Navigation – Plan du site

AccueilNuméros152PREMIERE PARTIE : DOSSIER THEMATIQUEThe Arab Press Published Outside ...

PREMIERE PARTIE : DOSSIER THEMATIQUE

The Arab Press Published Outside the Arabic-Speaking Areas: Contextual Effects

Introduction to the thematic issue
Franck Mermier
p. 25-40
Cet article est une traduction de :
La presse (en) arabe publiée hors de l’aire arabophone : effets de contexte [fr]

Texte intégral

  • 1 This publication originates from the seminar on the Arab press organised by Diana Cooper-Richet on (...)

1The title of this collection of articles and interviews requires some clarification.1 The Arab press published outside of the Arabic-speaking world, as referred to in the title, includes all publications (dailies and periodicals) edited and published in Arabic in countries where Arabic is not a dominant language. Although the expression “the Arab press” is in the singular, it does not constitute a homogeneous whole. Its plurality results from the heterogeneity of the historical and political contexts of its birth, its contents, the trajectories of its instigators and their motivations. This diversity is also linked to the target audiences and the relationships they have with the different Arab spaces in which they originate.

2Numerous studies have addressed the theme of media related to migration and in relation to the phenomenon of satellite television and reception practices among immigrants settled in Europe (Mattelart, 2014). With the development of new information and communication technologies at the turn of the 1990s, particularly the emergence of the Internet and satellite channels, the existence of an Arab public sphere, its constituents and its transformations, has given rise to a great deal of research (Alterman, 1998; Mermier, 2003; Gonzalez-Quijano and Guaaybess, 2009; Mohsen-Finan, 2009). Similarly, the issue of the economic and political control of these new media configurations, in a context of more or less effective privatisation, have also been scrutinised (Sakr, 2007; Della Ratta, Sakr and Skovgaard-Petersen, 2015).

  • 2 This includes the creation of the academic journal Arab Media and Society, founded in 1998 as Trans (...)

3In fact, the proliferation of spaces and forms of expression through new media technologies, particularly talk shows but also reality shows, has given the impression of an unprecedented pluralism that seemed to slightly loosen the restrictions on freedom of expression imposed by authoritarian regimes (Lynch, 2006; Seib, 2007; Heinemann, Lamloum and Weber, 2009; Kraidy, 2010). In this way there has been a convergence between regional research and disciplinary sub-fields, in particular a conjunction between regional studies and disciplinary sub-fields in the context of “Arab media studies”,2 which, among Anglo-Saxon observers, has already given rise to critical postures, notably on the part of Noha Mellor, who proposes to study Arab journalism as “an autonomous field with its own rules and capital” (Mellor, 2007: 43), drawing inspiration from Pierre Bourdieu.

4Within the Arab space, defined as a space of dissemination and reception that can therefore extend beyond an Arabic-speaking area, the press, defined as "all newspapers and periodicals" (Larousse), has been strongly affected by these developments. The transition to digital especially for those who successfully navigated the transformation, significantly disrupted the media landscape in most countries. The 2011 uprisings, followed by the wars that ravaged several Arab countries, with attendant dispersion and forced migration, also had profound consequences for the reconfiguration of media spaces, albeit consequences differentiated according to context. Repression and extreme violence provoked the search for new broadcasting spaces from the territories of exile. This in turn, led to the recomposition of the Arab press based on new centralities and the resulting transnational circulations arising from forced migratory flows.

5If we look back at the development of this Arab press created outside the predominantly Arabic-speaking countries, we can only observe that it is largely the consequence of migration situations.

A variety of designations

6The academic denomination of this press is varied and recalls the historical contexts that saw its birth or development. The Lebanese scholar Philippe de Tarrazi, author of the first history of the Arab press, does not distinguish between titles that were created in predominantly Arabic-speaking countries and those founded outside, except when it comes to ranking cities and countries in order of importance of newspapers and periodicals published between 1800 and 1929, even going so far as to determine the religion of their owners (de Tarrazi, 2020: 739-758). This wide-ranging study provides a map of Arab migrations, which have their own historical, political and cultural characteristics, depending on their points of departure and destination. One of the first syntheses specifically devoted to the "migrant Arab press" deals with the migration of the press both among Arabic-speaking countries and outside Arabic-speaking countries (Abū Zayd, 1985). For its author, the Egyptian Fārūq Abū Zayd, it was the same press that circumstances forced to settle elsewhere than in the home country of its founders. William A. Rugh isolates a separate category, that of “Offshore Pan-Arab Print Media” (Rugh, 2004: 167-180). However, one of the reasons that motivated the relocation of the press outside the Arab world was the search for greater freedom of expression, even if in the case of the London-based pan-Arab press studied by Rugh, its relationship with the powers that be, particularly in Saudi Arabia, was close.

7De Tarrazi already pointed out that a major reason for the creation of many Arab press titles in Europe and the Americas during the Ottoman era was the avoidance of censorship:

It is plain from the producing tables that some of the far cities in Europe and America, where the inhabitants do not speak Arabic, have surpassed in the number of journals and magazines several capitals and famous cities right in the heart of Arabic speaking countries. This is due to the immigration of a large number of journalists and writers in the day of the Ottoman government to which they were subject. This government oppressed and persecuted the thinking and learned men of her country. She was afraid of their writings… (de Tarrazi, 2020: 745)

Crossing the Atlantic

8Beyond these considerations on the effects of censorship in the relocation of the Arab press, migratory flows from the Levant (Syria, Lebanon, Palestine) to the New World also led to the creation of many Arab newspapers. Brazil surpassed all other countries in the Americas in terms of the number of titles, 82 newspapers and 13 magazines, according to de Tarrazi’s 1929 census, and it was also the country where the first newspaper in Latin America was created in 1894 (Bruckmayr, 2014: 245). Brazil was followed by the United States (52 newspapers and 27 journals), then Argentina (41 newspapers and 17 journals) and Mexico (15 newspapers and 2 journals) (de Tarrazi, 2020: 737). Already in 1910, there were more than 15 Arab newspapers in the United States (Cardinot, 2013), including Kawkab America (Planet America) published in 1888 in New York (Abu Laban, 1981). Several of these titles were closely linked to sectarian groups and represented, for Michael W. Suleiman (1999: 4), “the main socializing agencies conveying the messages of their sectarian leadership. Because the Orthodox had already Kawkab America, Al-Hoda was set up to represent and speak for the Maronites. Later, Al-Bayan proclaimed itself the newspaper of the Druze”. As Philipp Bruckmayr points out, the Arab press in Latin America, though numerically superior, has been the subject of far less study than the Mahjar press in the United States with its famous authors, Khalil Gibran and the writers of the Rābiṭa al-qalamiyya (Bruckmayr, 2014: 245-247). This author draws on data more recent than those used by de Tarrazi and shows the vitality of this press in different urban centres including Rio de Janeiro, which “before 1950 saw the emergence of at least 42 Arabic language newspapers and 5 magazines” (Bruckmayr, 2014: 249).

9Some of these titles had a truly “translocal” dimension linking emigrants to their city or region of origin in a shifting context where the balance between Ottomanism and Arab identity fluctuated greatly depending on individual and political circumstances. The Lebanese journalist Iskandar Riachi, recounting his crossing of the Atlantic on the German liner L’Imperator in June 1913, said that he had been invited by his compatriot Najla Mutran to come from Paris to New York to create a newspaper for the immigrants of Zahlé, to be called The New Country, in Arabic transcription (Riachi, 1966: 32-33; Riachi, 1954: 92). As Jonathan Friedman (2000: 199-200) observed: “Could it not be that the local is a relationship of interlocality and not simply a cultural representation, that is, a cultural and social practice on a larger scale?”

10It is also important to note that this press served as a vehicle for nationalist ideas such as Arab, Pansyrian and Lebanese nationalisms in particular (Bruckmayr, 2014: 250) and played an important role in “transnational political mobilisations” (Logrono Narbona, 2014; Fahrenthold, 2013: 34-63). In this issue, Camila Pastor de Maria Campos traces the evolution of the Arabic press in Mexico from the end of the Ottoman period (1878-1914) to the French Mandate over Syria and Lebanon. Her study focuses on two newspapers created within the Maronite community that reflect the ideological underpinnings of the positions taken in relation to major events occurring in the Levant, such as the Palestinian revolt of 1936, and in relation to the place reserved for these immigrants in the host society. The gradual shift from Arabic to Spanish, or the initial choice of the latter language for each of the two newspapers studied, also shows that this press differentiated itself according to the type of relationship that its instigators had with their country of origin and their chosen immigration destination. Its transformations were also the result of the evolution of the links between these two poles and their ideological, social and cultural anchoring strategies.

Shifting configurations and identifications

11To lump together under a single heading as “Arab migration” phenomena as diverse as the resettlement of populations from Hadramaut (in present-day Yemen) in Southeast Asia, particularly in Indonesia and India, with the migration of hundreds of thousands from the Levant to the Americas, or the migration of North Africans to Europe and Yemenis to the United Kingdom, is to conceal under the cloak of homogenising ethnic categorisations the specific dynamics and particular interactions that exist between the different spaces and populations brought together, often under the aegis of colonial authority. The Arab press wherever it exists reflects such particularities, whether among the outposts of the British Empire, the Dutch East Indies, in Zanzibar, Turkey, Russia, Switzerland, Germany, Italy, France, the United Kingdom, Malta, Cyprus, the United States, Canada, Mexico, Brazil, Cuba, Argentina, Chile, the Dominican Republic or Uruguay, From this list, which respects the order of countries established by de Tarrazi, it can be seen that the idea of an allophone press is shifting, since Zanzibar, which had been attached to Oman became an autonomous province of Tanzania in 1964, and the Sanjak of Alexandretta, assigned to the Syrian territory under the French Mandate, was ceded to Turkey in 1939.

  • 3 It was not until 1967 that Hadramaut became part of South Yemen, called the People’s Republic of So (...)
  • 4 Al-Nahḍa al-ḥaḍramiyya was even the name of a newspaper established in 1932 in Java.

12The spaces in which this journalistic production developed, whether in places of creation outside the so-called Arab world or in spaces of dissemination within that world, are, depending on the historical context, part of shifting political configurations whose national character can be reconstructed retrospectively. To describe the press of the Hadrami emigration in the present-day territories of Malaysia, Indonesia and Singapore as Yemeni, as Abdallah Yahia El Zine (1978: 163-189) does, would certainly have surprised its instigators.3 It initially had, as shown by the name of the first newspaper founded in Singapore in 1906-1909, Al-Īmān [The Faith], a strong religious orientation. The founding of newspaper companies was part of the Hadrami awakening (Nahda), along with the establishment of associations and modern educational institutions (Mobini-Kesheh, 1997: 233).4 The rise in economic power of the big Hadrami families resulted in the emergence in the 1930s of “ruthless Arab press barons in Singapore and Penang (region of Malaysia), employing mainly Malay journalists and distributing their newspapers widely in the Dutch possessions” (Clarence-Smith, 1997: 304). In the case of Senegal, however, it is interesting to note another case. Djim Dramé, in an article published in this issue, shows that the creation of a press in Arabic dates back to the country’s independence and was part of a public authorities’ policy promoting Islamic culture and relations with Arab countries. It was thus anchored in local Arabic-speaking religious circles rather than among Lebanese residents in Senegal. It was therefore not an allophone press but a local Arabic-speaking press.

From Ottoman Empire to Turkey

13A reference to the case of the Arab press in the Ottoman Empire and in Turkey is particularly interesting because it can give rise to temporal shortcuts on possible continuities but also because it can suggest interesting comparisons on conditions leading to the formation of an Arab press scene within a single metropolis over distinct periods marked by very different political and geopolitical contexts. It is also the very definition of Arab denomination that is at stake, since the political and cultural connotations that refer to it are far from stable and fluctuate according to situations, allegiances, the scale of membership and representations. The parallel drawn between the Ottoman period and the contemporary period to speak, for example, of a (re)creation of a press in Arabic in Istanbul seems specious, to say the least, if it suggests a false historical continuum associating the presence of an Arab media scene with the activation of the same referential horizon that the Arabic name would subsume.

14Thus, Fārūq Abū Zayd points out that the first title of the emigrant Arab press was Mir’āt al-Aḥwāl [The Mirror of Situations] created, in Istanbul, by the Aleppine poet and journalist Rizqallāh Ḥassūn al-Ḥalabī in 1855, which actually seems to be the first Arabic-language press title created in the capital of the Ottoman Empire (de Tarrazi, 1913: 86 and Abū Zayd, 1985: 19). It was followed by the daily newspaper Al-Ǧawā’ib founded in 1861 by the famous Aḥmad Fāris Al-Shidyāq, which ceased publication in 1884 (Roper, 1995: 213: Debbech, 2020: 97-101). Elias Hanna Elias, referring to the circumstances surrounding the founding of these two newspapers, does not hesitate to describe Istanbul as the “capital of the Arab press” (Elias, 1993: 24), while pointing out:

It may seem paradoxical that some Arabic-language newspapers were able to take up residence in Istanbul, the capital of the Ottoman Empire, which was not particularly favourable to the Arabic language, but which nevertheless constituted a pole of attraction for ambitions that had a chance of being fulfilled there.

15This press was created outside the Arab provinces of the Empire, in a context where the latter were not national entities, yet it was intended for them. Depending on the perspective, this phenomenon is likely to be overlooked as it was in this book on the “Turkish Press and the Press of Turkey” (Clayer et al., 1992), which makes no mention of the Arabic-language press even though several of the contributions concern the Ottoman period. It is interesting here to compare the testimony of the Lebanese writer Ǧurǧī Zaydān (2017: 86), during his visit to Istanbul in 1909, which mentions the names of eight Arabic-language weeklies published in Istanbul after the Young Turk revolution in 1908, six of which had ceased publication, with the data reported in Baykal’s (2019: 56-58) work on periodicals published between 1908 and 1923. Baykal lists 11 Arabic publications in Istanbul and the vilayets of Aydin (Smyrna region) and Salonika, i.e., 2% of the 140 Arabic publications authorised in the Ottoman Empire at the time.

16The creation of an Arabic media scene in Turkey after 2011 is by no means an extension of the one formed by Arabic newspapers during the Ottoman period. It is the result of a particular geopolitical conjuncture brought about by the uprisings of the Arab Spring, their repression and/or their slide towards internal dissension which notably provoked the resettlement of 3.6 million Syrians in Turkey as well as the displacement of tens of thousands of Iraqis, Libyans, Egyptians and Yemenis. It is also the result of the policy of influence pursued by regimes in Ankara and Doha, which joined forces to sponsor and finance a large part of the Arab media in Turkey (Mermier, 2021). More than differences related to the technological transformations of the press, which it is useless to go back over, it was in fact the political nature of territorialities and affiliations that changed before and after the formation of Turkish and Arabic nationalities, and therefore of the nature of relations between these entities.

17In this issue, the case of the online journal Al-Jumhuriya [The Republic], founded in 2012 by opponents of the Bashar Al-Assad regime, analysed by Adélie Chevée and Franck Mermier, shows how the circumstances of the uprising, war and repression in Syria led to the establishment of a transnational network of journalists and intellectuals linking Syria from the inside to Syrian capitals in exile, including Istanbul. The journal’s left-leaning ideological and cultural orientations, however, contributed to a drastic reduction in the presence of those of its contributors residing in Turkey after the hardening of the political climate following the attempted coup in 2016.

The handover from Paris to London

18These historical discontinuities can be seen in the examples of the Arab press in Paris and London. Fluctuating power relations and political rivalries, particularly between France and the United Kingdom, as well as the nature of the relations maintained by these European powers vis-à-vis the Arab parts of their colonial empires, had direct consequences for the environments in which Arab-speaking journalists were obliged to work. Fatna Ziani, responsible for Arabic language collections at the BULAC (the University Library of Languages and Civilizations, Paris), mentions in an interview published in this issue and conducted by Diana Cooper-Richet, that the library possesses issues of the bi-monthly Al-Tafāhum published in 1942 in Vichy by the Service des affaires musulmanes. It is interesting to note that, in his autobiography, the “Arabist” Charles Pellat, who was in charge of creating it, makes only an elliptical mention of it without mentioning its name, no doubt to conceal this inglorious episode in his professional itinerary (Pellat, 2007: 55).

19While France and the United Kingdom may have been breeding grounds for an Arabic-speaking press in search of freedom and a favourable publishing climate (Elias, 1993: 44), it is obviously necessary to take into account the different historical contexts in which this press developed, to identify the political motivations that presided over its creation. In the “media capital” (Charles, 2021: 464-465) that Paris would become, and which assumed new proportions following adoption of the 29 July 1881 law on the freedom of the press, Arabic-language titles were published for propaganda purposes by the French authorities. In this issue, Ons Debbech tells the story of Birğīs Barīs [The Paris Eagle], the first newspaper published in Arabic in Paris in 1859, under the aegis of Abbé Bourgade which aimed, explicitly, to promote “Christian civilisation” and French politics among Muslims. The creation of the newspaper Al-Ǧawā’ib in Istanbul, with subsidies from the Ottoman sultan, was also intended to counter the influence of Birğīs Barīs, whose circulation was not limited to Muslim countries following the example of the daily Al-Shidyāq, a newspaper created by Aḥmad Fāris Al-Shidyāq (Debbech, 2020: 99).

20Numerous titles were then published, such as Al-'Urwa Al-Wuthqā [The Indissoluble Bond], which was born in 1884 from a collaboration between the two Muslim reformists Jamal Eddine Al-Afghani and Mohamed Abduh. One of the contributions in this dossier that we owe to Eliane Ettmüller is devoted to the satirical newspaper Abū Naẓẓārāt Zarqā that Ya’qūb Ṣannū’ continued to publish in Paris after his exile from Egypt in 1878 and in which he advocated Egyptian nationalism to Europeans (Fahmy, 2008). During the First World War, the founding of the newspaper Al-Mustaqbal [L’Avenir] in Paris in 1916 was part of the context of the war between France and the Ottoman Empire and the plan to dismember its Arab provinces after the conflict. Across the Channel, and as early as the second half of the nineteenth century, several titles hostile to the Ottoman Empire emerged such as Al-Naḥla [The Bee]. Initially published in Beirut, this periodical started to appear in London, from 1876, after the exile of its founder Louis Sabounji (Zolondek, 1978; Visser, 2014). Similarly, propaganda titles such as Al-Ghayra (Elias, 1993: 45) were edited and published by the Ottoman administration in London, to counterbalance ideas that were hostile to it.

21In the mid-1970s, with the war in Lebanon, many journalists and press titles emigrated to Paris and London or were created there in the context of rivalries between Arab regimes. Nicolas Beau (1995: 150-157) referred to the large number of pro-Iraqi periodicals that were created in Paris during the 1980s and which later served the Saudi regime, especially during the first Gulf War (1990-1991). One of the flagship publications of the Arab cultural and political press based in Europe was the weekly Al-Yawm al-Sābi’ published in the French capital under the aegis of the Palestine Liberation Organisation from 1983. Bringing together journalists from different Arab countries and distributed as much in North Africa as in the Middle East, this journalistic experiment can be considered as one of the last lights of a certain political pan-Arabism centred around the Palestinian question. An article written by Aya Khalil, in this issue, gives an account of the characteristics of this weekly, notably through the testimonies of several of its contributors. Another of its eminent protagonists, Basheer Al-Bakr, relates the circumstances of his participation in this periodical in an interview published also in this issue and conducted by Franck Mermier. The replacement of Paris by London as the centre of gravity of the Arab press in Europe is discussed in relation to his own journalistic journey.

22Several pan-Arab newspapers were thus created in the British capital with Saudi financial backing (El Oifi, 2005), in particular, the daily Al-Hayat, bought by the Saudi prince Khalid Bin Sultan, relaunched in London in 1988, then relocated again to Lebanon in 2000 before disappearing twenty years later. For this dossier, Amal Nader and Mohamed Bendahan focused on three pan-Arab dailies (print and online) published in London and financed by the Saudis (Al-Sharq Al-Awsat - The Middle East), the Qataris (Al-Quds Al-Arabi - Arab Jerusalem) and the Emiratis (Al-Arab - The Arabs). The nature of the dailies’ relationships to their benefactors is analysed through their reporting on events that took place in 2017, 2019 and 2021.

23In 2014, the daily Al-Araby Al-Jadeed was published in London and Doha, extending Qatar’s policy of media influence to print media, with Al Araby channel also established as an alternative to Al-Jazeera. If London replaced Paris as an Arab media platform, it was because of the administrative facilities granted for the establishment of media companies, the absence of censorship and the greater accessibility of English, as mentioned by Basheer Al-Bakr in an interview published in this issue. The fact remains however, that the British capital has lost its attractiveness and that its role as a European hub for the Arab press is reportedly declining (Jarrah, 2008).

Press, Migrations and Transnationalism

24It is interesting to note the changes in the categorisation of the allophone press as it became part of emerging disciplinary fields accompanying the evolution of migration and the condition of immigrants, particularly in Western countries. Inflections from Anglo-Saxon and French academic traditions also play a role in its naming. Thus, from the “foreign press” (Génériques, 1990) in France, we have moved on to “ethnic media” (Rigoni, 2010: 7-16) or to the term “media and migrations” (Mattelart, 2007). It should be noted that in the United States, this press is referred to as the “Arab-American press”.5 Under either of these labels, a large amount of research on the Arab immigrant press has been conducted, usually resulting in case studies focusing on one title or on Arab journalistic and intellectual production in a given country, particularly in Europe (Gastaut, 2014: 105-118; Benchenna, 2014: 431-464; Saitta, 2014: 285-318; Azizi, 2016: 121-146).

25One of the concepts that has become exponentially more popular since the 1990s and has accompanied the process of “globalisation” is that of transnationalism (Green, 2011: 197-208). It has also been used to describe media carriers and productions that are included in the category of “transnational media” and to claim the existence of a “transnational public sphere” (Gupta and Fergurson, 1997: 48).

26In anthropology, one of the first definitions of transnationalism, linking it to migrants, is offered by anthropologists Nina Glick Schiller, Linda Basch and Cristina Blanc-Szanton (Green, 2011: 202-206). They call transnationalism the immigrant experience “to emphasize the emergence of a social process in which migrants establish social fields that cross geographical, cultural, and political borders”. Immigrants are understood to be transmigrants when they develop and maintain multiple relations—familial, economic, social, organizational, religious, and political that span borders” (Glick Schiller et al., 1992: ix). Anthropologist Steven Vertovec points out “that the long-distance connections maintained by migrants 100 years ago were not truly ‘transnational’—in terms of one contemporary sense of regular and sustained social contact; rather, such earlier links were just border-crossing migrant networks that were maintained in sporadic fashion as best as migrants at that time could manage” (Vertovec, 2009: 16).

27Tristan Mattelart (2007: 13-54) offered a valuable critical reflection on “transnational cultures” in relation to the media to highlight the relevance of Benedict Anderson’s thesis on “long-distance nationalism” created by the conjunction between migration and the internationalisation of the media (Anderson, 1998 cited in Mattelart, 2007: 55). This is echoed in Nancy Green’s warning about an irenic vision of transnationalism (Green, 2011: 208). Acknowledging the heuristic value of this notion for revisiting historical sources, she argues “against an over-interpretation of the fluidity of the present that would neglect the constraints that persist. The praise of mobility, of which the transnational is a part, is limited by the power relations inherent in the forms and facets of mobility.” Moreover, the relations of centre to periphery that marked the colonial period did not suddenly vanish with contemporary globalisation. As the anthropologist Jackie Assayag writes (Assayag, 2005: 279) “...these networks that direct and channel these ‘flows’ depend on poles of power and geopolitical power relations linked to the ‘global megalopolitan archipelago’ formed by a set of cities that contribute to the direction of the world”.

28The parallels that could be drawn between the Arab émigré press prior to the diffusion of new information and communication technologies and the news websites of the Internet age suggest, however, that beyond the obvious differences relating to the speed and density of connections and flows, constants can be observed, particularly at the level of context effects. The evolution of the place and status of Arab immigrant populations, of their (differentiated) expectations in relation to the host societies, not to mention the greater or lesser strength of identity assignments, permanently reconfigures the content, orientations and spaces of distribution of this press. Thus, while part of the Syrian press in Turkey experiences great precarity, it remains oriented towards the Syrian populations both inside and in exile (Badran, 2020: 69-85), certain press sites in Germany, the outcome of German-Syrian initiatives, provide a catalyst for Arabic cultural circles, such as Fann [Art], an online magazine in Arabic and German devoted to arts and culture (Mermier, forthcoming).

29By revisiting the theme of the Arabic allophone press from a diachronic perspective and in the light of contemporary technological and political transformations, this issue aims to focus on the consequences of the interactions that this allophone press has with the social, political and cultural configurations in which it is deployed. Its study lies at the crossroads of several disciplines: cultural history, information and communication sciences, political science, socio-anthropology and migration studies. The purpose of this issue is also to decompartmentalise disciplinary approaches. Finally, it aims to contribute to a reflection on areal studies by confronting the diversity of the contexts studied with the underlying question of how to define the changing configurations of theArab space.

Haut de page

Bibliographie

ABU LABAN, Baha, 1981, La présence arabe au Canada, Ottawa, Secrétariat d’État du Canada, Le cercle du Livre de France et Division du multiculturalisme, coll. “Générations, histoire des peuples du Canada”.

ABŪ ZAYD, Fārūq, 1985, Al-ṣiḥāfa al-ʿarabiyya al-muhājira [La presse arabe émigrée], Le Caire, Madbouli.

AKHOUN-SCHWARB, Dominique, 2003, La presse arabe et la France : inventaire des périodiques arabes imprimés, publiés entre 1875 et 1920, disponibles dans les bibliothèques de Paris, Lyon et Aix-en-Provence, rapport de recherche bibliographique, DESS Réseaux d’information et document électronique, ENSSIB.

ALTERMAN, Jon B., 1998, New Media, New Politics? From Satellite Television to the Internet in the Arab World, Washington, The Washington Institute for Near East Policy.

ANDERSON, Benedict, 1998, The Spectre of Comparisons. Nationalism, Southeast Asia and the World, Londres, Verso.

ASAL, Houda, 2016, Se dire arabe au Canada. Un siècle d’histoire migratoire, Montréal, Presses Universitaires de Montréal.

ASSAYAG, Jackie, 2005, La mondialisation vue d’ailleurs. L’Inde désorientée, Paris, Seuil.

AZIZI, Asmaa, 2016, “Presse des immigrés marocains : entre construction identitaire et mobilisation politique”, Communication & Langages, 187, p. 121-146.

BADRAN, Yazan, 2020, “Strategies and (survival) tactics: The case of Syrian oppositional media in Turkey”, Journal of Alternative & Community Media, 5(1), p. 69-85.

BAYKAL, Erol, 2019, The Ottoman Press (1908-1923), Leyde, Brill.

BEAU, Nicolas, 1995, Paris, capitale arabe, Paris, Seuil.

BENCHENNA, Abdelfettah, 2014, “De la mobilisation identitaire à l’entreprise lucrative ? Le cas du portail d’information Yabiladi.com”, in MATTELART, Tristan (ed.), Médias et migrations dans l’espace euro-méditerranéen, Paris, Éditions Mare & Martin, p. 431-464.

BRUCKMAYR, Philipp, 2014, “Arabic and Bilingual Newspapers and Magazines in Latin America and the Caribbean”, in ROPER, Geoffrey (ed.), Historical Aspects of Printing and Publishing in Languages of the Middle East, Leyde, Brill, p. 245-269.

CARDINOT, Dominique, 2013, “The reconfiguration of gender relations in Syrian Americain feminist discourse in the diasporic conditions of the late nineteenth century”, Clio. Women, gender, history, 37, [online] https://doi.org/10.4000/cliowgh.413.

CHARLE, Christophe, 2021, Paris, « capitales » des xixe siècles, Paris, Seuil.

CHELBI, Mohamed-Fehri, 1986, Les journaux arabes de Paris (1859-1919) : étude sociohistorique et sociologique, thèse de doctorat, Université Paris II.

CLARENCE-SMITH, William G., 1997, “Hadrami Entrepreneurs in the Malay World, c. 1750 to c. 1940”, in FREITAG, Ulrike and CLARENCE-SMITH, William G. (eds), Hadrami Traders, Scholars, and Statesmen in the Indian Ocean 1750s-1960s, Leyde, Brill, p. 297-314.

CLAYER, Nathalie, POPOVIC, Alexandre and ZARCONE, Thierry (eds), 1992, Presse turque et presse de Turquie, Istanbul-Paris, Éditions ISIS/IFEA.

DEBBECH, Ons, 2020, Ahmad Faris Chidyâq, Casablanca, Centre culturel du livre.

DELLA RATTA, Donatella, SAKR, Naomi and SKOVGAARD-PETERSEN, Jakob (eds), 2015, Arab Media Moguls, Londres, I.B. Tauris.

DUPONT, Anne-Laure, 2006, Ǧurǧī Zaydān (1861-1914). Écrivain réformiste et témoin de la Renaissance arabe, Beyrouth, Presses de l’IFPO.

ELIAS, Hanna Elias, 1993, La presse arabe, Paris, Maisonneuve & Larose.

EL OIFI, Mohammed, 2005, “L’opinion publique arabe entre logiques étatiques et solidarités transnationales”, Raisons politiques, 19(3), p. 45-62, [online] https://doi.org/10.3917/rai.019.0045.

EL ZINE, Abdallah Yahia, 1978, Le Yémen et ses moyens d’information, Alger, SNED.

ETTMÜLLER, Eliane Ursula, 2012, The Construct of Egypt’s National-Self in James Sanua’s Early Satire and Caricature, Berlin, Klaus Schwarz Verlag.

FAHMY, Ziad, 2008, “Francophone Egyptian Nationalists, Anti-British Discourse, and European public opinion, 1885-1910: The case of Mustafa Kamil and Ya’qub Sannu’”, Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East, 28(1), p. 170-183.

FAHRENTHOLD, Stacy, 2013, “Transnational Modes and Media: The Syrian Press in the Mahjar and Emigrant Activism during World War I”, Mashriq & Mahjar. Journal of Middle East and North African Migration Studies, 1(1), p. 34-63.

FRIEDMAN, Jonathan, 2000, “Des racines et (dé)routes. Tropes pour trekkers”, L’Homme, 156, p. 187-206, [online] https://doi.org/10.4000/lhomme.76.

GASTAUT, Yvan, 2014, “L’Algérien en Europe (1965-82), un relais médiatique sur l’autre rive de la Méditerranée après l’indépendance”, in MATTELART, Tristan (ed.), Médias et migrations dans l’espace euro-méditerranéen, Paris, Éditions Mare & Martin, p. 105-118.

Génériques, 1990, Presse et mémoire : France des étrangers, France des libertés, Paris, Mémoire-Génériques, Éditions ouvrières.

GLICK SCHILLER, Nina, BASCH, Linda and BLANC-SZANTON, Cristina, 1992, “Towards a Definition of Transnationalism. Introductory Remarks and Research Questions”, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 645(1), p. ix-xiv.

GONZALEZ-QUIJANO, Yves and GUAAYBESS, Touria (eds), 2009, Les Arabes parlent aux Arabes. La révolution de l’information dans le monde arabe, Arles, Actes Sud, coll. « Sindbad ».

GREEN, Nancy L., 2011, “Le transnationalisme et ses limites : le champ de l’histoire des migrations”, in ZÚÑIGA, Jean-Paul (ed.), Pratiques du transnational. Terrains, preuves, limites, Paris, EHESS/Centre de recherches historiques, p. 197-208.

GUPTA, Akhil and FERGUSON, James, 1997, “Beyond ‘Culture’: Space, Identity, and the Politics of Difference”, in GUPTA, Akhil and FERGUSON, James (eds), Culture, Power, Place. Explorations in Critical Anthropology, Durham/Londres, Duke University Press, p. 33-51.

HAFEZ, Kai (ed.), 2001, Mass Media, Politics & Society in the Middle East, Cresskill/New Jersey, Hampton Press.

HEINEMANN, Arnim, LAMLOUM, Olfa and WEBER, Anne-Françoise (eds), 2009, The Middle East in the Media. Conflicts, Censorship and Public Opinion, Londres, Saqi/IFPO/Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung/Orient-Institut Beirut.

JARRAH, Naim, 2008, “The rise and decline of London as a Pan-Arab media hub”, Arab Media & Society, 17 janvier, [online] https://www.arabmediasociety.com/the-rise-and-decline-of-london-as-a-pan-arab-media-hub/.

KRAIDY, Marwan, 2010, Reality Television and Arab Politics. Contentions in Public Life, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

LYNCH, Marc, 2006, Voices of the New Arab Public. Iraq, Al-Jazeera, and Middle East Politics Today, New York, Columbia University Press.

LOGRONO NARBONA, Maria del Mar, 2014, “A Transnational Intellectual Sphere: Brazil and Its Middle Eastern Populations”, in AMAR, Paul (ed.), The Middle East and Brazil. Perspectives on the New Global South, Bloomington, Indiana University Press, p. 199-214.

MATTELART, Tristan (ed.), 2014, Médias et migrations dans l’espace euro-méditerranéen, Paris, Éditions Mare & Martin.

MATTELART, Tristan (ed.), 2007, Médias, migrations et cultures transnationales, Bruxelles, De Boeck Université.

MELLOR, Noha, 2007, Modern Arab Journalism. Problems and Prospects, Le Caire, The American University in Cairo Press.

MERMIER, Franck, à paraître, “Creating a Syrian culture in exile. The reconfigurations of engagement”, in LARZILLIÈRE, Pénélope (ed.), In Motion. The Global Politics of Artistic Engagement. Beyond the Arab Uprisings, Leyde, Brill.

MERMIER, Franck, 2021, “À Istanbul, une scène médiatique arabe sous influence”, Orient XXI, 4 janvier, [online] https://orientxxi.info/magazine/a-istanbul-une-scene-mediatique-arabe-sous-influence,4393.

MERMIER, Franck (ed.), 2003, Mondialisation et nouveaux médias dans l’espace arabe, Paris, Maisonneuve et Larose.

MOBINI-KESHEH, Natalie, 1997, “Islamic Modernism in Colonial Java: The Al-Irshad Movement”, in FREITAG, Ulrike and CLARENCE-SMITH, William G. (eds), Hadrami Traders, Scholars, and Statesmen in the Indian Ocean 1750s-1960s, Leyde, Brill, p. 231-248.

MOHSEN-FINAN, Khadija (ed.), 2009, Les médias en Méditerranée. Nouveaux médias, monde arabe et relations internationales, Arles, Actes Sud/MMSH/Barzakh.

PELLAT, Charles, 2007, Une vie d’arabisant, Paris, Éditions de la librairie Abencerage.

POPP, Richard Alan, 2001, “Al-Rābiṭa al-Qalamīyah, 1916”, Journal of Arabic Literature, 32(1), p. 30-52.

RIACHI, Alexandre, 1954, Nous vivons avec les dieux, Beyrouth, Éditions Julia Felix.

RIACHI, Iskandar, 1966, Niswān min Lubnān, Beyrouth, Dar Al-Andalus.

RIGONI, Isabelle, 2010, “Les médias des minorités ethniques. Représenter l’identité collective sur l’espace public”, Revue européenne des migrations internationales, 26(1), 2010, p. 7-16.

ROPER, Geoffrey (ed.), 2013, Historical Aspects of Printing and Publishing in Languages of the Middle East, Leyde, Brill.

ROPER, Geoffrey, 1995, “Fâris Al-Shidyâq and the Transition from Scribal to Print Culture in the Middle East”, in ATIYEH, George N. (ed.), The Book in the Islamic World. The Written World and Communication in the Middle East, New York, State University of the New York Press, p. 209-231.

RUGH, William A., 2004, Arab Mass Media: Newspapers, Radio, and Television in Arab Politics, Westport, Praeger Publishers.

SAITTA, Eugénie, 2014, “Les médias des minorités ethniques en Italie : rupture et continuité avec les pratiques et discours dominants. Une analyse comparée de Yalla Italia et de Stranieri in Italia”, in MATTELART, Tristan (ed.), Médias et migrations dans l’espace euro-méditerranéen, Paris, Éditions Mare & Martin, p. 285-318.

SAKR, Naomi, 2007, Arab Television Today, Londres, I.B. Tauris.

SEIB, Philipp (ed.), 2007, New Media and the New Middle East, New York, Palgrave Macmillan.

SULEIMAN, Michael W., 1999, “Introduction: The Arab Immigrant Experience”, in SULEIMAN, Michael W. (ed.), Arabs in America. Building a New Future, Philadelphie, Temple University Press, p. 1-21.

TARRAZI, Philippe (de), 2020 [1913], Tārīkh al-ṣiḥāfa al-‘arabiyya [Histoire de la presse arabe], vol. 1, Le Caire, Wikāla al-ṣihāfa al-‘arabiyya.

VISSER, Rogier, 2014, Identities in Early Arabic Journalism. The case of Louis Sabounji, Amsterdam, University of Amsterdam.

ZAYDĀN, Ǧurǧī, 2017, Al-riḥlāt al-thalāth, Al-Astāna, Ūrūbā, Filisīn [Les trois voyages, Istanbul, Europe, Palestine], Beyrouth, Arab Center for Research and Policy Studies.

ZOLONDEK, Léo, 1978, “Sabounji in England”, Middle East Studies, 14, p. 102-115.

Haut de page

Notes

1 This publication originates from the seminar on the Arab press organised by Diana Cooper-Richet on 12 December 2016 as part of the Transnational Network for the Study of the Foreign Language Press, http://transfopresschcsc.wixsite.com/transfopress/single-post/2016/11/15/Séminaire-La-presse-arabophone

2 This includes the creation of the academic journal Arab Media and Society, founded in 1998 as Transnational Broadcasting Studies, published by the Adham Center for Television and Digital Journalism, School of Global Affairs and Public Policy, American University in Cairo.

3 It was not until 1967 that Hadramaut became part of South Yemen, called the People’s Republic of South Yemen and then, in 1970, the People’s Democratic Republic of Yemen.

4 Al-Nahḍa al-ḥaḍramiyya was even the name of a newspaper established in 1932 in Java.

5 See these archive sites of this press in Arabic or English: https://www.journalism.org/2012/11/28/arabamerican-media ; Archive Spotlight: Historic Arabic Newspaper Digitization Project | Moise A. Khayrallah Center for Lebanese Diaspora Studies | NC State University

Haut de page

Pour citer cet article

Référence papier

Franck Mermier, « The Arab Press Published Outside the Arabic-Speaking Areas: Contextual Effects »Revue des mondes musulmans et de la Méditerranée, 152 | 2022, 25-40.

Référence électronique

Franck Mermier, « The Arab Press Published Outside the Arabic-Speaking Areas: Contextual Effects »Revue des mondes musulmans et de la Méditerranée [En ligne], 152 | 2022, mis en ligne le 20 décembre 2022, consulté le 13 juin 2024. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/remmm/18394 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/remmm.18394

Haut de page

Auteur

Franck Mermier

CNRS (IRIS), Paris, France; franckmermier[at]yahoo.fr

Articles du même auteur

Haut de page

Droits d’auteur

CC-BY-NC-SA-4.0

Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont « Tous droits réservés », sauf mention contraire.

Haut de page
Search OpenEdition Search

You will be redirected to OpenEdition Search