In search of the ideal maternity: Mobility, key to childbirth dreamed of by economic elites?
- Cet article est une traduction de :
- La mobilité : sésame d’un accouchement sur mesure pour les élites économiques ? [fr]
Texte intégral
1This article focuses on the relationship to childbirth of women from the internationally mobile elites and giving birth in a private maternity hospital (Gelly & al., 2021). Recent work on the social differentiation of perinatal care (Sauvegrain et al., 2022) often explores the question of social relations of domination, from the perspective of racialization. Few studies have addressed this issue by exploring the relationship of health professionals to the upper classes. We have recently treated this question from a sociological point of view (Cristofalo & al., 2019; Gelly & al., 2021). Here we wish to approach this theme from the point of view of critical social geography.
2The analysis conducted and developed here is part of a research project on trajectories and social relations in perinatality (TRASOPER project) and opens up reflections on mobility, circulation and migration in the field of health. While we usually worked with people "migrating" for economic reasons (looking for work or better living conditions) and/or political reasons (persecution, violence), this survey confronted us with women from international elites, rather "mobile" than "migrant". These women had a specific mobility profile, insofar as their mobility is not the result of economic or political constraints, but of professional or residential choices (Wagner, 2005).
3We propose a discussion on the one hand on the registers of mobility, movement, and migration of these women, and on the other hand on the social relations that structure the relations between these women and health professionals in the context of pregnancy. Mobility appears here as a means of accessing places, maternity wards, where they can access services “sur mesure” (i.e. adepted to elite families way of life and to social expectations). Thus, we seek to show how pregnancy and childbirth, for these women and the professionals they meet, reconfigure specific spatial and temporal arrangements.
4In this article, we will analyse only one of the fields (the "pioneering" terrain) of the TRASOPER programme, which, for the project's researchers, proves to be the most original. This allows us to renew our theoretical and epistemological questions. The survey took place in a private non-profit maternity hospital, carrying out about 750 deliveries per year. It is a maternity hospital that takes care of physiological, non-pathological pregnancies, located in wealthy neighbourhood in western Paris. This maternity hospital welcomes an audience of women from elites classes, well endowed with economic and cultural capital. Between June 2018 and May 2019, we conducted 36 semi-directive interviews with women during hospitalization in the maternity ward that follows or precedes their delivery, 12 interviews with obstetricians, midwives, nurses, psychologists and secretaries, the observation of 60 medical consultations, 5 staff and service meetings. The interviews were transcribed and anonymized.
5We are interested in the social relationships that structure the relationships between patients and health professionals, and will show that body assignments of gender and class contribute to differentiating medical practices in places of care. In addition, our survey in structures dedicated to perinatality leads us to look at the mobilities of women from transnational elites (and their relatives) as well as the practices of health professionals who will take care of them. Also, at the crossroads between transnational circulations (of individuals, practices and knowledge) and migratory trajectories of women and their families, this article proposes a discussion on the terms and concepts to be mobilized to qualify and understand the mobilities of these women and inscribes the analysis of the circulations of elites in those of the development of "sanitary capitalism" (Batifoulier, 2015).
6Finally, we observe that class and gender relations structure mobility practices in relation to perinatality. The specific medical offer intended for international elites has characteristics of sanitary capitalism: privatization of the offer, diversion of doctors from the public to the private sector, consumption of care and technicality at all costs, individual negotiation of care reducing the risks associated with certain care. The desire to satisfy the wealthiest contributes to a differentiated medicalization of childbirth. Therefore, the possible circulations, for these women, puts health as an element "almost common" among others at the heart of mobility practices standardized internationally. In this, these practices differ from the notion of medical tourism, since these logics of consumerist choices are, through class practices, anchored in a possible and very easily accessible transnational space and refers to pratices of lifestyle mobilities and therapeutic mobilities.
Screenshot of the presentation of the practice of one of the gynecologists practicing in this maternity ward

In this private practice, psychiatrist, obstetrician-gynecologist, midwives welcome in the heart of the 7th arrondissement in this luxury space (with wall plants, a design and a refined decoration) pregnant women who for the most part will give birth in the maternity unit surveyed. Top-of-the-range coffee and tea are available in the waiting room, as well as the books of the doctors in the practice.
Table des illustrations
![]() |
|
---|---|
Titre | Screenshot of the presentation of the practice of one of the gynecologists practicing in this maternity ward |
Légende | In this private practice, psychiatrist, obstetrician-gynecologist, midwives welcome in the heart of the 7th arrondissement in this luxury space (with wall plants, a design and a refined decoration) pregnant women who for the most part will give birth in the maternity unit surveyed. Top-of-the-range coffee and tea are available in the waiting room, as well as the books of the doctors in the practice. |
URL | http://journals.openedition.org/rfst/docannexe/image/1830/img-1.jpg |
Fichier | image/jpeg, 216k |
Pour citer cet article
Référence électronique
Anne-Cécile Hoyez, Clélia Gasquet-Blanchard, Paula Cristofalo et Maud Gelly, « In search of the ideal maternity: Mobility, key to childbirth dreamed of by economic elites? », Revue francophone sur la santé et les territoires [En ligne], Les circulations en santé : des produits, des savoirs, des personnes en mouvement, mis en ligne le 29 août 2023, consulté le 14 mai 2025. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/rfst/1830 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/rfst.1830
Haut de pageDroits d’auteur
Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont « Tous droits réservés », sauf mention contraire.
Haut de page