes actors to different kinds of information and thereby facilitates knowledge transfer. Of particular relevance to the study of policy transfer, therefore, is how SNA can be used to ‘…describe the transmission of knowledge or useful information through interpersonal ties and social contacts with individuals’ (Bossche & Segers, 2013, p. 39).

Figure 1: The sociogram visualising the Australian and Swedish network of actors involved in the transfer of the Intelligent Access Program from Australia to Sweden.

Figure 1: The sociogram visualising the Australian and Swedish network of actors involved in the transfer of the Intelligent Access Program from Australia to Sweden.

This sociogram shows entire network and degree centrality measurement. Swedish actors are green coloured nodes, Australian actors are blue coloured nodes and international institutions and organisations are orange coloured nodes.

Source: Walker & Moulis (2022).

6A major attraction of the methodology is the capacity to produce visualisations of the networks under analysis. A variety of programs, such as UCINET and NetDraw, are used to visualise data and produce sociograms. These visual maps represent network structures and provide insights into relational factors that might be obscured or less apparent from the perspectives of the actors themselves. The sociogram in Figure 1 is taken from one of the policy transfer papers discussed in section 4 below, and the bow tie characteristic of the illustrated network reveals how a transnational policy transfer occurs through a limited number of key actors working to connect two distinct policy network systems. Supplementary quantitative analysis can also be undertaken to provide measures of network and actor characteristics, such as degree centrality, betweenness and other indicators of network density, actor interaction, and connections. Measures of network structures relevant to policy transfer are described in Table 1 below.

Table 1: SNA measures of network structures and application to policy transfer research.

Measure of network structure

Definition

Application to policy transfer research

Network density

Compares the number of ties in a network with the total number of possible ties between identified actors

Provides insights into the intensity of interactions between policy actors.

Degree centrality

Measures the number of ties that an actor has with other actors

Helps identify which policy actors are likely to be influential in a policy transfer network

Betweenness centrality

Measures how often a node falls along the shortest path between two other nodes.

Suggests a node has a role in brokering connections between policy actors to create a policy transfer network.

(Adapted from Knoke & Yan, 2008; Borgatti et al, 2018; Bojovic & Giupponi, 2020)

Source: the Author

7The above measures have high levels of analytical salience for policy transfer research, and a number of the studies examined in this paper use these measures to strengthen their critique of how transfer occurs. However, as noted earlier, these measures and visual maps tend to represent a captured moment, illustrating the relationships and the structure of a network at a key point in time. Policy and the actions around policy transfer shift and adjust over time, and while visual representations and measures of density illustrate network structure and the complex pathways of actor interaction, the analysis does not account for the speed and intensity of policy mobility and the flux that shapes transfer processes. Nor do the sociograms give us a sense (without qualitative supplementation) of how relations are held together and shift over time (Gulson et al., 2017). While acknowledging these temporal limitations, the use of sociograms to gain insight into network structure is helpful. In many policy domains, institutional actors remain relatively constant, and where policy transfer involves significant policy learning, network structures tend to display stability and evolve incrementally (Porto de Oliveira & Osorio Gonnet, 2023). In these instances, the dominance of key actors, the slow pace of policy change and the often embedded resilience of policy programmes suggest that the analytical value of network sociograms may persist for some time (Walker & Moulis, 2022, Morais de Sá e Silva & Porto de Oliveira, 2023 ). Similarly, numerous longitudinal studies that collect data at two or more points in time have been used to reveal how network structures change over defined time periods. While costly and time consuming, this method can provide some insight into the dynamic nature of transfer networks (Borgatti et al., 2018, p. 32).

Scoping study to investigate SNA in transnational policy transfer

8A scoping study (Arksey & O’Malley, 2005) was undertaken to identify the scope and nature of SNA in policy transfer research. The process involves rapidly mapping a research area and identifying the main sources of available evidence. The purpose of this scoping study is to summarise the application of SNA in policy transfer studies and to evaluate what insights SNA provides. The scoping study approach was selected because it provides a rigorous method to identify, map and synthesise relevant studies to assess the breadth and depth of available scholarly evidence. And while initially designed for broad research questions, the method has been subject to further development and refinement to strengthen its validity and usefulness (Levac et al., 2010; Daudt et al., 2013). There are five stages to a scoping study, including (1) identifying the research question, (2) identifying relevant studies, (3) study selection, (4) charting the data, (5) and collating, summarising, and reporting the results.

9For stage one, our research question is, “what is known from the existing literature that uses social network analysis to investigate international or transnational policy transfer?” For stage two, identifying relevant studies, we wanted studies published in academic journals in which SNA was applied to study international or transnational policy transfer or diffusion. This means that research articles suggesting SNA as a possible methodology are not included, nor is research outside the field of transnational policy transfer and diffusion. The search terms used were <“social network analysis” and (“international” or “transnational’’ or ‘’global’’) and (“policy transfer” or “policy diffusion”)”>. These search terms were used in Google Scholar and Web of Science, first in June 2022 and then again in May 2023. The abstracts of the papers identified in the searches were read to see if they fit our selection criteria. Published research papers that directly applied SNA to the study of international, transnational or global policy transfer were included. This identified five research papers that were suitable for the study. We then identified studies from the citations in these papers as well as the authors’ previous research, resulting in seven research papers. Step 4 of the study is presented in Table 2 and step 5, reporting the results, is presented in the remaining sections of this paper.

10A scoping study approach was selected for this work since this method is known to help identify the main body of knowledge that has bearing on practice in a specific area (Anderson et al., 2008) and is particularly useful when examining areas of knowledge and practice that are emerging. Although related, scoping studies differ from systematic reviews in a number of ways. The method is used to provide a preliminary assessment of the potential size and scope of the research experience (Grant et al. 2009) and provide a general reconnaissance of the strengths and weaknesses. While perceived as less comprehensive and thus potentially limiting the validity of findings, scoping studies are particularly useful in determining the value of subsequently undertaking a full systematic review (Levac et al.; 2010; Tricco et al., 2016) and this point is echoed in later discussion exploring areas for further research. The methodology helps to outline a targeted research agenda (Daudt et al., 2013) and this approach supports one objective of this paper, which is to stimulate critical discussion of the expanding methodological approaches applied in policy transfer research.

11Finally, it should be noted that while this paper focuses on transnational policy transfer, the term ‘policy diffusion’ was also used as a search term since in many works the terms diffusion and transfer are used interchangeably, reflecting their shared core research interest; the analysis of the movement of public policies (Baker & Walker, 2019). Diffusion studies tend to map the adoption of a particular policy across jurisdictions and are concerned with the broader global economic and technocratic forces that shape the choices of governments, and how this in turn affects the choices made by other governments (Braun & Gilardi, 2006). Policy transfer is similarly concerned with understanding the forces that motivate governments to adopt policies, but also how this process leads to policy change and adaptation. The interest here is in understanding the influence of context and how actors can work to reconstitute policy through the transfer process. Three of the seven studies reviewed present as works on diffusion, while the remainder more explicitly present as an analysis of transnational policy transfer.

Applying SNA for transnational policy transfer

12SNA has a rich history across various disciplines, including in sociology, political science (for example, formation and impact of political networks), psychology (structure and impact of social support networks), economics (diffusion of innovation across economies), anthropology (spread of cultural knowledge and practices within and across communities) and education (social networks’ impact on academic performance in high schools). There are also many applications of SNA from policy-adjacent fields with research relevant to policy transfer studies. For example, within the field of organisation and management studies, research has examined knowledge transfer, learning and information sharing within businesses, industries, and schools (Bossche & Segers, 2013; Harrison & Hu, 2012; Howlett et al., 2017; Sinnema et al., 2020), as well as how networks influence the impact of training on staff (Hatala, 2006; Hatala & Fleming, 2007). Significant work has examined political networks and there exist numerous studies analysing the network features of policy domains (Ingold et al., 2021; Knoke, 1996; Victor et al., 2016). This includes the analysis of networks of organisations, cities, and nations responding to climate change (Brown et al., 2016; Elliott & Zhang, 2019; Ingold, 2011; Kammerer & Namhata, 2018; Lee & van de Meene, 2012; Paterson et al., 2014); the effects of networks on tax policy (Cao, 2010), public health policy (Contandriopoulos et al., 2017; Gautier et al., 2020), disaster research (Bojovic & Giupponi, 2020) criminology (Baker & Faulkner, 1993; Bright et al., 2019; 2011; Morselli, 2009; Natarajan, 2006) and human rights (Lazer, 2012; Murdie, 2014). However, these analyses tend to remain limited to national policy domains (Knoke & Kostiuchenko, 2017), raising the question of how the methodology might be employed to the broader question of policy transfer and diffusion between jurisdictions and geographic regions.

13The studies summarised in Table 2 below represent a small body of literature that uses SNA to critique transnational policy transfer. The studies track the interactions of policy actors (nodes) (states, intergovernmental organisations, non-governmental organisations, public servants, and researchers) at conferences, forums, meetings, and through other connections such as citations (ties). The works draw on SNA as a method to provide greater insight into who is involved, how their interactions might be clustered and organised, and what these interactions and networks reveal about policy transfer. We review each study to identify how SNA was applied and its contribution to the analysis and key findings of the papers. The majority of the studies presented in Table 2 show how SNA provides a deeper insight into network structures and additional explanatory power about how policy transfer may have occurred. In the majority of the studies, the generation and analysis of sociograms is central to the analysis of networks and the transfer process.

Table 2: Uses, strengths and limitations of SNA in transnational policy transfer research

Study

Study focus and use of SNA

Research method

Key findings

Strengths

Limitations

Paterson, M., et. al. (2014).

Greenhouse gas emissions trading (ET) systems

Nodes: Individuals or organizations working on carbon markets

Ties: Common participation in ET venues

Intent: To test the hypothesis that polycentric policy diffusion proceeds from different starting points, rather than being a result of fragmentation.

Collection: Qualitative and quantitative (interviews and archival data)

Analysis: Qualitative and quantitative SNA

Network structure and quantitative measures inform the analysis of qualitative data to understand the political characteristics of carbon markets and policy transfer outcomes. The network diagrams illustrate fragmented and distributed diffusion with ET policy developing in relatively isolated clusters.

This is an example of a two-way tie (mutual participation).

The study makes use of the timespan over which the events linking actors took place: using multiple sociograms – the authors tell a story of discrete clusters becoming more linked over time.

Across this process, the key type of actor changed – the process began with epistemic communities and later key intermediary roles were played by nonstate actors.

Policy diffusion requires an understanding of how local factors interact with network influences. The authors find that network analysis by itself cannot explain how policy is adopted and implemented.

Kammerer, M., & Namhata, C. (2018).

Climate change mitigation

Policy. SNA measures supplement a larger auto correlation network analysis to model external factors that influence policy adoption by states.

Nodes: Countries

Ties: Mutual adoption of policy

Intent: To challenge the view that internal factors are most predictive of policy adoption decisions.

Collection: quantitative

Analysis: Quantitative Temporal network autocorrelation model

Countries more likely to adopt CC mitigation policies if they cooperate with other countries who adopt CC policies and are in similar structural positions.

The model supports the authors’ hypotheses about correlations between policy adoption and interactions between states and states’ relative positions in networks of states being predictive of their mutual adoption of a policy.

SNA measures of betweenness and centrality assist with the validation of findings from a range of other quantitative correlation analysis.

The SNA provides a post hoc view of states’ interactions that does not, by itself, reveal the content of, or motivation for actor interactions.

Spence, J. (2019),

People using Twitter to exchange information and ideas about Arctic development over a one-year period (2016 to 2017). To better understand Twitter as an arena for policy circulation.

SNA used to capture interactions on Twitter about a policy, based on key words.

Nodes: Twitter accounts

Ties: Mentions

Intent: To illustrate a network, identify key actors and understand network structure.

Collection: Quantitative

Analysis: Quantitative software based generation of sociograms

Barriers are being removed for different types of actors traditionally excluded from policy conversations.

Cautions that policy circulation and the sharing of information may be limited to self-contained twitter echo chambers. Identifying actors that connect across clusters are critical for the flow of ideas and information.

Work shows ‘the highly decentralised and loose nature of the Arctic development network, which has direct implications for how information flows within the network.’

The sociograms reveal a polycentric network with low dispersion and high density – pointing to the relative importance of nodes with high betweenness scores.

The challenges of transmitting information through a low-density network were illustrated by clusters of accounts polarised on the issue.

The study tests the thinness of the network concept: its results do not necessarily show that there is a difference between a common topic of conversation, shared interests and policy transfer. Network connection does not necessarily reveal quality, depth and nature of information exchanged.

Harris, J. (2019).

Nutrition policy in Zambia. SNA is used as part of an iterative study of the interactions between local and international actors in a country.

Nodes: Policy actors

Ties: Policy discussions (events)

Intent: To illustrate network structure and the divide between two recognised clusters of actors with divergent interests.

Collection: Qualitative (individual and group interviews)

Analysis: Qualitative and quantitative (developing social network maps)

There are two distinct advocacy coalitions built around different network of actors and each promoting competing policy priorities (food security and hunger vs stunting and nutrition quality). The activity of each network makes progress on nutrition policy challenging.

The sociogram confirms that the two competing policy clusters are linked by few intermediaries.

The author notes this divide is associated with observed policy inertia (highlighting the connection between low density and lack of information flow).

The study suggests that one cluster, over time, has come to have greater influence on policy than the other.

By comparing two policy options, this study illustrates the weight placed on the initial identification of the shared interests that determine the network – i.e., the network map assumes that the two policy options are, in fact, about the same thing, but this might be mistaken. The development of network data required high levels of engagement with participants and a willingness to contribute time and effort to the research process.

Pal, L. A., & Spence, J. (2020).

Anti-corruption networks centred in the OECD.

SNA is used to capture interactions between policy actors at specific events. The authors propose an event-focused network analysis (EFNA) method that uses SNA to study the relationships between specific actors (‘nodes’) and the number and strength of ‘ties’ (or ‘edges’) that exist between these actors, which constitute a network.

Nodes: Policy actors including states, NGOs, IGOs.

Ties: Cooperative interactions (events)

Intent: To illustrate how actors interacted on a policy issue.

Collection: Quantitative

Data analysis: Quantitative (descriptive SNA methods to analyse events)

‘Event-focused network analysis’ provides ‘more rigour and clarity’ in defining policy networks. SNA provides a deeper analysis revealing how policy transfer might occur through networks.

The sociogram reveals a centralised network with a core-periphery structure centred on a small number of key nodes with high betweenness scores.

This is an empirical view of a network, which allows us to test whether our inductive assumption of shared interests and predictions hold.

The second iteration of the study expands the dataset. Different results suggest the limitation that the network map is only as accurate as the data and the assumptions upon which it is compiled. The sociograms are static, moment in time representations of networks and little insight is provided into what the temporal aspects of the networks mean for policy transfer. For example, do actors continue to share and transfer policy information once the policy event has passed?

Gautier, L. et. al. (2021).

Performance-based-financing (PBF) Community of Practice’s in the health sector in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA).

SNA is used as one part of an investigation into the role of communities of practice, within polycentric governance models.

Nodes: Community of practice members

Ties: Citations of members by members

Intent: Investigate how the attributes, structure and strategies of Communities of Practice supported the diffusion of PBF.

Ties: Citations of members by members

Intent: Investigate how the attributes, structure and strategies of Communities of Practice supported the diffusion of PBF.

Collection: Qualitative (Interviews and thematic document analysis)

Analysis: Quantitative (semantic discourse analysis and SNA)

Despite good intentions to disrupt the established governance landscape, influential actors coming from high income countries (HICs) continued to drive the framing, and shaped health systems policy experimentation, emulation, and learning in African countries.

This is an example of a one-way tie (citation), and it reveals something that might otherwise be obscure.

Many citations were by the main convener of the community of practice (and therefore the main node), a finding which might be inconvenient for members.

The network was more hierarchical in practice than was perhaps expected by members.

The authors note that this study illustrates the difference between policy emulation and policy diffusion: participation in forums like this and citation of work does not necessarily imply the transfer, adoption and implementation of policy ideas into practice.

Walker, C & Moulis, A. (2022).

SNA is used to provide an empirical foundation for analysing a network also studied qualitatively.

Nodes: Policy actors

Ties: Cooperative interactions (events)

Intent: To illustrate how actors interacted on a policy question and to test actors’ understanding of the network.

Collection: Qualitative (interviews and workshops with key informants) and

Quantitative

Analysis: Qualitative and quantitative (developing social network maps).

SNA can highlight the connection of transnational policy transfer structures to key nodes in domestic networks.

Details an intensive methodological process that engages key actors in the generation of data and the validation of network depictions through SNA sociograms.

The sociogram revealed the influence of key intermediary nodes in the network of the policy originating country, the comparative density of the networks in the two countries (suggesting local adaptation), and the few links between the two countries. All this suggests a plausible story for how policy transfer occurred in the case study. The qualitative validation step in the method revealed that the sociogram’s finding of a polycentric network was surprising to some actors, demonstrating the utility of the method for complementing qualitative study. Policy actors valued the sociogram and network analysis claiming it expanded their understanding of the policy environment and helped them craft future action to help ensure the success of policy transfer and implementation.

The appearance of polycentricity in a map might suggest a flatter, less hierarchical network – but this might be an artefact of the illustration itself and requires qualitative testing of the nature of the ties between central nodes and others.

The method is resource intensive and requires significant time commitment and engagement from participants. This makes replication of the method challenging in many settings.

Source: the Author.

Uses and functions of SNA for transnational policy transfer research

14The summary analysis presented in Table 2 reveals the diversity of research topics to which SNA is applied to assist with the analysis and understanding of transnational policy transfer. The studies are both mixed method and purely quantitative in their approach, and the use of SNA sociograms plays a critical role in the interpretation of network features and the understanding of policy transfer. Pal & Spence (2020) is illustrative of an investigation into transnational policy transfer that applies SNA as a standalone methodology. They describe SNA as “a means to empirically examine specific policy networks” by using “graph theory” to “uncover patterns that might otherwise go undetected”. In their study, the authors create an “event-focused network analysis” – the policy transfer network is revealed by the interactions of actors at events, in this case, a data set of 388 OECD events in the policy area of anti-corruption and bribery. The resulting sociogram reveals a network with a “core-periphery” structure, with a core of connected states and intergovernmental organisations and identifiable central nodes with high betweenness scores, including the OECD itself. This structure offers some support for the claim that centralised networks are better at diffusing knowledge than polycentric structures, but it also reveals that even within this kind of network there can be identifiable subgroups with distinct interests – in this case, a subgroup of states and intergovernmental organisations spanning both the global North and South, and another subgroup of intergovernmental organisations and non-governmental organisations predominantly in the North.

15Importantly, the literature shows that SNA is not only a useful standalone methodology, but can also provide an empirical framework that complements qualitative thematic research into the motivations and characteristics of actor interactions within the network (Gautier et al., 2020; Paterson et al., 2014). On the one hand, SNA can establish that there are, in fact, certain interactions between actors, and this provides a basis for exploring their nature; and, on the other hand, SNA is a means of empirically testing qualitative findings about networks, for instance, actors’ own understandings of the network and their place in it. In contrast to the purely quantitative study of Pal and Spence (2020) the study by Gautier et al. (2019) shows the power of a mixed methods approach. In this study, the authors investigate the role of transnational communities of practice in policy diffusion through a case study of the Performance-Based Financing Community of Practice in Africa and its role in the diffusion of this accounting method. The study developed an SNA based on data from the discussion forum of the community of practice and thematic interviews to qualitatively test the captured picture of the network. The SNA alone provides insights that might otherwise be overlooked, such as, that the work of members of the community of practice is mainly cited by other members, with relatively little external reach, and that the organisation is hierarchical, with the few main nodes located primarily in higher-income countries. The qualitative study reveals that the empirical findings are at odds with the impressions of many actors in the network, and thus challenges the community’s perspective of its influence and where that influence derives. This in turn allows the authors to suggest a potentially important distinction between policy emulation, the citation of policies in other countries as influences on domestic policy, and policy transfer, which would be the successful implementation of another country’s policy through adaptation to local needs. This study clearly presents the utility of SNA within a mixed methods approach in unpacking a more refined understanding of transnational policy transfer processes. The studies by Paterson et al. (2014), Harris (2019) and Walker & Moulis (2022) also demonstrate similar mixed methodologies where SNA sociograms are used as tools to define network structures and then stimulate further qualitative analysis of actor interaction and processes of policy transfer.

Strengths and limitations of SNA for transnational policy transfer research

16An important field of information presented in Table 2 is the analytical strengths and limitations of SNA in policy transfer research. In the sampled literature, three important uses of SNA for transnational policy transfer are identifiable. First, SNA has been used to model the structure of networks. Pal & Spence (2020), with their focus on events, is a good example, as is Spence (2019), in which the author tracks mentions of Arctic policy on Twitter. In the latter study, the author uses Twitter accounts as nodes and their mentions of Arctic development (based on keywords) within a given time period. The analysis reveals a network that is international, features states, intergovernmental and non-governmental organisations, as well as private individuals, spans both the policy “demand side” (for example, the public service) and the policy “supply side” (media, researchers and so on), but is low density, dispersed, and clustered, all factors suggesting (and reinforcing) low information flows. Walker & Moulis (2022) identify a classic bow tie network that helps to confirm the often narrow cluster of actors involved in transnational policy transfer. Here the analysis reveals the tenuous connections that bridge complex and active domestic policy networks in transfer processes. The plotting and visualisation of networks often deepens the analysis and understanding of the role key nodes (ambassadors and champions of transfer) play in the transnational context.

17Secondly, SNA has been used to test hypotheses about the functioning of networks. Gautier et al. (2019) is an example, with the study motivated by a desire to better understand a particular kind of policy actor - communities of practice. Similarly, Paterson et al. (2014) is a study designed to test the authors’ hypothesis that polycentric policy diffusion proceeds from different starting points, rather than being the result of fragmentation from a common beginning. The study finds that the idea of an emissions trading scheme arose simultaneously in the US and Europe, with only “very tenuous” links between the two before the implementation of the policy.

18Thirdly, SNA has been used to challenge a common view of how networks operate. Kammerar & Namhata (2018) confront the view that internal factors are most predictive of policy adoption decisions, hypothesising instead that countries’ ties to other countries (i.e., their situation within a network of countries) are more predictive. Their test case is the adoption of climate change policy. The authors develop a model for policy adoption, with network position being one of the inputs. This input is in turn determined by an analysis of actors’ participation in a set of climate change forums between 1995 and 2015. The authors’ model confirms their hypothesis, suggesting that SNA is a tractable way of capturing the influence of network effects on policy adoption, correcting for an overweighting of internal (i.e., domestic) factors.

19The studies reviewed for this paper highlight the strength of SNA in teasing out and supplementing findings on how transnational policy transfer works. In particular, the tool has been successful in demonstrating the structure of networks, giving researchers insights into how information spreads (Harris, 2019) or does not spread (Spence, 2019).

20From this scoping review two studies are particularly noteworthy. Walker & Moulis (2022) successfully employ mixed-methods research to illustrate the key actors in a specific policy transfer case: the transfer of the Intelligent Access Programme – a trucking regulation and technology platform – from Australia to Sweden. They developed sociograms of the domestic network in Australia, which comprised of key actors in the implementation of the policy, and the international links between Australian and Swedish actors (Figure 1 above). These links were established based on interviews with participants in the process and then tested in a workshop with interviewees. The process of validation provided a fuller understanding of both the actors involved and the qualities of their interactions. The qualitative process supplemented a known weakness of SNA concerning the actual nature of relations between actors in the network and minimised analytical reliance on assumptions about relations. Updated datasets and sociograms were presented to transport agency officials in both Australia and Europe. The network density measure revealed a polycentric structure clustered around identifiable key nodes, while the degree centrality measure indicated that industry regulators were influential in linking different policy actors, but that there were more central nodes than interviewees had anticipated – the polycentric structure was flatter and less hierarchical than had been assumed. Among these central intermediaries were the telematics companies that supply the technology required for the regulatory system, which, it is suggested, may be indicative of the companies’ capacity to understand both the policy and how its implementation affects policy users. In this way, the iterative, mixed methods approach increases the legibility of the policy space, which is of interest to the specific actors in that space as well as to students of how policy ideas move within such spaces.

Figure 2.

Figure 2.

Source: Paterson et. al., 2013. Sociogram shows ‘Early venues and the Kyoto-Marrakesh process’.

21Paterson et al. (2014) make a valuable contribution by creatively using repeated iterations of SNA to help build a temporal understanding of a network. In this study, the authors track the interactions of actors in the development and implementation of carbon emissions trading schemes in the United States and Europe and find that the policy emerged simultaneously but largely separately in the two places. What is innovative in this study is that the authors produce a series of sociograms based on interactions at key venues at different times, which together produce a picture of how the network in this policy space has grown and changed over time. So, for example, a map of the main actors at two early “venues” for policy coordination – the Annex I Expert Working Group before the 1997 Kyoto conference and the 2001 Marrakesh conference – shows few links between the epistemic communities working on the policy in the United States and Europe. A second sociogram, which tracks who participated in both Marrakesh and later venues, reiterates that there were few nodes (actors) with high betweenness scores, and that the policy was developed by separate groups. Because the different venues took place at different times, the sociogram can be read temporally: there are few links between the earliest venues and later venues where the policy is operationalised. While still constrained to static measures at points in time, the study demonstrates that SNA can also be used to illustrate how network structure changes over a defined time period and what this means for the information transmitted by actors and events.

22While SNA has therefore proved useful in providing a better picture of how policy ideas travel in space and time, it is also subject to analytical limitations and is a costly and time-consuming method. Methodologically, networks are post hoc constructions of policy actors’ interactions. The soundness of this method depends on the accuracy of the dataset of these interactions, the appropriateness of the counting measure of ties (i.e., what kind of interactions), the identification of the actors, and the construction of the policy issue. All this is established at the outset of the study and can be tested as the study progresses (as in Pal & Spence, 2020, and Walker & Moulis, 2022 in which the dataset was expanded based on interviews). Nonetheless, networks and the sociograms that illustrate them are only as accurate as these underlying assumptions. The network concept is thin, measuring only the number of interactions, and often, particularly with regard to flows, it assumes the exchange of information and transfer of knowledge with each interaction. But in reality, it is not known what knowledge is transferred from actor A to actor B. The higher the level of assumption around data exchange and ties, the greater the chance of being wrong (Borgatti et al., 2018) The challenge of measuring flows (the exchange of information and transfer of knowledge) is evident when Spence (2019) questions what might indicate the difference between parties sharing a common topic of conversation and those genuinely sharing information with one another with a view to understand the impact on Arctic development policy. Similarly, SNA has a chicken and egg problem (Kammerar & Namhata, 2018): the causal question of why policy actors interact in the first place is not answered by this method. This can be important when actors have many reasons to interact, and so their position in the network may be structured by factors external to the policy in question. In Kammerar & Namhata (2018), the authors note that countries that adopt climate change policies are structurally similar in various ways and are already networked. It is important, then, to note that the information gleaned from SNA is only a model of actors’ interactions, at a particular point in time, and never the whole story.

23Interpretive reasoning of network models and inferring understandings of what specific actors could, should, or might do is also problematic. Sociograms may have a flattening effect, in which relations that are qualitatively hierarchical appear similar or equivalent based on quantitative measures. In Walker & Moulis (2022), centrality and betweenness measures identified a range of well-connected actors, but this alone was not enough to displace the actors’ own impressions of the greater influence of certain actors (namely, the industry regulators), and this required further qualitative testing. In these conversations, aspects of power, the control and allocation of resources, and other aspects of influence that help to explain why actor relations occur in particular ways become more apparent. Another flattening effect is that the initial construction of the policy space may elide qualitative differences between policy actors, and even inaccurately portray actors as engaged in the same policy discussion when in reality they may be talking past one another. Harris (2019) shows the contest in Zambian nutrition policy, but the broader context suggests that policy actors understand nutrition differently, and this may affect their connection with, and influence over, other actors in this network. In policy transfer specifically, both Gautier et al. (2019) and Paterson et al. (2014) note that while links between jurisdictions may be quantitatively established, this does not in itself indicate successful policy transfer or diffusion – it speaks only to potential policy emulation, or an interest in learning about policy from elsewhere, but not whether and how policy ideas have been transferred and implemented in local contexts.

Prospects for SNA in the research and practice of policy transfer

24A key finding of this scoping study is that the methodological and analytical advantages afforded by SNA are only beginning to be exploited in the field of policy transfer studies. This work has mapped the general range of applications, and in the near future it would be useful to undertake a systematic review to measure the consolidation of scholarly knowledge of the method and its application in the discipline. A comprehensive analysis of the grey literature would also be effective in scoping the application of SNA by practitioners as a tool to guide strategic action and intervention in transnational networks. Such work would help reveal how theoretical and methodological developments in transfer studies are impacting on the practice of policy transfer. The studies reviewed in this paper show that by identifying key actors (nodes), SNA can provide guidance on how policymakers and others can influence policy development and implementation within and across jurisdictions. For many policy actors and transnational organisations, strengthening the success of policy transfer processes is of particular interest. However, as noted earlier, the known temporal constraints of the method suggest that forms of intervention need to be carefully calibrated to account for the post hoc nature of network analysis.

25Central to the analysis and theorising of policy transfer processes is the recognition that SNA is not a theory of the policy process. Anyone seeking to examine such processes will need to connect the findings SNA elicits with theory on policy transfer and diffusion. Some of the papers reviewed do this more clearly than others. It is particularly evident in studies that show how SNA helps to demonstrate the polycentric nature of policy transfer and diffusion, whereby ideas and policies can develop separately at micro scales and coalesce in international arenas (Paterson et al., 2014; Walker & Moulis, 2022). Others use SNA to contribute to domain specific policy transfer theory, such as understanding nutrition policy processes (Harris, 2019) or international climate protection policies (Kammerer & Namhata, 2018). Although these articles have less to say about policy transfer as a phenomenon, they do provide guidance on how policy networks structure the relations and actions of a specific policy subsystem within the context of broader national and transnational policy transfer processes.

26One missing analytical framework and potential area for further research concerns what SNA might reveal about the role of power. While the bulk of policy transfer studies examine voluntary cases and processes of learning and emulation, there is evidence that states often face stronger coercive pressures to adopt policies designed from elsewhere. For example, austerity and compliance conditions that may be attached to support from international bodies such as the World Bank and IMF, and even the adoption of specified standards and production processes that are conditional for market access and associated trade agreements (Hadjiisky et al., 2017). Networks constitute the structural empowerment of actors, and the positioning of actors influences their capacity to determine where resources flow and impact on policy outcomes (McGee & Jones, 2019). Powerful nodes within a network may act to perpetuate certain norms and ideologies that institutionalise barriers to network adaptation and restrict who and how actors participate (Gaventa, 2021). Power shapes the openness of networks, and some policy transfer spaces may be highly transparent and visible, while others may be security sensitive and partially hidden or even invisible. The collection of data on nodes and ties is highly dependent on the transparency of networks, and while this is a common concern across all fields of SNA research, investigating this phenomenon within policy transfer studies would provide insight into what shapes the motivation and pace at which ideas and administrative systems move, or fail in their attempt to move, from one jurisdiction to another.

27SNA works best when it connects to broader theory on policy transfer, and it can help advance theory development and knowledge of policy transfer in several ways. First, by identifying knowledge gaps. SNA helps to map connections and interactions between actors, revealing knowledge gaps within a group or community. By analysing network structures, researchers can identify individuals or subgroups who may have limited access to information or expertise. Second, by understanding information flow. SNA helps to track the flow of information and knowledge within a network, clusters of networks and poly centric networks. By analysing the broader structure of networks (individual, cluster or polycentric), patterns of information exchange and the extent to which networks are connected or separate helps researchers identify influential nodes and hubs and the role they play in policy transfer (over and above what qualitative studies might reveal) within and across networks. This is important for understanding how information might flow and what action might be needed to support the effective dissemination of knowledge (Walker & Moulis, 2022). This information helps supplement other methods that seek to learn more on the quality, quantity and influence of knowledge transferred.

28Finally, while SNA has not been explicitly used in these studies to enhance policy learning, there is scope for sociograms to support this in three ways. First, facilitating collaboration. SNA provides insights into the collaborative dynamics among policy transfer actors, many of whom would be involved in analysing and learning how a policy in one location might be effectively adopted into another. SNA can more starkly identify actors who serve as key knowledge brokers or facilitators across networks. This is particularly useful where these knowledge brokers may be unknown, or where the full extent of their connections across a network is poorly understood. This was an unexpected finding of Walker & Moulis (2022). Second, enhancing learning communities. SNA assists in understanding the structure and formation of learning communities that are likely to emerge as policy transfer and adoption progresses. By examining social connections, researchers can identify the formation of clusters or subgroups, which can inform the design of interventions or learning activities to foster stronger communities of practice that support policy transfer and implementation (Gautier et al., 2021). The success of policy transfer is dependent on implementation and delivery, so here we might see SNA insights guide action that helps embed new policy approaches into existing institutions and policy delivery systems. Third, a further use may be the reflexive piece for practitioners. Sociograms and the visual depiction of key nodes and network complexity can be used as a learning tool to stimulate conversations and thinking by policy actors within these networks, or by those who aim to pierce into and influence them (a valuable insight that SNA provides in the field of criminology and the study of crime networks). Finally, it is important to note the limitations of SNA for the study of policy transfer that arose from this scoping review. SNA is only as useful for policy transfer research as the knowledge assumptions in general, and assumptions about policy transfer and diffusion specifically, on which the analysis is based. Therefore, researchers must be clear on the intentions of using SNA, with a firm grounding of what it can, and cannot, achieve for investigating policy transfer. In addition, the development of network data requires high levels of engagement with participants and a willingness on their part to invest time and effort in the research process. SNA can be an expensive and often time-consuming exercise, particularly when combined with qualitative methods that engage participants in the recall and articulation of actors (nodes) and the manner of interaction (ties) amongst them. And while some policy scholars have recently noted developments in SNA methodology that strengthen its technical capacity to model temporal variation in networks (McGee & Jones, 2019), implementing longitudinal studies to measure changes in network structure over specified time periods adds further cost and complexity to the research process.

Conclusion

29Social network analysis has a lot to offer transnational policy transfer research, and there remain areas of investigation that will generate valuable insights. Quantitative measures and the visual representation of actor networks provide new and powerful insights into how information and ideas can flow between parties and across boundaries. In particular, SNA provides a complementary understanding into the ideas and findings revealed from qualitative analysis. The method can model the structure of networks, test hypotheses on how networks function, and challenge the orthodox view of how networks operate. It adds a new dimension of validity to research findings and broadens the analysis and critique of the factors that shape policy transfer. The use of the method is somewhat limited within the policy transfer field, and its technical characteristics (the use of software applications and quantitative measures) require the application of a new base of research and analytical skills. This may explain the limited use of the method in policy transfer studies, as this field has traditionally been dominated by qualitative methods and approaches to research. There are limitations and constraints to the use of the methods, in particular its potentially costly and time-consuming nature and the generally static nature of its examination of structures of who is connected to whom, rather than focusing on processes and the quality of interactions. Nevertheless, this scoping study has highlighted the valuable addition that SNA can provide to the research toolkit of policy transfer scholars. In doing so, it hopefully stimulates further development and diversification of its use in this exciting field of public policy research.

Top of page

Bibliography

Arksey, H., & O’Malley (2005). Scoping Studies: Towards a Methodological Framework. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 8(1), 19-32.

Baker, T., & Walker, C. (Eds.). (2019). Public Policy Circulation. Arenas, Agents and Actions. Edward Elgar.

Baker, W. E., & Faulkner, R. R. (1993). The Social Organization of Conspiracy: Illegal Networks in the Heavy Electrical Equipment Industry. American Sociological Review, 58(6), 837-860.

Bojovic, D., & Giupponi, C. (2020). Understanding the dissemination and adoption of innovations through social network analysis: geospatial solutions for disaster management in Nepal and Kenya. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 63(5), 818-841.

Borgatti, S. P., Everett, M. G., & Johnson, J. C. (2018). Analyzing Social Networks (2nd ed.). SAGE Publications.

Bossche, P. V. d., & Segers, M. (2013). Transfer of training: Adding insight through social network analysis. Educational Research Review, 8, 37-47.

Braun, D., & Gilardi, F. (2006), Taking ‘Galton’s problem’ seriously: towards a theory of policy diffusion. Journal of Theoretical Politics, 18, 298-332.

Bright, D., Koskinen, J., & Malm, A. (2019). Illicit Network Dynamics: The Formation and Evolution of a Drug Trafficking Network. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 35(2), 237-258.

Bright, D. A., Hughes, C. E., & Chalmers, J. (2011). Illuminating dark networks: a social network analysis of an Australian drug trafficking syndicate. Crime, law, and social change, 57(2), 151-176.

Brown, M. E., Ihli, M., Hendrick, O., Delgado-Arias, S., Escobar, V. M., & Griffith, P. (2016). Social network and content analysis of the North American Carbon Program as a scientific community of practice. Social Networks, 44, 226-237.

Cao, X. (2010). Networks as Channels of Policy Diffusion: Explaining Worldwide Changes in Capital Taxation, 1998–2006. International Studies Quarterly, 54(3), 823-854.

Chu, K-H., Wipfli, H., & Valente, T., W. (2013). Using visualizations to explore network dynamics. Journal of Social Structure, 14(4), 1-23.

Clifford, B., & Morphet, J. (2015). A policy on the move? Spatial planning and State Actors in the post-devolutionary UK and Ireland. The Geographical Journal, 181(1), 16-25.

Contandriopoulos, D., Benoit, F., Bryant-Lukosius, D., Carrier, A., Carter, N., Deber, R., Duhoux, A., Greenhalgh, T., Larouche, C., Bernard-Simon, L., Levy, A., Martin-Misener, R., Maximova, K., McGrail, K., Nykiforuk, C., & Roos, N. (2017). Structural analysis of health-relevant policy-making information exchange networks in Canada. Implementation Science, 12.

Daudt, H. M., van Mossel, C., & Scott, S. J. (2013). Enhancing the scoping study methodology: a large, inter-professional team’s experience with Arksey and O’Malley’s framework. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 13(48).

Dobbin, F., Simmons, B., & Garrett, G. (2007). The Global Diffusion of Public Policies: Social Construction, Coercion, Competition, or Learning? Annual Review of Sociology, 33(1), 449-472.

Dolowitz, D. P., & Marsh, D. (1996). Who Learns What from Whom: a Review of the Policy Transfer Literature. Political Studies, 44(2), 343-357.

Dolowitz, D., & Marsh D. (2012). The Future of Policy Transfer Research. Political Studies Review, 10(3), 339-345.

Drezner, D. W. (2004). Globalization, coercion, and competition: the different pathways to policy convergence. 2004 International Studies Association annual meeting, Montreal.

Elliott, C., & Zhang, L.-Y. (2019). Diffusion and innovation for transition: transnational governance in China's green bond market development. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 21(4), 391-406.

Evans, M. (2019). International Policy Transfer: Between the Global and Sovereign and between the Global and Local. In D. Stone & K. Moloney (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Global Policy and Transnational Administration (pp. 94-110). Oxford University Press.

Evans, M., & Davies J. (1999). Understanding Policy Transfer: A Multi-Level, Multi-Disciplinary Perspective. Public Administration, 77(2), 361-385.

Garrett, K. N., & Jansa, J. M. (2015). Interest Group Influence in Policy Diffusion Networks. State Politics & Policy Quarterly, 15(3), 387-417.

Gautier, L. De Allegri, M., & Ridde, V. (2021). Transnational Networks' Contribution to Health Policy Diffusion: A Mixed Method Study of the Performance Based Financing Community of Practice in Africa. International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 10(6), 310-323.

Gaventa, J. (2021) Linking the prepositions: using power analysis to inform strategies for social action. Journal of Political Power, 14(1), 109-130.

Gulson, K., Lewis, S., Lingard, B., Lubienski, C., Takayama, K., & Webb, P. (2017). Policy mobilities and methodology : a proposition for inventive methods in education policy studies. Critical Studies in Education, 58(2), 224-241.

Grant ,M., & Booth, A. (2009). A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. Health Information and Libraries Journal, 26, 91-108.

Hadjiisky, M., Pal, L. A., & Walker, C. (Eds.). (2017). Public Policy Transfer: Micro-Dynamics and Macro-Effects. Edward Elgar.

Hanneman, R. A., & Riddle, M. (2005). Introduction to social network methods. University of California, Riverside.

Harris, J. (2019). Advocacy coalitions and the transfer of nutrition policy to Zambia. Health Policy and Planning, 34(3), 207-215.

Harrison, A., & Hu, Q. (2012). Knowledge Transfer within Organizations: A Social Network Perspective. 45th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS), 3766-3775.

Hatala, J. P. (2006). Social Network Analysis in Human Resource Development: A New Methodology. Human Resource Development Review, 5(1), 45-71.

Hatala, J. P., & Fleming, P. R. (2007). Making Transfer Climate Visible: Utilizing Social Network Analysis to Facilitate the Transfer of Training. Human Resource Development Review, 6(1), 33-63.

Howlett, M., Mukherjee, I., & Koppenjan, J. (2017). Policy learning and policy networks in theory and practice: the role of policy brokers in the Indonesian biodiesel policy network. Policy and Society, 36(2), 233-250.

Hulicka, A., Lucas, P., & Carson, L. (2021). Policy Transfer across Governance Systems: An Adapted Approach. Policy Studies, October.

Ingold, K. (2011). Network Structures within Policy Processes: Coalitions, Power, and Brokerage in Swiss Climate Policy. Policy Studies Journal, 39(3), 435-459.

Ingold, K., Fischer, M., & Christopoulos, D. (2021). The roles actors play in policy networks: Central positions in strongly institutionalized fields. Network Science, 9(2), 213-235.

Kammerer, M., & Namhata, C. (2018). What drives the adoption of climate change mitigation policy? A dynamic network approach to policy diffusion. Policy Sciences, 51(4), 477-513.

Kilduff, M., & Krackhardt, D. (2008). Interpersonal Networks in Organizations: Cognition, Personality, Dynamics, and Culture. Cambridge University Press.

Knoke, D. (1996). Comparing policy networks : labor politics in the U.S., Germany, and Japan. Cambridge University Press.

Knoke, D., & Kostiuchenko, T. (2017). Power structures of policy networks. In J. N. Victor, A. H. Montgomery & M. lubell (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Political Networks (pp. 1-24). Oxford University Press.

Knoke, D., & Yang, S. (2008). Social Network Analysis. SAGE Publications.

Krackhardt, D. (1987). Cognitive Social Structures. Social Networks, 9(2), 109-134.

Lazer, D. (2012). Networks and Politics: The Case of Human Rights. In R. Goodman, D. Jinks, & A. K. Woods (Eds.), Understanding Social Action, Promoting Human Rights (pp. 244). Oxford University Press.

Lee, T., & van de Meene, S. (2012). Who teaches and who learns? Policy learning through the C40 cities climate network. Policy Sciences, 45(3), 199-220.

Legrand, T. (2021). The Architecture of Policy Transfer. Ideas, Institutions and Networks in Transnational Policymaking. Palgrave Macmillan.

Levac, D., Colquhoun, H., & O'Brien, K. K. (2010). Scoping studies: advancing the methodology. Implementation Science, 5(69).

Marsh, D., & Sharman, J. C. (2009). Policy diffusion and policy transfer. Policy Studies, 30(3), 269-288.

Morais de Sá e Silva, M., & Porto de Oliveira, O. (2023). Incorporating Time into Policy Transfer Studies: A Comparative Analysis of the Transnational Policy Process of Conditional Cash Transfers and Participatory Budgeting. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 25(4), 418-438.

Morselli, C. (2009). Inside Criminal Networks. Springer New York.

Murdie, A. (2014). The Ties that Bind: A Network Analysis of Human Rights International Nongovernmental Organizations. British Journal of Political Science, 44(1), 1-27.

Natarajan, M. (2006). Understanding the Structure of a Large Heroin Distribution Network: A Quantitative Analysis of Qualitative Data. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 22(2), 171-192.

Padgett, S. (2003). Between synthesis and emulation: EU policy transfer in the power sector. Journal of European Public Policy, 10(2), 227-245.

Pal, L. A., & Spence, J. (2020). Event-focused network analysis: a case study of anti-corruption networks. Policy and Society, 39(1), 1-22.

Paterson, M., Hoffmann, M., Betsill, M., & Bernstein, S. (2014). The Micro Foundations of Policy Diffusion Toward Complex Global Governance: An Analysis of the Transnational Carbon Emission Trading Network. Comparative Political Studies, 47(3), 420-449.

Peters, B. G. (2015). Advanced Introduction to Public Policy. Edward Elgar.

Porto de Oliviera, O. (2017). International Policy Diffusion and Participatory Budgeting: Ambassadors of Participation, International Institutions and Transnational Networks. Palgrave Macmillan.

Porto de Oliveira, O., & Osorio Gonnet, C. (2023) Comparative Transfer Analysis: Policy Instruments, Space and Time, Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 25(4), 367-384.

Rose, R. (1993). Lesson-Drawing in Public Policy: A Guide to Learning Across Time and Space. Chatham House.

Scott, J. (2013). Social network analysis (3rd ed.). SAGE.

Shearer, J. C., Lavis, J., Abelson, J., Walt, G., & Dion, M. (2018). Evidence-Informed Policymaking and Policy Innovation in a Low-Income Country: Does Policy Network Structure Matter? Evidence & Policy: A Journal of Research, Debate and Practice, 14(3), 381-401.

Sinnema, C., Daly, A. J., Liou, Y.-H., & Rodway, J. (2020). Exploring the communities of learning policy in New Zealand using social network analysis: A case study of leadership, expertise, and networks. International Journal of Educational Research, 99, 101492.

Spence, J. (2019). Policy circulation through the Twitterverse: the case of Arctic development policy. In T. Baker & C. Walker (Eds.), Public Policy Circulation. Arenas, agents and actions (pp. 26-41). Edward Elgar.

Stone, D. (2000). Non-Governmental Policy Transfer: The Strategies of Independent Policy Institutes. Governance, 13(1), 45-62.

Stone, D. (2001). Learning Lessons, Policy Transfer and the International Diffusion of Policy Ideas [CSGR Working Paper].
http://www.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/CSGR/wpapers/wp6901.pdf

Stone, D. (2004). Transfer agents and global networks in the ‘transnationalization’ of policy. Journal of European Public Policy, 11(3), 545-566.

Stone, D. (2008). Global Public Policy, Transnational Policy Communities, and Their Networks. Policy Studies Journal, 36(1), 19-38.

Stone, D., Porto de Oliveira, O., & Pal, L. (2020). Transnational Policy Transfer: The Circulation of Ideas, Power and Development Models’. Policy and Society, 39(1), 1-18.

Tricco, A.C., Lillie, E., & Zarin, W. (2016). A scoping review on the conduct and reporting of scoping reviews. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 16(15).

van der Heijden, M. (2019). Agencies without borders: Explaining partner selection in the formation of transnational agreements between regulators. Regulation & Governance, 15, 725-744.

Victor, J. N., Montgomery, A. H., & Lubell, M. (Eds.) (2016). The Oxford handbook of political networks. Oxford University Press.

Walker, C., & Moulis A. (2022). Understanding Policy Transfer through Social Network Analysis: Expanding Methodologies with an Intensive Case Study Approach. Policy Sciences, 55(4), 693-713.

Wellman, B. (1983). Network Analysis: Some Basic Principles. Sociological Theory, 1, 155-200.

Top of page

List of illustrations

Title Figure 1: The sociogram visualising the Australian and Swedish network of actors involved in the transfer of the Intelligent Access Program from Australia to Sweden.
Caption This sociogram shows entire network and degree centrality measurement. Swedish actors are green coloured nodes, Australian actors are blue coloured nodes and international institutions and organisations are orange coloured nodes.
Credits Source: Walker & Moulis (2022).
URL https://journals.openedition.org/irpp/docannexe/image/4104/img-1.png
File image/png, 80k
Title Figure 2.
Credits Source: Paterson et. al., 2013. Sociogram shows ‘Early venues and the Kyoto-Marrakesh process’.
URL https://journals.openedition.org/irpp/docannexe/image/4104/img-2.png
File image/png, 453k
Top of page

References

Bibliographical reference

Christopher Walker, “Transnational Policy Transfer and the emerging use of Social Network Analysis: supplementing the researcher’s toolkit”, International Review of Public Policy, 6:1 | 2024, 23-45.

Electronic reference

Christopher Walker, “Transnational Policy Transfer and the emerging use of Social Network Analysis: supplementing the researcher’s toolkit”, International Review of Public Policy [Online], 6:1 | 2024, Online since 01 April 2024, connection on 10 November 2026. URL: https://journals.openedition.org/irpp/4104; DOI: https://doi.org/10.4000/11whp

Top of page

About the author

Christopher Walker

Australia and New Zealand School of Government & School of Government and International Relations, Griffith Business School, Griffith University, Australia

Top of page

Copyright

CC-BY-4.0

The text only may be used under licence CC BY 4.0. All other elements (illustrations, imported files) may be subject to specific use terms.

Top of page
Search OpenEdition Search

You will be redirected to OpenEdition Search