Cunningham David L. (dir.), The Wind and the Reckoning, United States, Lynmar Entertainment, 2022. Feature film, 94 minutes, color
Cunningham David L. (dir.), The Wind and the Reckoning, United States, Lynmar Entertainment, 2022. Feature film, 94 minutes, color
Texte intégral
1David L. Cunningham, an accomplished American filmmaker, with many documentaries and feature films to his credit, presented The Wind and the Reckoning for its world premiere at the 2022 Boston Film Festival, where it was honored with the best film award. It also won awards at the San Diego International Film Festival, but had a limited release in US theaters.
2It tells a vivid, albeit heartbreaking, story about events that took place soon after a couple of businessmen, backed by the American military, staged a coup d’état in 1893 against Queen Lili’uokalani, who was the 8th and last monarch in the Hawaiian kingdom. In an effort to assert its powers and protect the economy (and perhaps to counter the Queen’s strong sympathy for lepers) the new Republic of Hawaii undertook to enforce an 1865 quarantine law to contain leprosy, which was spreading across the islands, having been introduced by foreign workers.
3Set in 1893, The Wind and the Reckoning is a fictionalized retelling of the story of the Ko‘olau Rebellion, otherwise known as The Leper War. Based on a memoir by its leader’s wife (Piilani, 2001), the movie portrays indigenous resistance on Moloka‘i, “the island of the living grave”, to the new Hawaiian government. (Spoiler alert: the following discussion reveals the plot development of the film.)
4As it opens, we see a barefoot cowboy riding across a verdant pasture owned by a kindhearted, white cattle rancher. After the workday, Ko‘olau (Jason Scott Lee) returns to his little homestead where his wife, Pi‘ilani (Lindsay Watson), greets him. A wide-eyed, young son, Kalei (Kahiau Perreira) then turns up, lugging a surfboard under his arm; his surfing buddy, an affable, blond lad, follows and greets his friend’s father, who is seated by a little fire. When the latter boy inadvertently catches a glimpse of Ko‘olau’s diseased hand, he drops his board and scampers off in a panic to tell his own father, the newly promoted, local sheriff.
5Later that night, on “written order of… the Republic of Hawai‘i”, the lawman and a couple of deputies burst into the family’s house with weapons drawn. The polite and civil sheriff accuses Ko‘olau of being diseased. In the low light of hurricane lamps, he verifies that not only is the father infected but so is his son and only his wife, Pi‘ilani, remains uncontaminated. The sheriff gently encourages her to find a new husband, a suggestion which she finds deeply offensive. A narrative turning point then occurs: in an ensuing scuffle, Ko‘olau kills the sheriff, thus to become an enemy of the new state who must go into hiding, together with his family.
6The family finds refuge in caves on the ridge of the Kalalau Valley where they have fled. There, they encounter an affable, ragtag group of infected Hawaiians who are also trying to dodge the colonial authorities. Their rather eccentric leader, Reverend Kapahei “Judge” Kauai, tells Ko‘olau that a small squad of heavily armed American soldiers, commanded by Private John McCabe, a soldier in the Union Army, had been dispatched to track him down and round up lepers. But the Judge also offers another detail: a possible cure is rumored to have arrived from abroad.
7The American soldiers assault the caves to no avail and McCabe, a drunk who has become increasingly aggravated by his inability to capture the Hawaiians, orders a local marshal who is guiding the squad through this unfamiliar territory, to track down and take Ko‘olau dead or alive. Upon finding him seated alone on a fallen tree, he does not arrest Ko‘olau, however, but the two men talk and negotiate. Ko‘olau asks him why he has allied himself with such an unfair system of law, despite having been born and raised in Hawai‘i. The marshal, who feels evident sympathy for Ko‘olau, declares that he will guarantee safe passage to the leper colony for him and his son. When the Hawaiian rejects the offer, the marshal is courteous but immediately signals his commander that he has found Ko‘olau. The soldiers turn up and another fight breaks out but, much to the Captain’s chagrin, the American soldiers are once again driven off.
8That night in the firelit cave, as Pi‘ilani and Ko‘olau are resting with their son, a woman turns up and tells everyone that a doctor with a leprosy cure is waiting at the shore, where they must go for treatment. Suspicious, Ko‘olau sends a first group down to the beach next morning. En route, Captain McCabe leads an ambush against them (having sent the woman to lure the Hawaiians out of hiding). In the fighting, he is killed, the soldiers retreat and the marshal calls a halt to their pursuit of Ko‘olau.
9As the movie ends, we learn via a voiceover that soon afterwards both Ko‘olau and Kalei, father and son, died of leprosy and Pi‘ilani buried them, thus to “honor and fulfil” her duty that “no man, or government could break”. Pi‘ilani, final captions go on to disclose, never contracted leprosy and was able to write about the events on Moloka‘i on which the movie has been based.
10I do not want to end this review on a negative note because the movie does succeed on so many levels, not least of which is how touching and enthralling its story is. But I must add a quick note about the lighting, which is to say, the lack of lighting in several important scenes, such as when the sheriff initially comes to arrest and quarantine Ko‘olau and family and is killed. The darkness in which it, and several other scenes, occur makes following what is going on challenging, to say the least.
11While The Wind and the Reckoning is a straightforward account of indigenous resistance to the colonial state as well as the great strength of Hawaiian moral personhood, it is also much more. The movie does not just reduce its heroes to moral stereotypes. It is not, as I say, only a simple tale of good versus evil or of inevitable colonial subjugation. The cattle rancher, the sheriff and the marshal are all depicted as sympathetic, rather than imperious, colonials, while the Hawaiians are portrayed as possessing humor, commitment and honor, but also pain. It should rightfully be included with Hawaii (1966), Rapa Nui (1994), Picture Bride (1995), The Dead Lands (2014), Tanna (2015) and The Convert (2023), in other words, as among the best contemporary historical cinema of Pacific Islanders.
References
12Butler Martin and Dean Bentley, 2015. Tanna, Australia, Lightyear Entertainment. Feature film, 100 minutes.
Fraser Toa, 2014. The Dead Lands, New Zealand, New Zealand Film Commission.
Hatta Kayo, 1995. Picture Bride, United States, Miramax Films.
Hill George Roy, 1966. Hawaii, United States, The Mirisch Corporation.
Piilani, 2001. The True Story of Kaluaikoolau: As Told by his Wife, Piilani, Trans. Frances N. Frazier, Honolulu, University of Hawaii Press.
Reynolds Kevin, 1994. Rapa Nui, Australia, Maverick Films.
Tamahori Lee, 2023. The Convert, New Zealand, Jump Film and Television.
Pour citer cet article
Référence papier
David Lipset, « Cunningham David L. (dir.), The Wind and the Reckoning, United States, Lynmar Entertainment, 2022. Feature film, 94 minutes, color », Journal de la Société des Océanistes, 162 | 2026, 301-303.
Référence électronique
David Lipset, « Cunningham David L. (dir.), The Wind and the Reckoning, United States, Lynmar Entertainment, 2022. Feature film, 94 minutes, color », Journal de la Société des Océanistes [En ligne], 162 | 2026, mis en ligne le 30 septembre 2026, consulté le 13 novembre 2026. URL : https://journals.openedition.org/jso/18240 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/16v00
Haut de pageDroits d’auteur
Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont susceptibles d’être soumis à des autorisations d’usage spécifiques.
Haut de page


