Navigation – Plan du site

AccueilTous les numéros9 : 2Contre-cultures: Utopies, dystopi...Notes de lectureRussell Reising, 'Every Sound The...

Contre-cultures: Utopies, dystopies, anarchie
Notes de lecture

Russell Reising, 'Every Sound There Is'. The Beatles' Revolver and the Transformation of Rock and Roll

Sarah A. Etlinger
p. 158-159
Référence(s) :

Aldershot: Ashgate, 286 p.

Entrées d’index

Chronologique :


Genre musical :

rock music

Artiste :

Beatles (the)
Haut de page

Texte intégral

1Russell Reising declares in the introduction to his excellent collection commemorating Revolver that “Revolver has always been the right answer” (1) to any question concerning the “best” Beatles album of all time. Reising suggests that this album, instead of the more popular and critically acclaimed Sgt. Pepper, is rapidly tightening “its grip on our collective imagination”(1) for it introduces the Beatles as true pioneers of musical experimentation. As a “grandly complex and ambitious statement about the possibilities of popular music” (1, italics original), Revolver has become, at least for Reising and the collaborators in this collection, the original album of “firsts and onlies” (11), whose appeal has not waned, even recently surpassing Sgt. Pepper in terms of innovation, acclaim, and magic. This collection succeeds in capturing the magic of Revolver, both through its deeply personal and highly technical explorations.

2One feature of the collection that is particularly appreciated is the section titled “ ‘When I’m in the middle of a dream’: the contributors remember Revolver.” The contributors (comprised of noted music and Beatles scholars like Sheila Whitely, Ian Inglis, Walter Everett, and Napthali Wagner, to name a few), offer touching, personal, and interesting anecdotes about the staying power of the album. From this brief section, we get a sense of how powerful the album has remained since its 1966 debut, and are reminded that seemingly minor events like hearing an album can shape an entire career. Trite as it is, my own experience with Revolver echoes with many of these contributors, especially the fact that the album has continued to captivate my attention and admiration even after 20 years since I first heard it. These anecdotes set the stage for a powerful and meaningful discussion of the record’s more technical merits, which, for the most part, stand as a truly wonderful tribute to the magic, innovation, and genius of the album.

3That said, for a lay reader, the more technical articles, while useful in their own right, fall a bit short in the overall goal of capturing the magic of the album. Though I appreciate the sophisticated analysis that these articles offered, (gathered in the middle section entitled “ ‘It is Shining’: Revolver’s Musicality”), their offerings tended to obscure the “magic,” as it were, by introducing musical terms that were not accessible to general audiences. However, the writing and analysis is compelling, to say the least, and for readers more versed in musical theory than I, the articles should promise a welcome and thought-provoking examination of the Beatles’ technical merits. While not a part of this section, Everett’s fascinating comparison of the album’s roots in the Detroit Motown/ R&B scene stands as an accessible bright spot in the discussion of the Beatles’ musical innovations. Everett compellingly and effectively situates R&B as a key influence of the album’s innovations, and I can no longer understand the album separately from this comparison.

4Other true bright spots of this collection are Warwick’s “I’m Eleanor Rigby: female identity and Revolver,” McDonald and Kaufman’s “ ‘Tomorrow Never Knows’”, and the pair of articles on the minor Beatles Ringo and George, respectively Baur’s “Ringo Round Revolver” and Bannister’s “The Beatle who became a man.” These four articles, to me, characterize the spirit of the collection, allowing for a greater understanding of not only how the album was composed and produced, but also of the role that the personal plays in the album’s cultural staying power. Warwick’s quest to carve space for herself in “Eleanor Rigby” resonates with me as a woman, especially since it is one of the few Beatles songs in which there is a woman protagonist for whom we have sympathy. McDonald and Kaufman’s article on the influence of George Martin is particularly welcome, because Martin, while knighted due to his remarkable achievements, has often become swept under the rug in terms of how he shaped the records. Finally, the two articles on Ringo and George offer a fresher perspective on these two perhaps underrated and certainly shadowed Beatles, and show how their contributions to the groundbreaking album were indispensable and technically sound as well.

5These four articles, for me, capture the magic of the album, and ultimately achieve Reising’s goal of attempting to understand the cultural fascination surrounding Revolver, more than 40 years since its release. Perhaps I am a luddite, but for me the most fascinating aspect of the album is the artists who created it, and on this aspect, the collection doesn’t disappoint. In an age where we are constantly bombarded with media displaying the latest celebrity scandal, allowing us to have a brief window into someone else’s life, the windows into Revolver, still one of the most renowned and appreciated albums of all time, resonate as much more than simple glimpses. The collection as a whole succeeds in trying to understand how our relationships with the album are just as important as the musical and cultural innovations that the artists created, and this is an achievement almost as powerful.

Haut de page

Pour citer cet article

Référence papier

Sarah A. Etlinger, « Russell Reising, 'Every Sound There Is'. The Beatles' Revolver and the Transformation of Rock and Roll »Volume !, 9 : 2 | 2012, 158-159.

Référence électronique

Sarah A. Etlinger, « Russell Reising, 'Every Sound There Is'. The Beatles' Revolver and the Transformation of Rock and Roll »Volume ! [En ligne], 9 : 2 | 2012, mis en ligne le 15 décembre 2012, consulté le 22 juin 2024. URL : ; DOI :

Haut de page


Sarah A. Etlinger

Sarah A. Etlinger poursuit un Ph.D en Rhétorique et Composition à l’Université de Wisconsin-Milwaukee. Sa thèse explore le rapport entre les nouveaux médias et les manuels de composition, soutenant qu’afin d’être efficaces, ceux-ci devraient aborder les nouveaux médias de façon à inciter les étudiants à démultiplier leurs capacités expressives (écrite, orale, graphique, visuelle etc.) Dans le champ académique, elle s’intéresse notamment aux nouveaux médias numériques, aux film/visual studies, à la culture populaire, à la théorie critique et à la pédagogie. Francophile, elle aime cuisiner français, voyager en France et au Canada et la poésie française. Par ailleurs, elle est une fan des Beatles depuis de longues années, et elle nourrit la passion quasi obsessionnelle qu’elle leur dédie en collectionnant tout un attirail de bibelots à leur effigie.

Articles du même auteur

Haut de page

Droits d’auteur


Le texte seul est utilisable sous licence CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. Les autres éléments (illustrations, fichiers annexes importés) sont « Tous droits réservés », sauf mention contraire.

Haut de page
Rechercher dans OpenEdition Search

Vous allez être redirigé vers OpenEdition Search